I have listened to many interpretations of this including this one, and still i think John Scott's version on the St. Puals Cathedral organ is best. However this piece is really difficult to play. So anybody who can play this work must truly show some virtuosity
I'm getting really sick of your comments. If you think it's played wrong lets see you upload a video of this of you playing how its "SUPPOSED" to be played like.
Not bad, but I prefer one thousand times Daniel Roth at Saint-Sulpice in Paris (CD Motette 1999), for the interpretation as well organ and acoustic !!!
Slower tempos too fast, and faster tempos too slow, except for the fugue, which if played at that tempo in a really live space would just be mush, especially the pedal. Did you take alot of time between the fugue and finale? Not sure what happened there, couldn't follow a beat. might have been a recording issue. staccatos perhaps a bit too clipped? Perhaps a bit dry, even for french music, (which is hard for us americans to do, since we tend to shlak up french lit too much). Thanks, great!
I hasten to add that Americans do pretty much everything wrong, and I was born and raised in America. The education system is atrocious. Believe me, I taught in higher education for 35 years before high-tailing it out of there.
As for schlak in French repertoire, I agree that people take entirely too many liberties with it, especially Franck. If only organists would stop and ask themselves 'what would the composer want?' before distoring the music beyond recognition.
How on earth can someone play an incredibly difficult piece like this by heart.... Very impressive indeed.
Inspirandus 2 months ago
So un-musical.
Ansley1685 6 months ago
@Ansley1685 THIS IS SPARTA! No, actually it's Dupré. They should be played like this
Aufsmaul33 1 month ago
The final is awesome!
louislancelotti 1 year ago
so basically... what youre saying is... youre "fuckin' good"
simonjp90 2 years ago
i cant stop listening...after 10 times i like it as much i like it the first time, bravo bravo
JAKOBVDP 2 years ago
wow amazing, you are very very good.
JAKOBVDP 2 years ago
Kiyo! Awesome!!!
at90r 2 years ago
I have listened to many interpretations of this including this one, and still i think John Scott's version on the St. Puals Cathedral organ is best. However this piece is really difficult to play. So anybody who can play this work must truly show some virtuosity
wyldecut 2 years ago
Would anyone happen to have the sheets for this magnificent piece?
tuberman91kills 3 years ago
I have a really old copy of this, I could send you a photocopy this Sunday after I retrieve it from church if you give me your email adress.
- - - Cody.
codeman2008 3 years ago
...oh, and let me add: WAY TOO SLOOOW at 08:42. That part is the "Carillon" part, for wich Dupre is famous and he invented.
Capricornboy 3 years ago
I'm getting really sick of your comments. If you think it's played wrong lets see you upload a video of this of you playing how its "SUPPOSED" to be played like.
AllenOrganCrazy 2 years ago
huh? why does he shove the bench about an inch back at 4:19 right after the triopart???
Capricornboy 3 years ago
Why should you care why he shoves it back, calm down!
codeman2008 3 years ago
Not bad, but I prefer one thousand times Daniel Roth at Saint-Sulpice in Paris (CD Motette 1999), for the interpretation as well organ and acoustic !!!
organum74 3 years ago
Fantastically well played, in a typical dead American shed.
ihadaralf 3 years ago 5
the best interpretion I ever heard of this piece...sometimes a bit too quick.
m1riccabona 3 years ago
Slower tempos too fast, and faster tempos too slow, except for the fugue, which if played at that tempo in a really live space would just be mush, especially the pedal. Did you take alot of time between the fugue and finale? Not sure what happened there, couldn't follow a beat. might have been a recording issue. staccatos perhaps a bit too clipped? Perhaps a bit dry, even for french music, (which is hard for us americans to do, since we tend to shlak up french lit too much). Thanks, great!
TrackerAction 3 years ago
I just love your jury-panel approach to commenting about a performance. He's not auditioning for you, so why do you do this?
organman52 3 years ago 4
I hasten to add that Americans do pretty much everything wrong, and I was born and raised in America. The education system is atrocious. Believe me, I taught in higher education for 35 years before high-tailing it out of there.
As for schlak in French repertoire, I agree that people take entirely too many liberties with it, especially Franck. If only organists would stop and ask themselves 'what would the composer want?' before distoring the music beyond recognition.
organman52 3 years ago
Forti questi giapponesi... Bravo!
organimagister 4 years ago
Grazie per le vostre parole gentili.
kiyow 4 years ago
Non c'è da ringraziare: esecuzione di alto livello, organo stupendo... Grazie a voi per aver caricato il video!
organimagister 4 years ago
cameron carpenter..
michaeldegorio 4 years ago
and your point is...............?
Diapasonic 3 years ago
very well played. sehr gut!
bastian1608 4 years ago