Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (297)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • EN VERDAD LAMENTO QUE NO HAYA QUEDADO ENTRE LOS 13, ES EL MEJOR!

  • Idol would have been much more entertaining had the kept Reed, Creighton and Wolf!!

  • reed grimm is the world or universe idol, american idol is so tiny for he. In Brazil we like it.

  • He seems like he's enjoying himself which is nice to see

  • So sad he didn't make top 13. Loved him. Very talented and unique. Show would of been much better with him. I think most of American doesn't know real talent.

  • i cried when he got off ):

  • His song choices on the show were not the greatest, that's why he didn't go through..

  • Well Ido would have been uniqe this year with Reed, but I guess we're not going for unique. :(

  • He was my favorite, but I think he's song choices weren't the best. He should have done something a little more poppy and mainstream for the first performance to get into the top 13. He needed to make a first impression for America, most of who aren't ready fro what Reed brings. It took a while for them to warm up to Casey too...and still not enough. Casey should've been top 2.

  • My dad LOVES him and me too :) I was really frustrated when he didnt make it....

  • @OboroNinjaLeader Talent escapes you.

  • @OboroNinjaLeader sounds like we have a hater on our hands.. u dont know talent dude.. he was original.. charismatic, good voice, high or low.. thats all u need, plus a personable dude.. ur just a hater and wish u could even afford the gas money to make it to the audition.. tool

  • @shabooshay1991

    I know talent, and he doesn't have it. He can just play the drums. Thats it. Yet, he isn't even that good with the drums in the first place. His voice is terrible. No range, and no control. Zero skill at vibrato. Instead, he chooses to laugh and grunt like a jackass, to hide his terrible voice (which he doesn't hide well), because he doesn't have the vocal talent to pull of something that sounds beautiful

    You dont know shit you fuckin cunt. Try again.

  • @OboroNinjaLeader Who gives a shit about perfect singing? The rest of them are doing the same boring shit that has been done over and over again. If you want a perfect singer then listen to Aretha Franklin or Freddie Mercury who are far better than any shitty singer American Idol ever gets. This guy was actually entertaining and not some shitty sob story with no personality.

  • @SuperBspb

    Well......the judges give a shit. Which is why he didn't make it, This show is about great vocal talent. Not just being able to perform, in inclusion to having an ok voice. You need a great voice in this competition. He didn't have that. His voice was shit

    Any more questions sir? One thing before you ask any more questions. Try thinking things over with proper logic before getting at me. I know this must be hard for you to do ......but try. Don't waste your time like this again

  • @OboroNinjaLeader He did have a good voice, just not the same old kind of "I sing loud and make my voice go up and down" kind of voice that EVERY OTHER FUCKING SINGER HAS. He has more of a Jazz oriented voice.

  • @SuperBspb

    His voice wasn't good regardless of what genre you place him in. A good jazz voice you say? No. Most definitely not. When comparing him to the greatest Jazz Musicians of all time, it is a bit disrespectful to them, to even say he has a good Jazz Voice.

    Also, why are you saying he has a good jazz voice, and your previous comment conveyed disdain of beautiful voices and vocal talent? Isn't Nat King Cole one of the greatest vocal talents there has been? Somewhat contradictory dude

  • @SuperBspb

    Just stop dude. You are presenting nothing of relevance in your arguments, and are contradicting yourself in the end. If you were coming at me with good points and logic, I would continue this. You aren't though.

    Reed is shit dude. Get over it

  • @OboroNinjaLeader i guess youre into more talent people such as Rebbeca Black....

    im sorry to inform you that you have NO IDEA what a real artist is and Reed Grimm is one gifted motherf***er !!

  • @elizeviola

    You would guess wrong you illiterate bitch. First of all, he probably doesn't fuck mothers. Try using proper English please. Not made up terms that make no sense.

    Secondly, No....I dont like Rebecca Black. Nice attempt at a baseless exaggeration. You failed completely there

    Lastly, laughing, grunting and acting like an ass isn't singing, or performing. It is just a joke that this guy made it so far. He is talented at playing instruments, but not vocally talented you idiot

  • @OboroNinjaLeader ok xD haha

  • @OboroNinjaLeader Youre kind of stupid. :) Reed is the best.

  • @taylorwtknxs

    You are 100% idiotic and completely oblivious of what talent entails. Reed is the worst

  • thumbs up if you thought he would be the most unique and entertaining idol in the history of American Idol. He should be in the top 13.

  • i hate that he didnt make it... like, how is that possible that judges didnt even give him the wildcard?!? im soo sad :<< at least phil and heejun got it....:)

  • How did this guy not make the top 13?

  • I live in the same area as him!!

  • HAHA i just love that song ending when hes like "yeah" and randy start laughing :D hilarious!

  • This guy is one of the most annoying people on earth...he is 100% about himself and EVERYTHING he does is a performance (including the teary eyed call to his Mom)...in other words, make no mistake, he is NOT genuine....however, he is talented...I'll give him that much.

  • i loOoOoOOoove him

  • I swear every time he sings he's High!

  • Sweet! 

  • he's either fake as fuck, or just the most fucking annoying person in the world

  • just me who thinks that he reminds me of the character in bloody roar( the charmeleon)

  • If Reed did a duet with Casey Abrams it would be an amazing performance!

  • @Coridy Omg!!! I was thinking the same thing, my mom and I discussed this sometime ago.

  • I LOVE HIM

  • y'all should vote 4 this guy, my dads in a band with his brother

  • @kaleidoscopeeyes9896 they must be a brilliant band if they're anywhere near as talented as Reed

  • @fisasinger1 haha you could say that

  • my music teacher was in a band with him in college!!!! lol

  • He crazy. LET'S MAKE HIM KING!

  • he's lovely. probably a little mad.

  • he;s annoying and cocky

  • Winner!!!

    

  • Freaking hilarious! lol.

  • AHHH! I LOVE HIM SOOOO!

    

  • Oh yes yes yes! I LOVE this kid! <3

  • yup goofy. talented yes. goofy, over to the top, YES. you lose him in the talkies

  • when i see him, i see the natural music

  • I do not like this guy. He tries too hard and is annoying. Too awkward.

  • @glipa he's not trying to hard you can tell that the way he moves comes naturally

  • @glipa He's goofy as hell....but you CANNOT DENY that this dude is talented MUSICALLY. I think he's awesome when he sings...but as soon as he starts talking I tend to tune him out.

  • Reed is LOVE! <3 Pure and simple.

  • REED GRIMM FOR PRESIDENT! COME ON PEOPLE LET'S MAKE THIS HAPPEN! VOTE REED FOR PRESIDENT!

  • Reed Grimm for the win! Come on America. Make it so!

  • I seriously want him to win. Such a natural entertainer!

  • WHAT I LOVE HIM

  • nice

  • shaggy from scooby doo

  • @audrEYheart21 thats wexactly what i was saying!!!!!!

  • LOL....

    

  • He reminds me of Casey:) I saw him on Hollywood week and he's a true musician..hope he gets the live shows and maybe a top 5 xD

  • HE'S REALLY WEIRD BUT HE'S GOOD!!

  • nice sweat stains dude. 1:28

  • I'm supporting Reed Grimm, Colton Dixon and Philips Philips!!!!!

  • @Evalicious101 Those are the exact people I'm supporting too! Internet high five! Hahah! [=

  • @Evalicious101 AGREE!!! Now I just have to decide my top 3 girls..

  • .............yeah! LOL

  • University of Wisconsin La Crosse graduate, represent!!!

  • Repping Wisconsin. Gotta love it.

  • uncle reed you have talent luv ya(:

  • THis is talent!! skat, sing, playing guitar, drums piano like instrument, can do beatbox what else men????

  • BEST EVER 0:48

  • Some serious weed induced talent there.

  • stupid youtube annotations.

  • OMG

  • loooool

  • This is what american idol is all about!

  • Lmao Was Is Funny

  • Haha this guy is hilarious. Tonight he did Willy Wonka. It should get interesting when it gets to the live shows

  • how do u do that

  • fuck your shitty banners

  • enjoying every bit of it.

  • @HPMovies98 Hey, mine too! Wuss up hrry?

  • This makes me miss Family Matters a lot. Those were the awesome days.

    

  • GOOSE BUMPS

  • You go Reed!! Best of luck you have my vote!!!

  • So who immediately did a search for the original Family Matters theme song?

  • Performs like David Hicks or the winner of AI season 5?

  • @marcellin20 taylor hicks? i think he's a bit more jazzy where taylor was more blues... i think he'll be more like casey from last year

  • do it for casey! I love the scatting.

  • 1:30 please put some deodurant...

  • @ahmadthiab6 deodorant doesnt stop u from sweating hewas probaly sweating because he was nervous

  • So casey.. :) just a thought

  • La Crosse, Wisconsin! Get em Reed

  • That was kickass!

  • FUNNY BUT COOL

  • Blake Lewis anyone?

  • @OSUBucks007 this audition was way better than blake's... simons first comment to blake was "I don't think you're as good as you think you are" i dont think that was the case in this audition.

  • Hello, Look Im inviting to you, specially youth and children. to watch this video

    " Argentinos en las sombras " on YouTube, I am not waiting nothing for this, but hey, look the video maybe if you try to use more of your brain in sync with your heart and your willpower, you can have a different vision of life, not religion, you don´t need go to "any" church for understand this spiritual reality.

    SEARCH ON YOUTUBE " ARGENTINOS EN LAS SOMBRAS"

  • hahaha he is my cousin <3

  • xaxxaxa i love him :D

  • casey abrams

  • He either has an extremely long torso or really short legs. Good thing he's FREAKIN TALENTED!

  • Tom Cruise??

  • He preformed at my school and got to talk to him, he is sooo amazing, and was barefoot on stage :) haha he is AN AMAZING BEAT BOXER, check it out. Im rooting for him!

  • wow! there are lots of good contestants this year!

  • He proformed at my school. No joke he had the same shorts and sandals...and talent!!

  • Remind me of Taylor Hicks.....

  • @bellamari777 Totally. 

  • Genius,crazy and soooo lovely! :)

  • just wow! that was unbelievable!

  • very very good

  • Love him!

  • I think he'll definitely go the distance, really. So loose, confident and energetic. Not to mention his smooth, yet rough (when it needs to be) voice. Pretty good control too. He knows where he wants his singing to go. Can't wait to see what more he's got!

  • @MegaMacTV cant add to that comment..you nailed it

  • hahaha love this guy!!

  • yahh another unique one....

  • reed rocks

  • this is really cute!

  • aww he's so adorable lol

  • soooooooo freaking cute, gorgeous eyes!!

  • wow so original, loved it

  • At least he's entertaining, unlike 95% of the other persons auditioning this year...

  • 2012 American idol winner!

  • @kennapop3 I wouldnt be mad if he won, but i think its going to be between him, eben and phillips phillips and maybe 1 breakout chick.

  • @element00x If Eben makes it past hollywood week then that is a travesty. Kid is not on the same level as these other people. Not even close.

  • I LOVE Family Matters!!!! Love this audition!

  • he totally graduated from my high school. no big deal.

  • this guy is very good and different and will go far good job

  • this is the ugliest guy ive ever seen and he cant sing

  • Love all the losers who make "comment arguments" on the internet. How pathetic!

  • Awwww he's super cute! Not in a conventional kind of way too. Super cute. *_*

  • this guy made me smile :)

  • That's awesome:) why only audition now? ... Nice voice..

  • GREAT! :)

  • i love him he's a genius!!!

  • for me he s the best

    4 me really gooood

  • he sexy

  • he looks like shaggy from scooby too

  • I LOVE him =)!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • people check out his band "shoeless revolution"!!!! they are effin awesome! Mr. Superstellar!

  • This is my vote

    

  • ok .. now i really miss casey

  • @kakashei88 me too, he was the best

  • He's amazing but wayyyy to similar to casey abrams who came in 6th last year.

  • @RLAII yes, because all singers who know how to sing swing sound exactly the same.

  • he's like a new taylor hicks!

  • @spursfan4life no way

  • Ohhh fuckin YES!!! Love this!

  • Comment removed

  • i love this guy he make it looks easy and fun love his laugh

  • i love this guy he makes it seem fun and easy and love his laught

  • wow Reed you show em dude :)

  • Never heard this song being auditioned way to go with the improv!!!

  • he reminds me of Screech from Saved by the Bell! lmao

  • Check out Earl Stevenson from Canadian Idol

  • no top comment this is my chance! what to say?? FRIED CHICKEN!

  • his voice is slightly...errrm..,whats his bearded face from last season top 10ers.. Casey-ish..except more fun, funky, minus those obnoxious grunts!

  • Hahahaha this dude is so ripped!!!

  • LOVEEEE THIS GUY

  • I agree with you so much! I love this guy too!!!!!!! He's a total breath of fresh air, right? I mean, the power and soul with which he sings with- it's hard to find nowadays. TRUE passion, I mean. Everybody claims "american idol is my lifelong dream, all my life i've this and that and i AM the next idol..." c'mon ppl..... no. XD Reed should win period. lol. i'm not biased or anything,

  • @TheRealSteveBrahman, You're so foolish. My future will be great. I'll go to an amazing school, get an amazing job, marry a man who works hard for things (because I think that's how it should be done), and then I will help people like you. See, I'll have my moments where I'll be depressed, but I think I'll manage perfectly fine. I won't look at your page bc I don't cate to see what you look like. But thanks for the attention-seeking offer.

  • @sammmii42 LOL women and their fantasies and fairytale lives. Its fucking pitiful to sit here and read that you will be getting amazing everything. many more mature and smarter people have the same dreams, which rarely come true. you are definately the type of person that would crack under pressure and failure. and my offer was just a mere sight seeing opportunity. you said you didnt know what i looked like, so i told you to go to my channel to see...which i know you did see and liked

  • @TheRealSteveBrahman, You seriously have me all wrong. But whatever makes you sleep at night. I have no idea what you look like, nor do I care to know. All the good looks in the world would never change my mind about you. I will enjoy my doctorate degree. For Psychology. By the way. Maybe I'll see you in my office one day.

  • @sammmii42 look at my channel you will see a picture of my beautiful aesthetics. lol a doctorate degree for psychology. dear lord good luck with 6 years of building debt and a having a hard time finding a well paying job. oh lord you dun goofed. im guessing you are planning on marrying some rich guy for support? otherwise you will lead a miserable life listening to psychos and sob stories...dealing with suicidal threats. ultimately you will fall into a depressive state and kill yourself. ur life

  • she looks like jl!