Added: 5 years ago
From: hallsmiel
Views: 124,513
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (374)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • mi yulia!!! te amo te comprendemos<!

  • super la rola, me gusto mucho cuando estuvieron en mexico, lastima ke ya no estan juntas, pero lo weno es ke hay videos de ellas, SON LAS MEJORES¡¡ y tienen un voz ke impresionan... me encntan¡¡¡ woww¡¡

  • My throat hurts just from watching this !! Poor Yulia :(

  • Oh mi Dios.. veo a Yulia y me duele todo el esfuerzo que hizo con su voz en ese concierto :S porque sé el problema que tuvo con su garganta...me salieron algunas lagrimas :C pero me encantó!!! :D

  • Woh Yulia. No me gusta para nada su voz en esta presentación, hasta se le va! La esta forza de más y hasta se escucha mal :s

  • omg, tendria tos mi pobre yulia? seguro fe eso,ella canta genial

  • It is really sad that she can't sing her favourite song. It's so sad it makes me want to cry for her lost voice.

  • Ow, poor Yulia. She really sounds like she's suffering with that voice there.

  • I wish I was there...But I live in the USA, where t.A.T.u. stopped going to in 2004 or so...They only came back to the USA for 1 White Robe performance in 2007 or 2008.

  • lena siempre esta corriendo el ingles de yulia fijense lo que dice yulia " net song it's russian song, special for us" y lena la mira con cara de "callate la geta" luego la corrige diciendo "special for you" y es verdad.. yulia lo que quiso decir que la cacion es rusa y que es pecial para nosotros (el publico) por eso debio decir "special for you"

    en el dvd de dangerous and moving lena tambien corregia muuuchas veces a yulia cuando hablaba ingles jijijiji

  • que feo y que aguante de las cuerdas que dolor :S

    no debio cantar se lastimo mas

  • Comment removed

  • Poor Yulia, her voice sounds damaged, the same thing has happened to me

  • esta es mi cancion favorita de tatu aunque no se russo pero me la se toda en ingles!!! como quiesiera aver podido verlas en concierto pero yo estava muy pequena son geniales y muy bonitas!! :)

  • porke se sabe kien tiene las ganas verdaderas sin importar barreras sigui adelante yulia es lo mas nunka se sabe con e nos sorprendera pero aun asi sta el final!!

  • love the little foot stamp yulia does @ 3.07. speaking as a vocalist i know how frustrating it is when your voice refuses to do what you want it to and the amount of effort you end up putting in to get it to even work at all. Somehow it makes this my favorite Obezyanka Nol performance, seems so.....real.

  • seriously Yulia's Part was so damn Difficult !:her expression was pretty funny in the beginning 

  • They're so fine, I get wet in Russian♥ Я люблю тебя Юлия и Лена!

  • wow considering her vocal surgery she did amazing!

  • Awwwwww to see Yulia struggling is so hard

  • Yulia's english is the cutest thing ever =)

  • aun asi con dolor de garganta y todo, Canto muy bien!!!!!! :D

  • Yuliaaaa es Una Diosa Total,..hermosa y Valiente x haberse esforzado al maximo para dar lo mejor de si, en esta hermosa cancion,..sabiendo q no estaba muy bien de su garganta

  • She used to be so much cooler huh? Pre-surgery? She seemed like she used to be in it for the fun and music, and less about fame and notoriety. Something changed along the way, I used to be such a fan but I'm less than impressed with her as of late.

  • Her voice it's not perfect but she trid and this is good because show us that she wanna make us happy trying to don't use lip sing.

  • AMO la voz de YULIA <3...Asi este muy ronkita <3

  • Pobre Yulia, cuan veo este permonance hasta a mi me duele la garganta

    de ver como fuerza su voz.

    pero sea como sea son grandes.

    Son las mejores!

    T.a.T.u 4Eva!!

  • Also, Lena blatently checking yulia out at 1:57, just saying.

  • @emdiespock ......U mean "blatantly"..... yeah.... they still like each other.....

  • This performance might be the best of this song. For someone that weeks earlier got a throat surgery for a cyst on the vocal chords to belt out notes like that.. It doesn't matter if its quality, she did it, it must've hurt like hell and she would even let the audience do the last line. I think people should realize that this was the circumstances and give Yulia credit for her determination.

  • I honestly love this performance, she should continue to try to sing and not lip sync in my personal opinion... Too bad t.A.T.u will never be.

  • pobre yulia estaba enferma de la garganta es muy fuertye porq pudo usar play bak i no loiso

  • @pepegrim no estaba enferma.... lo q sucede es que ella tuvo una operacion de las cueldas vocales debido a un quiste... por eso en la mayoria de los conciertos ella dobla las partes que debe cantar...

  • mi yulia cantando bien como siempre aun asi recien operado no me importa igual se la escucho supero bien para mi su esfuerzo de cantar en vivo en esas condiciones fuen muy valiente de su parte y lena ni q se diga siempre cantando re bien

  • Yulia is the hottest girl in this whole world

  • puta que voz mas triste la de yulia es q en esos tiempos recien le habian operado y se ve q tiene aun la marca de la operacion en el cuello :(

  • Lena should've done Yulia's high note part instead

  • Comment removed

  • my favorite T.A.T.U ´s song

    jaja aun recuerdo cuando vi este especial en Telehit (cuando pasaban buena

    música .-.)

  • even so, she sounds great!

  • poor yulia!!!!

  • but i am glad she got it done because it could have popped. There was one concert where before the surgery she was lip-sync because if she went to her normal tempo it would pop and i wasnt sure if they said she would have been sick or something else

  • And for the record this was the only time she attempted to sing that chorus live on a concert...

  • @dlslz i know, how convenient. The only time she sings the chorus live and she sucks, and then they say OH SHE WAS SICK. Right....

  • lol and Julia claims she's going to be hot shit in Russian with her solo career. hahaaaa

  • Unfortunately everything has a price. A voice so beautiful and so high-pitched at 16, heavily used, may have caused a problem in the vocal chords...

    it's a touching presentation

  • which one is yulia. and she had vocal operation O . O

  • Comment removed

  • i love t.A.T.u.! And i'm sorry for Yulia because of her problem! And i'm proud of her!! And she is so heppy when she's singing. That's so cute!!! And Lena is amazing like always!!

  • @Daca95tATu4ever what problem did yulia has?

  • @edgeofseventeen17 She had a throat surgery before, and her voice was damaged...

  • part 3 done going for 4

  • Poor Yulia, she was so cute...

  • God, Yulia was good.... I dont know how she sang this with her throat situation, she was even brave, she could have damaged more her voice, but since then she is better ^^ And thats awesome cause i love her voice, the raspy sound gives the songs a sexy touch lol. Lena as great as always ♥ Love them, and i miss the old tatu... but we´ll always remember these times :)

    Love them.

  • Me acuerdo cuando fui xDD todos empujándose bien genial xDD. Que tiempos aquellos U_U nunca volverán U_U. Yulia todavía estaba bonita xD y no me importaba su voz toda desafinada xD.

  • Класс, девчонки молодцы! Татушки супер!

  • yulia hace algunos años la cantaba mejor en vivo que en la reproduccion tiene una voz excelente espero que con la terapia vuelva a ser la mismaa .

  • I think that Yulia don't like her voice in this appearance, but i love it. And i love that she's so happy when she's singinng ;)

  • Her voice is better now as a matter of fact the v power is live 1 year later her parts are all live and she sounds better.She was recovering from a throat surgery.

  • Ow.

  • This video is so so sad... Yulia I LOVE you so much! Shes a very brave women to still be performing in such a condition. I wished she never had those high parts! I FUCKING LOVE YOU YULIA!

  • A -CALENTAR LA GARGANTA

  • они супер!!!

  • it's horrible how yulia sings!!!

  • @luunatick she had had a throat surgery before, because a throat cyst ¬¬ and her voice was damaged.. she was pretty cool 4 singing this song live and herself.

    She is better since then, thank God.... love her ♥

  • YOu can telll Yulia is trying hard...shes doing pretty good..but i feel bad for her im pretty sure it hurts...o=poresita yulia!

    GO t.A.T.u.!

  • OMG, go Yulka, I'm with you!

    Jesus, she's amazing.

    Doesn't that hurt her? o0

    I mean, when she's screaming.

    Yulia, we love you!

    She sing it very well!

    Lena, look after your sweetheart ;D

  • jesus christ i think i'm in love

  • I love Yulka <3

  • does anyone know what Yulias voice is like now, i know she is going solo but i wonder if her songs will have high notes and stuff

  • @seanjnugent Well her voice has gotten better scince this perfomance you know she had just had throat surgery weeks before.

  • @seanjnugent We still havent heard ANY songs from Yulia's solo career! But this video was shot in 2006, its 2010 so Im sure Yulia sounds better and hopefully she takes vocal lessens and exercises! I hope for the best!

  • Dios! Cantam com amor na alma! Amo t.A.T.u.

  • te Amo Yulia mi Prinsecita Rusa....

  • Ela estava bem roca, quase não consegue cantar..mesmo assim foi lindo!

  • vengan a chile

  • Recuerdo cuando salio este showcase en vivo! fue genial! Me trae muy buenos recuerdos.

    Y esta cancion es FANTASTICA!

    Love Taty!

  • you know what? i prefer more this exhibition to one in playback ù.ù and i love the way yulia smile... they're so cute *____*

  • Alguien sabe que significa Obezyanka Nol o Monkey Zero?????

    Osea la frase no tiene mucho sentido, he buscado algun significado pero no lo he encontrado en español es "Mono Cero"

    pero tampoco tiene sentido

  • Sgnifica "Nula e Frágil"

    É como se diga 'Mi vida estás sem senso e fragilizada"

    Bien, Descuple não escrevo espanhol!

  • es comod ecir persona vacia nula. todos tienen derecho al amor pero los monos no. ellas c representan como los monos. x eso dice, los monos iviran en la prision

  • ver todo este ripo de videos hace que se me erize la piel , yo etuve ahi :D:d:d:d: AMO A TATU

  • poka madre julia!!!!!!!!!!!!!tatu!!!!!!

  • OMG, Yulia.

  • aaai que hermosa voz..pobre se nota el esfuerzo q hace para poder cantar =( i love you chicas

  • Im agree with, eventhought Yulia couldnt reach the high notes she tried and she did such a great performance beside lena n.n..... I love them

  • i agree, even if yulia had a hard time hitting the high notes, i have greater respect for her and the fact that she tried and it still sounded good =D

  • un aplñauso a Yulia que esa se esforzo a pesar de todo... no que otras cantantes ni eso hacen

    le vale todo y ella si canta en vivo, no como una britney spears

  • Moya Veselaya!

    I love Yulia, and Lena too <3

  • estan muy lindas,,,,,esta cancion esta buenisima y se agradese el esfuerzo q hace Yulia para cantar en vivo,,,,,,,,eso se merece mucho respeto y se prefiere escuchar asi en un concierto q un playback

  • They always smiling when they sing this song :) I saw a video where Yulia had bad mood and at the end of this song she smiled again :)

  • Even though Yulia couldn't hit the notes very well, i still think it sounds beautiful.

    this in one of my favorite live videos

  • ala ke tal desafinada :S jajaja

  • ya no llegan a peru ya confirmaron su separacion

  • me dolio la garganta nadamas de oir a Yulia :( pero aun asi la amo :') se esforzo por hacerlo y eso es algo ke casi nunca hace :')

  • I love that Yulia actually sang the high notes live :) That's very rare.. Even though it didn't sound great it was still really brave of her to try XD We still love her even though she can't hit those high notes that well anymore (and Lena was great too by the way)

  • I love t.A.T.u.

    Yulia was courageous a lot, and Lena was very supportive.

  • sha had had surgey only a few weeks before this

  • ya i found out recently

    but still just seeing her try to hit the notes....i like it haha i know call me wierd

  • Poor Yulia :-(

  • viva mexico y tatu orale yuliaaaaaaaa!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • It's nice from her to sing without any playback, even if she don't sings very well. But I understand, these are really difficult parts !

  • she just had throat surgey when this video was done!

  • I know that, that's why I said it was nice from her because she can't sing very well but do it anyway.

  • Omg. LOL wow man.. she sounds so great. Almost as good as that bird living on my roof. Damn she's talented.

  • LMAOOO hahaha!

    Even if her voice sounds raspy and like she was agonizing i kinda like it lol sounds a bit... dunno... sexy? lol

  • you are sicko :D

  • S s sS S s S s Super HotttTT!!one!11!one

  • if youre russian you must not be ashamed, because Lena is the hottest girl on the planet, and yulia is very brave to sing after her vocal operation, especially that hard part!

    tatu are super! and russian girls are the best :)

  • @TheHorsenation

    I`m not sure that you know who is Lena and who is Yulia. Yulia is the dark hair girl, and Lena is the red hair one.

  • Obezyanka Nol - Obezyanka 0 Little Monkey Zero To anybody nobody is guilty To each pool on the moon Only there are no co-ordinates more On which you will be to me I any more there, and you not here Clouds have missed each other silly little monkey, you meanwhile are little monkey, I am live while My cheerful My ridiculous pain I little monkey a zero You little monkey a zero
  • Fair loonies can to be treated Will not release neither you, nor me This grief to us not to come off little monkey's will live in prison little monkey's will live in prison All love, and обезьянкам grief little monkey, you will dream me My cheerful My ridiculous pain I little monkey a zero You little monkey a zero
  • Whoever got that shirt is so damn lucky.

  • OBEZISHCA HORB XD

  • yulia is trying so hard! I feel so bad for her! damn vocal cyst!!

    And I am a proud fan of hers as well!

  • @yuliarocks15

    sounded like husky to me, and it's such a great performance. i'll be forever their fan.

  • Poor Yulia...

    I'm proud to be her fan! : DDD

  • Ał, ał, ał moje uszy. Jej to musi boleć!

  • q bueno estbo ese concierto las amo aun que ya no esten juntas soy daniela

  • Oh my gosh, poor Yulia! That sounds so painful! Considering her vocal cyst, she sounds pretty great! What the hell happened with that title, though? "Obezishca Horb"? 0.0

  • Do you know how hard it is to sing perfectly at that range without screwing up... Even with that cyst that she has i think she sound beautiful...

  • o luciano ferreira barreto foi e e o cara que as estuprou a mando da mae quando soube que iriam para a russia.

  • 0:24 Yulia parece extasiada por la belleza de su canción favorita :)

    0:39 Alguien se va de la nota (desafina) y Lena lo mira como diciendo "qué fue eso?" xD

    0:45 El tipo que escribió el título no tenía alfabeto cirílico y pretendió imitarlo con letras latinas...òó

    1:27 Yulia sacude la cabeza xq sabe que suena horrible; luego mira a Lena como diciendo "escuchaste eso?"

    Y sin embargo, en todo el video no deja de sonreír!!!

  • 0:24 Yulia seems to be in ectasy at the beauty of her favourite song

    0:39 Someone plays a strange note (out of tune) and Lena looks at him like "what?"

    0:45 The guy who wrote the title did not have Cyrillic alphabet on his computer, so he tried to imitate it with latin letters...ÒÓ

    1: 27 Yulia shakes her head because she knows she sounds terrible; then she looks at Lena like saying "do you hear this?"

    And still she doesn't cease to smile!!

  • It makes me sad to see Yulia like this. I wish I had the power to make her voice better again. She seemed to be trying so hard, and I'm proud of her. GO YULIA!

  • what at the time was Julie?

  • it's live at least

    I love them ..but when they came to Argentina..first they didn't give any public shows..only on tv..second..they didn't sing live....

    Obezyanka nol..I love it...I can swear I sing it better than Julia...but they are t.A.T.u....Try as she may, she will never do it!!....but Julia's the best!!!....they really rock!!!

    I'm looking forward to hearing their solos music!!!!....It'll never be the same....!!!

    Julia.....I love you!!!

    And your voice's the sweetest on Earth!!

  • They gave a live show in Argentina, and they sang live, it's a pitty that you missed it, and buy the way, they aired the show.

  • 3:46 Yulia was upset about sound of her voice.

    3:52 Lena said to Julia in russian that it' s normal, continue.

  • Amazing!!!!!!!!!!!! It's not song, it's another phenomenon from TATU. They're very talanted. I'm from Russia.

  • Yulia- "Special for us!"

    Lena- "Special for YOU!"

    HAHAHAHA

  • Yulia sang live this song!!! EXCITING!!!

    I love her and Lena.

    t.A.t.U. ROCK!!!

  • they' were just trying to keep up with the themes...

  • Yulka rocks super!!!!!!!

  • Yulia is AWESOME!!! this is a hard song and you can see how hard she try to sing. Congratulation!!! and good luck.

  • Yulia sang live in this song..

    I mean she tried as hard as possible..

    cos this is one of her personal favourites:)

  • that's what you called talent. they are REAL ARTISTS! they don't lip sync just like those other singers who can't even sing.

  • yeah they did but it was all because of Ivan Shapovalov. And now they don't do that anymore, they really sing even though Yulia's voice is not the same anymore.

  • love this video, it's hard for me to finish it because I was like tearing up. Yulia was fucking awesome, even though she can't even sing those notes at that moment she still tried.

    Lena is so supportive to Yulia, so so sweet. love t.A.T.u

  • super awesome live :)

    I'm so glad that yulia sang this song all way trough.

    just awesome

  • i lover u ttatu and i wish i was there my parents are from guadaljara love uu guys

  • juliaes

    ermosa

    ermosa

    la

    amo

    .

    arthhu!!*

  • poor babe, 1:28 she's like saying: " fuck i can't" but i really appreciate she sang live!!! i hate when they go playback. i love Yulia's voice, she did everything she could, she's great.

    i wish the come to Spain! we love t.A.T.u. here too!

  • I agree, it sucks but she could have just quit right there, so it is cool that she went all the way.

  • i agree.

    it must've really hurt her :(

    bless. she did very well :D

  • cuantas operaciones lleva ya yulia de la garganta???

  • poor julia, Ivan Shapovalov has destroyed all her voice !!!!!

  • Her voice is much better now, but yes, at this moment she was still fairly fresh out of surgery and couldn't sing well, but I am impressed she even tried. But yeah I agree Ivan is responsible for it and is a bastard for it!

  • what ivan have done with her voice??.what was happen acctually??...

  • You have heard their first album with Not Gonna Get Us, Show Me Love, How Soon Is Now and few other tracks where she is screaming, well he made her do that all the time and those sessions and singing them on stage caused a vocal cyst, which was removed around this time that is why her voice sounds so rough, but it has since gotten much better.

  • I love the shirt that they give Yulia at 2:15 - 2:18 does anyone know where i can get one like that? i really want one! maybe one thats not exactly like it?

    Me super encanta la playera que le dan a Yulia en 2:15 - 2:18 hay alguien que sepa donde puedo conseguir una asi? porfa! me encanta!! aunque no sea exactamente igual, pero algo parecido?

  • NETA! prefiero que CANTE asi a que haga PLAYBACK su voz es HERMOSA! y la cancion se scucha mejor asi...realmente en VIVO!! vino a mexico en vivo y sin peluca...todo real! ademas ella se vee que esta disfrutando del SHOW! pk sus fans cantaron la cancion con ella a pesar de que la lengua nada que ver! es una de mis canciones preferidas de ellas y neta este video esta bien chingonsisisimo no soy FAN de tatu, solo me gustan unas canciones y esta es GENIAL en vivo Salu2 Atte: Angelovsky!
  • I love their songs.. so beautiful.

  • VIVE t.A.T.u. !!!!

    Je les adore!!

    Cette chanson est superbe!!

  • YO ME PREGUNTO : SI KISS VINO AL PERU PORQUE MELA t.ATu NO PUEDE VENIR QUE VENGA TATU AL PERU !

  • ESO!!!! QUE VENGAN A SUDAMERICA, CARAJO!!!!!!!! xD

  • ami en lo personal la voz dej ulia me enamora y si se dan cuenta entre mas esta ronca mas hace tiernas sus caras kuando se esfuerza

  • a ver ke alguien cante cuando tiene tos y problemas en garganta ahora la voz no siempre es la misma y uno no siempre tiene la misma salud cansancio y mucho movimiento afectan el rendimiento del cuerpo aun asi ellas cantaron y no kancelaron se merecen mis respetos y yulia se ve ke disfruta cantar y esa alegria me emociona saludos
  • Totalmente de acuerdo!!! Encima aunque le cuesta y todo, se ve que quiere hacerlo, se esfuerza por ello, y le gusta! Y para mi, lo hace muy bien! (quiero ver a alguno de los que critica cantando eso, a ver si pueden, incluso sin quiste ni nada!)

  • ademas hay que tomar en cuenta que

    ya lleva muchas operaciones

    en las cuerdas vocales

    pobresita...

    al menos se esfuerza

    y eso es realmente admirable

  • me gustaria veros a esos que criticas a yulia cantando con un kiste en la garganta y inflamacion,deberias estar agradecidos de que al menos fue al concierto otros artistas directamente lo cancelan y k le den a los fans