an honorable cover. I was lucky enough to hear Buddy Holly when he was alive--and this cover has the sincerity and humility that Buddy Holly displayed in his performance.
@violinroy "Horrible"? lol, well I guess there's always someone who has to be negative. How about you post your own version as a video response and we'll let people compare. ;)
@RobertJeffreyMiller Well, that's one of the worst responses to give, you can dislike something without the ability to do it yourself. I myself can't play this song half as good as you, and I can't sing as good as you, but I didn't really like it... The singing is false enough for me to notice it (and according to people, I'm pretty bad at noticing it), over-all, you did everything right "technically", but it lacks one thing.
@TheDJGrandPa Well, his critique was worse; yes, I could do better, but I know my performance wasn't "horrible". At least your critique isn't just "you suck".
@violinroy what do you do, find someone playing Buddy Holly and type in "This is horrible" ???. I've seen this same remark from you on other Buddy Holly videos. Why don't you get yourself a hobby or something?
McGregor doesn't quite have Buddy Holly's stance down (left leg in front of the right by a step and slightly to the side, with the right leg keeping time to the beat, for example) and his tone is a bit nasal-sounding in the two songs on YouTube, but it does look like he puts on an amazing show.
this is my favourite song of Buddy Holly that you do and I think u do it so well. Its to bad u cant to Buddy for PNE cause you'd definitely win the whole show with it. I can tell you guys I saw him live for this performance and it was amazing!!Made my heart melt even more so than usual.
Wow.. Man You Made Me A Fan.. Been A Fan Of Buddy Since I Was A Little Kid... You Should Think About Doing A Buddy Holly Album... His Songs.. Id Buy Em.. lol
:D Thanks CashFan4, you made me chuckle. Thanks CashFan4, dlpine & Leftovers666 & everyone for your nice comments, which have convinced me to continue doing my Buddy Holly tribute while I pursue my own songwriting. I just have to work on the hair. I had to do it myself and didn't have enough time to style it closer to Buddy's way.
You need to "attack" the text more. You seem concerned to sound "pretty" instead of energetic. (I used to do Buddy's stuff. At least you have hair ;) as mine has thinned out way too much).
RJM, again i am so impressed with your talent. and buddy holly is a personal favorite of mine. what he did in twenty-two years amazes me. do you perform professionally? i sure hope so. thanks.
It's guys like this who keep the spirit of Buddy Holly alive. Thank you!!!
Cowboy11474 6 months ago
an honorable cover. I was lucky enough to hear Buddy Holly when he was alive--and this cover has the sincerity and humility that Buddy Holly displayed in his performance.
bellbonne 7 months ago
This is awesome! Thanks for keeping the spirit of Buddy alive! One of the greatest musicians to ever walk this earth.
TigerArmyNeverDies 8 months ago
Darned good. And that's from someone who know's
trextrextrex 8 months ago
very cool. Don't stop, do more!!!!!!!
Karlpetry 9 months ago
i loved it! you might not of had the "oomph" that buddy had but this is really good
MrGlue42 10 months ago
i like it good job do what u love
flagle35 10 months ago
Nice take, but you need wilder suits, skinner ties and more gy-ra-tishuns!
RAVE ON!
voidforpurpose 11 months ago
Really great work ;) just ignore people like "Violinroy" he dont know what he talks about ;)
slashgnr12 1 year ago
Just hold still! all that walking around is 1970s and 80s stuff.
violinroy 1 year ago
This is horrible
violinroy 1 year ago
@violinroy "Horrible"? lol, well I guess there's always someone who has to be negative. How about you post your own version as a video response and we'll let people compare. ;)
RobertJeffreyMiller 1 year ago 7
@RobertJeffreyMiller Well, that's one of the worst responses to give, you can dislike something without the ability to do it yourself. I myself can't play this song half as good as you, and I can't sing as good as you, but I didn't really like it... The singing is false enough for me to notice it (and according to people, I'm pretty bad at noticing it), over-all, you did everything right "technically", but it lacks one thing.
Rock and Roll.
TheDJGrandPa 1 year ago
@TheDJGrandPa Well, his critique was worse; yes, I could do better, but I know my performance wasn't "horrible". At least your critique isn't just "you suck".
RobertJeffreyMiller 1 year ago
@violinroy Wrong. Dude, I'm a huge fan of your stuff. Its awesome, keep on doing what you're doing.
rjs11189 1 year ago
@violinroy what do you do, find someone playing Buddy Holly and type in "This is horrible" ???. I've seen this same remark from you on other Buddy Holly videos. Why don't you get yourself a hobby or something?
stringbenderE2E 1 year ago
@RobertJeffreyMiller I think it is really good. Good job!
coolhand67 7 months ago
Anyway - Great performance!....minor point but 'spazz' out a little.....rubber soles?
johnsain 2 years ago
dude,....put some more of your 'body' into the solo. ; )
johnsain 2 years ago
Body Holly? I didn't want to slip on the floor. :P
RobertJeffreyMiller 2 years ago
Very good.
Iyebaka 2 years ago
Great and we have the same name too !
BobandyHolly 2 years ago
Well done, dude!!
nestorgs 2 years ago
great sound, kudos to the singer, keep the old days rolling
dragonheart1947 2 years ago
Thank you very much, dragonheart! I'll do my best! :)
RobertJeffreyMiller 2 years ago
The Absolutely Best Performer of Buddy Holly Songs on the World is Angus McGregor !!
The Voice of him is so Great ! Absolutely Perfect Show ever I´seen. The Songs playing here on Youtube : Oh Boy and Rave on.
sweatlove07 2 years ago
McGregor doesn't quite have Buddy Holly's stance down (left leg in front of the right by a step and slightly to the side, with the right leg keeping time to the beat, for example) and his tone is a bit nasal-sounding in the two songs on YouTube, but it does look like he puts on an amazing show.
RobertJeffreyMiller 2 years ago
One of my all time favourites.Wish I could play my Strat the way you do!Is there any CD available??
TheBuddyfan 2 years ago
I am still lokkin for my Buddy Holly. I lost you in the parking lot. this guy rocks. love it. rave on my fav song by the late great Buddy Holly.
mskittykatty 3 years ago
This is amazing! absolutely the best cover ive seen so far! youve got it all down, tone beat, everything! well done!
lolakitty4484 3 years ago
I bet you Buddy Holly would have liked Mellencamp's music though
MagiMysteryTour 3 years ago
Oh I agree.
RobertJeffreyMiller 3 years ago
this is my favourite song of Buddy Holly that you do and I think u do it so well. Its to bad u cant to Buddy for PNE cause you'd definitely win the whole show with it. I can tell you guys I saw him live for this performance and it was amazing!!Made my heart melt even more so than usual.
feeona27 3 years ago
Wow you are great
reimansuccessteam 3 years ago
Thanks!
RobertJeffreyMiller 3 years ago
where are the crickets?robert you are cool but you need the double bass and the mad drummer!!!!! hell i will do it!!!!
jamierourketen 3 years ago
Thanks, jamie! I will be putting a band together for my Buddy Holly tribute for future shows.
RobertJeffreyMiller 3 years ago
Excellent. You've got it man.
You have inspired me to start playing again
Have a look at my efforts if you have time. I'd like to know what you think
Cheers
Spencer (Luton, England)
StikPivot 3 years ago 3
Thanks, Spencer, I enjoy your videos and am glad you have started playing again!
RobertJeffreyMiller 3 years ago
i have thr original rave on song on cd and i love it i sing it in school alot and the kids sing a long
PeteAndJakee 1 year ago
Wow.. Man You Made Me A Fan.. Been A Fan Of Buddy Since I Was A Little Kid... You Should Think About Doing A Buddy Holly Album... His Songs.. Id Buy Em.. lol
popeyekds 4 years ago
Thanks, popeyekds! I am working on an album of my own stuff but will likely be doing some Buddy recordings at some point as well. :)
RobertJeffreyMiller 4 years ago
Where were you when they casted The Buddy Holly Story. You kick ass!
CashFan4 4 years ago
:D Thanks CashFan4, you made me chuckle. Thanks CashFan4, dlpine & Leftovers666 & everyone for your nice comments, which have convinced me to continue doing my Buddy Holly tribute while I pursue my own songwriting. I just have to work on the hair. I had to do it myself and didn't have enough time to style it closer to Buddy's way.
RobertJeffreyMiller 4 years ago
You need to "attack" the text more. You seem concerned to sound "pretty" instead of energetic. (I used to do Buddy's stuff. At least you have hair ;) as mine has thinned out way too much).
dutchpuppy2 4 years ago
"I feel pretty, oh so pretty." :p Well, I only had about 3 hours of sleep so I was lucky to even be conscious! It's a fair comment though.
RobertJeffreyMiller 4 years ago
AWESOME!!!!
CashFan4 4 years ago
RJM, again i am so impressed with your talent. and buddy holly is a personal favorite of mine. what he did in twenty-two years amazes me. do you perform professionally? i sure hope so. thanks.
dlpine 4 years ago
Nice cover
Love That Song
Leftovers666 4 years ago
You got the groove - Nice cover!
rockabillyotis 4 years ago
Thank you very much, rockabillyotis and everyone else, for all the wonderful comments!
RobertJeffreyMiller 4 years ago
Not bad at all, keep it up.
reekster 4 years ago
Wow! this is a great cover.
awesome job.
npknhdfrvr 4 years ago
Thanks so much, I really appreciate the comments!
RobertJeffreyMiller 4 years ago
Rave On! My favorite Buddy song. You do him justice!
jdunn58 4 years ago
Amazing! You have it all: a wonderful voice, a wonderful gift with the guitar, and a wonderful stage presence! Way to go!
comoxrunner 4 years ago