Only touching on the story-thank god. Horror films? Sad songs? Listen to this, nothing touches it-SAW 2? Zombies? Bedtime stories!
Thank goodness
-We in Vancouver have two stories-Picton and Olsen: if you don't know about these stories-don't investigate but, just know Vancouver-we also have much to answer for.
I just wish we knew why!!! people aren't inherently evil and Myra or Ian had nothing in there backgrounds to lead to this horrendous act. They are as sick as one another and i agree that she will be burning in hell for what she has done. I just wish more than anything that Ian, before he dies tells the police the whereabouts of Keith Bennett. To lay the poor lad to rest and give his mother peace before she dies. I am a Christian but even for me there are acts beyond forgiveness.
I agree. Personally I find myself feeling guilty when trying to forgive this. How can you, I or anyone else out there forgive them. If Winnie Johnson (Keith's mum) ever forgives them that might change but until then I find it almost disrespectful towards all the families, and of course the kids. Just don't think the forgiveness is ours to give.
If it was my kids I would want no forgiveness or mercy in this world or the next, for the perpatrators.
Oh man i was gonna ask if kieth was related to Alan but didnt but cos i assumed they wernt. Just did a quick search on it and fucking started crying when i learnt he is. But i sort of feel guilty for feeling more sad that he was related to alan bennet but i shouldent should i?
thank fuck hindley's dead im glad she died of cancer aswell she deserve's it 4 the life's of the children her & ian took evil bitch i hope she rots in hell & ian will hopefully join her soon evil bastards
Couldn't agree more. Having said that, Brady has been trying to starve himself for years and wants to die. I'll happily pay my taxes to keep the cunt alive and lingering on as long as possible. He sees death as his escape. I hope he doesn't get it for a long time.
I love the lines "You may sleep, but you will never dream. Very powerful lyrics as is the norm with Mozza. That and the contradicting imagery in 'But fresh lilaced moorland fields cannot hide the stolid stench of death'. What a tribute.
Killing Ian Brady has nothing to do with being able to find that boy. The only way to find him most likely is for Brady to tell them. Killing him has nothing to do with it.
When I consider what happened to these innocent children, this song always makes me very sad - infact, I almost cry whenever I hear the opening few chords of Johnny's guitar!
Buenas, entre todas las canciones de The Smiths, esta es una que se hace resaltar mucho la forma poetica y bella de contar algo siniestro, es algo que caracteriza mucho a Morrisey. Muchas gracias por colocar el video.
Remember to watch in high quality. Clear all your internet option to do so. Please view all my favorite and video dont get lost. See how much I know.Learn something new.Dont be left out like the rest.You only lived once.You will ask wow he knows that.Because I am at a different level. 20 years ahead.From today.Imagine. Thank me later.Universe Technique
oh man, i can't beleive that hindley and brady were such fucking retards and did that to those poor kids! if they were still alive i'd kick there fucking asses!
No, Hindley died a few years ago in hospital(thank fuck), but Ian Brady is still in prison. If I was in charge of the prison he was in, I'd cut his balls off, torture him, slash him and batter him. He's a cunt that deserves the devil ramming pokers up his arse for all eternity.
how on earth jonny marr makes that sound i dont think i'll ever know, it gives you so many diffrent feelings, Beautiful and haunting..in the light of what the song is about..how the talents of marr and moz didnt make them superstars i dont know..but i guess Morrissey wouldnt have wanted that anyway
Agree about Rourke. The Smiths were so amazing as a band. Morrissey's lyrics, Marr's guitar, Rourke on the bass and Joyce on the drums. Too bad they were so messed up outside of the music. They flamed out far too soon.
can anyone tell me why there are no videos of Morrissey singing this song? I get the feeling that he did not like to sing it in concert, for obvious reasons.
played it once and that was it,i think it was the first song they ever played live. didnt feel that it was appropriate to keep doingit becouse of the subject matter.
'The Smiths' created phenomenal songs, mate, and this is the only one that is very sad. The reason why it is so sad is because it's all about 'The Moors Murders'. I mean, what did you expect the song to sound like when it was about something so sad?
okay i wont care for you people's reply'S but is it just me or can this guy sing horribly? i swear the way he sings it makes no since and this song altogether feels very hard to listen to
I gave you a thumbs up...because he REALLY isn't for everyone...he didn't ever intend to be...he knew who would be attracted to him and that suits him just fine!
wow dude ... i find this singing so incredible on this song that i never even imagined i would see a negative comment about it.... He is just so in tune and rhythem with the guitar ... can't imagine it being sang any other way
Hmmm kyletjackson, it seems you are describing a psychopathic/sociopathic disorder as the cause of Bradys actions, absolving him of personal responsibility due to insanity. I disagree. The problem comes with the semantic definition of "Evil", not the most useful of words. In this case i use it meaning he took delight in others suffering and was both sadistic and malicious in doing so, knowing full well the consequences of his actions. Whether he felt empathy/emotion or otherwise irrelevant.
monk, the thing is that it makes all the difference. He knew the effect of his actions on his future IF he was caught, but he saw no fault in his actions. He wasnt immoral, you have to know right from wrong to be immoral. He was Amoral, as in he didnt have or understand morals, he saw murder as a perfectly acceptable action.
Listening to The Smiths brings back memories of the beautiful past. Ironically, as harsh as they seemed at the time, I would give anything to go back to 1990 when I first discovered their music.....and my first love!! This band will always be a part of me, helping me through some of the lowest times in my life.
this i have to say is the best song the smiths have ever made... and myra and ian should be pissing in there boots when they hear this song because they will be avvenged!!!!!
Good work, ignore Monkey7r he hasn't got a fucking clue what he's talking about. You've made a dark, forboding series of images that perfectly capture, and synchronise with the song.
This song always makes me cry. I know the case od The Moords Murders very deeply. It's horrible... but still, tjis song is very, very strong and brilliant. I love The Smiths!
Ha ha, touche my friend. As you rightly point out I'm in no way a genius and don't have a creative bone in my body. Easier to critique than create right? I'll rephrase " Video not my cup of tea but Bartproost has obviously put a lot of effort and thought into making a tribute to a classic track" Peace man! :)
I've been listening to this song in my car (from the original Smiths album, of course) for the past week straight. It's such a simplistic melody, relatively, but so hypnotic and addictive at the same time. I've got to research who "Hindley" is and all that; till I looked up the lyrics online, I thought Morrissey was singing, "Invalid wakes and invalid says, invalid wakes, invalid wakes..." Awesome song though. And great video as well:)
I'm still listening to this so good
timsmashuhoe 1 week ago
Great song
timsmashuhoe 1 week ago
3 people that we will haunt when they laugh. SERIOUSLY!
CrimsonDragon2505 1 month ago
Ah, child murderers, what vivisection was designed for.
xCarpeJugulumx 5 months ago
@IntoCaves Ha, I replied to a comment from 3 years ago. And even wierder you replied to it. X)
Excellent taste in music, sir. My hats off to you :)
1013637 7 months ago
still their best song to date if u ask me..
this is just something i've never heard before
to believe this was on their debut album is just.. sick!!
simionTheOne 7 months ago
You might sleep but you will never dream...
Caligula138 1 year ago
This song always brings a tear to my eye and your video accentuates the sadness and tragedy of the events beautifully.
9999biggers 1 year ago 3
I hope that Hindley died a slow and excruciatingly painful death!
lincbond442 1 year ago 4
such a wonderful song. and beautiful art done for it. kudos
DomWrath 1 year ago
The sound of the light.
Nothing
Thank you
Ugly and yet beautiful.
davesdatingtips 2 years ago
Only touching on the story-thank god. Horror films? Sad songs? Listen to this, nothing touches it-SAW 2? Zombies? Bedtime stories!
Thank goodness
-We in Vancouver have two stories-Picton and Olsen: if you don't know about these stories-don't investigate but, just know Vancouver-we also have much to answer for.
davesdatingtips 2 years ago
This song is so creepy when you know what it's about...
BritishBrummie 2 years ago 8
This comment has received too many negative votes show
it's about me abducting some children and then abusing them and slaughtering them and then burying them in the moors.
thetalentedmrman 2 years ago
@thetalentedmrman I love ignorant people, they make me feel clever.
LikelyLad97 10 months ago
I love your drawings. I want them for my walls. You are amazing!
khasperg 2 years ago 4
I just wish we knew why!!! people aren't inherently evil and Myra or Ian had nothing in there backgrounds to lead to this horrendous act. They are as sick as one another and i agree that she will be burning in hell for what she has done. I just wish more than anything that Ian, before he dies tells the police the whereabouts of Keith Bennett. To lay the poor lad to rest and give his mother peace before she dies. I am a Christian but even for me there are acts beyond forgiveness.
loobylou145 2 years ago 3
I agree. Personally I find myself feeling guilty when trying to forgive this. How can you, I or anyone else out there forgive them. If Winnie Johnson (Keith's mum) ever forgives them that might change but until then I find it almost disrespectful towards all the families, and of course the kids. Just don't think the forgiveness is ours to give.
If it was my kids I would want no forgiveness or mercy in this world or the next, for the perpatrators.
So yes, I agree with you!
gracie1232 2 years ago 2
Your right, I thought Quantum physics was hard to understand beacuse it hurts my head when i try to understand it. This has the same effect.
toweronepower 1 year ago
Oh man i was gonna ask if kieth was related to Alan but didnt but cos i assumed they wernt. Just did a quick search on it and fucking started crying when i learnt he is. But i sort of feel guilty for feeling more sad that he was related to alan bennet but i shouldent should i?
toweronepower 1 year ago
thank fuck hindley's dead im glad she died of cancer aswell she deserve's it 4 the life's of the children her & ian took evil bitch i hope she rots in hell & ian will hopefully join her soon evil bastards
CSRKO1993 2 years ago 17
i dont know why people gave you a thumbs down
MaryCFraser 2 years ago
Couldn't agree more. Having said that, Brady has been trying to starve himself for years and wants to die. I'll happily pay my taxes to keep the cunt alive and lingering on as long as possible. He sees death as his escape. I hope he doesn't get it for a long time.
gracie1232 2 years ago
I love the lines "You may sleep, but you will never dream. Very powerful lyrics as is the norm with Mozza. That and the contradicting imagery in 'But fresh lilaced moorland fields cannot hide the stolid stench of death'. What a tribute.
Jonesycool92 2 years ago 5
Dark and sublime bass lines, perfect match to JM's guitar tunes....Rourke u r so talented and underrated.
LOVE U ANDY!!!
karziflora 2 years ago
a broken man has nothing to look back on with pride, nothing to look forward with hope
uplixnaw 2 years ago 6
This comment has received too many negative votes show
"does it put you in a child killing trance?"
Yes.
aNightmaresRequiem 2 years ago
what a fucking tribute
gerthie 2 years ago
What sick fuckers.
vanostraniii 2 years ago
this song is very very hypnotic, the guitar/melody always puts me in some kind of a trance.
54spiritedwill54 2 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
does it put you in a child killing trance?
ccclllsport 2 years ago
Gorgeous drawings. Thanks for putting this together!
veggiesareyummy2 2 years ago
Ever seen that painting "Myra"? It's Hindley's mugshot in children's handprints. Hits a nerve, don't it?
ezelfikker 3 years ago
great tribute to familys
Liam94WestBrom 3 years ago
What a song. Very chilling but nevertheless
zutroy85 3 years ago
the only way they can find the last boy is to kill ian brady after he tells them..
they cant kill him, casue its the easy way out for him. this story is awful :(
DropDeadLeaa 3 years ago
Killing Ian Brady has nothing to do with being able to find that boy. The only way to find him most likely is for Brady to tell them. Killing him has nothing to do with it.
adsj2f2 3 years ago
When I consider what happened to these innocent children, this song always makes me very sad - infact, I almost cry whenever I hear the opening few chords of Johnny's guitar!
LennonMorrissey 3 years ago 3
"Oh Manchester, so much to answer for..."
bloc47 3 years ago 3
Buenas, entre todas las canciones de The Smiths, esta es una que se hace resaltar mucho la forma poetica y bella de contar algo siniestro, es algo que caracteriza mucho a Morrisey. Muchas gracias por colocar el video.
Larxk 3 years ago
genius, there first song together at the early stages when it was just moz and marr.
restless999 3 years ago
'how on earth jonny marr makes that sound i dont think i'll ever know, '
he's just arpeggiating open chirds. ita not that difficult. johnny marrs strenght lies in the taste of his playing not its difficulty.
reltonpelton 3 years ago
Remember to watch in high quality. Clear all your internet option to do so. Please view all my favorite and video dont get lost. See how much I know.Learn something new.Dont be left out like the rest.You only lived once.You will ask wow he knows that.Because I am at a different level. 20 years ahead.From today.Imagine. Thank me later.Universe Technique
universetechnique 3 years ago
oh man, i can't beleive that hindley and brady were such fucking retards and did that to those poor kids! if they were still alive i'd kick there fucking asses!
mhisk8isapunker 3 years ago
I think hindley is still alive and in broadmoor prison.
vorkutaman 3 years ago
No, Hindley died a few years ago in hospital(thank fuck), but Ian Brady is still in prison. If I was in charge of the prison he was in, I'd cut his balls off, torture him, slash him and batter him. He's a cunt that deserves the devil ramming pokers up his arse for all eternity.
LennonMorrissey 3 years ago 5
Amen to that. I hope the cooks in Broadmoor are spunking into his meal every dinner time.
vorkutaman 3 years ago 5
I agree. I was born over 20 years after this case but it still horrifies me. I can't believe someone can be so evil.
gemmm85 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
yawn
zutroy85 3 years ago
What do you mean?
LennonMorrissey 3 years ago
Its Ian Brady who is stil alive, Myra Hindley died a few years ago from cancer.
gemmm85 3 years ago
considering I live on Saddleworth what a moving song - if not the most poignant ever
the smiths will never be repeated or surpassed
carcass88888 3 years ago
how on earth jonny marr makes that sound i dont think i'll ever know, it gives you so many diffrent feelings, Beautiful and haunting..in the light of what the song is about..how the talents of marr and moz didnt make them superstars i dont know..but i guess Morrissey wouldnt have wanted that anyway
JcjR1988 3 years ago 3
even noel gallagher says jonny marr,cant play as good as jonny marr?he's that good
NAH1HODGE 3 years ago 2
I think Andy Rourke's bass helped a lot.. He's so underrated
Factory0utlet 3 years ago 4
Agree about Rourke. The Smiths were so amazing as a band. Morrissey's lyrics, Marr's guitar, Rourke on the bass and Joyce on the drums. Too bad they were so messed up outside of the music. They flamed out far too soon.
U2berox 3 years ago 3
Beautiful and tragic drawings of the poor children. R.I.P.
Angelina1east 3 years ago 4
wrote a short story based on this it really inspired me such a horrible event turned into such a great song...
frizzielizzie3001 3 years ago
wow i didnt fink of it gunna be like this i had to learn about the moorland murders in skwl n this song helped me whoop
wtcaniput 3 years ago
very dark and moody what a tune typical smiths awesome ... oh manchester.....
gburny 3 years ago
LE FALTA HALGO PERO NO SE QUE
caledd 3 years ago 2
me 2
mrpentium 3 years ago
can anyone tell me why there are no videos of Morrissey singing this song? I get the feeling that he did not like to sing it in concert, for obvious reasons.
mrpentium 3 years ago
played it once and that was it,i think it was the first song they ever played live. didnt feel that it was appropriate to keep doingit becouse of the subject matter.
ZAMPAROAD 3 years ago
It was played once in Manchester I think. It wasn't played live again because; well obvious reasons like you said.
Murjoe16 3 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
music to slit your wrists to
rubys200777 3 years ago
this song is very very hypnotic, the guitar/melody always puts me in some kind of a trance.
KENVAIL 3 years ago 6
yup....
jlp58mjp 3 years ago
this is the stereotypical crap that outsiders bring on Morrissey/The Smith's music and it is completely ignorant.
Those with the least knowledge comment the most!
winterman93 3 years ago 7
oh my god, you listen to Chumbawamba, NICKELBACK! and fucking Flogging Molly and you take a shot at The Smiths? HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
beIshazzar 3 years ago 22
Thats funny:)
eanerickso 3 years ago 3
@beIshazzar Pwned him GJ.
1013637 7 months ago
'The Smiths' created phenomenal songs, mate, and this is the only one that is very sad. The reason why it is so sad is because it's all about 'The Moors Murders'. I mean, what did you expect the song to sound like when it was about something so sad?
LennonMorrissey 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
okay i wont care for you people's reply'S but is it just me or can this guy sing horribly? i swear the way he sings it makes no since and this song altogether feels very hard to listen to
Waacm 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
The strangled croon isn't for everyone.
DowJonesss 3 years ago
It is for me!
momomimimomo 3 years ago
Is for me, too. :b
DowJonesss 3 years ago
I gave you a thumbs up...because he REALLY isn't for everyone...he didn't ever intend to be...he knew who would be attracted to him and that suits him just fine!
winterman93 3 years ago 3
wow dude ... i find this singing so incredible on this song that i never even imagined i would see a negative comment about it.... He is just so in tune and rhythem with the guitar ... can't imagine it being sang any other way
kasra333 3 years ago
Very moving....great work!
MsJulie73 4 years ago
I love Morrissey, He makes my genitals giggle
johnnypolotdi 4 years ago 7
I've uploaded my most recent illustrated video: 'This Night Has Opened My Eyes' by The Smiths.
youtube/watch?v=1IL0gfbuBRs
Enjoy.
bartproost 4 years ago
Evil CUNTS, the pare of em!!!!
Would have LOVED to get my HANDS on Ian brady,
I would have throttled the EVIL CUNT!!!!
Monkfish05 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
He wasn't evil, he was deeply disturbed, he was cursed with madness and an inability to understand emotion, he had no conscience.
kyletjackson 3 years ago
Hmmm kyletjackson, it seems you are describing a psychopathic/sociopathic disorder as the cause of Bradys actions, absolving him of personal responsibility due to insanity. I disagree. The problem comes with the semantic definition of "Evil", not the most useful of words. In this case i use it meaning he took delight in others suffering and was both sadistic and malicious in doing so, knowing full well the consequences of his actions. Whether he felt empathy/emotion or otherwise irrelevant.
Monkfish05 3 years ago 5
monk, the thing is that it makes all the difference. He knew the effect of his actions on his future IF he was caught, but he saw no fault in his actions. He wasnt immoral, you have to know right from wrong to be immoral. He was Amoral, as in he didnt have or understand morals, he saw murder as a perfectly acceptable action.
kyletjackson 3 years ago
He was as evil as a human can ever get. He was mental but evil all the same. The familys of the victims should be allowed to get their vengence
ccclllsport 3 years ago
It's because he was Scottish. The Scottish are the devil incarnate.
vanostraniii 2 years ago
Listening to The Smiths brings back memories of the beautiful past. Ironically, as harsh as they seemed at the time, I would give anything to go back to 1990 when I first discovered their music.....and my first love!! This band will always be a part of me, helping me through some of the lowest times in my life.
gtz1100kmf 4 years ago 4
Find me!! Find me nothing more. We are on a Sullen misty Moor.
How is it possible to be so terribly EVIL????!!!! Bastards. Were these SCUMBAGS for real?????
*The Monk sheds a tear for Humanity*
Monkfish05 4 years ago 3
The song is from 83 actually
ostattack 4 years ago 2
defintely the best Smiths/Morrisey songs ever, I went backwards with the Smiths and heard their debut album last and was instantly hooked!
fuckyouboob 4 years ago
this i have to say is the best song the smiths have ever made... and myra and ian should be pissing in there boots when they hear this song because they will be avvenged!!!!!
lidd36 4 years ago
Good work, ignore Monkey7r he hasn't got a fucking clue what he's talking about. You've made a dark, forboding series of images that perfectly capture, and synchronise with the song.
Kagemusha22 4 years ago
What a brilliant song and well done video.
BALUSHNA 4 years ago 2
This song always makes me cry. I know the case od The Moords Murders very deeply. It's horrible... but still, tjis song is very, very strong and brilliant. I love The Smiths!
TheKillUncle 4 years ago 3
I studied the history of this track extensively, and made the video based on what I learned...
Thank you for your nice comments on my drawings: I trust you're an artistic genius :-)
bartproost 4 years ago
Ha ha, touche my friend. As you rightly point out I'm in no way a genius and don't have a creative bone in my body. Easier to critique than create right? I'll rephrase " Video not my cup of tea but Bartproost has obviously put a lot of effort and thought into making a tribute to a classic track" Peace man! :)
Monkey7r 4 years ago
Peace. At least we can agree on our taste in music... :-)
bartproost 4 years ago
the moors murders were terrible.
haunts me still.
lonelysingingdoll 4 years ago
I've been listening to this song in my car (from the original Smiths album, of course) for the past week straight. It's such a simplistic melody, relatively, but so hypnotic and addictive at the same time. I've got to research who "Hindley" is and all that; till I looked up the lyrics online, I thought Morrissey was singing, "Invalid wakes and invalid says, invalid wakes, invalid wakes..." Awesome song though. And great video as well:)
pabulum28 4 years ago
The Smiths performed this song live once only. I'd love to see it.
NinetiesYouth 4 years ago
do you know what year, 84?
fuckyouboob 4 years ago
Controversial!
MidlandNinja 4 years ago
This is a superb video to my favorite Smiths song. Really wonderful work! It's such a sad song but has so much beauty. This was a very tragic story.
simonbnyc 4 years ago
awesome
love this song nice video
erin2b 4 years ago
really cool. Although that GeoVid sign is really annoying.
DeadLinDy 4 years ago
"fresh lilac moorland fields cannot hide the stolid stench of death" Oscar Wilde lives!!
siouxsiezque 4 years ago
really good stuff excellent song moz most unique writer as well as the kinks both rule !
blatantleyawsome 4 years ago
that was fantastic. Cant you get rid of the demo version label. Your work deserves better!
invertedbeardthe2nd 4 years ago
@invertedbeardthe2nd: Wish I could, but honestly don't know how! Anyone know any good (free) ppt to video converter software? And where to download?
bartproost 4 years ago
If you can supply me your original ppt file, im sure I can solve it for you (or at least give it a good try)
invertedbeardthe2nd 4 years ago
Yeah was waiting for this to appear, my fave song next to shoplifters of the world.
clarkey01 4 years ago
One of the most moving Smiths songs, and this animation goes well, I like it. Nice one.
t0r0y0o 4 years ago