Haley Reinhart - Earth Song (1st Song) - Top 4 - American Idol 2011 - 05/11/11

[beriokhj]

and I just listend to the original song - Haley, I am pretty sure, Michael would have loved your interpretation!!! You did very very well, and you stuck very close to the original.

[beriokhj]

Haley is a fantastic singer - what really strange judges, at least two of them...

[MenInSlacks]

Randy at 1:35 haha :D

[undrawingend]

how can you beat original get a grip , but sang it it brilliant

[oscaralvaradoify]

@campushaw.... ikr!!!!!! lol

[luellarainn]

Casey made me laugh my head off! But haley did wonderful

[campushawn]

Look at jlo expression at 2.24 she looks like a bitchhhhhh. In your face haley is better than you. hahaha

[multiiloveadam]

@keborylam no ur beyond hope. Wtf is wrong with you? This is one of the most beautifully written songs and u sound like a complete moron when u say it's garbage. I feel for your children if u Eve get any..

[multiiloveadam]

@cbpizza4 they weren't judging Haley they bullied her every week abd its no secret everyone noticed. They were extra hard on her and went easy on the others. Both Randy and Jlo shouldn't be judging

[PedroYounisGoncalves]

she should have gone to the final "Lauren vs. Haley" it was the least it could have happened after the elimination of the great Pia! I was in shock with Haley! She really grew up, when she made it to top 13 i was like "she doesn't even sing that well..." and during the competition i was like "OMFG! :O". She IS a real superstar!

[Cbpizza4]

I hate it when you people write crap about what the judges say. Its their opinion!!! Haley is in a competition- if she cant take the criticism maybe this industry isnt for her...so build a bridge and get over it!

[rng4evr]

I watched this performance at least 20 times. Why duz it only hav 27207 views? lol I watched this enuf times to perform it exactly like her without watching..

[soccerfan07712]

@hecklord AGREED

[Artie25]

I'm so tired of Randy's "HaHaHa" :D + replay button oficialy got raped

[hecklord]

AI10 was a big dissapointment... there were many talented contestant in top 12 and we came up with 2 country tweens who sings mediocre as top 2..

[keborylam]

You are beyond hope. Please don't vote. Please do not have children.

[rng4evr]

Wow, I'm looking at the comments n 10 of them r from me... But that's just the first page... HALEY FOREVER!!!

[PrettyInPlaid92]

Haley did awesome with this song. I loved her here and I will always love her. But what really got me was the last two seconds of the video with Casey laughing and jumping for her(:

[rng4evr]

HALEY

[rng4evr]

Wow I love her! This my 5 time watching this... Today!

[rng4evr]

I watch this everyday:)

[rng4evr]

When she picks up n the group comes behind her, I feel so tingly..

[Youssymeerkat]

This performance is absolute perfection. When she starts growling...my heart stops for a second.

[rng4evr]

One of her best...

[12345RachelH]

Idk what to say O.o

[KimberlyST]

Haley is the best ever contestant on idol!! i am thrilled she has been signed and am looking forward to her first album!!! This girl is very unique and she can sing anything!!

[silversauceran]

I see Randy bobbing his head like he's totally into it. What's that about Randy? Can't you be honest and say she's amazing

[Hawkfeather1]

@keborylam obviously youre a fucking douchebag who knows absolutely nothing about good music

[rng4evr]

I loved this performance. The judges r just douche bags.

[razvan2525]

great !

[beast1022]

WOW - GET CHILLS NO MATTER WHICH VID I WATCH OF HALEYS PERFORMANCE - DAM SHES GOOD - HALEY 4EVER!!! SHE ROCKS!!!

[keborylam]

What a stupid song...but a beautiful rendition. Waste of her talent on such garbage lyrics.

[USERNAME2816]

@keborylam did you listen to the lyrics? cause you would'nt know it from that comment

[keborylam]

@USERNAME2816 I listened to the lyrics. G - A -R -B -A-G-E. Go hug a tree will you?

[USERNAME2816]

@keborylam 1. im not a tree hugger. 2. mj was one of the best song wirtters 3. your an idiot

[USERNAME2816]

@keborylam oh forgot to add HES TALKING ABOUT CHILDREN DIEING MAINLY NOT TREES YOU DIDENT LISTEN TO THE LYRICS IF YOU THINK THE SONG IS ABOUT TREES AND TREES ONLY. BACK TO #3 YOUR AN IDIOT

[keborylam]

@USERNAME2816 Ok, so Instead of hugging a tree you could hug a whale. According to MJ they are crying. It is nonsensical, infantile,, factually wrong kind of lyrics that would appeal to an intellectual midget you are proving to be (and a great speller too!).

[USERNAME2816]

@keborylam I dont care about spelling on youtube because it wont affect me latter in life so stop trying to be my granma cause you sound alot like her. 2. im not a midget im 5'11. 3. its black people hes talking about watch the music video.

[USERNAME2816]

@keborylam Whoops forgot the d in grandma my bad gonna get mad again? 

[Serena77Elvis]

She did this better then Micheal

[laserbeam898]

Vote for haley on faxo.com American Idol of the month by clicking the I am Human button or signing in with twitter and clicking haley! She's 4th so far but she needs a lot of votes to beat the top three! VOTE! Thumbs up so people can see!

[freyjaagustsdottir]

I love the move she does at 1:42 !! Hehe

This performance rocks! Go Haley!

I can't wait for when you do your own music :)

[KonigLeandro]

Haley does a great job in this video..it's actually one of her best...Randy Jackson is infuriating...it's time for the "dawg" to get the boot .

[hattiehedgehog]

@KonigLeandro it's just his opinion and thats why he's there! i disagree with him but people shouldn't get mad at him for expressing an opinion which he's paid to do

[hecklord]

14 people likes country tweens

[staceya1814]

hee hee wanna gurl

[rhettzkie]

fuck those people who clicked the dislike button!! .l. .l.

[TheNeverendingfire]

most underrated idol performer ever!

[DaGavinX]

Casey cheering for his girl, so cute!

[teddibearzluv]

and I loved how she sang from her heart =)

[teddibearzluv]

This was a incredible performance....I dint agree with the judges wen they said Haley yelled!? dont tell me MJ Dint yell :P

[Vikkiclark1999]



[21STEPS21]

"What About Natures Work"... (what about the rights of spring:), HALEY THIS IS SO NATURALLY SKILLED that you just gotta keep rockin it out, naturally! *WOW* YOU definetly flayed your fears, pro style, here! Shawn Jordan

[thedizzlecat]

james should have wom i cried when he left ROCK ON james!!!!!! Go for it dont let anything that stands in your path stop you!!!!!

[ubberJakerz]

@thedizzlecat while hes increadable, hes still not nearly as great as the top 2 or 3

[ccbutkus]

Obviously Randy has no clue about the original because MJ sceams more than Haley at the end. He should be embarrassed since he's supposedly knows everything about MJ's music.

[awesomegirls6]

people that didnt deserve to be voted off

Casey , he was awesome i love him :)

HALEY I WANTED HER TO WIN

Paul , he rocked , love his personality

James , rock will live on :)

[MatchesMalone242]

@awesomegirls6 it's a format problem. if it was a one vote per person (or even device; once per phone, once per computer/IP Address) then maybe they'd have had a chance. but people can vote 100 times for someone. so Lauren and Scotty might have had more votes, but in theory Haley could have had more individuals vote (just fewer times per on avg).

[lieytAA]

best performance eva !!!

[jazzinjanet]

another one jealous of Haley FYI Fantasia sucks you can't even compare Haley to Fantasia. Fantasia fits in with the rest. Haley is different and unique and can sing anything lets hear Fantasia sing Jazz the way Haley did............

[Eadr79]

One of the best

[MRTRENTONBEST]

ANYONE WHO DOES A MICHAEL JACKSON SON IS PUT TO THE TEST...NOT EASY TO COMPETE WITH THE GREAT JACKSON...GOOD JOB HALEY!

[staceya1814]

Look the lil girl is a wanna be r&b singer!!!! She displayed that when she sang Alisha keys song fallin! Jazz i'n the same a's r&b!!! She can't be fantasia and fantasia is r & b!!! Ya she cite but she was tooo sneakey hee hee wanna b!!!!

[eagle19612002]

@staceya1814  ur about stupid!

[SophandElly]

She has a beautiful voice, I'm upset that I can't vote to be honest, living in the UK. I absolutley love this song and praise her vocals so much. Such a gorgeous, talented girl that is underrated by everyone apart from Steve Tyler. We all love Steve.

[seff503]

sorry but Charice version is better!

[iloveu53785]

the judge -besides steven are deaf

[elva2011]

Haley is so underrated! The judges always praise everyone even when they're just ok but with Haley they are always really tough. I really hope she makes top 2!!!

[awesomegirls6]

@elva2011 too bad she didnt :(

[puurplephoto]

She did amazing. Idk what they meant by "screaming". To me it looked like she was really feeling and I would scream it too lol GO HALEY!

[603xxg]

GO HALEY!!!!

[SavagePersonified90]

This was BY FAR the best of the inspirational songs. Haley has so much passion for what she is singing about, it is breathtaking.

[ec5798]

watching it back a second time, i realize this lot better than i originally thought. stupid judges are getting into my brain!

Go Haley!

[livioangel]

wow 

[jumptoit3]

I got chills. I could really sense her passion.

[LOVEADAMLABERT3068]

@jumptoit3 I have them to this girl can Sang she has my VOTES

[hattiehedgehog]

randy was just giving his opinion and thats what he's there to do but what jennifer said was unnecesary! saying good things and then saying that negative thing about song choice, i don't think she's a good judge

[Allan39]

The one artist that has progressively got better and better, its more than well done it's Great !!! she needs to make a record with this song, the house of the rising sun and I who have nothing, all are brilliant

Thanks

[Marmaidena]

Love

[chinzebo]

She just gets better and better...I am pleased and she may go on to do some BIG things!!

[lkane90]

*Click love button*

[JackieJax41]

This girl is good, she gave me goose bumps, Michael would be soooo proud of her.....

[dedee152]

Haley would have made Michael proud they way she sung this song. Randy and Jennifer are losing it. Thank God Stephen spoke up and gave Haley the best advice. Don't listen to Randy and Jennifer they are wrong. She will be the next American Idol for sure.

[rosepetal108]

@dedee152 Agreed. They are all good, but this was best song of the night hands down. Even better than her second song. Seriously! I love all 4 final contestants each in their own way but come on. This was brilliant!

No other song put a tear in my eye, but this sure did.

[kennethrhuvic]

Haley my american Idol!! Jlo and Randy are both losers!!!

[oke00306]

i just got mad when j-lo and randy start judging her,,,

i love steven tyler

[helloimsarah100]

I voted for haley 103 times last night (:

and this morning i voted another 30 times!

THIS IS THE BEST PERFORMANCE ON THE IDOL STAGE IN YEARS!

Haley needs to win American Idol this year, she deserves it so much more than lauren or scotty! Haley & James for the final would be EPIC!! REINHART for the WIN!!! (:

[oke00306]

@helloimsarah100

100% agree... if the top 2 aren't haley and james, thats gonna be the anticlimacs for this greatest season...

just like season 8, when the best not win...

i just can't wait to see the result!!!

[helloimsarah100]

@oke00306

RIGHT!!! (:

im excited myself! add me on here so we can be friends (:

[oke00306]

HALEY FOR IDOL

i vote for her straight almost two hours

i just can't be calm, after the greatest performance in stage ever, but the judge seems dont like it.. thats looks crazy!!! she move me to vote... perhaps she move us america

[grannygiggles]

@oke00306 This is why there needs to be a vote limit per number. The unlimited votes turn a talent contest into a popularity one. And even after your 2hrs of calling, some 13yr old girl in Iowa probably voted twice as much for Scotty.

[nuvamusic]

For me, this was really good, and way better than her second performance.

What were the judges -namely JLo and Randy- smoking???

[nooriskandar]

Haley Reinhart- 1-866-436-5702 and 1-866-436-5706

vote guys. this is WAR!