I'm glad that Princess Daphne was on the list because she's without a doubt the hottest female Disney character. I think the Dark Queen from Battletoads should have made the list.
@JReed1985 princess daphne was NOT a disney character she came from a series of games called dragons lair witch was created by don bluth he did work for disney at one point but when he created princess daphne he was working for advanced microcomputer systems sorry just a heads up.
@TheBazman111 well either way I still consider her a Disney character because she was created by a former Disney animator but no matter. She deserves a place in the top ten video game babes.
@oscalavera her name is princess daphne oh shit i had a deja vu i dream on this i told someone the name of that princess for real o shit jaja what a life
Just what is it with the sex appeal in video games? you haves guys who are fit and muscular and chicks who has sexy curves and a nice ass. Usually these characters involves in Action/Fighting games like Chun Li for example. Why is that almost every game they have that? Is it to draw consumers into buying their product?
...At first, I always thought Samus is guy but turn out, I was wrong when her armor explosion to reveal her long blonded hair... I went like this 0_0. Now I know. In Super Smash Brawl, she was in that game. I was totally horny while I played her in whole game...
When you guys get tired of looking at videos and want to chat with a real, sxy teen girl! im me (yahoo -> SpoiledBrat19f ) or (aim -> jessicateases19)
if you are tired of looking at teasing videos and want to see the real thing live, contact me... my yahoo screen name is: SpoiledBrat19f and for aim: jessicateases19
I fell lame for even commentin' here, but #4 was a total fail IMO.
I'm not sure if #7 was for Christie Peridot or the Dead or Alive girls in general. Christie Peridot would deserve at least #3, if not #1.
To all Alyx haters, fuck ya
Also, anyone that actually seriously doesn't know who #'s 6, 3, or 1 is a complete moron... well, actually if ya don't know who ANY of these characters are, except for #10 and #8 than ya seriously don't know jack shit about games
@ButtaNToast This man in a perfect example of how not to raise your kids. Notice the tasteless "You can calm down and go back to grade two now." Then again, what would the internet be without trolls?
Sir, you can calm down and go back to stating your own opinions on other youtube videos, since clearly you've nothing better to do with your life.
@heavell99 "Sir, you can calm down and go back to stating your own opinions on other youtube videos, since clearly you've nothing better to do with your life. "
Surprised Cammy isnt in this. Chun li is hot, but cammy is way hotter. What about Sofia from Battle Arena Toshinden? Russian girls in leather with whips are sexy. Julia Chang is hot too. So is Ivy from soul calibur Tifa isnt here? (oldskool tifa, with the huge tits and miniskirt) Terrible selections.
Wait,Samus is female?! (SHIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIt
lol dude everyone knew she was a female since well ever no? but its true his picks r off lol no offense but like the 3 first i was like who the fuck r they just the doa/street/snk chicks would of made a better top 10 then this lol.
was the guy drunk when he made these picks ? He left out Ana Wong (Resident Evil) and Nina Williams (Virtua Fighters and Death by degree), plus Princess Daphnie of Dragons Lair don't no appear til the very end. and the one he has at #1, no one ever knew that was a female till now. And FYI...Lara Croft beats them all
@miaow81 you forget that Metriod started out as an arcade game in the early 80's and the poor graphics were like the old pac man as well as Joust... there was no way to determan the sex of the character
@wraith13 Dude...people have known Samus Aran was a female since the original Metroid. Just because YOU didn't know it doesn't mean everyone else hasn't known it since the first person died in the game in 1986 and her armor exploded to reveal a woman.
@SolaranX as I told Miaow81 ... Metriod started as an arcade game in 1980"s like pac man and the poor graphics you never really knew if it was a robot or a soldier in a battle suite...plus you prove my point that NO ONE knew the sex of medriod UNTIL armor exploded to reveal medroid as a woman.. if not for that insident we would never known
@diegoribero Yes we finally find out that metroid is a female.congrats , still she is not up to the stats that Lara Croft (10 years and going strong) and if you old enough to have seen the arcade game of Metroid the graphics were poor
Whats 6??
gameaddict248 5 days ago
Uhm.... wheres Aya and Saki from onechanbara ?
tlittletalk5 1 month ago
WHERE THE HELL IS JILL VALENTINE???
DJCJThaPrinceOfJB 3 months ago
I like the song.
TheVillainOfThisTale 3 months ago
Oh, I'm in this part of youtube again
Josiah2634 3 months ago
who's number 4?
cuntrag4 4 months ago
I'm glad that Princess Daphne was on the list because she's without a doubt the hottest female Disney character. I think the Dark Queen from Battletoads should have made the list.
JReed1985 4 months ago
@JReed1985 princess daphne was NOT a disney character she came from a series of games called dragons lair witch was created by don bluth he did work for disney at one point but when he created princess daphne he was working for advanced microcomputer systems sorry just a heads up.
TheBazman111 3 months ago
@TheBazman111 well either way I still consider her a Disney character because she was created by a former Disney animator but no matter. She deserves a place in the top ten video game babes.
JReed1985 3 months ago
Fucking bad Quality
Maxxer0815 4 months ago
number 6 is the best.
TheStimpyland 4 months ago
What the name of this music??? D:
TheWarRevolutionTime 4 months ago
dont agree with this list... carry on.
Xellith 4 months ago
@Xellith of course you don't agree with it! it's a 5 year old video!!!
aaron75fy 4 months ago
@aaron75fy No I just never would have picked 6/10 of those as my top 10 ever at any point in time lol
Xellith 4 months ago
@Xellith every one is different, but i hesitate to learn which 10 would you have picked back then
aaron75fy 4 months ago
TOP 7
7 - Ada Wong
6 - Sheva Alomar
5 - Ashley Grahan
4 - Eva ( mgs4 )
3 - Claire Redfiel
2 - Jill valentine
1 - Exella Gionne
BaseRadio 4 months ago
Eva i remember that part <3
BaseRadio 4 months ago
Создатель ролика извращенец олд скула. Незачёт.
KniFEorBulleT 4 months ago
whats 7 from?
pakrat271 4 months ago
@pakrat271 dead or alive 4
spazzzo2011 4 months ago
Number ten was look like a lesbian
sisatmaoc 4 months ago
#6 & # 2
TheRodry007 4 months ago
# 9 was the girl from perfect dark
scorcher004 5 months ago
samus number one? really? might as well pick Maria from Castlevania symphony of the night
neurosis44 5 months ago
Hey dude what games are thies girls from!! Plese answer!
michelle09428 5 months ago
@michelle09428 for no reason im correcting your errors "Hey dude what games are these girls from!! Please answer!"
Coughranbranden 4 months ago
@Coughranbranden Hey thanks, I´m from Denmark, sooo... ;-)
michelle09428 4 months ago
i saw number ten, then i just decided to quit
bluemgv 5 months ago
who is the 9?
ILightWas 5 months ago
@crazysaijo , cant see the name, working off phone, the girls name is trish
mrshadowcristal 5 months ago
Man you jurk off to much watching cartoons! get real!
Samyaza69 5 months ago
Wheres Claire Redfield??? And #3... I DISAGREE
Josh6957992 5 months ago
@Josh6957992 well about the #3, there are pretty cool skins =)
DivingHawker 5 months ago
why Lara croft 2nd and robot chick 1st? this is all wrong
TheUnknownD 6 months ago
what about girls from Mortal Kombat?
Soyargentinocordobez 6 months ago
what about lady from dmc 4
crazysajko 6 months ago
How bout Morrigan from DarkStalker...psh...narrow minded reviewers....
Rocketfist15 6 months ago
my top ten
watch?v=sUu_U-I1ox4
CRASHISONLYGOODGAME 6 months ago
no tekken..
meishalaurafionax 6 months ago
ZOEY FROM L4D ALSO HOT ;]
Centaurian0190 7 months ago
Comment removed
Centaurian0190 7 months ago
i've been googling the last 3 for years. i dont need a video to tell me this!!
BooglyBoot 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
watch?v=iq0IUMH2QlY
coco bandicoot porn
Mrchadwarden1 7 months ago
240p we meet again
GTAstuntking 7 months ago 16
Oh I guess you've never heard of an entire series called Final Fantasy
Fugicara 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
watch?v=dmM9AifbbBo
PRINCESS PEACH PORN!
Mrchadwarden1 8 months ago
shit list.
scorpionb055 9 months ago
My #1 would be tied between Tifa and Kasumi.
JJEDI1138 9 months ago
ahh hyeaaaa SAMUS!!!!
Zenekei 10 months ago
Ada Wong people, Ada Wong!!!!
rj0001977 10 months ago
@rj0001977 :D I know right
Hetaliafan25 8 months ago
samus number one number #11111111111111111111111111111 =)))))))))
thumps up!!!!!! if you think so too
w2lf 10 months ago
jill valentine is not even in it WTF!!
grimbomufc09 10 months ago
i agree with samus being number #1
chaos9115 10 months ago
hahahah, you actully just gave her 1?! lol
this vid is crap
AidanChandlee 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Name of blonde girl at 1.15??
tobegallagher 10 months ago
This video ia Bullshit
Deyreel 11 months ago 21
@Deyreel didn't you read the video information? it's 5 years old
aaron75fy 4 months ago
@Deyreel
screw this video. those girls aren't hot
Hawkins90210 3 months ago
Eva deserves first place
ms18occ 11 months ago 2
Samus (no.1) is a bounty hunter so far the best female protagonist ever
geloelcubano95 11 months ago
menuda mierda,, y Tifa Aeris Rinoa de FF´s ? y Jill y Claire de Resident Evil ? y Mai ?????
txumo 11 months ago
Name of blonde girl at 1.15??
oscalavera 1 year ago
@oscalavera her name is princess daphne oh shit i had a deja vu i dream on this i told someone the name of that princess for real o shit jaja what a life
HWJSLS2SADAH234 11 months ago
stole the vid dude
slayerfido2 1 year ago
Samus is good but i still think lara deserves the 1st place
Dodo567892 1 year ago
10 isnt a girl
gloup81 1 year ago
@gloup81 yes she is...
kalzorath 1 year ago
Respond to this video... 9,7,6,2,1
are the hottest thumbs up if u agree
SuperCoolkid1071 1 year ago
Ah cmon! Lara is more sexy than Samus!
djjonasc 1 year ago
Just what is it with the sex appeal in video games? you haves guys who are fit and muscular and chicks who has sexy curves and a nice ass. Usually these characters involves in Action/Fighting games like Chun Li for example. Why is that almost every game they have that? Is it to draw consumers into buying their product?
andrewtom3d 1 year ago
dude mirnada from mass effect 2
TheGarrrettHB 1 year ago
What da' fuck is Final Fantasy?
CLICKMEYOULOSER 1 year ago
...At first, I always thought Samus is guy but turn out, I was wrong when her armor explosion to reveal her long blonded hair... I went like this 0_0. Now I know. In Super Smash Brawl, she was in that game. I was totally horny while I played her in whole game...
dunnooooo1234789 1 year ago
Laaarrraaaa <3333
XkairiXnekoX 1 year ago
a list without Tiffa is not a list at ALL
owerseer 1 year ago 2
WHAT THE FUCK MAN ?
WHY THERE IS NO JILL, HUH ?
FAIL
Damn3691 1 year ago
haha they all suck
DoctorRainbow8321 1 year ago
@truvak uuhh Seamus is a guys name and Samaus is the character
IcelandicBeast 1 year ago
@IcelandicBeast It's "Samus" and she's a girl.
Moonchipz 1 year ago
this countdown sucks... but Seamus, she rules.
truvak 1 year ago
Fuck yeah EVA!
emazinglyemi 1 year ago
Why don't you guys look at real women instead of pixels -.-
bloodfox1222 1 year ago
@bloodfox1222 It's funny - because for you to be able to comment on this, YOU had to look at the video..
emazinglyemi 1 year ago
Yeah BLOODRAYNE!!!!
nastymkfan 1 year ago
didn't see that one coming, even though i KNOW samus is the absolute number one!
DeHomunculus 1 year ago
jilll from re is hot jill from re5 is fuicking hot shes teh hottest charachter
killingdj0 1 year ago
Jill is more sexy girl of all games
SIrIntegra4Fairbrook 1 year ago
WHERE THE FUCK IS CORTANA
kaine22111 1 year ago 2
When you guys get tired of looking at videos and want to chat with a real, sxy teen girl! im me (yahoo -> SpoiledBrat19f ) or (aim -> jessicateases19)
qplatinumangel08v 1 year ago
No Jill Valentine and no Anna from Fear Effect......
samballa23 1 year ago
where's mai shiranui?????
zava007 1 year ago
zoey from left 4 dead
asskakakaka 1 year ago
if you are tired of looking at teasing videos and want to see the real thing live, contact me... my yahoo screen name is: SpoiledBrat19f and for aim: jessicateases19
shornygirlxi 1 year ago
3rd. Miranda from Mass Effect 2
2nd. Bayonetta
1st. Jessica Chobot from IGN
dzgeneration 1 year ago
only one i agree with is Alyx
SanderEhamaa 1 year ago
@SanderEhamaa cause she loves the player
guyboy625 1 year ago
@guyboy625 ahem..maybe...
SanderEhamaa 1 year ago
where is Kerrigan , where is Nova they both are from starcraft and not get in the top 10 lol ...
SpeedeyFreaks 1 year ago
Jill Valentine and Aya Brea should be there.
Re1Mu2R3 1 year ago
19F here bored, with cam who wants to play? contact me (yahoo screen name: SpoiledBrat19f or aim:jessicateases19)
jsweetdollxxxd 1 year ago
#2&3 DA BEST O.O
oscardelahoya522 1 year ago
NUMBER 4 IS NOT IN A VIDEO GAME!!!!!!!
zmarticuzmyluv 1 year ago
@zmarticuzmyluv
Dragon's Lair. Look it up. And next time check your infos before posting shit.
AustrianReaper 1 year ago
@zmarticuzmyluv The game is dragons lair, its an old arcade game.
starkey1356 1 year ago
This top ten sucks....!!!
Netxen 1 year ago
SAMUS IS SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO HOT!!!!!!!!!
384PurpleMetalBlade 1 year ago
Where's Jill Valentine?
74maddawg 1 year ago
where's jill valentine ??
remitentcarlos 1 year ago
I knew samus was number 1 as soon as I started watching.You should update this though.Faith (Mirrors edge) is definitely a candidate
mustachio31 1 year ago
what about Orchid?????????
carlosmovistar2009 1 year ago
dude no fense but....this video was really lame.
ppteddypp 1 year ago
omfg, yes eva from metal gear solid 3! Ahhh!!!
iheartlovebleach 1 year ago
I fell lame for even commentin' here, but #4 was a total fail IMO.
I'm not sure if #7 was for Christie Peridot or the Dead or Alive girls in general. Christie Peridot would deserve at least #3, if not #1.
To all Alyx haters, fuck ya
Also, anyone that actually seriously doesn't know who #'s 6, 3, or 1 is a complete moron... well, actually if ya don't know who ANY of these characters are, except for #10 and #8 than ya seriously don't know jack shit about games
Ada Wong should be here.
OyVey666 1 year ago
Alyx Vance? No.
ARCboogieman 1 year ago
Lara Croft's got the #1 ass in video game history.
Her cleavage would be in the top 10.
X360Comedy 1 year ago
Lara Croft is the only hot one in this video and the one before her is just sort of creepy
jwhitloctombraider 1 year ago
lol he stole the vid...
freakofnature1974 1 year ago
i dont think a lot of thought was put into the selection for this video
W4NZ1 1 year ago
ur kiddin me right
Clairesandison 1 year ago
donde quedo may de KOF?
Z1FU 1 year ago
geeeeeeeeeeek
izzy104 1 year ago
WHOOOO GO SAMUS
Skippyjed 1 year ago
Cant belev you put snake eater in there
Derier12345 1 year ago
0:37 whos this?
mihai96z3d 1 year ago
Dude, what about Zoey from Left 4 Dead?!
scenezombie909 1 year ago 2
@scenezombie909 Left 4 Dead didn't exist in 2006. :p
MaverickAlvis 1 year ago
@scenezombie909 yeah im thinking the same until i noticed that this was made in 2006
stritagon 1 year ago
dude i disagree with number 3 might as well put Ashley from re4
xxsergio59xx 1 year ago
i think they should have sheva form resident evil 5
leerocks360 1 year ago
@leerocks360 In 2006?
SaintUtah 1 year ago
MGS3 EVA ftw. but who was #3?
solidsnake2234 1 year ago
@solidsnake2234 number 3 my friend was alyx vance (giggity) from the half life series :DDDDD
afrue987 1 year ago
Note that there is no subject to the pedo choice. It implied that I meant Tifa, but it cannot be clarified unless I say what I meant.
You can calm down and go back to grade two now.
ButtaNToast 1 year ago
@ButtaNToast This man in a perfect example of how not to raise your kids. Notice the tasteless "You can calm down and go back to grade two now." Then again, what would the internet be without trolls?
Sir, you can calm down and go back to stating your own opinions on other youtube videos, since clearly you've nothing better to do with your life.
heavell99 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@heavell99 "Sir, you can calm down and go back to stating your own opinions on other youtube videos, since clearly you've nothing better to do with your life. "
Ahem.
ButtaNToast 1 year ago
@ButtaNToast ...... your big words confuse me
afrue987 1 year ago
what about morrigan?
rafitalco 1 year ago
Surprised Cammy isnt in this. Chun li is hot, but cammy is way hotter. What about Sofia from Battle Arena Toshinden? Russian girls in leather with whips are sexy. Julia Chang is hot too. So is Ivy from soul calibur Tifa isnt here? (oldskool tifa, with the huge tits and miniskirt) Terrible selections.
mmmmmarcus 1 year ago
@mmmmmarcus I've noticed your diversity, but your selection of Tifa disturbs me.
That's a pedo choice.
Try finding Jill Valentine (RE:1) and Claire Redfield.
They're ACTUALLY hot.
And they're legal
ButtaNToast 1 year ago
@ButtaNToast How is tifa a pedo choice? She's freakin 20 years old, you dork.
mmmmmarcus 1 year ago
Wait,Samus is female?! (SHIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIt
CLICKMEYOULOSER 1 year ago
@CLICKMEYOULOSER lol exactly..... metroid prime play through it without knowing she is a girl and when she dies.. .WTFFFFFF u onw no shes a girl
afrue987 1 year ago
where is jill valentine and rebecca chambers?
legosanta007 1 year ago
10,Lara Croft
09,Chun Li,
08,sheva alomar
07,excella goine
06,mileena
05,jade
04,kitana
03,rebecca chambers
02,jill valentine
01,Claire redfield
charmed9prue 1 year ago
@charmed9prue do you know what mileena really looks like right?
Xfan17 1 year ago
Who's and from what game is #9?
Sylvestro 1 year ago
It's the users choice! If you're favorite isn't there. Make your own video.
PinoyPsychoPath 1 year ago
Where's Tifa and jill valentine
metalica1337 1 year ago
lol dude everyone knew she was a female since well ever no? but its true his picks r off lol no offense but like the 3 first i was like who the fuck r they just the doa/street/snk chicks would of made a better top 10 then this lol.
miaow81 1 year ago
What is the game called for number 6??
number1ninja111 1 year ago
@number1ninja111 metal gear solid 3
gohan5566 1 year ago
no video game character beats bayonetta. SEXY!!!
liTTleBender25 1 year ago
was the guy drunk when he made these picks ? He left out Ana Wong (Resident Evil) and Nina Williams (Virtua Fighters and Death by degree), plus Princess Daphnie of Dragons Lair don't no appear til the very end. and the one he has at #1, no one ever knew that was a female till now. And FYI...Lara Croft beats them all
wraith13 1 year ago
@wraith13 hmm i believe everyone knew samus was a female since hmm pretty much forever.
miaow81 1 year ago
@miaow81 you forget that Metriod started out as an arcade game in the early 80's and the poor graphics were like the old pac man as well as Joust... there was no way to determan the sex of the character
wraith13 1 year ago
@wraith13 Metroid did NOT start out as an arcade game. It started on the NES, Nintendo themslves comfirmed that.
fjh1616 1 year ago
@wraith13 lara croft beats them all i agree ;)
afnica1 1 year ago
@wraith13 Dude...people have known Samus Aran was a female since the original Metroid. Just because YOU didn't know it doesn't mean everyone else hasn't known it since the first person died in the game in 1986 and her armor exploded to reveal a woman.
SolaranX 1 year ago 26
@SolaranX as I told Miaow81 ... Metriod started as an arcade game in 1980"s like pac man and the poor graphics you never really knew if it was a robot or a soldier in a battle suite...plus you prove my point that NO ONE knew the sex of medriod UNTIL armor exploded to reveal medroid as a woman.. if not for that insident we would never known
wraith13 1 year ago
@wraith13 Obviously you ignore the JUSTIN BAILEY Metroid password exists (Nes game from 1986)
You cant compare Joust and "old pac man" with the Nes Metroid...
besides 20 years are more than enough to tell the one in the suit is a girl by the time you see/comment this video.
diegoribero 1 year ago
@diegoribero Yes we finally find out that metroid is a female.congrats , still she is not up to the stats that Lara Croft (10 years and going strong) and if you old enough to have seen the arcade game of Metroid the graphics were poor
wraith13 1 year ago
@wraith13 lara croft is an ugly milf
mangasleejosh2 1 year ago
@mangasleejosh2
You realize what you said is extremely hypocritical, right?
EdtheBlueNinjaYoshi4 1 year ago
@EdtheBlueNinjaYoshi4 how?
mangasleejosh2 1 year ago
@mangasleejosh2
You said she was ugly, but MILF stands for "Mother I'd Like to Fuck".
EdtheBlueNinjaYoshi4 1 year ago
@EdtheBlueNinjaYoshi4 oh....yeah i guess that doesnt make sense
mangasleejosh2 1 year ago
@wraith13 Lara Croft is one of the ugliest girls in video games.
NightmareX7 1 year ago
@NightmareX7 Wow this was the shitiest shit ive heard in months LARA CROFT RULES!!!
drMINDdamage 1 year ago
@wraith13 metroid wasn't ever on arcade, dipshit.
musicintrees 8 months ago
@SolaranX it doesnt show her as a woman when u die in the first.
musicintrees 8 months ago
who is 3?
mankindkn 1 year ago
@mankindkn im pretty sure her name is alex from the half life series. in the orange box or maybe you can just buy it by itself.
xxtodger85xx 1 year ago
@arghle456 fucking tard.
DrinkyKrow1 1 year ago