Before I just knew that this is a very beautiful sad song ... but now that I have my heart broken, I understand the lyrics the melody, it's just too hard~ T . T ...
this is mainstream chinese/taiwanese music, it wouldn't be gay even if they did use the female "ta" seriously all these arguments are annoying!!! who cares, drop it and enjoy the music
this is not a MV about gay love + in many places they use that "Ta" for both sexes. and it's TRADITIONAL (FAN TI ZI) not simplified... only Mainland china uses (officially)
他 is used because that is the general word used for someone when it is not specified, doesn't have to be a man in this case and it's not a spelling mistake.
think you guys got in wrong.for chinese in taiwan which is the 'qian ti zi'their ta is writen the same for both gender female or male.He did not fall for the gay in the mv.
i posted translations a few posts ago. there was nothing in there mentioning a dead bf. just her asking her bf who he loved most. her or a (w.e gender) other person
dang ni jue ding ni yao li kai wo When you decided you wanted to leave me wo mei you shuo shen me I didn't say much jiu dang zuo ni zi you Just treated you as you were free you hao ji ci wo dou xiang wan liu So many times I wanted to pull back ku qiu ye mei you yong Intense begging was of no use jiu dang zuo shi ji mo Just treated it as loneliness
mm i wont deny that the character is the male him but when im writing, even if im mentioning a female, i often use the male version out of ease since thats what i(im assuming most people are the same) learned first. ive heard that this song describes how he loves his gay friend instead of her. interpretation is free to opinion. this song just reminds me of my ex soooo ill keep it hetero sexual in my mind =]
holly crap, the video might be scenes from a gay taiwanese movie, i dont remember seeing it but... i hope it's a movie cause i really want to see it. can someone tell me the name???
omg i didn't know this song was about gay love <3 i thought they just mess up the 他. now i love this song even more!!! whos the cute actor/model in the video?
Uhh.. verbally yes I guess, ... 他 the male form (with the man on the side)... 她 the female form (with the female on the side)... still a little different character wise, that is how I learned it anyways... recently too soo....
anyone notice... faye has short arms? love her hair. great song. tiny bit confused about the whole gay thing tho...songs stirrs up enough emotions about being abandoned, adding the gay thing to the mix just makes it too complicated
you are an ignorant pig, and please use correct English gramma and words. you should be the one ashamed of yourself. go and get yourself some education before posting anything, ever again.
2011 快 2012 年了
仍舊愛
這首歌!!
有一種, 說不出的, 感傷的美...
CSjimmykudo95 1 month ago 9
Faye kinda look like Hebe in this mv for some reason xD js..
CSjimmykudo95 1 month ago
i love much to this song ~~~ <3 <3 nice feel to listening !!
MySchuka 2 months ago
其实 你很爱他 就像你能为了他失去我一样··
zikui0924 2 months ago 3
不曉得大家知不知道
這首歌FIR有唱另一個版本
是用鋼琴來詮釋的
alen516 2 months ago 3
nice song dudeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee
MySchuka 3 months ago
哈哈看到zheng08的回應我覺得好好笑XD不說還真的沒發現...
teresa820107 5 months ago
我之前也有聽過網路上的~好像風格又更哀傷???都同一個人唱的說
minnie7832 5 months ago
也是這張我最喜歡的歌^^
前奏超級超級有FU
好聽ㄋㄟ
這樣淡淡的唱
好聽ㄋㄟ
XD
是少數關於愛情的我有感受到歌詞的淒涼
配樂好好聽喔
ahebe20 6 months ago in playlist FIR的歌 4
於是愛恨交錯人消瘦
lemonsky189 6 months ago
失戀聽了,心能清醒起來的歌
Vansyn1900 6 months ago 4
听了真伤心
sq5211082 7 months ago 4
前奏有點長..="=不過很好聽!
melody90012 8 months ago 4
不要不要!聽到我都心痛 真的不要放棄
ccq1215 9 months ago
聽到心坎裡 心好痛!!聽到心坎裡 心好痛!!聽到心坎裡 心好痛!!聽到心坎裡 心好痛!!聽到心坎裡 心好痛!!聽到心坎裡 心好痛!!聽到心坎裡 心好痛!!聽到心坎裡 心好痛!!聽到心坎裡 心好痛!!聽到心坎裡 心好痛!!聽到心坎裡 心好痛!!聽到心坎裡 心好痛!!聽到心坎裡 心好痛!!
jill109019 9 months ago 3
oh my they just broke up.. Faye and Real :(
jiexuan 9 months ago
really awesome!!
lmwpassion 10 months ago
it been played for many... times,still find love it so much! 不敢奢求,你说爱我;就坦白告诉我,谁是你的最爱;其实你很想他,就说出口吧。
AlleyFun2011 10 months ago 2
it been played for many... times,still find love it so much! 不敢奢求,你说爱我;就坦白告诉我,谁是你的最爱;其实你很想他,就说出口吧。
AlleyFun2011 10 months ago
說妳沒有想他.是可憐我拔...
qazft12v 11 months ago
說妳沒有想他.是可憐我拔...
qazft12v 11 months ago 2
說出了~我的心情~
729648225 11 months ago 2
之前很喜欢听的歌曲 现在听回依旧很好听 歌词也很好
beyourstar 1 year ago
很喜欢 可是KTV不敢唱。。。太高了- -
punkjexx 1 year ago 4
不想再次聽到你說 你很愛他.......
TheMicky1830 1 year ago 2
一分鐘的前奏也太長了吧
samson14hk 1 year ago 14
@samson14hk 我覺得前奏很好聽, 能彈出很寂寞的FEEL出來
ForteVSBosco 1 month ago 6
Does anyone know who the male character is?
simplicity428 1 year ago
這首歌在說我現在的心情e!
cryimg 1 year ago
peipei0611 1 year ago
這首歌很適合現在的我
frozen8310 1 year ago
這首歌很適合現在的我= =|
frozen8310 1 year ago
Before I just knew that this is a very beautiful sad song ... but now that I have my heart broken, I understand the lyrics the melody, it's just too hard~ T . T ...
xgirldyx 1 year ago
邱澤!!!!!!!!!!@@@@@@
albert111 1 year ago
is there a male version for this
decemberbenjamin 1 year ago
我也感觉 难唱哦~nice song
lovemyself520 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
飛兒在這裡真醜...............
johnchannetshow 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@johnchannetshow 你媽也很醜 生你這種垃圾
cronohyde 10 months ago
我很喜欢这首歌
ZhenniLi 1 year ago
好聽!!好聽!!!
xiongz88 1 year ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
垃圾歌
sky9456 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
MAKE A CHANGE IN CHINA !!!
w w w . ALF . us . ms
heartforanimals 1 year ago
- 現在的妳 - 應該很幸福吧 ;
babii8023 1 year ago 7
其实你很想他 就说出口吧...
不想再次听到你说 你很爱他...
因为你每说一次,我的心就痛一次...
HolyKiller43 2 years ago 18
這首歌 感覺好難唱
tv00335566 2 years ago 12
hay quá
kenny131487 2 years ago
hay quá , 1 bài hát hay ,
kenny131487 2 years ago
天啊 超好聽!!!!
peter07012 2 years ago 9
So sad song
So good faye!
AI913 2 years ago 2
so sad....
peter07012 2 years ago
Faya voice is hella nice!!!!!!!
xaychen 2 years ago 10
無奈而悲傷的訴說這段心境過程,娓娓道來濃濃的不捨和愛戀,可是最後結果,也只能黯然神傷...
好悲傷的歌
mandyych 2 years ago 156
@mandyych
eric21424 1 year ago
i love tis song!!it make me feel touching..
LyJiaYnG 2 years ago 8
好好聽!
hang1969 2 years ago 6
好感动哦,好好听哦。~~~
tengtengxi 2 years ago 14
to downstairs:
that's not the point
7658724 2 years ago 7
Why does she always smell her right armpit?
supremewhip 2 years ago 6
This has been flagged as spam show
HAHHAHA lol
reesesbits 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
maybe her right armpit smells better than her left
shammmuk 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
LOL, funny comment . But insulting. HAHA !
willysoh93 2 years ago
AHAHAHAHAHAHAHHA omggg... that is such a random thing to notice!! xD you made my day supreme.
jetizon 2 years ago 3
每次听这首歌都很想哭,情绪非常激动。想起了他的背叛,就坦白告诉我谁是你的最爱。。他很爱她却骗我说其实他是爱我的。。我已没有借口,只能放手,不敢奢求你说爱我。。
moondymoondy 2 years ago 27
this song is amazing. the more u hear it, the more u love it...!
bearnannan 2 years ago 12
這個影片回應是針對:S.H.E - Shuo Ni Ai Wo 說你愛我
看到的時候囧掉了
hknt2003 2 years ago 12
为什么?
不明白。。。
pong93 2 years ago 6
nice song nice singing
dhllkk 2 years ago 3
歌詞一針見血..
每次聽到都好想喊
cpwkwk 3 years ago 10
Nice song!
nice Faye!!!
liuye11111 3 years ago 2
我超级喜欢飞....
特别这歌....因为...这歌刚出时...恰巧....他....出轨了....
我也一样问过...你爱我还是她...他也一样回答...他爱我....结果...其实...他是爱着她....
n9lin 3 years ago 21
whats this song called in english??
tahghg123 3 years ago
u love her/him a lot LOL....that's the best translation i can get
clifflin3 3 years ago
ni - you
hen - realy/very/alot
ai - to love
ta- he/she/it but that character is for 'him'
so you realy love him or you love him alot.
UniversalTruths 3 years ago
right on! lol.. when i saw the title id laugh bc id always love using those words xP
rickiex 2 years ago
i LIKE this song too
^0^"
dr3amkiss 3 years ago 4
I love this song.
Albeit the beat and the music seems kind of too cheerful for such sad lyrics, but that's what I like.
lalaheaven 3 years ago 6
This has been flagged as spam show
It's strange, but their songs seem a bit more upbeat lately.... like 3 wish
Before, their old songs, lydia and fly away, seem more like...rockier? don't know how to describe.
But then I haven't heard that many from F.I.R. X)
summertwinkle 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
thats a good thing. their old stuff sounded too much like j-rock shit.
cjao67 2 years ago
tis song so nice !!
loveslicious 3 years ago 5
this is a very pretty song; i love it!
LilStarling1110 3 years ago 3
I love the intro of this song, cool guitar style with nice voice from Faye, such a nice song =)
superlcs333 3 years ago 9
this is mainstream chinese/taiwanese music, it wouldn't be gay even if they did use the female "ta" seriously all these arguments are annoying!!! who cares, drop it and enjoy the music
zheng08 3 years ago 73
this is not a MV about gay love + in many places they use that "Ta" for both sexes. and it's TRADITIONAL (FAN TI ZI) not simplified... only Mainland china uses (officially)
CharlyChan 3 years ago 8
thamk you!it pronounce the same but spell differently
KXCrocks 3 years ago 5
Faye is very beautiful in this mv
paullocwen99 3 years ago 27
Faye is very beautiful in this mv
paullocwen99 3 years ago 14
nvm i saw the girl TA during 2:30 hahaha.
sophiahah 3 years ago
or maybe i think it can go both ways.
i love this song =)
sophiahah 3 years ago 3
they just misspelled the ta right? this MV is not about gay love?
sophiahah 3 years ago
@sophiahah
他 is used because that is the general word used for someone when it is not specified, doesn't have to be a man in this case and it's not a spelling mistake.
grayex 11 months ago 2
LOL .
cant you all see on 2.30 the mv wrote 她 ?
it is not gay lah . -.-
xiinx 4 years ago 4
yupp. the guy 'ta' can be used for both guys and girls. =)
lol is it only me who thinks that the electric solo was kinda.. out of place? 0_0
chaserj7 4 years ago
think you guys got in wrong.for chinese in taiwan which is the 'qian ti zi'their ta is writen the same for both gender female or male.He did not fall for the gay in the mv.
lovelies23 4 years ago 2
the video says that the guy her boyfriend loved was killed, and shes asking her bf who he loved the most.
sababa20 4 years ago
i posted translations a few posts ago. there was nothing in there mentioning a dead bf. just her asking her bf who he loved most. her or a (w.e gender) other person
cjao67 4 years ago
I meant the music video .. not the words of the song , the actual video. But oh well , who cares who she's singing about .. it's a gorgeous song ! ^^
sababa20 4 years ago 3
cjao67 4 years ago 2
yin wei wo neng ming bai
Because I can understand
ta de wen rou dui ni shi zhong jie tuo
Her kindness was a kind of release for you
jiu tan bai gao su wo
Just honestly tell me
shei shi ni de zui ai
Who do you love the most?
cjao67 4 years ago 2
qi shi ni hen ai ta
Actually you really love her
dui wo de cheng fa
As my punishment
shuo ni mei you xiang ta
Saying you didn't think of her
shi ke lian wo ba
was pitying me, right?
cjao67 4 years ago 2
wo yi mei you jie kou
I already don't have any excuses
zhi neng fang shou
I can only let go
bu gan she qiu
I don't dare demand you
ni shuo ai wo
to say you love me
cjao67 4 years ago 2
qi shi ni hen ai ta
Actually you really love her
ta hen wen rou ma
Is she really gentle?
qi shi ni hen xiang ta
Actually you really miss her
jiu shuo chu kou ba
Just say it
cjao67 4 years ago 2
the chiinese character ta.. says "he".. not "her"..
"actually you really love him"
sababa20 4 years ago
mm i wont deny that the character is the male him but when im writing, even if im mentioning a female, i often use the male version out of ease since thats what i(im assuming most people are the same) learned first. ive heard that this song describes how he loves his gay friend instead of her. interpretation is free to opinion. this song just reminds me of my ex soooo ill keep it hetero sexual in my mind =]
cjao67 4 years ago
aww ^_^
sababa20 4 years ago
wo yi bu xiang duo shuo
I already don't want to say too much
wu zhu er duo
I cover my ears
bu xiang zai ci ting dao ni shuo
Don't want to hear you say again
ni hen ai ta
that you really love her
cjao67 4 years ago
I some what get that , the songs is to the girl who's loving her bf ....
kiddykitty 4 years ago
sigh,stop arguing about such stuff please.dont you guys find it pointless?just enjoy the song will ya?
lovelies23 4 years ago 3
d ko maintidihan
postlang3rd 4 years ago
NICE!
Lycoria 4 years ago
that actor in the MV is roy qiu ze.
faye has a lovely voice.
everybodyshout 4 years ago
great song =)
10ui3 4 years ago 3
man i cant get over this song until i figure out everything, its so SAD. i am gonne keep watching over and over again.
shyandgay 4 years ago
holly crap, the video might be scenes from a gay taiwanese movie, i dont remember seeing it but... i hope it's a movie cause i really want to see it. can someone tell me the name???
shyandgay 4 years ago
omg i didn't know this song was about gay love <3 i thought they just mess up the 他. now i love this song even more!!! whos the cute actor/model in the video?
shyandgay 4 years ago
but isnt it true that nowadays they use that "ta" as the uniform word for him/her? to simplify things, so i heard..
jenniferzzzzzz 4 years ago
which ta? u mean this one 他? idk if they unify it or not...
shyandgay 4 years ago
Uhh.. verbally yes I guess, ... 他 the male form (with the man on the side)... 她 the female form (with the female on the side)... still a little different character wise, that is how I learned it anyways... recently too soo....
princessgigglies 4 years ago
no it's not. in chinese writing, if the sex is unknown, it's usually use 他 (male)... but if u insist about gay i m speechless :/
hkrickywu 3 years ago 15
i like the fact that they're actually pretty talented.
alias91919 4 years ago 4
do they have any recent songs? could someone tell mee? ^.^
happystar11 4 years ago
anyone notice... faye has short arms? love her hair. great song. tiny bit confused about the whole gay thing tho...songs stirrs up enough emotions about being abandoned, adding the gay thing to the mix just makes it too complicated
rabidtypist 4 years ago
Ohh, I didn't know FIR sang this! D:
theSCIENTISTxxx 4 years ago
best song of the year
mauiwong 4 years ago
this song very nice n sweet aspecially Faye, she look like very sweet n beautiful, Ian n Real also "cool"!!!!
fir20she07 4 years ago
SO you love him.... him, erm, hmmmm, so it's about gay love?
ok, interesting
joycechuey 4 years ago
pls dun put all this chain,bcuz if u blive u r lover,u shud nt be doing this type of shameful things
samanthazzz 4 years ago
What? O.o
Minyon 4 years ago
you are an ignorant pig, and please use correct English gramma and words. you should be the one ashamed of yourself. go and get yourself some education before posting anything, ever again.
devilisation 4 years ago
gramma? really now, you were just emphasizing the use of correct GRAMMAR dumbass.
aznenvazn 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
so i had a typing mistake, big deal, u cunt face
devilisation 3 years ago
she have an rich and powerful voice that hold hearts together...beautiful song: )
tiffanyG 4 years ago
em...wat is goin on in the video who does the guy like?
lovely song......
SHiRLiSss 4 years ago
what's the mtv about actually?
xantex 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
There are 20 angels in this world
10 are sleeping
9 are playing
1 is reading this
put this on 4 video comments within 15 mins,if u do, sum one u love will surprise u sum how!! If u don't , u will lose ur love.!!
AlucardDA 4 years ago
emo! love it.
PEARLIEWIRLIE 4 years ago
ray from malacca.. i hear this songs i will thinking of u.. even u not love me but nvm.. i still wait ur answer..
Yumi7575 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
read dis
There are 20 angels in this world
10 are sleeping
9 are playing
1 is reading this
put this on 4 video comments within 15 mins,if u do, sum one u love will surprise u sum how!! If u don't , u will lose ur love.!!
titimun 4 years ago
cool
6241256292224784 4 years ago
OMG TIS IS SO SO NICE!
kennigologist 5 years ago