- (from pt.2) the waterfall is too opaque to see Sonic, the rings make a REALLY bright glimmer, and the scripted gravity spring... you know, just the small things
- the special stage is... lacking. While I like the music theme and concept, the execution is a bit on the atrocious side. It need a complete artistic overhaul.
-there's also some audio and visual glitches, most noticeable in the final act. That'll need some fixing.
@AerobianAngel I didnt make this game and it's been out of production for a while. I kinda want to let the commenters know that I didnt make this and that I cant do anything about it. Drama insued (afaik) and this project got rebooted into a totally different thing.
Buddy, there are no bets to be had. I KNOW that I can't do better. My comments were only on the tiny things that really don't matter much, after I clarified that this game is one of the best Sonic Fan games I've seen and does nearly everything right.
This game has got to be the best Classic Sonic Fan Game I've seen so far. Yes, it beats Fan Remix (actual storyline instead of Sonic 2 rehash FTW). Since it basically does almost EVERYTHING right, I'll just list the negatives:
- the title screen is unbalanced. You have Sonic, Tails, and Knux crammed in this tiny Sonic CD emblem, but hardly anything in the background to balance it.
- some little aesthetic details irk me, like the standard run mode (beta sprite is unappealing), the SPEED FLASH
hey how the hell do you transform into super sonic anyways it says sonic can transform into super sonic once he gets all chaos emeralds but you cant or something though doesnt say that once you get all for knuckles or tails
@dakidukno god damnit i was gonna type in as a comment GAME OVER YEAHHHHHH before i saw your comment already saying it D: and was gonna apparently eventualy get 17 if it werent for you bastard D:
Seanieb64 were u successful in getting all 7 gems? i tried and failed only because the game froze when ever i went in the special stages lolz at least on my attempt on getting my 6th emerald.
I wish they would release this game already. Why is it almost every awesome fangame never makes it past demo state? It's sad, this is so much more of what I wanted out of a sequel to Sonic 3 and knuckles. Sonic 4 just looks like another reboot.
very clever that its fan made they done a good job but in my opinion you cant beat the original, they should of always kept sonic 2d when they made all the other games they were just shit lol.
have you read the interview with the former head of sonic team? they've been trying to kill the franchise for about 15 years now, purely by releasing horrible game after horrible game.
For all intents and purposes, this is Sonic 4, and I freakin love it. Graphics, presentation, especially music. Competing with this, Project Needlemouse has a lot to live up to.
Sonic, on the Genesis, was never about speed. It was about solid platforming with the occasional fast moment. The Uniracers knockoffs came much later. And no, that isn't a compliment.
Solid platforming > holding RIGHT for most of a level with the occasional jump.
@2IBbristol Yes but the music in that game is so boring... I actually just stopped playing an ACT of Casino Street for about a minute just thinking about how much better Sonic 3's music was... The music in SEGAS abandoned Knuckles Chaotix and Sonic CD should have been reused. Also, the physics are still VERY wrong. Sonic has almost no "kick" in anything he does... waste of money for a Sonic REMAKE. This doesn't deserve the title "Sonic 4" as it's not original in any way. Sonic XG in HD = WIN!!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Looks decent overall, though the run animation looks... awkward. The level design is pretty solid, though, and the bonus stage, while unoriginal, works. The sequel to Sonic 3 and Knuckles idea is an interesting one, too.
Also, people really need to stop with the Sonic CD worship. Seriously.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Using its title theme for the invincibility period (especially nonsensical if you're using original stage themes), using its ear grating jump sound effect, etc.
when well sega learn? Megaman went back to old school. So is mario. I'm so tired of these Sonic 3D games. Sonic fans have better ideas than sega itself.
Looks beter than the latest Sega Sonic games...:)
sjorspion 3 weeks ago
why are the chaos emeralds so big! now when sonic gets all of them he'll become Hyper light speed sonic! =O
MrBlublur 1 month ago
(c)
- (from pt.2) the waterfall is too opaque to see Sonic, the rings make a REALLY bright glimmer, and the scripted gravity spring... you know, just the small things
- the special stage is... lacking. While I like the music theme and concept, the execution is a bit on the atrocious side. It need a complete artistic overhaul.
-there's also some audio and visual glitches, most noticeable in the final act. That'll need some fixing.
Well, that's all the bad. I hope those get fixed.
AerobianAngel 7 months ago
@AerobianAngel I didnt make this game and it's been out of production for a while. I kinda want to let the commenters know that I didnt make this and that I cant do anything about it. Drama insued (afaik) and this project got rebooted into a totally different thing.
seanieb64 7 months ago
@AerobianAngel bet you couldnt do any better
krisbo123 2 months ago
@krisbo123
Buddy, there are no bets to be had. I KNOW that I can't do better. My comments were only on the tiny things that really don't matter much, after I clarified that this game is one of the best Sonic Fan games I've seen and does nearly everything right.
AerobianAngel 2 months ago
This game has got to be the best Classic Sonic Fan Game I've seen so far. Yes, it beats Fan Remix (actual storyline instead of Sonic 2 rehash FTW). Since it basically does almost EVERYTHING right, I'll just list the negatives:
- the title screen is unbalanced. You have Sonic, Tails, and Knux crammed in this tiny Sonic CD emblem, but hardly anything in the background to balance it.
- some little aesthetic details irk me, like the standard run mode (beta sprite is unappealing), the SPEED FLASH
(c)
AerobianAngel 7 months ago
@AerobianAngel Unfortunately, this has been out of work for many years, and I didn't make it, either.
seanieb64 7 months ago
@seanieb64 Truly is a shame, but alas, 'tis the fate of many fan games.
AerobianAngel 7 months ago
If only you could transfer this to the dsi.
JDaMac815 8 months ago
hey how the hell do you transform into super sonic anyways it says sonic can transform into super sonic once he gets all chaos emeralds but you cant or something though doesnt say that once you get all for knuckles or tails
froakentoken1 9 months ago
@dakidukno god damnit i was gonna type in as a comment GAME OVER YEAHHHHHH before i saw your comment already saying it D: and was gonna apparently eventualy get 17 if it werent for you bastard D:
froakentoken1 9 months ago
you need to played sonic and nuckles to understand the story.
MRtetri5 11 months ago
Amazing music in this level!
CrystalFissure 1 year ago
I really like how the special stages work.
gyrrakavian 1 year ago
Please give a link to a version of this game..... It's so awesome!
WholeNoteWarren 1 year ago
WTF? 3:28
DJman601 1 year ago 3
Very innovative!
I think the game play is a bit rough though.
I really like it.
SuperSweeting 1 year ago
Good job!
XinoZ16 1 year ago
Lol stage 1's music is the Mvc1 credits bgm
BCannonThaMc 1 year ago
Seanieb64 were u successful in getting all 7 gems? i tried and failed only because the game froze when ever i went in the special stages lolz at least on my attempt on getting my 6th emerald.
subway007 1 year ago
I hate how most of these fan games/hacks use sonic CD's jump sound. It's really annoying after a while.
deesies 1 year ago
i lov the free fall background with all the grounds all fallin
VincettPatrick 1 year ago
this is the true sonic 4
raveakidd 1 year ago
I have recongnised the ending theme of marvel vs capcom 1 on background
stryder33 1 year ago
You're far too good for just fangames. Work for Sonic Team and go into console games like this one! They need you!
Johnny2071 1 year ago
I wish they would release this game already. Why is it almost every awesome fangame never makes it past demo state? It's sad, this is so much more of what I wanted out of a sequel to Sonic 3 and knuckles. Sonic 4 just looks like another reboot.
shorty1k 1 year ago
very clever that its fan made they done a good job but in my opinion you cant beat the original, they should of always kept sonic 2d when they made all the other games they were just shit lol.
dannyboiii19 1 year ago
@dannyboiii19 At least we're getting Sonic 4 now, developed by the team that did the Sonic Advance and Sonic Rush games, so hooray for that.
milkmanv1 1 year ago
Looks good, but physics are way off.
kloroformd 2 years ago
whats with the shinobi wall jumps? lol looks good mind :D
CashForGash 2 years ago
final fall boss back ground just looks amazing
supersonicseed 2 years ago 2
where can i dl the demo,looks awesome cant wait to play it
OrinZolis 2 years ago
haha, it's not a joke, his argument is "let it die, sonic was good, but not that good"
i'm like, why the hell would you put a sonic hater as head of sonic team?
it's fucked up.
xphoenixdownx 2 years ago
have you read the interview with the former head of sonic team? they've been trying to kill the franchise for about 15 years now, purely by releasing horrible game after horrible game.
xphoenixdownx 2 years ago 6
lol
seanieb64 2 years ago
@xphoenixdownx
Did you also hear that it was a false to piss off Sonic fans? lol
BrawlRelatedReviewer 1 year ago
@xphoenixdownx LAWL that parody was funny
thalazar 1 year ago
this would be awesome as a real game on the DS or something. For real
JayChyllin09 2 years ago 2
I think when this game is finished, I'm going to just pretend that no Sonic game came out after the Genesis era.
If I ever take over Sega, I'm hiring the creators of Sonic XG, and using XG to completely retcon everything that happened past S3&K.
Axelhander 2 years ago 4
Yes, 'tis truly a sad day when you realize that fans are making better games than the company themelves.
MetalSonicEX 2 years ago 4
For all intents and purposes, this is Sonic 4, and I freakin love it. Graphics, presentation, especially music. Competing with this, Project Needlemouse has a lot to live up to.
AJBSONIC 2 years ago 5
looks fuckin niiice...but fuck the level design, haha. NO SPEED.
ElMastero 2 years ago
Sonic, on the Genesis, was never about speed. It was about solid platforming with the occasional fast moment. The Uniracers knockoffs came much later. And no, that isn't a compliment.
Solid platforming > holding RIGHT for most of a level with the occasional jump.
Axelhander 2 years ago 16
whoever made this needs a lesson in level design
sethisawesome 2 years ago
Yes and no. Many of the design elements are sound, but some of the level doesn't have that "flow" classic Sonic levels had.
Axelhander 2 years ago
I swear to god I Love how you just start from the end of Sonic and Knuckles.
Im sad right now..
TroopRazorwire 2 years ago 3
This should be a Wii Ware game, where is there no Sonic Wii Ware game Sonic Team?!
This is it!
AshleyJoyGT 2 years ago
This is on the PC, it'd be a pain to port to the Wii I'd imagine.
seanieb64 2 years ago
I wouldn't want Sonic Team to make it.
Axelhander 2 years ago
@AshleyJoyGT Isn't Sonic 4 coming to WiiWare?
2IBbristol 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@2IBbristol Yes but the music in that game is so boring... I actually just stopped playing an ACT of Casino Street for about a minute just thinking about how much better Sonic 3's music was... The music in SEGAS abandoned Knuckles Chaotix and Sonic CD should have been reused. Also, the physics are still VERY wrong. Sonic has almost no "kick" in anything he does... waste of money for a Sonic REMAKE. This doesn't deserve the title "Sonic 4" as it's not original in any way. Sonic XG in HD = WIN!!
Xilosphere 1 year ago
Man, I wish Sega still made Sonic games like this.
Looktisme 2 years ago 7
Don't we all.
seanieb64 2 years ago
Oh yeah!
andrewfernandez105 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Looks decent overall, though the run animation looks... awkward. The level design is pretty solid, though, and the bonus stage, while unoriginal, works. The sequel to Sonic 3 and Knuckles idea is an interesting one, too.
Also, people really need to stop with the Sonic CD worship. Seriously.
LadyMiaow 2 years ago
What do you mean Sonic CD worship?
millgiass 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Using its title theme for the invincibility period (especially nonsensical if you're using original stage themes), using its ear grating jump sound effect, etc.
LadyMiaow 2 years ago
GAME OVER, YEEEEEEAAAAAA!
dakidukno 2 years ago 21
This Game Looks Good!
sonicandrock 2 years ago 2
From where does the level music come?
nigelrugby 2 years ago
The creators Hands, They made it
BlazefireLP 2 years ago
the ending of marvel vs capcom 1, sounds more of less like a remix of it
KamenKami 2 years ago
The remix used was made by SonicTweaker, of Sonic Retro and Sonic Megamix fame in the Sonic scene
seanieb64 2 years ago
looks better than sega ones o0 my god
rodrigoaal18 3 years ago
lol game over yeeeeeeeeeeeeaaaaaaaaaaaaaaahhhhhhhhhhhhhh
sd28821 3 years ago
SEGA RALLY :D
seanieb64 3 years ago
I love this game.
DarkProwl 3 years ago
when well sega learn? Megaman went back to old school. So is mario. I'm so tired of these Sonic 3D games. Sonic fans have better ideas than sega itself.
Mephilesthedark360 3 years ago 2
You make better sonic games then sega.
ScreamingPixel 3 years ago
This isn't my game, I'm not this good, lol.
seanieb64 3 years ago
who did it
sora4139 3 years ago
If you look at part 1, you'll see the name. Or at the end of this part
seanieb64 3 years ago
ok ill look
sora4139 3 years ago