Added: 3 years ago
From: KMRakaKAT
Views: 234,758
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (461)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Im sorry, but there are some ppl who know shit bout music, and what its made of. This whole Pink Floyd is made of the greatest! Would you like to come with me to one of their show? If you want to find out what's behind these beautiful eyes, you'll might have to seek, might have to go in some one elses shoes. How would you feel as the wall?

  • Oh my!! ..... If someone dislikes this, go find something to like.. But dont.. Dont ever dislike Pink Floyd.. k?

  • FUCK DILL HARRIS!

  • re-release The Wall in Vinyl. best sound ever.

  • the rythm... is love

  • THE WALL IS BEING REMASTERED AND RE RELEASED IN A SEVEN DISC BOX SET COMING JANUARY NEXT YEAR!!!

  • @cford1992 What are the other five for?

  • @thewriter1008 2 of them is live footage, 1 is unreleased material, and the last one is supposed to be a remastered version of the movie, I'm not sure what the last one is for though

  • @cford1992 already got it with DSoTM and WYWH...but its gonna be beast, just BEAST.

  • Pink Floyd were masters.

  • @ayenab7 *Are masters, and forever will be.

  • I'm from France and I look forward to be on Monday to see 'The Wall' by Roger Waters in Paris !

  • I saw The Wall in Oslo the 1th of May. The most amazing experience ever! I had goosebumps the whole time! And Roger is such an awesome guy with the best accent.

  • if you want to find out what's behind thewes cold eyes you'll just have to claw your way through this discuise.

    You have to work hard for what you beleive in.

    Quote of the century.

  • @machinimafan27 the best rock & roll band of all time IMO... OK, Led Zeppelin gets a honorable 2nd!:-) (I mean, *with Roger Waters* in the band)

  • if you want to find out what's behind thewes cold eyes you'll just have to claw your way through this disguise.

    The quote of the day.

  • I went and saw roger waters playing this ( the whole album ) In the MEN arena :D I'm 12 years old, and very lucky to have seen it. Amazing album.

  • at the begging of this song you hear "where we came in" faintly. at the end of the almbum, after Outside The Wall, you hear "Isnt this where?"....think about it

  • 3:10 STUKAAAAAA!

  • One of best album's of Pink Floyd, together with The Dark Side Of The Moon, Pink Floyd is the best in the world, they own everyone.

  • That Intro <3

  • Isn't this where we came in?

    

  • 9 people will just have to claw their way through this disguise.

  • @bigbadbeavis Yes... sad...

  • @bigbadbeavis That's the worst dislike joke I've ever seen. It doesn't even make any sense.

  • that drop at the beginning gets me every time.

  • Ha, I love this song, and The Wall in general, but I feel bad, since I just jumped at the sudden change in the beginning. I'm surprised, that usually never gets me!

  • Octavarium, holy shit, i'm glad Dream theater references this band alot, both masters of mind fucking music.

  • I always smirk between In the flesh? and Thin Ice because it sounds like a baby is being dropped from a dive bomber

  • I love this album and love Roger Waters for this. He is the most genious musician ever walked this earth and will be remembered forever.

  • amazing music and lyrics. Definitely one of the best albums ever made

  • when does it say "we came in"?

  • @mptsfcecsja At the very beginning very faintly.

  • its been tooo long since ive listened to the wall :$ i need to resurect myself!!

  • BEST ALBUM EVER

  • I'd just like to say I love that you made this playlist

  • this song is meant to describe his father's death and childbirth and you can see how it relates with the powering guitars and drums, explosions and sounds of a bomb dropping. the lyrics show signs of disappointment and cruelty, and the start of the song carries on from the most realistic and beautiful songs ever made, 'Outside The Wall'. What an album.

  • @MrHarrybongo

    then why does he randomly yell, WE'RE ADDING SOUND.

  • Anyone else notice the guitar sounds like Brian May in this piece?

  • if you play the last few seconds of the last song in the album the words Isn't this where...Then play the first song on the album and the words We come in?

    Put them together and the words say "Isn't this where we come in?"which might symbolize that he is still stuck inside his head.I never could figure out what the words mean though.

  • @GodzillaFan0 Yep, its supposed to be a big circle... I guess the story never ends!

  • so theyre two versions of this song?!

  • @Deathsquad49

    no, the titles are different this one has the question mark, the other doesnt, so theyr e different

  • @Deathsquad49

    You're meant to listen to the album one song after the other, in order. They tell a story. You can also just read the lyrics, but it's not the same. The lyrics and tone are way different in the two songs.

  • i get a hard dick from this (and the latter) track

  • Oh, I get it: Pink is telling us his story after the events of The Trial and he is now outside the Wall. That's why it segues perfectly off of Outside the Wall, because we have now come back to the beginning and yet, based on the fact that he's telling the story we've just seen, it also a continuation.

    I just stated the obvious, didn't I? Dang it. I always do that.

  • @stitch99 yeah, that's it pretty much. This is basically the "present" while the other songs depict things happening earlier in his life.

  • From 0:35 to 0:45 = James Bond :)

  • @eXPerienceyeah

    wtf dont compare him to something much greater than him

  • 0:17 always scares the shit outta me.

  • Best music album of all time imo.

  • Love it.

  • this is one hell of a cycle, (just imagine at the end of each week you just go crazy in a stall and imagine "the trial" each week, damn that would be awesome.)

  • I love the guitar in this song :D

  • @randyrhoads1fan

    who doesnt

    btw Ozzy FTW

  • it's impossible to play this song without my speakers on MAXED volume :D

  • Saw Waters live in the 2010 tour in Houston. Greatest moment of my life. Peace

  • This is among the great and uniqe like supertramp, Dio, crash test dummies, such and such, but 30 years? Ok i agreed eminem is trash but think about muse, soad, scars on boardway thats uniqe. Just sayin :)

  • nobody realizes that this is so good.... it's freakin 30 years old (or longer/shorter) and people still comment on it every single day,,, someimtes 2 or three times a day. I'd like to see if anybody gives a DAMN about ANY artist that we have today, 30 years from now. Maaaaaaayyybbbeee eminem. thats about it.

  • @karatejoegreen...... tool..U2..radiohead....now think of the beatles..the rolling stones..led zepplin...there is countless amounts of great music..i just named a few..eminem..lol..not so much..hope you are not comparing floyd to emenem..floyd is pure invention.

  • @panchobriano Oh no, i totally agree with you. Pure invention. I'm just sayin, the only reason people would still talk about him is because he can write lyrics. Thats about it. It's still rap tho, not good.

  • 9 People don´t have Any Idea of what Real Music is.

  • its hard to here this and not want to listen to the whole album....

  • art

  • Just want to know why do most of you watch this if you hate pink floyd? Honestly thats kinda retarded to watch a video or listen to a song just to post comments on how "YOU" didn't like it.

  • this song goes from an intense, climatic ending then just randomly skips to a baby crying, lol.

  • 9 people hate Rock music

  • In 'Goodbye Blue Sky' i heard a cat meowing in the end, this one a baby.. not meowing - crying. All these tracks have something like that?

  • @siemvandenberg No.  Not every song on the album.

  • So if Floyd cannot be topped. which i probably agree with.. who is second best? my pick would probably have to be the grateful dead or the beatles.

  • There´s something eluding the 9 persons sunshine

  • one of the best song ever

  • Epic

  • we came in?

  • By far my fav band. then the beatles, then guns n' roses.

  • nice ending

  • Some of the tracks on "The wall" sounds amazing!

  • im 13 n i luv this song

  • @2554ash congrats

  • It is so amazing that the first lyrics of this song complete the last lyrics of Outside the Wall, the last song of the album, and same melody too, like the albums meant to cycle.... damn

  • @bigbadbuddhahead roger waters liked to make a lot of cycled songs like in animals with pigs on the wing 1 and 2

  • @bigbadbuddhahead it's because it's reflective of the cyclic natural of the themes portrayed in "The Wall"

  • @bigbadbuddhahead ? i didnt hear any lyrics at the beginning

  • @pureintellectual The first lyrics of this song begin at 1:33

  • @pureintellectual

    u must listen closer!

  • @yuepon13 i tried looping the album on my zune so i can hear what he says but there's a couple seconds of nothing at the end of Outside the Wall so what i hear is "so this is where--" then it cuts off and at the beginning of this song i just hear half a second of unintelligible mumbling

  • @pureintellectual

    he says "isnt thus where we began" or soemthing of that nature

  • @yuepon13 He say's "Isn't this were we came in?"

  • @pureintellectual Says "Isn't this where we came in?".

  • @bigbadbuddhahead A lot of people think that it's also meant to show how Pink's problems don't end.

  • @bigbadbuddhahead its to show that the battle is never over, and we must keep finding and destroying our walls... love it

  • @bigbadbuddhahead That is what makes the album 10 times scarier. In the end, did he die? Commit suicide? Break free of his wall and go onto live? Was it just a big episode he was having and where he dreamt of being outside the wall? Is The Wall his afterlife as well? This is why I can never lay it to rest, because everytime I listen to it I ask myself, isn't this where I came in? Creepy shit!

  • @thespecter2 I think there's a line in one song (I want to say the Trial) in which Pink says something about the place "where he came in"(through the wall). So I think that he went back through the same place he came in. But I guess we can never know, can we?

  • @spudmuffin99 it was at the End of Outside the Wall, where he goes "isnt this where?". and it connects to the beggining of the album

  • @ImpalerXll No, not that. In the middle of "The Trial" he sings "There must have been a door there in the wall when I came in". So I guess I heard it wrong when I was refering to it in the previous comment, but I still think he went back through the Wall.

  • @bigbadbuddhahead I think they did that to symbolize that whenever one person gets through the wall, another person goes in, and perhaps repeats the events that happened to the first person.

  • BEST LP EVER !

  • BEST ALBUM EVER !

  • I don't think they could have picked a better opener for this album, it sets the tone for what's to come

  • I listen to this album and The Who's Quadrophenia when I'm writing my rock opera. Wicked awesome stuff, rock operas. They're not easy to write, but the result is very much worth the effort.

  • if you wanna find out whats behind these cold eyes, you'll just have to claw your way through this disguise! BEST LINE EVER <33

  • Paralleling his own conception and birth into life as well as the narrative, Pink invites the audience at one of his rock concerts (and by extension, us the listener) to delve into his story.

    Just read that and had a realization.

  • it would be awesome if someone could anwser my question

  • @CaptainSchwartz I think what he is expressing is that feeling of exploring the unknown because "In The Flesh?" is the song that is placed near the very beginning of the album in order to explain the events that are about to come in the main character's life, which is filled with disappointment. Give me a reply if that does or does not make sense.

  • 20 and love Pink Floyd. Yup, I was born in the wrong generation of music.

  • im 11 and this is my favorite song EVER

  • @fox199tp wooww!!! Good for you!!

  • @fox199tp listen to In The Flesh (without the questionmark)

  • best album

  • what does space cadet glow mean?

  • I was listening to a 'the wall' playlist for the 999th time and really diggin into these songs, more than usual...

    the messages could be addressed to anyone, seriously this album could represent everybody's life and its just amazing, seriously amazing.

    and in the ending, there's this "isn't this where....", the 'outside the wall' melody made me think of childhood and i thought '...it all started' would be a nice 'ending' for that sentence, then the album started again

  • holy crap. listen to the very last song in the album then go quickly to this 1. u can barely here a "isnt this where?" at the end of the last song....the album is a loop!!!!!

  • @shanesuss

    what? but this is where it all begins

  • I have a question: what does "that space cadet glow" mean? what is Waters referring to when he sings it? I never fully understood that lyric.

  • if the wall were a guy i wud turngay in .034 seconds

  • I grew up with my Dad playing Pink Floyd all the time. Around 16 I turned on this album to listen to it for real for the first time. I nearly cried, it's so beautiful. That goes for the rest of Floyd as well.

  • Dark side of the moon is the best

  • nine people are faggots who don't know good music.

  • @UnknownImpurity802 they probably hit the thumb down by accident. This song is not unlikeable. Kicks ass!

  • @UnknownImpurity802 gay people can like good music.

  • 9 people are not in show business.

  • in cas your wondering wat hes saying at the end its "turn it! turn it off! TURN I OFF"

  • MOST BRILLIANT RECORDING EVER RELEASED THIS ENTIRE ALBUM !!!!

    BEEN WITH ME SINCE I WAS 10 years old in 1980 thas 31 years and still amazing !!

  • Comment removed

  • First got turned on to Floyd on a road trip... now every road trip I take I have to start it off by listening to this song!

  • @KMOK1LLA (I am OhNoNotGregory reincarnate) I agree - I was pretty wasted when I wrote that "pooey old men" comment. I don't know where it came from; I've been listening to this album, lovingly, for (good God) 23 years and it always keeps giving. Thank you for the timely upbraid :-)

  • i wake up with this song every day just to feel awake

  • 0:40 is kinda like empty spaces

  • i cant hear "we came in?" :S

  • @jcast18k It's at the very beginning, like literally 0:00, and it's quiet. You really have to be listening closely to hear it, but it's there.

  • @thewriter1008 it should sound as loud as the end but it doesnt :S

  • @jcast18k Atleast it's louder then the heartbeat throughout the beginning of the song. You can usually hear it with headphones though.

  • Anyone else notice the drum sorta sounds like a heartbeat when he starts sing which is sorta reminiscent of Speak to Me? And all of Dark Side of the Moon for that matter.. I also noticed in Us and Them that a little part of the piano/organ/whatever sounded slightly like the piano/organ from Flaming in Piper at the Gates of Dawn. (But I think that is probably really stretching it.)

  • AHAHAHAHAAHAHAHA!!!!None of you get it !!!!

    LMAO!

    Ignorant!

  • Comment removed

  • @Angelica21600 I'm gonna play Young Lust at my wedding. lololol

  • @ShiiruReborn thats a good song. i <3 that oneee

  • @Angelica21600 Yeah it is. I love all of them on the wall actually lol. I was just kidding though. Young Lust doesn't fit a wedding at all hahaha

  • @ShiiruReborn meh. im one of those people that would actually do that. lmao

  • @ShiiruReborn good call, but i don't think she's gonna like it haEUIHuieIUHeaiuh

  • @ShiiruReborn thats awesome. i really hope you do

  • @ShiiruReborn loooooooooool, kind ironic in it,cheers!

  • @Angelica21600 Doesn't really feel like a wedding song.

  • @gilli39 to me it does. lol

  • @Angelica21600 Probably not a GOOD idea, but it is a funny idea.

  • @Angelica21600 No. This entire album is not wedding music.

  • @BAsamholden21 do you know what a joke is? fag.

  • @Angelica21600 Do you know what not sounding like a stupid bigot is? Moron.

  • @BAsamholden21 yes. yes i do. in fact, i should be saying that to you. every single person accept you that has replied to this comment understands that this is just a joke. nothing more.

  • @Angelica21600 Yes, because being a bigot has to do with not having the same sense of humor as you, not saying things in a discriminatory fashion.

  • @BAsamholden21 chyah. whatever. now go cry in your emo corner, you stupid pussy.

  • @Angelica21600 Where am I crying? Why am I an emo pussy, and why are you so mad bro?

  • @BAsamholden21 "Do you know what not sounding like..." Wow I had to read that again. She obviously hurt your feelings for calling you a fag. Truth hurts doesn't it? Let me rephrase that.....The truth is you are so not a non-gay guy but rather not a guy that is non metro-sexual. I'm trying to be as politically correct as you can handle.

  • @DickLodge68 Mad Bro?

  • @BAsamholden21 "Mad Bro"? Huh? Good luck to you...learn how to phrase a sentence. .

  • @DickLodge68

    Good luck learning what people are saying if you can't figure out what obvious common day language means.

  • @DickLodge68 You obviously don't know what trolling is. It's a art that you cannot comprehend, and the phrase "Mad Bro" comes from that.

  • @BAsamholden21 I could care less.

  • @Angelica21600

    Please stop trying to throw around words that you obviously can't understand the meaning of, or you wouldn't be using them. Being gay is NOT an insult, and responding to things casually with it as such is offensive on multiple levels, and makes you look like an idiot to anyone who's over the maturity level of a 7 year old.

  • @blazefire2

    i don't know what your talking about, but i know one thing, you don't get off anywhere telling a person to not speack a certain way. also, you seem to be taking offense to being called gay, considering you had tell the faggot that it is specifically not an insult, cause if you were a normal gay person, you wouldn't have given a fuck. also, words are only words, the only meaning they have is the one you give it.

  • @Angelica21600 I have a good idea...Don`t get wed.Just enjoy the Floyd.But if you must get wed?....^.^

  • The only thing I hate about this song is that Youtube doesn't automatically come up with the "?" version when typing it in... and I guess that's misappropriated hate since it's Youtube's fault.

  • I saw this fucking shit in concert.

    Best concert EVER.

  • ROLL THE SOUND EFFECTS!!!

  • pooey old men singing of past times and thinking it clever to loop an album with blah gnung came in. And the music is all dead now, it sounds like a weird lament from a dead race

  • @OhNoNotGregory Nice swing and a miss not only is this music just as meaning full and culturally significant today as it ever was, but it's obviously not dead because people are still listining to it and your spending your time on it to try and bash good music.

  • @OhNoNotGregory Pratt

  • @OhNoNotGregory pooey old men?

  • It's in 3/4 time. That's a waltz tempo. You don't see a lot of rock songs in that beat. Pulled off perfectly here, of course. Great opening track.

  • 1st time i listened to the wall this song freaked me out cuz the random guitar intro but now im just like 3-2-1 bang!

  • Muito bom este som lembro muito dos amigos de cruzeiro do oeste tempo bom rsrsrsrsrs...

  • 9 people did not want to go to the show

  • @sradss GAHH i never noticed that! thats pretty damn cool.

  • I went to the Roger Waters concert at the sprint center in Kansas October 30, 2010 -- he did the wall.. Probably the BEST concert I've ever seen in my damn life!

  • i love pink floyd theyre so awesome i went to one of there concerts on november 21 2010

  • Comment removed