Moonshoes got the "idea." I was thinking the same thing. The reason why JD was so upset at "him" dying -- it wasn't the old guy. It was Ben. With any other patient, JD wouldn't have been so crushed and Cox wouldn't have had a total meltdown. This episode was like the Sixth Sense. You have to watch it more than once.
You can tell Ben is already dead as he says in part 1 that he will be taking picture till the day he dies, but in this part his camera is gone and only doctor Cox is speaking to him
i didn't realize certain things when I've this the first time, but after seeing it 5 times i see more and understand..... i don't like the things I understand!!!
@LadyLatias One way is through infection (the most common cause) due to the lack of an immune system. Another reason is that the cancer cells can get into the spinal cord or the brain and cause the patient to lose control of their nervous system, which can lead to cardiac arrest.
why is JD making fun of turk for having a "butt face" when he had the same thing done to his forehead when his brother wrote PROM! on it with that permanent marker?
ben said he would be the weird guy who takes his camera everywhere till the day he dies, once dr cox gets back he isnt wearing it anymore, this show is so clever with the suttle clues it gives you into whats really going on
There's a very easy way to see when the Ben you see isn't the real one anymore. The real Ben claims himself that he'll carry his camera around til the day he dies. 2:25 is the very first time in this episode that you see him without his camera and he even picks his shirt to make the audience notice somethings missing. Meaning he's already dead at that point.
I think everyone is misunderstanding it. The old guy didn't die, thats the point. You're supposed to think he died but it was actually Ben. Thats why Ben now only talks to dr Cox, because he is the only one who can see him. He also no longer carries his camera - "until the day I die."
this was the first time id seen this episode. just finished the 3rd part but obviously had to see this again! ben was following JD when JD was pushing the wheelchair. Now i see why. Why else would ben go with JD.Theyre not friends.
could it be that ben's just a ghost? since this old guy died and jd's blamed for that dr. cox just talks to ben and nobody else speaks to him or even sees him.. so what do you think?
jd is also a buttface, remember a few episodes back with the janitor and the pen that didn't come off? he had a flashback when "PROM" was written on his head with that type of pen and he rambled about buttskin.
I really don't think that Ben should have died he was funny awesome and cool and above all that cox likes him it would have been nice if cox had at least one person to talk to
@rachg01 I assume he dies at 1:06 when JD's pager goes off and he says " that's a code." After that we see him without his trademark symbolizing that he is dead.
@weirdguy75 he had cancer and it went into remission but he never checked up after he left. cox tells jd to check up on his condition but it's too late already - it's already spread. he goes into cardiac arrest and dies when cox leaves. spoiler alert
what I haven't been able to figure out is Cox runs out to bail out a dude while Ben was fine then all of a sudden he croaks. Sounds like Perry was out no more than 45 minutes. How could Ben go from totally healthy to dead in that time frame?
I just had a mind blowing moment... the patient that died was Ben, not the old man. I may be wrong, but I think it's one of those tricky double things. I am I the only one who just noticed this because I'm feeling a little thick. =P
@cobra1x3 lol it took me sometime to figure that out too. coz i was thinking how the hell did ben die, then i remembered JD said someone died so it must of been Ben and if you think about it no-one really talked to Ben after JD said he died. Ahh confusing yet heart- wrenching
Yes that's right, Ben did die, as we see in the next part, and after JD announces the news to Dr Cox, the Ben we see in the rest of the scenes up until the funeral is from Dr Cox's subconscious, as he feels guilty.
Mostly due to having to bail out the DUI guy, and he also blames JD for leaving him in charge,
even though Ben had leukaemia and there wasn't a lot either of them could do.
It's a sad episode, but also one of my favourites.
Yes that's right, Ben did die, as we see in the next part, and after JD announces the news to Dr Cox, the Ben we see in the rest of the scenes up until the funeral is from Dr Cox's subconscious, as he feels guilty.
Mostly due to having to bail out the DUI guy, therefore not being with Ben at the hospital, and he also blames JD for leaving him in charge,
even though Ben had leukaemia and there wasn't a lot either of them could do.
It's a sad episode, but also one of my favourites.
SPOILER ALERT! Dont read comments till you finish this episode.....
nick2099j 2 weeks ago 5
you had to spoil it in the top comments of course you did
LibertyWaxlips 1 month ago
in case you came back from 3/3, here you go 2:12
studystrike 1 month ago
this is one of the saddest episodes of scrubs
rocker103 2 months ago
Jd was a butt face first. He had to get the prom sign from his forehead
BlackFlag2006 3 months ago
Elliot: Oh c'mon, no one gonna call you names...Turk: I know, but -- JD: Face!!!
that was EPIC
Norw3gianMoos3 3 months ago
@Norw3gianMoos3 Turks sad face after hearing this makes me laugh :D
86ntx86 1 month ago
But face XD
ThePBandJSandwich 4 months ago
Please don't like comments that tell the point!
For those who watch Scrubs the first time....
mathefreak1993 4 months ago 11
Moonshoes got the "idea." I was thinking the same thing. The reason why JD was so upset at "him" dying -- it wasn't the old guy. It was Ben. With any other patient, JD wouldn't have been so crushed and Cox wouldn't have had a total meltdown. This episode was like the Sixth Sense. You have to watch it more than once.
tracyblogger 4 months ago
2:18 Pretty sure JD is talking about ben.
FabrielOne 5 months ago
@FabrielOne he is, but when ben is walking around after that its just a trick of dr. cox's imagination
dempsonator 5 months ago
nice hand... I meant the cards hahahah
Ur0pinionDoesntCount 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
JD's a butt face as well remember "PROM"
jamiejohnson2196 5 months ago
I had never noticed that mole before this episode...
RainbowTourmaline 5 months ago
You can tell Ben is already dead as he says in part 1 that he will be taking picture till the day he dies, but in this part his camera is gone and only doctor Cox is speaking to him
verySkillfulTKS 5 months ago
Whatever Butt face.
EjvindDark 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i love ben =)
seravox 5 months ago
Comment removed
seravox 5 months ago
I finally got it. Ben died when JD told Cox he went into cardiac arrest. I thought it was the guy in the wheelchair.
pps22001 6 months ago
@pps22001 That was the point! I thought that too. but they sometime talk about reception (funeral) n stuff. you have to listen closely tho...
WTFadtheking 5 months ago
@pps22001 oh also you notice how NOONE talks to ben or even NOTICE him
WTFadtheking 5 months ago
when Turk reached out and Carla slapped his arm away... it reminded me of Elf :D
TheCheeselover3000 6 months ago
02:46 no camera...
Matt561 6 months ago
@Matt561 :( It's so sad. I couldn't believe it and I started crying.
crybabygirl08 6 months ago
leonard the afro guy had a jerrycurl at first
SuperNoobforlife 6 months ago
chris "buttface" turk
SuperNoobforlife 6 months ago
gosh i love Ben!
robhondenkop2 6 months ago
That code was Ben dying
menwoolover1 7 months ago
@menwoolover1 Oh.... Thank you for explaining; I was confused.
132411guy 7 months ago
@132411guy yea i thought the old guy in the wheelchair died lol
souldragon121 7 months ago
"Dr Kelso i think i found a way this effects one of your loved ones....it effects me?"
"Swing and a miss Ted!"
RockStar12521 7 months ago
Homeless guy shoulda run off with the watch
xBigetto 7 months ago
yes Carla
feel GUILTY! feel VERY GUILTY! i don't even understand how turk stands this chick
05290066 7 months ago
isn't jd a butt face too? from when his brother drew PROM! on his forehead with black marker?
theMOLLY2211 7 months ago
when i first saw this i didn't know it was ban that died. i thought it was the guy that JD said OH MY GOD HE'S GONNA DIE.
then realised that ben said he would carry his camera round till he died and then he didn't have it. god im slow
300Alex1 7 months ago
wen i first saw this i knew it was ben that died since jd stopped interacting with him but i didn't wanna face it for som reason lol
nwolwo 7 months ago
mrs. carla butt face !!! hahahahah
AGponycat 8 months ago
This is such a smart episode, i didnt get it at first but its amazing how it turns out. Favourite episode ever.
wowowoowowowowwo 8 months ago
i didn't realize certain things when I've this the first time, but after seeing it 5 times i see more and understand..... i don't like the things I understand!!!
TheGreatOmegaDragon 8 months ago
nice hand... i meant the cards!
marissawtts 8 months ago
I just realized the irony in this part of the episode-Dr. Cox tells JD that the old guy isn't going to die in the next 30 mins, but then Ben does :(
Bookgrl98 8 months ago
Ben doesn't have his camera! :(
Bookgrl98 8 months ago
Just outta curiousity, how does leukemia cause cardiac arrest?
LadyLatias 9 months ago
@LadyLatias One way is through infection (the most common cause) due to the lack of an immune system. Another reason is that the cancer cells can get into the spinal cord or the brain and cause the patient to lose control of their nervous system, which can lead to cardiac arrest.
saturnoutlaw 9 months ago
why is JD making fun of turk for having a "butt face" when he had the same thing done to his forehead when his brother wrote PROM! on it with that permanent marker?
KadeTurner35 9 months ago 6
i though JD was kiding at first cuz Ben was righ tbehind Cox i thought they were messin with Cox, playing a joke
breeship 9 months ago
0:41 THE BEE GUY!
BejnXander 10 months ago
ben said he would be the weird guy who takes his camera everywhere till the day he dies, once dr cox gets back he isnt wearing it anymore, this show is so clever with the suttle clues it gives you into whats really going on
Tom94zr 10 months ago 34
that hurt here and here
marissawtts 10 months ago
best alarm clock ever.... hahahaha
buwaneka66 10 months ago
@appletinihamshire it Starts As soon As JD says his heart stopped beating...
sweetLolly01 10 months ago
@appletinihampshire it Beginns As soon As JD says: His Heart stopped beating 20 minutes after you left.
sweetLolly01 10 months ago
spoiler: is he talking to the real ben at this point or not? now that i know the ending, i'm wondering when the fantasy began.
appletinihamshire 11 months ago
@appletinihamshire
There's a very easy way to see when the Ben you see isn't the real one anymore. The real Ben claims himself that he'll carry his camera around til the day he dies. 2:25 is the very first time in this episode that you see him without his camera and he even picks his shirt to make the audience notice somethings missing. Meaning he's already dead at that point.
SealOfHatred 9 months ago
Yes, It's so smart to walk around talking to a spirt in a hospital, it's not like they have a psych ward
TheCheeselover3000 1 year ago
Wtf, i didn't even realize Turks mole xD
iluvyeww1 1 year ago
I think everyone is misunderstanding it. The old guy didn't die, thats the point. You're supposed to think he died but it was actually Ben. Thats why Ben now only talks to dr Cox, because he is the only one who can see him. He also no longer carries his camera - "until the day I die."
MoonshoesArtemis 1 year ago 57
Ben does die in the next 30 minutes...=(
DragonSpeedful 1 year ago
2:25 when ben comes in frame, he no longer has his camera. Ben said he would carry it to the day he died...
Dman9612 1 year ago
@Dman9612 thats the point
marissawtts 1 year ago
my god ur gonna die !!!!!!
bar11bar 1 year ago
this was the first time id seen this episode. just finished the 3rd part but obviously had to see this again! ben was following JD when JD was pushing the wheelchair. Now i see why. Why else would ben go with JD.Theyre not friends.
jecka1982 1 year ago
@jecka1982 ben was following him because he needed some tests done for his cancer
MrMidgetman1996 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@jecka1982 ben was following him because he needed some tests done for his cancer
MrMidgetman1996 1 year ago
the kid screwed up!
okay! DARN KID!
demiselenanightlife 1 year ago
at 2.26 zach's voice goes soo deep! it's almost normal. LOL
teafortwoplease 1 year ago 2
There she goes, Mrs Carla Butt-Face
tomsmiler 1 year ago
could it be that ben's just a ghost? since this old guy died and jd's blamed for that dr. cox just talks to ben and nobody else speaks to him or even sees him.. so what do you think?
crazychick1605 1 year ago
@crazychick1605 he is cuz then y would cox be freaking out. he usually doesnt when a reg patient dies
marissawtts 1 year ago
jd is also a buttface, remember a few episodes back with the janitor and the pen that didn't come off? he had a flashback when "PROM" was written on his head with that type of pen and he rambled about buttskin.
IGiveCommentary 1 year ago
The bum at 3:54 reminds of Vicent from Beauty and the Beast (series)
merdelune9 1 year ago
I laugh everytime at "Darn kid!"
scrubs4everr 1 year ago
surgeon was the creepy guy in seinfeld that was helping elaine with the cataloge
IndianaBoy84 1 year ago
Not to be that guy, but when J.D calls Turk a butt face, isn't he being a hypocrite considering the Prom prank Dan pulled on him?
deutschland08fn 1 year ago 3
I really don't think that Ben should have died he was funny awesome and cool and above all that cox likes him it would have been nice if cox had at least one person to talk to
joshuabouwman 1 year ago
Drunken human alarm clock was awesome.
CactusJackManson1 1 year ago
isnt JD also buttface from when his dad wrote "PROM!" on his forehead?
usacommunist 1 year ago 3
Haha,nurse Snickers
epik78 1 year ago
oh i get it now. the patient that we thought was dead is alive (i think thats him) at 3:21
rachg01 1 year ago
it'd be nice to know when he died
rachg01 1 year ago
@rachg01 I assume he dies at 1:06 when JD's pager goes off and he says " that's a code." After that we see him without his trademark symbolizing that he is dead.
jshspeight 1 year ago 2
@jshspeight yeah probably.
rachg01 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@weirdguy75 he had cancer and it went into remission but he never checked up after he left. cox tells jd to check up on his condition but it's too late already - it's already spread. he goes into cardiac arrest and dies when cox leaves. spoiler alert
papajy 1 year ago
what I haven't been able to figure out is Cox runs out to bail out a dude while Ben was fine then all of a sudden he croaks. Sounds like Perry was out no more than 45 minutes. How could Ben go from totally healthy to dead in that time frame?
weirdguy75 1 year ago
@weirdguy75 JD said he went into cardiac arrest. That's a heart attack. They can happen at any time, or at least come out of nowhere.
Keimatsu 1 year ago
Comment removed
papajy 1 year ago
Comment removed
papajy 1 year ago
Comment removed
papajy 1 year ago
Oh. My. God. Is Dr Cox growing a beard?
RatsMyHeart 1 year ago
what is kelso eating at 1:19? it looks like granola and butter. Ew.
The kid screwed up. *tears and wrinkled forehead*
BEEP BEEP BEEP!
but........... FACE
MeIsSmarticle 1 year ago
I just had a mind blowing moment... the patient that died was Ben, not the old man. I may be wrong, but I think it's one of those tricky double things. I am I the only one who just noticed this because I'm feeling a little thick. =P
cobra1x3 1 year ago
@cobra1x3 No i'm pretty sure you're right :)
EmilyStation1994 1 year ago
@cobra1x3 wait ben as in jordans brother
ellegirlrocks 1 year ago
@cobra1x3 lol it took me sometime to figure that out too. coz i was thinking how the hell did ben die, then i remembered JD said someone died so it must of been Ben and if you think about it no-one really talked to Ben after JD said he died. Ahh confusing yet heart- wrenching
TaiiwoBaybee 1 year ago
people who put their "heritage" over their loved ones are annoying.
carla is my least favorite character on the show.
adrasvaiyen 1 year ago
Poor Kelso at 1:44.
yoyopeiyn 1 year ago
So you're gonna be a buttface!
nickz0rz 1 year ago
2:20 ish i think jd was talking about jordans brother not the old man
watashiwaninja 1 year ago 2
Comment removed
Salma448 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@watashiwaninja @watashiwaninja
Yes that's right, Ben did die, as we see in the next part, and after JD announces the news to Dr Cox, the Ben we see in the rest of the scenes up until the funeral is from Dr Cox's subconscious, as he feels guilty.
Mostly due to having to bail out the DUI guy, and he also blames JD for leaving him in charge,
even though Ben had leukaemia and there wasn't a lot either of them could do.
It's a sad episode, but also one of my favourites.
x
Salma448 1 year ago
Yes that's right, Ben did die, as we see in the next part, and after JD announces the news to Dr Cox, the Ben we see in the rest of the scenes up until the funeral is from Dr Cox's subconscious, as he feels guilty.
Mostly due to having to bail out the DUI guy, therefore not being with Ben at the hospital, and he also blames JD for leaving him in charge,
even though Ben had leukaemia and there wasn't a lot either of them could do.
It's a sad episode, but also one of my favourites.
x
Salma448 1 year ago
@Salma448 It was tricky to understand. I went back and re-watched it. It's up there in my top episodes too :)
watashiwaninja 1 year ago
@Salma448 Thanks for clearing that up!! i was so confused lol :]
r0b3rt0nr8x 1 year ago
I don't wanna play the next part :(
redalader 1 year ago 235
@redalader Yeah, this is possibly the saddest episode.
Yedaddy1234 1 year ago
@redalader
one of the most emotional parts in t.v.
jackwuzhear 11 months ago
carla is dumb
zico739 1 year ago
@zico739 agreed.
jaraefields1 1 year ago
i know but
FACE!
XD
brotherjames10 1 year ago 114