I've been trying to obtain freedom in my shoulder with different shoulder rests, chin rests, asking for instruction from my teachers and trying to copy great players. This is the first time I've had any hope that I'd be able to correct my stiff, muscular neck and shoulder grip. What a great teacher, and what a great post! Thanks a million!
@billfiddle I don't think you can make out anything in any of his earlier videos to determine that he maintains the base index finger contact all the time.
There's a difference between occasionally touching and frequently touching
It's ok to touch it occasionally but if it becomes a habit of squeeze the base of the 1st finger against the neck, you will not be able to play any fast passage.
My left hand gained tremendous agility after learning to leave a gap between the 1st finger joint and the neck.
@unotelly there r actually two methods. Another Sir Menuhin's video where he was teaching a masterclass showed a boy who was taught different but played just as well. Although he insisted on leaving space between the index and neck, I think it's just a personal preference thing. Just look at all the great violinists who didn't play the same. :)
Thank you thank you thank you!
00Jabberwoofles00 1 week ago
I've been trying to obtain freedom in my shoulder with different shoulder rests, chin rests, asking for instruction from my teachers and trying to copy great players. This is the first time I've had any hope that I'd be able to correct my stiff, muscular neck and shoulder grip. What a great teacher, and what a great post! Thanks a million!
cate7791 2 weeks ago
5:56 I've heard "condom on my head" ;d
kickalion 3 weeks ago
@lovetheatre100: there's just the six. I wish I could find the complete versions of the last three though.
Lemon77UG 1 month ago
Will we be seeing any more of these wonderful videos.
lovetheatre100 1 month ago
wow, Mr Menuhin!!! What a Professor!!!! Wonderful!!!!
chjimenez 1 month ago
very very very good !
MusicPredominates 1 month ago
aye, perhaps, anyhoo, it's a great vid of Sir himself, tanx for that! :-)
billfiddle 4 months ago
Great teacher!
7Adelheid 4 months ago
WOAH cool a plastic violin XD
Grobanite122549 4 months ago
can't think of a violinist who does NOT have this contact, including Menuhin himself, just watch his early videos...:-)
billfiddle 5 months ago
@billfiddle I don't think you can make out anything in any of his earlier videos to determine that he maintains the base index finger contact all the time.
There's a difference between occasionally touching and frequently touching
unotelly 4 months ago
Thank you ! Excellent information !
1redviolin 5 months ago
David Oistrakh touches the neck with his first finger joint . 2 ways ok .
amezcuaist 6 months ago
@amezcuaist
It's ok to touch it occasionally but if it becomes a habit of squeeze the base of the 1st finger against the neck, you will not be able to play any fast passage.
My left hand gained tremendous agility after learning to leave a gap between the 1st finger joint and the neck.
unotelly 5 months ago
@unotelly there r actually two methods. Another Sir Menuhin's video where he was teaching a masterclass showed a boy who was taught different but played just as well. Although he insisted on leaving space between the index and neck, I think it's just a personal preference thing. Just look at all the great violinists who didn't play the same. :)
ss032010310103 2 months ago in playlist More videos from Lemon77UG
@ss032010310103
I agree with you. Personally, Menuhin's method works better for me due to my smaller hand size.
unotelly 2 months ago
David Oistrakh touches the neck with his first finger joint .
amezcuaist 6 months ago
Brilliant,Thanx....
McSnicket 6 months ago
Absolut bliss to see this again...I cannot thank you enough for uploading these lessons.
askbrahms 7 months ago
this is gold!
Jedum 8 months ago