Added: 2 years ago
From: LuvNileyNews
Views: 586,374
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (1,976)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • lol why did u make this if ur obvioulsy a niley fan? this song's for selena.

  • haler every song he makes is not for miley , selena, maya, or whoever is on your mind his songs are for his fans who believes and loves him

  • PROOF THAT THIS SONG IS NOT ABOUT SELENA:

    in one of the jonas brothers songs off their second album "the jonas brothers", theres this song on it that nick wrote called just friends. look it up. in the lyrics it says "i've been making plans, like a picket fence and a rose garden." this was in 2007, prob wayyy before he had selena on his mind. my best guess is that rose garden is about his childhood friend maya.

  • NILEY ;(

  • @sabru011 Yea right

  • It's About Selena.

  • this is deff about selena kuz in the begining he says how she was "brought in by a beautiful mistake" and how her mom was a "kid her self" and selenas mom was only 16 when she had her and her daddy didnt stay

  • It's about the White House's Rose Garden

  • reminds me of a younger version of John Mayer

  • do do do do do doo hahahaha nice :P

  • I MISSS NILEY SOOO MUCH! :(

  • miss niley sooo much!!!

  • Comment removed

  • the song is sweet but its a bit slow and low voiced

  • This song is about Selena Gomez not Miley, if you know that post it on every Rose Garden song!

  • I wish everyone would stop and think. Not all songs are about someone. Alot of singers who are happily married sing about being heartbroken or cheated on or lonely.....this doesn't neccesarily have to be about someone. Peace ;)

  • No, this song is about Selena , Not miley :) Nick is perfect, i should be Selena =D

  • Okay look this is about selena and maya just take a second selena her mom was 16 when she had her her parents divorced when she was 2 she was working on tv at 9 yrs old (barney) even though I know it wasnt a flower shop maya her mom had her when she was 15 her dad died when she was young and she did have a job at a young age like 13 i think So its about them both just live with it
  • why is there a picture of miley?

    

  • @therealmajamarcussen cuz people think its for miley

  • This is my song from nick now lets end the argument lol he is all mynn myn myn and MYN so the rest of ya get lost :D

  • i'm number one niley fan but this song is for maya! :)

  • THUMBS UP IF YOU WANT THAT NICK SING A SONG TO YOU

  • is this a real story about selena?

  • @touta4822 No its about his friend maya

  • who cares who the songs about,

    its an amazing song nevertheless. 

  • ahhhh, also..i know this song just 'screeeeeams' selena to you guys..but miley also has a rose garden(: but im still not saying the song is about miley guys!

  • this song is about selena gomez not miley coz mileys dad was always there

  • @luvsnickjonas1 COme on guys, how come you just talk about miley and selena? Fyi, this song is about Nick's friend, Maya, who grew up without her father and was really close to the Jonas Family.

  • Okay, who cares if it's about Miley or Selena?

    Just enjoy the song. Geez, people...

  • Is the picture Photoshopped? Miley looks far too small... ^^

  • @FrickinEpic Yea, obviously; if it was real, she would've been sitting on his lap or something xD

  • @itsbannaple48x True xD

  • CHILL! people if you actually listen to the lyrics you CAN TELL that its NOT about miley cyrus or selena gomez! jeeze. the VERY BEGINNING, as in the first 2 lines sound like selena, but the rest of it doesnt. and their is like a couple lines that sound like miley. so everyone needs to CHILL THE HELL OUT! @luvnileynews just has the the background picture as nick and miley because shes a fan of them!

  • @eddwarddlovee What? The WHOLE song screams out Selena. Especially in the second verse with the "she was young but not naive."

  • @unpredictaaable i never said it didnt. but nick said he wrote this song alot time ago. so it about neither of them

  • @eddwarddlovee I was just pointing it out 'cause you said that it didn't sound like Selena at all when it so painfully reflects Selena's life. Anyone who say otherwise is in denial :/ Selena even admited how she used to have a rose garden when she was younger.

    And he wrote is 2-3 years ago, he knew Selena then. Just saying.

  • @unpredictaaable i know alot of parts reflect her. im not in denial. i already said they did. and i dont wanna get into a fight with someone over someting stupid. so..bye.

  • @unpredictaaable Oh MY GOD. This song is NOT about Selena. If you were a fan, you would know nick wrote this song for his close friend Maya, who grew up without her father and was really close to the Jonas family.. ._.

  • @0oLenaaao0 Seriously? I KNOW this song is not about Maya. The line, "and her daddy didn't stay" MEANS he left them not PASSED AWAY. And I know for a fact she doesn't work, nor did she work when she was 9. Why can't people except that it's written about Selena. It's not a hard concept.

    And idk, if it was as simple as Nick writing a song for Maya then he would simply say it was for a friend instead of keeping it a secret~~

  • @unpredictaaable Dude, he SAID it was for maya. ._. but whatever, believe what you want. au revoir

  • @0oLenaaao0 Dude, would you like ot link me to this? Don't give me some crap article by some teenybopper magazine or some BS website.

  • whoever thinks this song is for or about miley their really wrong. mileys parents had her later and their still married. miley never had a rose garden. now who thinks its selena has a better shot at being right. selenas mom had her when she was 17 and her daddy left and selena had a rose garden when she was younger

  • You people are so Naive at times you know.

  • You all need to STFU and enjoy this beautiful song.

  • Guys this song isn't about Miley or Selena, it's about me. lol.

  • it doesnt even matter who its about incase you guys didnt notice nelena and niley are both over

  • i love this song,so much emeotion in the lyrics. and nicks passionate voice its agreat song.

  • yall r so slow it dont matter who its about wat matter is that he is talented and that this song is beutieful ...duh

  • @lyric0089 you all are so slow. It doesn't matter who it's about, what matters is that he's talented, and the this is song is beautiful ..duh

    just incase nobody understood this, there has to be something wrong with you if this girl or boy, is calling you slow. XD

  • This song sounds really weird!! But love this!!

  • I like this version better, love this song

  • love this song :)

  • this is not about miley its about selena

  • this was actually ment for selena gomez btw.

  • why is miley in there..? :/

  • Go Niley!

  • idc who its about i love it. but i dont like the studio version :/

  • I don't care WHO the song is about. It's a beautiful song, and whoever it is about is Nick's bussiness, not ours :)

  • i hate him writing about someone else life that so fuck up i hope Selena get mad him for doing that

  • Comment removed

  • This song isn't for MILEY NOR SELENA! It's for his best friend. Don't believe everything you see until you see it 100 times.

  • @MushroomTeexD I saw it 6 times is that good enough lol.. Im pretty sure its about Selena, because he told Bop magazine that it was about a friend of his who he just met a few years back, and she told him her life story about how she had to get a job at a young age to help her mom who had, had her at the age 16 and there was a place she loved to go which was the rose gardenn, and that she was wise beyond her years, sounds like Selena to me...

  • @ClaireSupport thts where i heard iit from too. but then tiger beat sed it was ment 4 her. and tht same day the song came out. miley got mad and wore a jonas brothers shirt. so. im pretty shure its selena

  • yuh this song isn't abt miley coz miley is way too good for nick :) yuh so it shud be selena :)

  • Does It Really Matter Who It Was For.? Its His Business. ANd We As His Fans Should Keep It That Way. As Long As We Like His Music Its All.

  • this isn't about miley OK i said it!! fewh now that that's over i'm gunna watch more of miley's stay.

  • listen any real jonas fan who watched living the dream 1 knows that Maya`s dad passed away and thats why she lives with the Jonas fam, its about Selena, shes was conceived before marriage and her dad left her and her mom ..

  • It's not about Selena or Miley at all. it's about Nick's best friend.

  • I'm not saying it isn't about miley or selena, but why dose everyone have to assume that every song he writes is about one of them?! and even if it was about one of them, dose it atually matter?! It's Nicks buissness, not ours!)

  • I LOVE THIS SONG!

    EXPECIALLY THE I HOPE YOU LIKE IT =B

    MADEMOISELLE N.

    Hello mi mujer =B

    ANGELITA =B

  • ahhh love this son <3

  • This song was made for Selena!

  • this isnt about miley Its about Selena Gomez her dad left & her mom was 16 when she had her

  • One chose : LOVE YOU NICK JONAS

  • i'd have to say that it's about Selena because her mom had her at sixteen and her mom and dad divorced when she was five so he want around and she was working at the age of seven on barney..

  • Did you guys ever think it was about somebody thats not even famous? Lol

    or he could of just watched a movie and inspired him to write a this song.

    it doesn't have to be about miley or selena or anyone else he dated lol

    it could just be someone from his child hood you never know.

  • Selena, hun :P

  • Why's Miley in the picture? She wasn't brought into this world, out of a beautiful mistake, when her mom was just a girl and her daddy didn't stay!

    Selena duhhhhh

  • in miley's new album, one of the tracks is "every rose has it's thorns", wonder if it's somehow related to this song..

    STAY & PERMANENT DECEMBER are also included on track list.. wonder if it's a niley song.. ♥

    i badly want to hear PERMANENT DECEMBER!! grrrr. the album is out here on june 22nd :(

  • yeah . this is about selena . Her mom is only 16 years older than sel so he totally wrote it about selena even though she didn't work at 9.

  • @musicchord44 well she kinda did because she was on barney at the age of seven but he he changed the age but it's whatever

  • Im glad he got inspiration from Selena < 3

  • this song is about NOBODY! shut up and listen to this beautiful voice. jeez...

  • yeah i really like miley and selena but selena was in barney at age 9 sooooo i dont think this song is about either of them...and miley was always a rich kid her dad had a tv show and he was a singer WAY before she was even born ...so yeah not about either no way!

  • Very good version of Rose Garden look up by Shad K Rose Garden

  • you realize this song was written for Slena Gomez. Listen to 0:38,

    Miley father is her biological father

    Selena has a step dad

  • @bbyphat32 yea thats wat i was going to say...

  • what a hell doing this bitch in this perfect song??? miley is a daughter of a bitch...she's the biggest bitch!

  • i thought this song was about selenz gomez no.??

  • umm LuvNileyNews...u know this is about Selena Gomez and NOT Miley Cyrus?

  • @singsongs456 It could be about both. Listen to the lyrics.

  • @georgiamilne ummm NO bcuz in the song it sez "and her daddy didnt stay" miley cyrus and her dad are like best friends

  • @singsongs456 Yeah. I know. 'But her daddy didn't stay" Miley's dad kept on going to tour when she was little.

  • @georgiamilne uh ya ik but her dad took her on tour look at sum of her pics shez singing onstage with herr da. and #2 in the song it sez "when her mom was just a girl" selena's mom had her at 16 mileys mom had her at 30 sumthin

  • @georgiamilne that song is about Selena, her dad left them, and now she has a step dad.. the song is not about Miley

  • very good song.

  • don't really love this song as much as i love nearly all of his other songs on the album.

  • this song is very touching, cause my dad left me and my mom

  • just because he writes songs about girls doesnt mean they are about real girls he is just making a song so chill out and actually talk about the song and how you like it not fighting about what girl it is about maybe it is about selena but who cares its his love life we have no buisness knowing about his relationships

  • for selena actaully

  • I LOVE this song :D ♥

  • gosh, who cares who this song is about?

  • si esta cancion fue dedicada para selena gomez

  • thisis about selena

  • I don't really care who it's about, I just think it's a pretty song...

  • When I first heard this song I said "Nick wrote this about Selena."

    If you knew anything about any of Nick's relationships or the backgrounds of the Disney Starlet's, you'd know that Selena's mom had her at 16 and her father left. Miley was born into a very wealthy family. Her father is BILLY RAY CYRUS. While he basically only had a few successful songs, you still can make a lot of money out of that.

  • ya Miley has nothing to do with this song

  • Its about selena you dumb peeps

    Ha

    He gets really high pitched.

  • why is there  a pic of miley it should be selena

  • This is wrote about Selena Gomez x

    But still an amazing song! <3

  • This is wrote about Selena Gomez x

  • кво прай Майли там?:Д

  • this song is about selena gomez not miley

  • this has nothing to do with miley her mom dint have her at 16 and her daddy did stay stupid obssed fans of niley fuuck niley all about nelena ahahahhaha

  • believe me it's about SELENA Gomez. I read it in a magazine.

  • I hate nelena & love niley but it's wrong to say that it's for Miley not Selena well Miley never had to face these prolems so it's better to remove this video.........

  • i was reading the magazine and its about selena its his apology thts why im even listening to it.

  • nick has a nice voice he sings this better than who i am

  • I read about this it is about SELENA. Gosh! look it up

  • Ummthat head was digitally added to the photo :) Talkin bout miley !

  • No miley always that rich girl cause of her dad while selena's mom acctually had her at 16 and her dad left. so yea its not about miley and i kno cause miley even said in a interview that she was always kinda rich so defiantly not about her.

  • @11nelena11 I could be Miley..

    Mileys dad & mum weren't prepared, and her dad kept on going to tours and Miley started working at age 9. And Miley had so much hate and that's where the line. "Everytime she dried her tears could come in"

    It could be about Miley & Selena, and it could be about Demi or Nicole.

  • @georgiamilne not really....they were pre pared because mileys older siser, and big brother wer born by thn. Miley didnt eve have to raise a finger while selena did have to work...and miley's mom had her after she was 16 while sel's mom had her at 16. A nick was interviewd in a magizine and it even said it was about selena.

  • @11nelena11 its not for NEITHER of them! it for his best friend!!!!!!

  • its about selena gomez

  • its about selena he says it in all the magazines

  • mags are all ies everyone knows tht

  • this is effing incredible!!!! 10x better than the jonas brothers!

  • This is about selena because her mom had her a 16 and she has a STEPdad not a real dad so mabye he left and she was an actress at age 9 and when it says before her years shes always elegant and wise so maybe it is about selly

  • u call her selly like she is your friend

  • just a buch of people call her that she isnt my friend but it was just a joke to call her that

  • I Love This Song!!!! Nick is my favorite jonas hehe

  • this is about Maya, his best friends, just read some of the lyrics and you will see.

  • @KStewfan13

    No... its about Selena

  • he dated selena for what 2 months he has known maya his whole life there is a stronger chance it is about her

  • @DisneyChannleRocks

    No, he said it was about her

  • its about selena

  • i love this songg!

  • Ok thanks.

  • Is the one on the CD live like this? Or does no one have the REAL version? And is it really this short? Anyway, I LOVE THIS VIDEO!!!! GOOD JOB!!!!

  • on mp3 rocket you can get the real studio version

  • @zahooraflower

    i dont really care, they are still cute together!

  • is totaly about zelena

  • this is about selena gomez it was in the M magazine

  • totally for selena(: haha miley.. selena is way better for him..

  • @flowers526luber1

    selena is older than him

  • OMJ!!!

    Why Miley Cirus? she's ugly.

    Nick have to be aloooooone!

  • Well they are dating so really its not about miley.

    miley has both parents so it wouldnt make since.

    use your brain.

  • the song Just Friends by the JBS also mentions a rose garden so who knows maybe rose garden stands for sometihng only nick knows or maybe about Selena or miley IDK or maybe he likes rose gardens huh ppl every thing about that??? just enjoy the song

  • Rose Garden is a politcal term to do with the Presidency - you know Nick's fascination with the presidency was the inspiration and theme of this album...

  • @mikzville yea u dont know that for sure u cant be 100 percent sure

  • this is about selena not miley

  • This song is not about miley cyrus nor selena gomez, it's about his best friend who is a girl and her father died so she started working when she was 9, miley started working at age 10 cleaning toilets and selena 7 at barney.

  • @XxXxJustLikeThatxXxX thats not true about miley or selena or his best freind

  • @piglove4ever maybe, but my point is that not all of his songs are about miley or selena, it could be about someone else.

    but who is it about then? if not his bestfriend, then who?

  • @piglove4ever Stop arguing, gosh you all are acting like 3 year olds... how about you do some research copy your sources, and than see which one said the person it was about the most.

  • y u calling me a 3 year old? to me i said theres no proof that its about Selena or miley only nick really knows. u a 3 year old cuz u cant read

  • But Mya wasn't a mistake... And her dad didn't die when she was 9 he died when she was like 11 or 12...

  • No its about SELENA. What you are reading are total lies.

  • the picture is great....hehehe.....(that is just my opinion)....NILEY!!!!!!!!!!!! (also opinion)

  • NICK AND MILEY SHOULD NEVER BE TOGETHER miley is so uncewwl and nick is like nick is so hawt i mean come on common sense selena is CLEARLY the better choice! NICK JONAS + SELENA = 4EVA unless you know he wants to date me than bubi Selena

  • hahaha i tottally agree(:

  • nick comfirmed about selena.

    and they are dating.

    the end.

  • @xoxlovexamyxox where?

  • @xoxlovexamyxox no he didnt its rumored that he did

  • i like demi with him, idk why, but thats just my oppinion...but i guess niley and nelena are okay too!either way i love nick<3333

  • mE like

  • WHY IS MILEY THERE ITS ALL ABOUT NELENA

  • @SelenaGomezLoL innit!