I sincerely wish for this guy that he get some experience of life, love, grief, etc. if he wants to play someday like an human and understand Beethoven's humanity.
The meter marking on score was 2/4, not 4/4 or 4/8. That is, if we played it too slow (more than 6 min), it sounds like a piece with 4/8. BTW, the tempo marking was Andante, not adagio. The andante means "flowing" on classical period. In fact, the distingwish on 'andante' and 'allegretto' are not as much as we think (in classical). In fact, even the slowest version (Brendel, maybe :P), he played it about 7:20. BUT....I didn't repeat any period :P.
I know that you don´t repeat anything but I play this song, too... I have heart very much recordings and it is fact that all people play is much more slowly... and it sounds better if it is slowly! I´m sorry....^^
ur 2 fussy about rythme man talk about the musiality of the piece which i found none in this performance with a very rough harsh sound and poor touch.that is more important than the diviation of rythme.the rythme and timeing wasnt that bad!
I liked it but you seem to 'smack' the piano keys in an unsettling midi-like way. Maybe it's the way that it was recorded or the piano itself.
PianoForteAndrew 2 years ago
Technically played well...but an utter lack of devotion and feeling :-(
chriswales19 4 years ago
I sincerely wish for this guy that he get some experience of life, love, grief, etc. if he wants to play someday like an human and understand Beethoven's humanity.
romotchka 4 years ago
jep, it's like a machine... that's very bad...
maxibusch 2 years ago
MUUUUCH TOO FAST!!! normaly this pice is 08:00 minutes... (sorry for bad english i´m from german)
maxibusch 4 years ago
well...the tempo was not too fast. :P
The meter marking on score was 2/4, not 4/4 or 4/8. That is, if we played it too slow (more than 6 min), it sounds like a piece with 4/8. BTW, the tempo marking was Andante, not adagio. The andante means "flowing" on classical period. In fact, the distingwish on 'andante' and 'allegretto' are not as much as we think (in classical). In fact, even the slowest version (Brendel, maybe :P), he played it about 7:20. BUT....I didn't repeat any period :P.
Volodos0409 4 years ago
I know that you don´t repeat anything but I play this song, too... I have heart very much recordings and it is fact that all people play is much more slowly... and it sounds better if it is slowly! I´m sorry....^^
maxibusch 4 years ago
ur 2 fussy about rythme man talk about the musiality of the piece which i found none in this performance with a very rough harsh sound and poor touch.that is more important than the diviation of rythme.the rythme and timeing wasnt that bad!
amirmot 4 years ago