You are absolutely right in principle. I enjoyed this video; 'should be an interesting series. If I might, I will only quibble slightly with you about the level of a Go AI. True, a first dan can easily best any AI but that player is not a first year player. 1-dan is actually the first level of professional play, 9-dan being the highest level. Amateur rankings work in reverse order and are termed kyu-1 and above. The kyu rankings are determined by relative strengths when using handicap stones.
A la, Kasparov versus Big Blue, have they tried similar programming experiments with the game Go? If so, were the results any different than with Chess? -- other than the games' different rules, of course.
Although I'm getting a PhD in math, I can't play chess worth a darn! My brain just isn't wired to think in multiple parallel directions, which is essential in chess.
I know a lot of math oriented people. They all hate chess. I, on the other hand, hate math and love chess. I don't know if this is the general rule, but most likely it is not.
I've heard that claim made about go before, that computers can't play it well, but I can't beat computers regularly at go. I wonder what rule set the computer would have to follow to be 1st dan? I don't know. That's the problem with go, the rules aren't standardized. For example, the first time I learned go I learned a rule set that seems to only be played in one coffeehouse in south central PA.
I forgot about that Big Blue Kasparov (sp?) incident, lol
fauyd 2 years ago
(___x___)
zam319 2 years ago
good video, looking forward to watching the rest. Also, thanks for introducing me to the wonderful game of GO.
samuelmichaud 3 years ago
there are a lot of go playing computer programs that rank differently from 15k all the way to 1dan.
ki6eki 3 years ago
You are absolutely right in principle. I enjoyed this video; 'should be an interesting series. If I might, I will only quibble slightly with you about the level of a Go AI. True, a first dan can easily best any AI but that player is not a first year player. 1-dan is actually the first level of professional play, 9-dan being the highest level. Amateur rankings work in reverse order and are termed kyu-1 and above. The kyu rankings are determined by relative strengths when using handicap stones.
DiscipleZ3R0 3 years ago
A la, Kasparov versus Big Blue, have they tried similar programming experiments with the game Go? If so, were the results any different than with Chess? -- other than the games' different rules, of course.
StevenErnest 4 years ago
The best Go AI in circulation can get stonecold WHIPPED by a first year player.
TheCarruths 4 years ago
What
msa1985 4 years ago
Although I'm getting a PhD in math, I can't play chess worth a darn! My brain just isn't wired to think in multiple parallel directions, which is essential in chess.
TheMathGuy 4 years ago
Perhaps there's something to be said for the poetry of numbers.... but that would be letting the cat out of the bag.
TheCarruths 4 years ago
Pawn to king 4!
CousinoMacul 4 years ago
I know a lot of math oriented people. They all hate chess. I, on the other hand, hate math and love chess. I don't know if this is the general rule, but most likely it is not.
ThatChristian 4 years ago
I've heard that claim made about go before, that computers can't play it well, but I can't beat computers regularly at go. I wonder what rule set the computer would have to follow to be 1st dan? I don't know. That's the problem with go, the rules aren't standardized. For example, the first time I learned go I learned a rule set that seems to only be played in one coffeehouse in south central PA.
bubblesort 4 years ago
very fascinating...great job
TogetherForPeace 4 years ago
This is awesome. Thanks for it =D.
masterrx 4 years ago
Cool, chess!
ryanisfootdrums 4 years ago
wow, man. I lose at chess about 95% of the time.
clockworkhorrorshow 4 years ago