Therefore, Melinda Doolittle went the way of Tamyra Gray, who is the archetype for shocking elimination. Jennifer Hudson, who was also controversially voted off to 7th place in season 3, also appeared in this video.
The problem is Jordin is a teenager and the vast majority of voters are teenagers, and this is true for most TV contests. So most teenagers would go for someone who's closer to them, and is still a good singer. However, Melinda is a much better singer, but her songs probably would not appeal to most teens who prefer mainstream pop, and its very obvious that Jordin will go into mainstream pop.So in actual fact, Melinda is still a better singer, but lost out mainly because of this reason.
melinda has more talent but i guess the public took i liking to jordin becuz shes more appealing in the sense shes more confident and ofcourse she appeals more to the youth but u know me being a teenager i think melinda should have won she showcased the real talent she deserved to
this doesn't really matter you guys.. different people have different tastes and everybody needs to accept that fact that people are going to like different things in the world at some point.
Melinda is a way better singer than Jordin. Even Jordin knows that. She's got plenty of time to develop her singing voice though..and I hope she does.
Jordin can't sing r+b or country. Please she can barely sing pop. Melinda didn't need the idol winner title to sell records like Jordin does. Good luck, Melinda on your new career.
Melinda is very talented but Jordin was better and younger so she had a bigger fan base. Melinda will still sell cd's to her R&B base audience whereas Jordin can sing multiple genres.
DUI is a serious offense but rarely gets punished. To me it should be treated like attempted murder because you could have a wreck and kill someone easily AND you know you are drunk when you get behind the wheel.
This is why I stopped watching this show.. It sickens me to see the most talented/best singer get voted off.. So tired of the BS! Yeah, I hate Paris Hilton to.. Miss Priss, tired of seeing her in the knews begging for sympathy.. She's just a dumb twit..
i wanted melinda to win american idol, i want ciara to win all three bet awards, i want paris hilton to just go to jail and stop requesting less days!
i know...my favorites never win...tamayra, clay, jennifer hudson, vonzell...Nadia, Paris...Chris ...Elliot, and Melinda Doolittle....maybe i should say i hate my favorites and then they might win...lol!
Melinda is way better!!!!!! period!!!
sassygirl907 1 year ago
Therefore, Melinda Doolittle went the way of Tamyra Gray, who is the archetype for shocking elimination. Jennifer Hudson, who was also controversially voted off to 7th place in season 3, also appeared in this video.
TediusZanarukando 3 years ago 3
i wanted melinda to win american idol
54spiritedwill54 3 years ago 8
Melinda lost because she was better. People on AI always vote for the badder singer.
DragonballXL 3 years ago
I think Melinda don´t need to win ths contest , she a giant , she surely makes her career , no doubt about it .
Groek123 3 years ago 5
The problem is Jordin is a teenager and the vast majority of voters are teenagers, and this is true for most TV contests. So most teenagers would go for someone who's closer to them, and is still a good singer. However, Melinda is a much better singer, but her songs probably would not appeal to most teens who prefer mainstream pop, and its very obvious that Jordin will go into mainstream pop.So in actual fact, Melinda is still a better singer, but lost out mainly because of this reason.
Icelordess 3 years ago 10
melinda has more talent but i guess the public took i liking to jordin becuz shes more appealing in the sense shes more confident and ofcourse she appeals more to the youth but u know me being a teenager i think melinda should have won she showcased the real talent she deserved to
rockglamour62 4 years ago
Melinda is the winner indeed!!
jeffnug 4 years ago
Melinda should have won Jordin was good but she was not near as better than Melinda but Melinda is my American Idol not Jordin
babygurl122207 4 years ago 5
Is she any kin to dr. doolittle
tmillhollon 4 years ago
Melinda is not a american idol,she is a STAR! and you all will see just give it time. American idol is amature to her.
angelinlulu 4 years ago
Jordin rules...MELINDA IS THE BOMB!!! I hope we listen more from her in the near future
mcZoRrI 4 years ago
this doesn't really matter you guys.. different people have different tastes and everybody needs to accept that fact that people are going to like different things in the world at some point.
BlakeAndJordin4eva 4 years ago
JOrdin and Melinda are good singers but Melinda is in a different field than Jordin.
prodiege 4 years ago
prodiege Quote "Jordin and Melinda are good singers but Melinda is in a different field than Jordin."
different filed all right! The back field.
Melinda not satr material
ptoca 4 years ago
PTOCA, you're a moron who can't even spell two words in row. Oh, and you're also a rude bitch.
cbaker3122 4 years ago
I agree. Anyone who would say something like what PTOCA did and spell "field" as "filed" IS truly a moron with no taste.
cbaker3122 4 years ago
Melinda is a way better singer than Jordin. Even Jordin knows that. She's got plenty of time to develop her singing voice though..and I hope she does.
lynnpwilliams 4 years ago
Jordin can't sing r+b or country. Please she can barely sing pop. Melinda didn't need the idol winner title to sell records like Jordin does. Good luck, Melinda on your new career.
teaful 4 years ago
Melinda is very talented but Jordin was better and younger so she had a bigger fan base. Melinda will still sell cd's to her R&B base audience whereas Jordin can sing multiple genres.
DUI is a serious offense but rarely gets punished. To me it should be treated like attempted murder because you could have a wreck and kill someone easily AND you know you are drunk when you get behind the wheel.
Phonetroll 4 years ago
That's not true. Did you hear her sing Have a nice day? The judges, Bon Jovi fans and even Bon Jovi praised her.
sportsqueen 4 years ago
This is why I stopped watching this show.. It sickens me to see the most talented/best singer get voted off.. So tired of the BS! Yeah, I hate Paris Hilton to.. Miss Priss, tired of seeing her in the knews begging for sympathy.. She's just a dumb twit..
Dominozone 4 years ago
i wanted melinda to win american idol, i want ciara to win all three bet awards, i want paris hilton to just go to jail and stop requesting less days!
jorgeghetto 4 years ago
i agree with it so annoying, paris should get raped by butch lesbians .its not fair,melinda is the voice of america
beautyqueenfreak 4 years ago
what happen to american people? Melinda is, in fact America Idol 2007.
portoalegre1 4 years ago
i know...my favorites never win...tamayra, clay, jennifer hudson, vonzell...Nadia, Paris...Chris ...Elliot, and Melinda Doolittle....maybe i should say i hate my favorites and then they might win...lol!
tallrob11 4 years ago
Its clear you all just have poor taste.
Jordin Rules
ptoca 4 years ago
taste is not something that is right or wrong! yes, 2 plus 2 is always 4, but taste is an opinion not a fact!
tallrob11 4 years ago
american voters sucks!
elub21 4 years ago
u suck!
ydna2003 4 years ago
UTOT MO!
elub21 4 years ago
portoalegre1 Quote "what happen to american people? Melinda is, in fact America Idol 2007. "
In fact you are wrong. You couple of thousand people fortunately could not carry the vote.
American Idol "Jordin Sparks" by margin of 90%
ptoca 4 years ago