فيلم قصير: أفلا يعقلون - الجزء الثاني

[schaymae]

اكثر من رائع !!

[tarimlover1]

خلع قلبي

لا حول ولا قوة إلا بالله ..

مُحزن أن أمثاله أصبحوا كثير .. يارب رحمتك بهم احفظهم من كيد شياطين الجن والإنس وثبتنا على رضاك

[mohmedosama03]

جميل

[wgdanmourad]

بارك الله فيكم فلم رائع



[merymonib]

رووووووووووووووووووووووووووووو­ووعة

بارك الله في كل من قام بانجازه

[haithambecko]

بسم الله ما شاء الله

[rorocan]

ما شاء الله بارك الله فيكم على هذا العمل

[egyguy5]

انا مش معاك فى ان موضوع تصوير الشيطان لانك لو لحظت ان الشيطان لم ياتى للتوبه.

و لكنه عرض قصه لتشويق الشيخ الذى لم يترك صلاة الفجر لالهاءة عن الصلاة و فى نفس الوقت عرض القصه و تصويرها.

[hishamgameel]

اللهم سبتنا علي دين الاسلام وعلي مله نبينا محمد صلي الله عليه وعلي اله وسلم

[khaled05511]

السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته .. أولآ بآرك الله فيك على هذا الرد الجميل .. ثانيآ انصحك اخي الكريم بأن تركز في الحروف وفي النطق العربي السليم اخي العزيز > ( سبتنا = ثبتنا )

[0124623545]

Gazakom allah 7'eeer ya regala wa isA kolo fe mezan 7asanatkom

[mndo26]

رائع مع التحفظ على بعض الجوانب

والموسيقى

لكن التصوير والاداء والاخراج رائعين

[blackfire202]

لا بس ميه ميه والله

[didomoka]

لا والله فيلم رائع ملوش حل

الله اكبر

تسلم ايد اللي عمله واللي مثله

جاااااااااااااااااااامد

[ALWSN]

فظييع

[sanfofo]

الصراحة اخراج و تصوير رائع وقصة اروع كمان

[oomaro]

الفكرة حلوة بس الموسيقى :------------------------- لماذا ؟

[Muslima844]

أعوذ بالله من الشيطان الرجيم

[hisamhiii]

اشهد ان لا اله الا الله وان محمدا رسول الله

فيلم جامد ومجهود رائع

[elpopxa7med]

tmam film gamed  rabna yewafa2kom ya regala....ento mneen?!

[4451545215]

جميل ورائع جدا جدا جدا ولكن الصوت يكون أنقى من هذا

[ceniima]

السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته

في الحقيقة من ناحية الفيلم رائع

وكل شيئ فيه في المستوى

واتمنا من اخ هاني والطاقم بتاعو وكل الاخوة يشرفونا

ويشوف الافلام بتاعنا

نادي سينما الشباب

المغرب

[Islamnight00]

بارك الله فيكم يا اخوان وجعلها الله في ميزان حسناتكم

[eltayeb2020]

gamed gedn

[islyoung2]

لأو أنكم فقط تقوموا بترجمته إلى الإنجليزية لتكون الفائدة عامة.

[bash967]

إبداع في ابداع كل الشكر لمن ساهم في هذا العمل الرائع كتب الله اجركم وتقبل منكم وزادكم موهبه

نتمنى ممن لديه الخبره في هذه المجالات ان يحذو حذوكم

[AHMEDSHARK4313]

الفيلم رائع و يتكلم عن واقع مؤلم للأسف يمر به كثير من شبابنا

[samsamiisamiiii]

its beautiful, again the story is very complicated

and this is a very nice soltion to the OLD -new STORY of salvation,

great work, i congratulate all the BRAVE people who made this nice short,

sami

[samsamiisamiiii]

NEVERTE:: I dont know the story of this production, but i assume its a school project, the story is very complicated, and it shows a great courage for few young artists to stand for this challange, the techniques are really nice, teh movemnet of the camera is nice, the lighintg is good too, i had a little problem understanding the dialogue, propably for simple equipements, but the techniques in general and the MIZANSIN as IZENSTIEN says is great in this movie,

[Ahmeddrug]

bgd ento malkooooooosh 7all w bark alah feko

[niverteniverte]

من ناحية التنكنيك و الاخراج و التصوير والمناج ز الموسيقي الفيلم ممتاز و بداية رائعة لكن من ناحية المضمون و السيناريو و القصة الفيلم ضعيف جدا و بيخاطب عقلية أطفال أو علي الأكثر مراهقين يرجي في المرات القادمة اختيار مواضيع أكثر عمقا تتناسب و طبيعة الواقع الأليم الذي نعيشه.

أسلوب معالجة الفكرة طفولي وخطابي لأقصي و مش لازم يعني نصقف لأي موضوع بيتكلم في الدين ونقول رائع و ممتاز وبارك الله فيك من نغير ما يكون عندنا نظرة نقدية متمعنة والا عمرنا ماحنشوف تقدو

ولا ايه

[ahmedsaed]

مبدعين

[bebobasla]

لو سمحت ممكن رقم المونتير هاني حمدى

[bebobasla]

الفيناله بتاعت الفيلم جامده جدا بس ميتزله من الغرب بس الممثليين كوييسيين جدا ربنا معاكو

[bebobasla]

الف

[livindaki]

اشهد ان لا اله الا الله وان محمدا رسول الله

[ahmed484]

اشهد ان لا اله الا الله وان محمدا رسول الله

[masoraa]

بجد فيلم هايل وقصتة جامدة جدااا وسيناربو والاخراج وختى الموسيقى بجد حاجة رائعة انا بحييكم على العمل الجيد دة ومنتظرين المزيد

[KID1194]

ما شاء الله عمل متقن

والله الفلم له هدف وهدف سامي

اللهم اهدينا واهدي بنا

[wanagj]

sobahn Allah..سبحان الله العظيم اللهم اهدينا لما تحب وترضى

[wanagj]

thanks guy...(gay bad word)

[amabrook]

feen kilmt mohamed rasol allah???

[zidanmando]

يا رب إهدينا وإهدى كل شباب المسلمين

[amrseliman]

فيلم رائع وجزاك الله خيرا

[gfragrance]

لساني يعجز عن الشكر وللامتنان للذين قاموا على صنع هذا الفيلم المعبر ...

الله يكتر من أمثال هؤلاء الشباب ..

والله يهدي شباب أمة محمد عليه الصلاة والسلام ...

يارب يكون لهذا الفيلم عبرة في قلوبنا جميعاً..

[moatasemcx]

6/10 acting and directing

10/10 scenario

By the way the intro music is a Christian Gospel

Excellent idea Bad performance

[ASHstu]

أكثر من روعة

[peacefulthoughts]

Amazing work mashallah. Not only is the story unique and powerful, but the acting, the filming, and the sound effects are of excellent quality! Mashallah :)

If you'd like, I can translate what the actors are saying to English and send it to you so that you can add subtitles. That way it can reach more people who need this kind of reminder inshallah.

Jazakum Allahu khayran for your excellent work and amazing effort you put into this.

Salam :)

[tarekeldeeb]

Great Idea ..

Honestly, I am not one of the clip's team. (I wish) ..

If you can easily make the subtitles .. we can cooperate to make a subtitled video ..

JAK

[peacefulthoughts]

I'm really sorry. I got a lot of work and was busy for a while... If I get some time I will do this inshallah and will send it to you once it is done. sorry about that.

[tarekeldeeb]

waiting ..

[lekuwait]

فيلم أكثر من رائع وقصه جديده ومؤثره..جزاكم الله ألف خير

[hotbird911]

If U Guys Only can translate it to english it'd be awesome .. islam is great religion

[0124518007]

bgd nice nice film we atmna enko testamero fe elcareer da..bgd shabab gamda gedan we rabna ma3ko......

[nardinodr]

gamed awi bgd...3agbani el fekra ya gama3a bravo 3aleko ya shabab

[PixlDream]

outstanding, keep goin ..Best part @ 7:54

[amoorelebiary]

good job

[atef4all]

جزاكم الله خيرا

ننتظر المزيد من الأعمال الاسلامية المتميوة

[doudilali]

تحية خالصة من المغرب.فعلا عمل رائع جدا ومتقن إلى أبعد الحدود. بارك الله فيكم.

[zinab2blessa]

it was really GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOD,i loved it

[youssefmadny]

فيلم حلو بجد فكر وتمثيل واخراج وقصه طبعا (انا كنت مع تامر فى العسكريه انا من هندسه بس انت ممثل كويس وعقبال متبقى ممثل كبير )

[babye177]

الفيلم رائـع وقصير وهادف وخفيف

بارك الله في اخواننا المصريين واتمنى ان نلحقهم ونسير على خطاهم كسعوديين ونترك الافلام التي لاتجني الا تهكم الناس علينا والسخريه امثال فلم كيف الحال

[Ger0lene]

Begad it's perfect...

The script is really unique and articulated in a scary yet realistic demeanor making the point vividly coherent...

From a cinematic perspective, I think you guys did a gr8 job...

The director of photography is brilliant with all the thought put in the camera angles reflecting very elaborative ideas... And the montage and sound mixing is really gr8...

Begad gr8 job!

[mohamedalmaghraby]

thx guys u did something i wish i could do

[nenolovememo]

nice job mostafa khater (faculty of law),tamer karam(faculty of arts),mostafa saied (faculty of ...,mahmoued ma3erk and director hany hamdy thank's all cast this comment by bebo&diesel (mostaf mahmoued) thank's all.

[NihadAly]

fa el fekra wad7a...weli mo2men en el music 7aram 3aref, weli shayefha 7alal howa 7or

fa let's instead congratulate all of those who made the movie coz it's really really great..rabena yegazikom 3ano kher we 3an kol 7ad beyshoufo!

Salam

[tarekeldeeb]

I totally agree .. fe3lan e7na kharagna barra elmawdoo3 !

[NihadAly]

elsalamo 3alaykom gami3an,

Ya shabab, ento tele7to bara el mwdou3 keda...fekret el music makanetsh el asas

Aslan kol eli fil video (drugs, alcohol,etc.), hal fih ma3luma gedida 3an eh 7aram we eh 7alal? ay muslim 3aref eh 7aram we eh 7alal..bas di tazkera gamila we 7aga mel 7agat eli el wa7ed ama yeshofha wala yesma3ha yefakar fi eh eli beye3melo we yerage3 nafso.

[basssent]

well i like the movie veeeeeeeeery much....begad rabena yewafa2kom....

nagivator i think u lost the whole point of the movie by concentrating on this very small part beta3 el music.......ya3nee the movie didn't make any comments on the music....they just played it in the background...till i read this conversation i didn't notice what song was played fel background aslan

[666navigator]

If you wanna do something for Allah (swt) do it justly and equal to all types of people. So the message comes across everyyone. Because right now, the people who enjoy other sort of music will say "Oh, but what I listen to is not 7aram then" You need a message to all different type of people!!

[666navigator]

In addition, no matter how bad you make other music genres look like. No one will care. But if you used metal, the majarity will care and people will start getting the bad idea about a musical genre that owes no harm to anyone.

[NorastheVillain]

بس برده انامقلتش فى الفيلم ان الاغانى دى سبب انو كافر ولاكن سماع اغنيه ذى الى انا كنت حتطها دى اكيد حرام لانها الاغنيه اسمها يوما ما على الصليب وعلى فكره المقطوعه الى انا حتطها فيها اسم الاغنيه واكيد الناس الى بتسمع ميتل عرفنها

[NorastheVillain]

و اخيرا لو انت شايف انى بهاجم المذيكا المتل فانا حر من حقى اقول رئي وده ميقلش منك فى حاجه من حققك انك تدافع عن مذكتك برحتك لاكن متغلطش فى الناس الى ما بتحبهاش

[Ger0lene]

Guys i think the music thing is much more metaphorical than a genre...

Maybe ur partially right 2 jump to conclusion bcz of the quote of "not any music"... but still, the whole thing is symbolic and just resembles the type of people rather than a type of music..

[666navigator]

Then why did you use Heavy Metal? Do you know people who make metal some evil thing made other people get hurt badly and not justly. Arab governments are so blind about this subject and people like you just make people who enjoy metal suffer. You are an enemy to something you do not know. You could've used something else!!! Instead of Metal!?!?

[tarekeldeeb]

Brother ... dont be so angry ..

1- I'm not that film's author/director .. i only spread it .. and the director thanked me for that ..

2- Even he, did nothing wrong .. as we (the director and I) see that all music (specially the heavy ones) are 7aram .. it's NOT UNJUSTIFIED to blame any of them .. they are all wrong .

[tarekeldeeb]

Please ..

استغفر الله ..ولا تغضب ..

وابعد عن تلك الموسيقا ..لعل الله ان يطرح الفرح في قلبك من باب اخر

and please end this discussion.

Salamo alaykom

[666navigator]

I am not angry and I am willing to support. There is no such thing as heavy music is 7aram and soft music is 7alal. They are ALL WRONG in all types of cases. I could be a Sufi and associate music with Islam, does it make me kafir? (I am sunnite btw)

[666navigator]

You and the director say its wrong. But both of you need to show ALL TYPES OF MUSIC IS 7ARAM. Not just one!! You need to show it and not say it here.

[NorastheVillain]

انا قصد بالاغنيه دى مش الميتل بس الاغاني الى فيها كلام عن الانبياء و عن الله سبحانه وتعلى بشكل غير لائق بعد كده عرفت ان الاغانى المتل هيا المتخصصه فى الاغانى الى من النوع ده

[666navigator]

Islam is a message, and its a message to the people. It is made for us to keep and follow. We didnt create it of course. No one did but He.

[tarekeldeeb]

I agree 100%

:)

This means that God .. and only God, who has the right to say what's 7alal and what's 7aram ..

even if 99% of the earth's population did something, this does not mean that it's 7alal ..

I really dont know the Metal nor the Hiphop .. nor any of that you've mensioned .. I'm not against 1 in precise .. but against all ..

[NorastheVillain]

نا اسف يا جمع على الجدال الى انا فاحتو بنكم بس انا عايذ اقول حاجه انا شفت حفلات لى الناس الى بيحبو المتل وبصراحه لقات انهم تصرفات غريبه ذى مثلا حركه يد اسمها قبده ستان وستان ده الشيطان حركه تنيه اسمها قبديد الالحاد

[666navigator]

Tarek, you know exactly what I meant. And yes it is MY RELIGION because it was GIVEN TO ME by Allah (swt)

[666navigator]

Did you know which musical genre actually supports drugs, alcohol and sexual activity? Its rap music. Yes, its bin doing so since the 80s and nobody ever says anything about them, or beats them (government officials) etc. If you thought for one second, that rap music videos are the REASON why people take drugs etc. is what the problem is. Then again, you cant say Rap/Hiphop and RnB are bad because there are SO MANY MUSLIM RAPPERS AROUND THE WORLD WHO SPEAK FOR ISLAM. .

[tarekeldeeb]

.. and there are many alcoholic Moslems around the world ..

does this make alcohol 7alal ?

.. look brother ..

وما كان لمؤمن ولا مؤمنة اذا قضى الله ورسوله أمرا ان يكون لهم الخيرة من أمرهم

so i suppose u go search for what God had judged about this issue ..

salamo alaykom

[666navigator]

Dude, I was not justifying alcohol. I was talking about the music that MIGHT drive people to do so. Yet there is another sect of each music that could also deprive someone from drinking. Thats what I am trying to say. Look at Yusuf Islam, he is a singer and hes doing something good for Islam.

[tarekeldeeb]

Ma shaa Allah .. I love him so much ..

didn't you ask yourself: why all (or most) islamic singers dont sing with music ??

They only sing solo .. or in a group .. or with some human sound effects .. !

MUSIC is 7aram ..

got my point .. brother ?

:)

[666navigator]

Music is music and can be written in different type of ways brother. At the end of the day, they are musicians either by their voices or musical instruments.

[NorastheVillain]

سئلت حد ميتل هد قلى ده عادى الحركات دى معنها كده لاكن احنا مش قصدنها بالمعنى ده قلتلو يمكن بس بصراحه انا مقتنعتش بعدان انا فى الفيلم مقلتش ان المذيكا دى سبب انو كافر و الاغنيه الى انا حتتطها بتقول كلام حرام فعلا

[666navigator]

You have Common a rapper in USA who converted into Islam and always sings about Islam. There is no Islamic Heavy Metal yet but inshallah there will be. But there is alot of christian metal bands who support the cause of Allah etc. You cannot judge one sort of music and forget all other types when you know ALL TYPES of music is haram.

Take care brother!

[666navigator]

Hahaha, funny. Listen man, I am muslim and I am happy with my religion. I enjoy my Metal Music because its music. Im not slave to it and I listen to it when I am in the mood.

[tarekeldeeb]

its not "YOUR" religion .. it's Allah's !!

We follow .. and do not customize !

[666navigator]

You know whats funny aswell? Real devil worshippers hate metal because metal music give them bad reputation LOL!!! You guys have no idea what is the music about, seriously. Ignorent idiots!!

[tarekeldeeb]

ok .. Metal Music (and most of the music as well) is considered forbidden (haram) in Islam.

Why can't u live without music ? .. u became slaved to it !

That's the fact.. Metal is haram, and most of its lovers take drugs as well..

NB> Posting too many replies doesnt mean you are talking write !

[666navigator]

Then again, the satanism used in Metal Music is only an image. The people behind satanic lyrics or imagery are actually atheists. Just like someone made this film about the devil, why cant musicians talk about the devil aswell? In good or bad, it doesnt matter. Because at the end of the day you either do it for the greater good or just to make money. You have not justified Heavy Metal music to be the devil's music. Im sorry.

[666navigator]

I am sorry but you failed to show metal music to be a bad thing. There are thousands of the christian metal bands that have a lyrical theme of God and they are against satanism etc.

[666navigator]

Could you please explain to me why Metal was involved in negativity through out the film? Why associating the devil with the music when music in all its forms is by the devil works?

[666navigator]

There is a problem: There is something I am against. Since I enjoy listening to Heavy Metal, I do not drink or take drugs.

[korayem]

Gamed gedan gedan..mashallah

We need more of that type of entertainment and education...much less Tamer Hosny, Amr Diab, Adel Emam...

To me, I always see the show business as a curse if the person working in that field is not aware of the conequences of his actions: millions watch what you do...on several years and years! imagine a 1930 movie that had bad parts or permits haram actions, till today the producer, actors..etc will gain saye2at!!

Ja3alahy allah fe meyzan 7asanatkom.

[ashroof2005]

الفكرة ليست قوية بالقدر الكافي

السيناريو والحوار غير متميزين ..

أفضل أداء تمثيلي من وجهة نظري كان للشيطان ثم الشيخ

التصوير والاضاءة والاخراج أكثر من رائع واحترافي للغاية

هذا الفيلم يستحق جوائز في الإخراج ان لم يكن قد حصل عليها بالفعل

تحياتي لهذه التجربة المتميزة