ashley miley vanessa real voices

[shopoholic36]

I love them all!! They were messing around!! Miley Cyrus was my role model and idol when I was 7,8,9 and 10!! And I loved High School Musical 1, 2 and 3 when I was younger!!

[shopoholic36]

They were all messing around Ashley Tisdale is better than that!! They are all amazing women!! When I was 7,8,9 and 10 Miley Cyrus was my role model and idol and I loved High School Musical 1,2 and 3!!

[Purplefreak2060]

Ashley was so messing around

[Mirulike]

I Love Ashley

[Mirulike]

so good

[deegiisuuri090]

do yo guys even have proof that ashley is singing that song?there are only few posters of her

[selen6ish]

1:VANNESSA

2:MILEY

3:ASHLEY

[threeDrascle]

ashley was obviously messing around

[ahsongbird]

ashley sucks

[Zorrofairy]

if u think about it they pretty much all sound da same except for ashley

[ladykracher90]

love miley :*

[peppermintcat]

Miley !! That's what pure talent sounds like :)

[ebben100]

Why wasn´t they on 9/11 plain?

[BlackRosesNyan]

miley : fine

venessa: awesome

ashley: very bad 0_0

[TheOdilie]

@BlackRosesNyan agreed !

[shrimp102599]

miley sounded like a dude

ashley sounded like SHIT

vanessa sounded AMAZING the best out of all three

ashley needs singing lessons

[johnnapaulaSy14]

ashley's voice here is unpleasant... vanessa's is cool :D <3

[johnnapaulaSy14]

VANESSA IS THE BEST! LOVE HER SO MUCH ! <3

[angelpekas911]

I like vanessas the best

[arielzbkny]

they all sounded good without the music except for ashely

[Salonie03]

Vanessa sounds best from the three lol XP

[MileyOffcial]

Great voice miley ♥

[calvincorveauTV]

in recording a song if you have a mistake you will repeat it to make it perfect that's why it became more beautiful.

[vanessa51807]

aashly sound horrible

[katya411]

All singers are a bit auto-tuned. :L

[JustShutUpAndLoveMe]

Ashley Roxxxxx End of Story.

[FaithandKenzie]

0:28  IS THAT DEMI LOVATO?!

[MileyOffcial]

@FaithandKenzie NOOOOOOOOO o.o'

[FaithandKenzie]

@MileyOffcial Hah it looked like her for a minute..

[FaithandKenzie]

0:28 IS THAT DEMI LOVATO?!

[farahsagily96]

@FaithandKenzie took me forever to stop it to 0:28..nah its not demi..just one girl with long volume hair

[FaithandKenzie]

0:28 IS THAT DEMI LOVATO?!

[ImmortalCyrus]

Miley without music is better !! GO MILEY <3

[SusannahlovesMiley]

Miley of course

[ellasuffer]

1. Miley

2.Ashley

3.Vanessa

[EspositoSuarez]

1. Miley <3

2. Vanessa =)

3. Ashley !

[abb992]

they all sang really well without music!! your just a jealous hater!!

[honoush]

@abb992 I never said I hated them if u had taken two minutes out of ur life to check out my channel u would know im a huge fan of all of them,u have no right to say im a jealous hater I only made this to boost the confidence of other people who would like to sing but dont have the guts for it I wanted to give the message that ur voice can be average but u can still follow ur dreams so be4 u post rude comments on someone's video check to see if ur information was true

[TheRand06]

so true i totally agree ...im a singer too and its such a natural thing to sing better when there is music...somehow it makes you more confident to sing..better...

[Giusy0597]

1: Vany

2: Ashley

3: Miley <3

[1997Esie]

Miley is the best without music but i find that vanessa is better without music then with music :D

[pulcra100]

miley was the best, ashley was terrible and vanessa was hardly singing

[123buffylover]

music or no music, ashley is terrible

[ocb1999]

I say Miley !!!!

[memebabyV]

1. Vanessa

2. Ashley

3. Miley

Vanessa the best singer!

[memebabyV]

Vanessa is the best! she have an amazing voice!

[xupaxups14]

para mi la mejor de las tres es Vanessa Hudgens:)

[duhduhdada]

they made the mistake of putting old and new

[2010LyricMaster]

their all good... but miley at the top man

[KaylaLoveYaLucas]

@2010LyricMaster nope Vanessa. Well unless your a autotuned fan

[IsabellaRocher]

They all sing greeeat without backround music, but the mistake u made was putting an old hannah montana song, i mean, when she was young and a more grown up miley with music, in wich her voice is obviously changed, but not only because of the music but the age . Anyway, they're all great :)

[KennySouthparkfan]

1. ashley

2. miley

3. vannessa

[TheCamillasouza]

Porra, mas de acordo com a música muda a voz, né.

[1925stefy]

1.vanessa

2ashley

3.miley

[beccenzoandlaurenzo]

1.ashley

2.miley

3.vanessa



[DanaOriginals]

i love them all,but i think

1-Miley

2-Vanessa

3-Ashley

[MrBananaramagirl]

I would rate them:

1. Vanessa

2. Ashley

3. Miley (i dont like her)

[JustShutUpAndLoveMe]

Ashley is a great singer, i've been on her concert and she has great vocals, better than all disney stars!

Here she was just messing around with Zac, jumping and dancing, you can see it in some HSM behind the scenes video!

Vanessa and Miley are great too, if they weren't talented, they wouldn't have record deals, but if everyone has to rate them....here it goes:

1-Ashley

2-Miley [though i don't like her]

3-Vanessa

[MultiFireflie]

Miley sounds great without music.

Ashley sounds not that bad, I think.

And Vanessa also. :-)

[memebabyV]

1.VANESSA HUDGENS (my idol)

2.MILEY CIRUS

3.ASHLEY TISDALE

[PhyscoGymnast]

Well I guess it was good, but when Miley was singing without any music she was just warming up so that's not her actually trying. And for Ashley…well she doesn't really have any excuse! But with Vanessa she was only playin around…she wasn't actually singing properly so u can't really judge them! :)

[starlight8161]

miley sings better naturally with music then without luv them all they all did good

[ImJustBia]

Miley was warming up.

[limonatacikolata96]

Vanessa sings better than demi - demi sings better than ashley - ashley sings better than selena - selena sings better than miley - miley sings better than emily.. That's it !

[CyrusCherry]

@limonatacikolata96 Miley sings waaaaaaaaay better than Selena, LMAO.

[TheMileysuperfan7]

@CyrusCherry I love you Chantal.

[4everSardegna]

but what they sing without music is not what they sing in the video with the music -.-

[RetardedGeneration]

Ashley sounds horrible naturally, sorry! :P

[GYMNASTICSGIRL1232]

i love you ashley but ew you cant sing ae :/

[TheCuteFreek]

Miley sing without music much better than in music video))))

[zvaleskav]

Vanessa is the best <3

[gamey6969]

Ashley is so real good!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[VanZacAshLuc]

Vanessa's grandparetns were bought professional singers, so obviously Vanessa is much better.. C-:

[sarrikat1]

MILEY THE BEST

[jsisaza94]

Vanessa is the best¡¡¡¡¡

[twiliteluver101]

i hate ashley's singing without music! urg. NO HATERISM INTENDED.

I really like Vanessa's but I like Miley's too. Tough call!

[Xiflyx3]

eww, ashley.

[bfs7999766]

Miley NEVER had a talent evryone was so stupid and gave her millions she cant even sing

[limonatacikolata96]

Van is the best.. (Ashley was just kidding there with zac)

[seilndy]

Miley is good, but I`m better. ASHLEY CAN`T SING, God help me. Vanessa is the best

[christmascoolgirl]

vannesa teh best much better!!!!!

[jobroslovers98]

vanessa- BEST

[richard5770]

they sing very well that's stuped video

[kikoCYRUS95]

ashley and miley are the best !

[lauren8kristine]

@kikoCYRUS95 WTF!?!?

[kikoCYRUS95]

@lauren8kristine what ? that's my opinion

[JeSsJaY2]

what the fuck is up with ashley's vocie YUCK

[MarylouDG516]

ashley sing so bad ahaha !!!!! Miley's so good !!!! And what to say abbout vanessa ? she's a biiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiitchhhhh !

[JeSsJaY2]

@MarylouDG516 i agree with you sooo much

[limonatacikolata96]

@MarylouDG516 You have to say who sings good.. Not who is a bitch.. Vanessa ius the best, she isn't a bitch.. Miley is the bitch!

[MarylouDG516]

@limonatacikolata96 lol , so i need to told you than theres a lot of picture of vanessa than you didnt see !

[limonatacikolata96]

@MarylouDG516 No, I saw all her nude pics.. And? I'm still a fan of her.. I don't like it if people say 'I was a fan of van, but she took nude pics, now I don't like her anymore' That's really dump..Because she's still talented.. That she has nude pics doesn't mean that she's not talented anymore.. Who thinks like this is just abject..

[MarylouDG516]

@limonatacikolata96 you change of subject now .. i didn't say than she's not talented , i say she's a bitch ! and yeah she is ! i ever been a fan of her , not because she's not talented , because i don't want to love someone who supose to be an example for the kids , because she's not

[limonatacikolata96]

@MarylouDG516 Just because YOU don't like her? It doesn't mean that she's a bitch.. Okay you can say 'I don't like her' But you don'z have to call her bitch.. Everybody knows: When she took those pics, she was 18.. New in Hollywood and she didn't know what she's doing.. But now she regrets it.. And that's what counts.. It was for her boyfriend.. I don't think that she's a bitch then.. And at first when she was famous ( with 17) She didn't have nude pics.. And what did u think about her 2006?

[MarylouDG516]

@limonatacikolata96 if it was for her boyfriend , why those picks are on internet ? wathever , i dont really care about what you think ... thats my opinion and i respect your opinion , you can like her if you want , its not my problem xd

[limonatacikolata96]

@MarylouDG516 But it'S my problem that you call her a bad name

[LDisney21dvm]

they are all awesome but

1.vanessa.

2.miley

3.ashley

[shakkeyourass]

Vanessa is the best!! I love her so much!!

[LilSexyTootie11]

Miley is great Ashley withou a beat no Vanessa is great to love you MILEY and VANESSA and,ASHLEY

[MissLovesMusic2010]

Miley all the way!

[XxlaladyxX]

vanessa is the best <3333 haha

[ZanessaSingStar]

Vanessa Hudgens the best girl 

[luckyangel997]

so it is different but they are all good

[FireBlastxx]

I think they can all sing great without music, get this, Ashley is just messing around, she wasnt being serious when she did that, and i do that, when the music comes on, you get in the tune to the song, and then my voice goes higher, believe me, most people do that when they sing :)

[jewingten]

In that recording of Ashley Tisdale singing, she was just messing around, it wasn't a real try : (. I think that there are a lot better videos of her singing live than that.

[xxSalimullahxx]

OMG dnt u guyz realise dat ashley tisdale is not singin seriously???

the way she says theeeeeesss instead of this??

actually ash is wayyy better dan miley and vanessa and therz no question abt it!!

[FireBlastxx]

@xxSalimullahxx i agree:)

[limonatacikolata96]

@xxSalimullahxx You're right ashley was kidding there with zac.. But I don't think that she's better than van or miles.. :)

[xxSalimullahxx]

@limonatacikolata96 Well she is!! SOOOOO MUCH BETTER!!!

[Missingyounow29]

@xxSalimullahxx

Vanessa is so much better than Ashley so yeah

[misswildgirl15]

ashley doesnt sound good without music

[FireBlastxx]

@misswildgirl15 she's just messing around, god you can tell

[misswildgirl15]

wowo ashley is by far the worst

[FireBlastxx]

@misswildgirl15 SHES MESSING AROUND

[DoUc1210]

Vanessa = THE BEST

[meganF924]

miley and vannessa are good anyway but ashley is a bit bad

[Shelleycat999]

Hannah - She sings good without and with music

Ashley - She sings good without and with music

Vanessa - She sings good without and with music

THEY SING FINE!

[CheckYesSabina]

it would be better if the acoustic song matched the recorded song

[zvaleskav]

Vanessa And Miley are so good singers! Ashley sing good but no so much

[xlilmizjezreelx]

Out of the 3, Miley has the strongest voice. But Vanessa is obviously the one that had little autotuning done to her songs, because she sounds almost exactly the same. And Ashley was just... I don't know, but I think she got better now.

But VANESSA HUDGENS FTW! <3

[TVXchristianTVX]

GAY FAGGOTS

[xkatiexccx13]

ok... the reason why they all sound different in the music videos is becuause they use something called autotuning, which makes their voices sound WAY better than they rly are. it matches up their notes with the right notes and makes it more clear and then they sound totally different. and in Vanessa's video the sounds didnt even match.. it might have been a glitch tho idk.

[TaylenaTeam]

i really love vanessa's singing.

[wannaberckstrs]

miley and vanessa were the best but i think ashley was messing around

[XxMarMarx]

miley sounds the best!

[Abbiii3]

Umm miley sings better with Music

Ashley deffintally needs music

Vanessa needs music

THEY ALL DO

ashley was worst tho

[Crstalrocks]

Ashley is still Preety But shocking with out music

[cullenkueken95]

miley has an unique voice and vanessas voice is so strong and clear .. i ♥ it!!

[xxlinhtaylorxx]

of cause everyone good wiv music on

[lala32027]

MILEY CYRUS

[yhen7]

: ashley was just joking around. she sang it on a video with zac efron.

[SmileyFanDestiny]

MILEY!!

[Meguna13]

mileys was good but it was a long time ago. shes better now. ashleys was probably joking around or its fake and vanessa was good without music

[mariawithmakeup]

BT WHEN MILEY S8R8D IT WS WEIRD

[mariawithmakeup]

MILES IS SNGN GUD ASHLEY WS ALSO K VANESSA ES ALSO COOOOOOOOOOL

[AshlyTfan]

that was before ashley had the nosejob, now she can sing a lot better :)

[XxraydabossxX]

miley and vanessa are the best ashley is good but her voice wasnt good for that song with no music

[lovee00721]

vanessa hudgens sounds better live so does miley

[tlp031102]

Vanessa is the best!!

[realmomoko]

Miley and Vanessa sings ok but ashley...

[shilias0809]

vanessa sounded best without music and ashley sounded best with music miley needs more pratice on both

[TheKasiaM]

It's like singing songs also depends on

[jemlara17]

..."VANESSA STAYS AT THE TOP!!!!!!!!

[toocuteaaraj]

asley sucks without music

[rhonalyn95]

i think Ashley is just having fun that time and vanessa too.. haha.. anyway Vanessa's so good.. miley's voice is husky and the echo made her sound bad.. but i think she hit the notes.. they are all good..

[msserena08]

I have to give Vanessa props. When she did the first HSM, I hated her voice because it always sounded like she was whining. She has realy improved. Miley and Ashley....stop while you're ahead. You know what, don't stop. With all the autotuning and editing that's done in studios today, anyone can be a star.

[shoricika99]

can I know whatz the song of vanessa hud-gs?

[sweetbola666]

@shoricika99

Sneakernight ....is the name of the song!

[shoricika99]

@sweetbola666 thank you

[daijhearene]

miley and vanessa sounded good ashley sounded o.k

[SelenaStation]

Miley sound awesome :D<3

[thecale77]

Ashley Sounds Perfect In The Music Video & Without Music I Love Ashley

[noahcyrus100]

luluanddenis said the truth ashley sing so bad a capella

[johncharmed]

oh comon this is rehearsed except ashley's... hello for me the unique one is ashley... the weird is miley's, and the iriritating s vanessa's

[13Jossie21]

Vanessa sounds the same but great Miley sounds ok but the worst I think without music is Ashley

[chica13ist]

vannesa=1, miley=2 ashley= not even close to 3

[Zuzbur]

Miley and Vanessa is great in both version but ashley is terrible

[321BRATZ]

Ashley and Vanessa sound the best to me. All of you that say ashley can't sing think about it. Ashley is probably practicing think about how fast she's singin. but miley and vanessa's parts were rehearsed

[babyp35]

Vanessa is cool without music.

[LizetteRoxx]

u cant really compare them singing their real voices to the videos because its not the same song and ppl sing different songs in differen ways.. i know my voice changes depending on the song.. so this isnt really accurate .. we didnt see the video of ashley either so she could have been playin 4 all we know... point is this isnt accurate and no i aint makin a fuss just stating facts ♥

[Zanessafan12345xoxo]

ashley sounds bad.... miley sounds ok... vanessa sounds great!!

[TheTiinyone]

i dont think that you can really compare these just because the songs are different...yes i do realize that ashley cant sing and miley is good but shakey live sometimes and that vanessa is probably the best in these clips however i like miley cyrus so i think she was the best...just my opinion though

[peacelovecheesy]

omfg ashley friken sucks!

[DanaLAstyle]

miley is the best!!then Vanessa and then Ashley...i didn't mind that Ashley is so bad...ouuuuch

[Angelrose113]

Miley- 8

Vanessa- 10

Ashley-4

[ChocolateVanessaFan]

i have to say it now

ASHLEY CANT SING!!!!!

her voice is so annoying and she cant sing and DANCE at the sam time!!

but miley and vanessa CAN!!

pff and ashley is always covering songs!!!

So silly...SORRY

[VanessaAndMiley4ever]

Vanessa is the best <3

[Sassimausel]

@VanessaAndMiley4ever no I think Ashley is better

[Kizy2007]

vanessa is so much better.

[HelloBlackKitty]

ti behonest wit u they both have diff voices but i dont see them being known as really gd singers cuz they cnt sing

[Tangochelsea]

wow. miley sucks even more than usual!