This is one of the most beautifully written jewel of pieces. And agreed that Lili Boulanger is a true genius who died way too young. Thank you for this clip.
PLEASE NOTE that calling Piatigorski a Ukrainian because his town of birth is today in the Ukraine is ridiculous, he was a JEW who was undoubtedly happy to eventually become an American Jew (or a Jewish American, whatever).
I'm not sure that's a wise distinction. If someone were to say "Because he was a Jew, Piatigorski wasn't a real Ukrainian," that would be an anti-Semitic remark. Therefore, it seems equally wrong to say that "Piatigorski was a Jew, not a Ukrainian." Can't Ukrainians be proud of their co-nationals who don't happen to share the same ethnicity? That seems generous, not racist.
@nsimington You put it very convincingly in principle and make it impossible to disagree. Yes, let Ukrainians be proud of any famous person born there! One could - just to be contrariwise - comment that at the time Piatigorski was born and grew up it's unlikely he would have thought of himself as a Ukrainian but rather as a subject of the Tsar (briefly of the new Soviet régime too), who was eventually very happy to become an American.
This is one of the most beautifully written jewel of pieces. And agreed that Lili Boulanger is a true genius who died way too young. Thank you for this clip.
ddtan75 10 months ago
Love the piece and the performance.
PLEASE NOTE that calling Piatigorski a Ukrainian because his town of birth is today in the Ukraine is ridiculous, he was a JEW who was undoubtedly happy to eventually become an American Jew (or a Jewish American, whatever).
MikJFr 11 months ago
@MikJFr
I'm not sure that's a wise distinction. If someone were to say "Because he was a Jew, Piatigorski wasn't a real Ukrainian," that would be an anti-Semitic remark. Therefore, it seems equally wrong to say that "Piatigorski was a Jew, not a Ukrainian." Can't Ukrainians be proud of their co-nationals who don't happen to share the same ethnicity? That seems generous, not racist.
nsimington 9 months ago
@nsimington You put it very convincingly in principle and make it impossible to disagree. Yes, let Ukrainians be proud of any famous person born there! One could - just to be contrariwise - comment that at the time Piatigorski was born and grew up it's unlikely he would have thought of himself as a Ukrainian but rather as a subject of the Tsar (briefly of the new Soviet régime too), who was eventually very happy to become an American.
MikJFr 9 months ago
Absolutely sublime. Thank you.
rheumer 1 year ago
I haven't heard this in a while. Very beautiful
stardappledgreen 1 year ago
Lili is the genius.
watasenia 2 years ago
Lovely. I was not familiar with this work.
merrihew 3 years ago