Look. two hundred and 40 thousand Irishmen fought in the first war and that was just the irish regiments. This song is written by a Scot. And its not stated what country Willy Mc bride was from. It doesnt fucken Matter. The fact is the song is sung by scots and Irish alike in rememberance. I think that was the aim of the writter. If ye keep taking Shite about "whos song it is" Your missing the unity. Stop living in the past ye stupid uneducated fucks.
Great song!I heard someone sing this on the karaoke about 4 years ago and it took everyone,s attention,including mine (and I had never heard it before).I now sing it myself on here the way I thought it was sung,but since I,ve came on here I don,think I,ve heard 2 similar versions,check mine,under my name.
And this is afterall a Scotsman's song w/him sitting alongside a forgotten Irish Lad's grave w/nary a bone in it!
When Bogle claimed the writing of it in Ireland he barely escaped w/em claiming The Fureys wrote it. Clearly the Pipes and Fife in the lyrics are derived from the Scots playing of "Flowers of the Forest"!
Remember, more than anything, this song is about the "War to End All Wars"! "The Forgotten War" repeated time n again through history & even today, in these games children play!
Yeah, apparently he was hiking through France, on the border of Belgium, and it was getting kind of late, and no cars were coming, so he hopped over a wall to camp. Well, he found a nice patch of grass and set up tent, he then awoke in the morning in a graveyard, and found Willy McBride's grave and wrote is song at his tomb stone. If you notice, the lyrics are asking Willy questions, and indeed he did the same, the day he met poor Willy.
MarkoFritzgig meant no disrespect in this. He brings awareness of how little we value human life in Real War & Games alike!
Exactly what Bogle emphasized in his songs on the fallen in a forgotten War. His view, was War was a futile endeavor, that leaves only loss in it's wake!
In War Lives drop like flies and leave us w/vague memories, grave stones & Lives wasted. Bogle's songs sing of this!
Killing Games played today, leave no time to care for Life, Death or Honour, just as in Real Life!
that is not how its sang you twat and its just horibble to play that song with that crappy game i mean really im try`n to find th original by the Irish Rovers
To you the youtube user MarkoFritzgig who put this tripe on here: This is a song which is to be respected and not fu!@ed up with. Now I don't know if you made this video or just copied it from somewhere else, but either way it was done in extremely bad taste. My god man, try and have a little respect. See the bird, well do ya see it? You should cuz I'm holding it up to the screen aimed at you right now!
irishboysalford, better check your history mate. there was no conscription on the island of ireland. 36st ulster were a volunteer division. 16th irish (johnny redmonds nationalist volunteers) and 10th irish was `regular`army where volunteers went all during the war. this song is not about an irish soldier but A SOLDIER. it just happens the irish took this to their hearts as we suffered as much as anybody-and didn`t talk about it.
Your talking a load of crap, The Irish don't talk about it? that's got to be the biggest joke going, the songs about any solder who died in the great war, Willie McBride just happens to rhyme with grave side.
if you know anything at all about irish history hetrodoxly -the unionists celebrated their part in the war and still do. the nationalists didn`t(until recently) as they came back from the trenches to a distinctly anti british climate in ireland after the easter rising. it was something to be forgotten quickly and not talked about. me? i think this attitude was criminal. it was even scrubbed out in school text books of the time. and i said this wasn`t about an irish soldier or can`t you read?
Maybe i can't read because i was born and raised in a pre "celtic" (1970s) Kerry, every ordinary working man in the British isles had a hard time, white Englishmen were bonded into slavery and sent to the west Indies to slave with the blacks, it's about time we got over ourselves,
But had they died by Pearse's side
Or fought with Valera true
Their graves we'd would keep where the Fenians sleep
me i was brought up in the 70`s in pre celtic scotland-to irish parents that had to emigrate. i liked the country enough to come home when i was old enough-if your so bothered about all of this come back. and the choice of your song is apt being an anti `british army song` but you may at least get the lyrics right the second verse is-or fought with cathal brugha. and the point is if we don`t remember ourselves-nobody else gives a shit. me i know who i am you obviously have a problem re identity.
hossie give you a couple of clues-france isn`t in dublin-and no gas or barbed wire were used in dublin and theres no countless white crosses in the sand in dublin or anywhere else in dublin for that matter oh and the lament `flowers of the forest` was virtually only played by scottish regiments. now away like a good lad and google `eric bogle` the man who wrote the song-it might help you understand it better. !!!DUH!!!
hahahaha wow calm !!! and im not a lad im a girl !!!!! soooooorrrrrryyyyyy !!!!!!i got it wrong dont need to take it so seriously !!!!! its a brill song !!!!!! and im also irish so relax a bit stop getting worked up !!!!! i heard 1916 and thought it was about that !!!!
aye ok hossie! you just wouldn`t believe how many from this country get it wrong and can`t be told other wise! and it is a brill song-also check out-and the band played waltzing matilda-sung by liam clancy-another cracker by eric bogle.
I can appreciate the idea, but yeah, kind of tasteless mate. And I concur with the poor editing. You could have made this alot easier to take and avoided some flak by making it follow the song more.
this song is about an irish man conscripted to the british army like many others had no choice in the matter and was put on the front line to protect the british heros.
i totaly agree it is total crap to put a video like this to accompany a song such as this,,,if this is respect for what those people did for us then all i can say god help us all, where would we be if not for brave that fought for us
I seriously hope this was an atept at irony,to put a song about the waste of unessisary war with a game thats basically mindlessly kill everything in front of you
thats so disrespectful to those who fell in the first world war. you cant compare a war where people lost lives to some computer game! i mean fair enough, play the game but dont put a song like this over it and call yourself "willy mcbride" just wrong mate.
its about a soldier in ww1 he says. no let me tell u wot the real meaning of the song is. its saying what were they really fighting for what did they die for, well hang on was it really worth it. but we still remember you. you are heroes and shall never be forgotten.
Scottish-Australian singer-songwriter Eric Bogle 1976. It has a few names: "Willie Mcbride", "The green fields of France" and "No Man's Land".
The 19 years old Ptv. William McBride is buried in Authuille British Cemetery, near Albert and Beaumont-Hamel, where the Inniskilling Fusilliers were deployed as part of the 29th Division.
As far as i know, Eric Bogle was just the first one to actually record it and to make it famous. As far as me relatives toled me, the song was a folk song long time befor that.
as someone who grew up with this song would like to say this is a great cover, but what you,ve done with the video is amazing, and really fits, can tell you,ve understood it
Eric has written a sequel 30 years later called "Hallowed Ground" - have a hunt for it.
rdvqc 3 months ago
i hope u all died fast n n clean boys,,,,rip,,,matt
mattshep29 2 years ago
yea sure, ww2 game uhu . . . .
garaapje 2 years ago
ha he said willy
lrtmacca 2 years ago
Well said!
vanillabearno12 2 years ago
Look. two hundred and 40 thousand Irishmen fought in the first war and that was just the irish regiments. This song is written by a Scot. And its not stated what country Willy Mc bride was from. It doesnt fucken Matter. The fact is the song is sung by scots and Irish alike in rememberance. I think that was the aim of the writter. If ye keep taking Shite about "whos song it is" Your missing the unity. Stop living in the past ye stupid uneducated fucks.
corporal747 2 years ago 4
:O Willy fought monsters?!!?!?! :O
Penanera 2 years ago
war games, about a song rmembering war heroes?
some may find this very disrespectful
LawrenceBarclay 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i'm irish and can i just say, as a proud irishman, this is really funny
Frankieireland 3 years ago
Great song!I heard someone sing this on the karaoke about 4 years ago and it took everyone,s attention,including mine (and I had never heard it before).I now sing it myself on here the way I thought it was sung,but since I,ve came on here I don,think I,ve heard 2 similar versions,check mine,under my name.
JohnMcCash 3 years ago
And this is afterall a Scotsman's song w/him sitting alongside a forgotten Irish Lad's grave w/nary a bone in it!
When Bogle claimed the writing of it in Ireland he barely escaped w/em claiming The Fureys wrote it. Clearly the Pipes and Fife in the lyrics are derived from the Scots playing of "Flowers of the Forest"!
Remember, more than anything, this song is about the "War to End All Wars"! "The Forgotten War" repeated time n again through history & even today, in these games children play!
mysonyps3 3 years ago
Yeah, apparently he was hiking through France, on the border of Belgium, and it was getting kind of late, and no cars were coming, so he hopped over a wall to camp. Well, he found a nice patch of grass and set up tent, he then awoke in the morning in a graveyard, and found Willy McBride's grave and wrote is song at his tomb stone. If you notice, the lyrics are asking Willy questions, and indeed he did the same, the day he met poor Willy.
KurzWebber 3 years ago
MarkoFritzgig meant no disrespect in this. He brings awareness of how little we value human life in Real War & Games alike!
Exactly what Bogle emphasized in his songs on the fallen in a forgotten War. His view, was War was a futile endeavor, that leaves only loss in it's wake!
In War Lives drop like flies and leave us w/vague memories, grave stones & Lives wasted. Bogle's songs sing of this!
Killing Games played today, leave no time to care for Life, Death or Honour, just as in Real Life!
mysonyps3 3 years ago
you are so disrespectfull!
dancefreeklovetosing 3 years ago
your such a twat for disrespecting this song and what it stands for with you playing a stupid game. I am disgusted.
Buzz011 3 years ago
that is not how its sang you twat and its just horibble to play that song with that crappy game i mean really im try`n to find th original by the Irish Rovers
Sincerly: Meservius
meservius 3 years ago
To you the youtube user MarkoFritzgig who put this tripe on here: This is a song which is to be respected and not fu!@ed up with. Now I don't know if you made this video or just copied it from somewhere else, but either way it was done in extremely bad taste. My god man, try and have a little respect. See the bird, well do ya see it? You should cuz I'm holding it up to the screen aimed at you right now!
AndrewDeLong 3 years ago
dont mock this song its serious...its not funny
BassAce111 3 years ago
irishboysalford, better check your history mate. there was no conscription on the island of ireland. 36st ulster were a volunteer division. 16th irish (johnny redmonds nationalist volunteers) and 10th irish was `regular`army where volunteers went all during the war. this song is not about an irish soldier but A SOLDIER. it just happens the irish took this to their hearts as we suffered as much as anybody-and didn`t talk about it.
restlesswave 3 years ago
Your talking a load of crap, The Irish don't talk about it? that's got to be the biggest joke going, the songs about any solder who died in the great war, Willie McBride just happens to rhyme with grave side.
hetrodoxly 3 years ago
if you know anything at all about irish history hetrodoxly -the unionists celebrated their part in the war and still do. the nationalists didn`t(until recently) as they came back from the trenches to a distinctly anti british climate in ireland after the easter rising. it was something to be forgotten quickly and not talked about. me? i think this attitude was criminal. it was even scrubbed out in school text books of the time. and i said this wasn`t about an irish soldier or can`t you read?
restlesswave 3 years ago
Maybe i can't read because i was born and raised in a pre "celtic" (1970s) Kerry, every ordinary working man in the British isles had a hard time, white Englishmen were bonded into slavery and sent to the west Indies to slave with the blacks, it's about time we got over ourselves,
But had they died by Pearse's side
Or fought with Valera true
Their graves we'd would keep where the Fenians sleep
'Neath the hills of the foggy dew
The Irish weren't the only one's there.
hetrodoxly 3 years ago
me i was brought up in the 70`s in pre celtic scotland-to irish parents that had to emigrate. i liked the country enough to come home when i was old enough-if your so bothered about all of this come back. and the choice of your song is apt being an anti `british army song` but you may at least get the lyrics right the second verse is-or fought with cathal brugha. and the point is if we don`t remember ourselves-nobody else gives a shit. me i know who i am you obviously have a problem re identity.
restlesswave 3 years ago
the song is clearly about a young soldier that died in 1916 at the easter rising !!!duh!!!
hossie88 3 years ago
hossie give you a couple of clues-france isn`t in dublin-and no gas or barbed wire were used in dublin and theres no countless white crosses in the sand in dublin or anywhere else in dublin for that matter oh and the lament `flowers of the forest` was virtually only played by scottish regiments. now away like a good lad and google `eric bogle` the man who wrote the song-it might help you understand it better. !!!DUH!!!
restlesswave 3 years ago
hahahaha wow calm !!! and im not a lad im a girl !!!!! soooooorrrrrryyyyyy !!!!!!i got it wrong dont need to take it so seriously !!!!! its a brill song !!!!!! and im also irish so relax a bit stop getting worked up !!!!! i heard 1916 and thought it was about that !!!!
hossie88 3 years ago 2
aye ok hossie! you just wouldn`t believe how many from this country get it wrong and can`t be told other wise! and it is a brill song-also check out-and the band played waltzing matilda-sung by liam clancy-another cracker by eric bogle.
restlesswave 3 years ago 2
haha !!!! i only heard the song last year and thought WOW what a tune !!! im also 19 like lol !!!!!! il be checkin them out
hossie88 3 years ago
you dont really understand what this song is. i hope you are a teenager , because if your not you need to grow up.
slayer310mike 3 years ago
I can appreciate the idea, but yeah, kind of tasteless mate. And I concur with the poor editing. You could have made this alot easier to take and avoided some flak by making it follow the song more.
Rodgin88 3 years ago
u compare a man's death to a stupid video game? disrespectful..
irishpride26 3 years ago 4
this song is about an irish man conscripted to the british army like many others had no choice in the matter and was put on the front line to protect the british heros.
irishboysalford 3 years ago
What a load of crap.
hetrodoxly 3 years ago
i totaly agree it is total crap to put a video like this to accompany a song such as this,,,if this is respect for what those people did for us then all i can say god help us all, where would we be if not for brave that fought for us
padderuk 3 years ago
I seriously hope this was an atept at irony,to put a song about the waste of unessisary war with a game thats basically mindlessly kill everything in front of you
Sate12 4 years ago
This is an anal assraping of a great song.
Frank12391NL 4 years ago
it's not even edited to the video correctly... =/ it could be a kickass video if you knew how to cut it.
panzertortoise 4 years ago
wtf this song doesent go with the game at all
fuckinscott 4 years ago
thats so disrespectful to those who fell in the first world war. you cant compare a war where people lost lives to some computer game! i mean fair enough, play the game but dont put a song like this over it and call yourself "willy mcbride" just wrong mate.
BabyyEmilyy 4 years ago 3
its about a soldier in ww1 he says. no let me tell u wot the real meaning of the song is. its saying what were they really fighting for what did they die for, well hang on was it really worth it. but we still remember you. you are heroes and shall never be forgotten.
brotherdevil 4 years ago
"Green Fields of France" by Dropkick Murphys. This is a modified version, faster than the original. It is about a soldier who died during WW One
icebro 4 years ago
absolutly brill this is the best song ever it stops people in our country from fighting because people from both sides fought in WW1
buckfastvictim 4 years ago
wait, can you tell me the history of this song, like who wrote it and where it origianated from?
thanks
winch19904 4 years ago
Scottish-Australian singer-songwriter Eric Bogle 1976. It has a few names: "Willie Mcbride", "The green fields of France" and "No Man's Land".
The 19 years old Ptv. William McBride is buried in Authuille British Cemetery, near Albert and Beaumont-Hamel, where the Inniskilling Fusilliers were deployed as part of the 29th Division.
jacksawild 4 years ago
thanks a lot man, i really appreciate it, i love the song, but until now, it never had any meaning!
winch19904 4 years ago
You're welcome. It is a great song with true meaning; unlike some of the stuff that litters our charts and airwaves these days.
jacksawild 4 years ago
haha i totaly agree! haha great song...
pat1219904 4 years ago
As far as i know, Eric Bogle was just the first one to actually record it and to make it famous. As far as me relatives toled me, the song was a folk song long time befor that.
scousepunk 4 years ago
great song, gay song.
winch19904 4 years ago
nice blend of a contemporary video with a historic song...people must understand this!
colinnats 4 years ago
is this dropkick murphys.. i tyring to download this song.. its amazing
shaunAKAegghead 4 years ago
yes this is the drop kick murphy's...
winch19904 4 years ago
as someone who grew up with this song would like to say this is a great cover, but what you,ve done with the video is amazing, and really fits, can tell you,ve understood it
joniper85 4 years ago
stupid game
gavroche67 4 years ago
A very inappropriate combination of music and video.
Cliodule 4 years ago
I LOVE THIS SONG! But the video makes it suck.......
oivia12 4 years ago
very good version of the song pity bout the video
TmoneyBallyhar 4 years ago
Can't argue with that.
MarkoFritzgig 4 years ago
klass song!
mossy121c 4 years ago
good song but whats the video.
Fionnstaines 5 years ago
It's a guy running through the Unreal Tournament, fighting for survival until he dies, overwhelmed by enemies.
MarkoFritzgig 5 years ago
loce this version so much more full w. the paino
x84caveman84 5 years ago