Great, you're a fan of NY too! I just adore him. He's one of the 10 best ever. But your cover versions are fantastic. That's why I subscribed. Maybe I'm gonna try some as well, but my voice doesn't come that close.
This song was written in the key of Am , yet this recording here has dropped the key down just like Neil's version ...So this is either Neil singing it slower and better or someone who can imitate him really well .
Actually the more I listen to this recording the less it sounds like Neil .. Close , but not the same ... This guys voice is much softer ... Guitar work is the closest to Neil's that I ever heard though ... It's dropped down to D and that's why it sounds so good .
I thought this was the album version as well, but if you check out Thorny2's other clips - he might be legit. If this is real, someone needs to put him in a studio.
Is this a joke. I am a massive fan of this song and like the recording. However it is the same as the Neil Young version, with the vocals echo'd slightly to disguise Neils voice. Come on
Well done mate. its very well done. I would say have a little less eco on the voice, more reveb on the harp, less trebble and more bass on the guitar, erm.. reverb the whole thing, but thats production, Well done
its missing that raw edge that Neil Young had but still good nevertheless.
wldfan 1 year ago
What a great cover!
Ross17033 1 year ago
Great, you're a fan of NY too! I just adore him. He's one of the 10 best ever. But your cover versions are fantastic. That's why I subscribed. Maybe I'm gonna try some as well, but my voice doesn't come that close.
jogo1209 1 year ago
yeah this dude rapes it, nice
Conf1ictz 2 years ago
hay's for horses
swidrericn 2 years ago
i think this song is real nice on the ears .. good one for smokin to
co1d5m0ke 2 years ago
Excellent !!!!!
loveguitars 2 years ago
this is an okay song but hey hey my my is way better
frylok23 3 years ago
What acoustic are you using in this recording?
NaturesGlory 3 years ago
Ask Neil, all this guy did was record off a CD.
nowookiee 2 years ago
Comment removed
BrucePetty 3 years ago
omg there are 2 songs, "my my hey hey (out of the blue)"
and "hey hey my my (into to the black)"
dont call anyone are retard when you don't know anything dumbass
iseeyourprettyface 3 years ago
LOLOLOLL your a retard lol jkjk i didnt no ether in til i learned the lyrics
but ya i dont no why he changed them
chrissept21 2 years ago
He actually sings both my my hey hey and reversed.
WhatTheFork 3 years ago
fail.
Manu9078 3 years ago
wrong key on harp
gtarz38 4 years ago
Hey Todd, its Mike, josh showed me your page, Dude, great job on this song, one of my favorite songs, and you did it awesome. just...wow
Burn3933 4 years ago
Right on Bro. Thanks for checkin it out and thanks for the sub.
Thorny2 4 years ago
Wicked job. I did a version of this song too, If you are interested just click my username.
Canstey84 4 years ago
u wanna be a good man, and show me how u played the harmonica? id really appreciate it if u did
furby19 4 years ago
The more times you listen the less it sounds like Neil Young,it's kinda weird.
dannysabre 5 years ago
I agree but still!
Pupwood911 5 years ago
This song was written in the key of Am , yet this recording here has dropped the key down just like Neil's version ...So this is either Neil singing it slower and better or someone who can imitate him really well .
straydog02 5 years ago
Yeah your right straydog02
Pupwood911 5 years ago
Actually the more I listen to this recording the less it sounds like Neil .. Close , but not the same ... This guys voice is much softer ... Guitar work is the closest to Neil's that I ever heard though ... It's dropped down to D and that's why it sounds so good .
straydog02 5 years ago
this is a great voice and song... I can say best cover ever I have heard...
Keep up the good work..
Alirizakutlu 5 years ago
I LOVE Neil Young but I hate him a little bit cause he made that song Southern man and I live in the state Alabama although I am southern.
Pupwood911 5 years ago
wow it sounds exactly the same as the original version
i think ur legit for sure
dylan236 5 years ago
i record it and put it on my mp3 !!! congratulations for this version !!
alex33lacher 5 years ago
I thought this was the album version as well, but if you check out Thorny2's other clips - he might be legit. If this is real, someone needs to put him in a studio.
criminalgavi 5 years ago
Rock Chick
Give Neil Young some credit, his voice is much reedier and emotive than this.
andybute 5 years ago
Is this a joke. This is so obviously the album version with some effect applied to Neil young vocal to disguise it. Good song tho.
rockchick1903 5 years ago
I'm really diggin' the playing man, that's really excellent you should deff. get it put on CD.
I also agree with a few people, less echo on the vocals would sound better, make it feel 'crisper' and more live.
digitalhead 5 years ago
Is this a joke. I am a massive fan of this song and like the recording. However it is the same as the Neil Young version, with the vocals echo'd slightly to disguise Neils voice. Come on
rockchick1903 5 years ago
Is this a joke. This is so obviously the album version with some effect applied to Neil young vocal to disguise it. Good song tho.
rockchick1903 5 years ago
Very good man, its nice to hear someone do this song correctly (other than Neil ofcourse)!
Ranger01 5 years ago
Well done mate. its very well done. I would say have a little less eco on the voice, more reveb on the harp, less trebble and more bass on the guitar, erm.. reverb the whole thing, but thats production, Well done
kyral210 5 years ago
playing and sound quality is great, I was looking for the original to play along with but this will do just fine, thanks for posting.
burnsy403 5 years ago
Very Very awesome!! on of my favourite songs!! You definately do old neil justice!! Your one talented man!!
Mosesholeproof 5 years ago
great guitar!
superjokerrr 5 years ago
Very good , sounds very good. Keep it up!!
johnolsson 5 years ago
i thought it was ok; the guitar was good but the heavy echo/reverb on the vocals was a bit corny...
luthervoncool 5 years ago
are you tuning each string down, or just E strings?
gmmsi 5 years ago
Each string..And thanks everyone for the positive feedback!
Thorny2 5 years ago
excellent cover, maybe you should do some recordings & get them on cd !
joncas8931 5 years ago
You know...you sound AWESOME. Damn GOOD job!
ma0namaste 5 years ago
Harp is Bb, yes?
muddytrack 5 years ago
Guitar tuned down 1 whole step and Bb harp
Thorny2 5 years ago
What's the small b for?
TomShirkII 5 years ago
Bb means B flat
B# means B sharp
muddytrack 5 years ago
Thank you. Can you accomplish this on one harp? or are they separate harps? Thanks again
TomShirkII 5 years ago
2 diff harps
muddytrack 5 years ago
One Bb harp
Thorny2 5 years ago
There is no such thing as B#. There is only a half step between B And C
Thorny2 5 years ago
You nailed this one!
The guitar and vocal are great!
g6120 5 years ago