It took a while for me to realize this, but Tsuji sang Aibon's 'suki, suki, suki' at the last part there. I wonder what was going through her mind when she sang that. Must have been really painful for her.
Of course Miya did the best, she had the best range and control out of all of this line up. n_n
Maasa has always had poor control although she is much better today then in this video clip. Risako sang very, very well for her voice at this stage. Only a bit flat on her last notes.
Maimi always sounds better in upbeat songs, but she sounded really good in this. Raspy :3
Yui was crackly but wasn't meant to be a good singer. Erika's range was good, a few quavers here and there.
miyabi sung so well. she was by far the best here, the others were good too, but miyabi was the best. so please disregard my comments below, i removed them, but still disregard them. i think i was on crack or something when i said she was the worst, she clearly is the best here. my bad. XD
Omg.....I was freaking amazed when Miya hit those high notes! Miya is so GOOD!!! And I love how she just smiles cutely after that. I love you, Miya~!!!<3
@HelloProjectLover2 Okay, well, clearly, you're the only one here that thinks so. I agree that Maimi has a good voice, but a lot of the times (not in this performance), she gets really off-key. Miyabi's may be nasally, but compared to others, she has a great voice. It's not shaky either. Her high note was phenomenal. That's not accomplished a lot by girls who are her age (in this performance). You must really hate her or something. O___o
I really think that Miyabi is a little overrated. Out of all these girls she has the highest voice which is why she hit the notes. Risako is always terrible. Maimi. Maasa and Tsuji always sound better with low vocals
@BlueDolphin2011 miyas not so overrated as you think..shes where she is cause of talent she isnt pushed to the front...the girl still only has one pb...
please don't hate me but how is it possible that nono sounded so bad? my ears are bleeding. I mean she totally ruined those parts that aibon used to sing! miya was awesome though <3
This was the first time I've heard a song from these girls that made me feel I was listening to average people singing. Sorry if that may PO some of you guys. I'd be below average if I sang, but I don't do it for a living...or for fun! Lol.
Abe Natsumi's graduation. That's the first and best version I've heard of this song.
@principex1000 no las conoces O.O bueno aparte de tsuji son yui okada y erika miyoshi de biyuden, miyabi natsuyaki sudou masa y risako sugaya de berryz koubou y maimi yajima lider de ºC-ute
@principex1000 no las conoces O.O bueno aparte de nozomi tsuji son yui okada y erika miyosi de biyuden miyabi natsuyaki sudou maasa y risako sugaya de berryz koubou y maimi yajima
Risako is umm let say not at good as she could be at 1:43 :( Its horrible.Miyabi was the only good one.Maimi ok and nono was okish but the rest were terrible
I think they weren't the best in this concert, the song not-live is much better. I was just wandering, why are Miyabi, Risako and Maimi here? Isn't this supposed to be a Morning Musume song? Still, I think Maimi and Miyabi were the best. :)
Tsuji can sing a lot better than she did here.. a *lot* better. Miyabi was really good with Takahashi's part at the end. As for Yui's high note.. eh.. I'm just gonna erase that from my memory.
No offence to any of them, but this song doesn't suit them. =/ I love them all dearly, but I think the original group is the only one that does this song justice, it's a powerful song and I found that the way they sang it was a little...limp.
Tsuji is as good as usual. Maimi and Miyabi did great, I like the "I love you for what you are" bit a lot. the one singing 1:30 cracked the high note somehow. the rest... their singing isn't bad, but it sounds werid.
What happened here? They sing good, but here they sound... horrible. I'm sorry but I don't like the way they're singing, without feeling and out of tone.
kinds shows, noone can really come close to folks to orginally sang the song. i think the younger singers haven't really had that much vocal traning and i think morning musume members are mostly pushed beyond their limits at being vocally flawless. the original singers of this song were all morning musume members.
Yui??O_O OMG that was actually embarassing~~Reina adn Rika!!~ xD they were like lauguhing!!~ xD good thing when Yui sang her "Ame Nochi SUKU"~~Part~~ Miyabi saved her with "Oh Yes i love you"~~parts x3
And not sure which short haired girl you mean, but it's either Natsuyaki Miyabi from Berryz Koubou or Miyoshi Erika from v-u-den. That depends on which girl though.
that was horrific. Even though Tsuji sang in tune the song was just really bad. I love them all to bits but I don't like this. But they're still new. But no cover will ever beat the original I think. Thanks for the upload
that was horrific. Even though Tsuji sang in tune the song was just really bad. I love them all to bits but I don't like this. But they're still new. But no cover will ever beat the original I think. Thanks for the upload
For a second, I thought you meant Niigaki Risa! I would be like, "Dude, she's not even in this performance and she has an amazing voice!: Well, Risako's voice is unstable at times, but she has her good moments, too. ^_^
but i would agree if you said the younger girls who sang this outshone the older ones who also sang in this rendition. Nono looked... reluctant to sing
...it sounded like the battle of the nasally voices, compared to the original. I don't know why they chose Tsuji and Yui to be pretty much the two main roles--neither of them are particularly strong vocalists when it comes to this type of song, at this pitch.
It took a while for me to realize this, but Tsuji sang Aibon's 'suki, suki, suki' at the last part there. I wonder what was going through her mind when she sang that. Must have been really painful for her.
dizzyai 2 weeks ago
Comment removed
uptoCHINAtown 2 weeks ago
Comment removed
uptoCHINAtown 2 weeks ago
Tsuji are awesome ~ <3 kawaii ~
ichigi93 5 months ago
:3 miya!! so good
Roxxybby012 6 months ago
-gonna skip the obvious Miyabi worship-
RISAKO IS SO CUTE<3
RaReiRoo 8 months ago
miyabi the best~~~
risako and tsuji are good too
anime08mish 11 months ago
Of course Miya did the best, she had the best range and control out of all of this line up. n_n
Maasa has always had poor control although she is much better today then in this video clip. Risako sang very, very well for her voice at this stage. Only a bit flat on her last notes.
Maimi always sounds better in upbeat songs, but she sounded really good in this. Raspy :3
Yui was crackly but wasn't meant to be a good singer. Erika's range was good, a few quavers here and there.
Nono sung well.
wahashimoto 11 months ago 3
i think okada should have taken ai's lines and nono take aibon's lines
putumsing1212 1 year ago
miyabi sung so well. she was by far the best here, the others were good too, but miyabi was the best. so please disregard my comments below, i removed them, but still disregard them. i think i was on crack or something when i said she was the worst, she clearly is the best here. my bad. XD
HelloProjectLover2 1 year ago 6
Comment removed
MiyuHinamori 1 year ago
Comment removed
WolfzXMiya 1 year ago
Comment removed
WolfzXMiya 1 year ago
Comment removed
HelloProjectLover2 1 year ago
Comment removed
WolfzXMiya 1 year ago
Comment removed
HelloProjectLover2 1 year ago
Omg.....I was freaking amazed when Miya hit those high notes! Miya is so GOOD!!! And I love how she just smiles cutely after that. I love you, Miya~!!!<3
WolfzXMiya 1 year ago 4
Comment removed
HelloProjectLover2 1 year ago
@HelloProjectLover2 WTF ARE YOU TALKING ABOUT? O____o
miyelleSEJI 1 year ago
Comment removed
HelloProjectLover2 1 year ago
@HelloProjectLover2 Okay, well, clearly, you're the only one here that thinks so. I agree that Maimi has a good voice, but a lot of the times (not in this performance), she gets really off-key. Miyabi's may be nasally, but compared to others, she has a great voice. It's not shaky either. Her high note was phenomenal. That's not accomplished a lot by girls who are her age (in this performance). You must really hate her or something. O___o
miyelleSEJI 1 year ago 4
@HelloProjectLover2
I really think that Miyabi is a little overrated. Out of all these girls she has the highest voice which is why she hit the notes. Risako is always terrible. Maimi. Maasa and Tsuji always sound better with low vocals
BlueDolphin2011 1 year ago 3
@BlueDolphin2011 miyas not so overrated as you think..shes where she is cause of talent she isnt pushed to the front...the girl still only has one pb...
shiori012 6 months ago 2
Maasa and Risako sounds horrible! What happened to them!!!
Miya just the same...
Okada and Erika good...but Tsuji and Maimi are the best in this perf.!
♥
DW08nF 1 year ago
Omg they sing so bad, and look like hores compared with sakura gumi
demin789 1 year ago
please don't hate me but how is it possible that nono sounded so bad? my ears are bleeding. I mean she totally ruined those parts that aibon used to sing! miya was awesome though <3
ingalovesmusic 1 year ago
This was the first time I've heard a song from these girls that made me feel I was listening to average people singing. Sorry if that may PO some of you guys. I'd be below average if I sang, but I don't do it for a living...or for fun! Lol.
Abe Natsumi's graduation. That's the first and best version I've heard of this song.
LookSquirrel 1 year ago
Miyabi~ always the best, the number one =P
no offense, but Risako was...kind of horrible with her "suki"...
this performance was a bit a comedy show...>.>
MiyuHinamori 1 year ago 5
2:23 - 2:27 o0
cheekyxcherryvi 1 year ago
Miya, my princess, saved this all<3
Well...Nono & Maimi were okay too ^w^
But the rest....well let's say they didn't shine very much in THIS performance x3
xXxChokocchixXx 2 years ago 6
what the hell. with Lida her eye shadow is fucking dark. I don't like it
electricfreak 2 years ago
yui was.............kinda super bad?
2animerocks2 2 years ago 3
kien son ellas nadamas konosko aah tsuji nozomi y las demas kienes son?
principex1000 2 years ago
@principex1000 no las conoces O.O bueno aparte de tsuji son yui okada y erika miyoshi de biyuden, miyabi natsuyaki sudou masa y risako sugaya de berryz koubou y maimi yajima lider de ºC-ute
ranmaru07 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@principex1000 no las conoces O.O bueno aparte de nozomi tsuji son yui okada y erika miyosi de biyuden miyabi natsuyaki sudou maasa y risako sugaya de berryz koubou y maimi yajima
ranmaru07 1 year ago
Isn't Akari in there too? sounds like her 0:50
KorasiaLady 2 years ago
@KorasiaLady That´s Sudou Maasa, from Berryz
MermaidPrincessLuna 2 years ago
Risako is umm let say not at good as she could be at 1:43 :( Its horrible.Miyabi was the only good one.Maimi ok and nono was okish but the rest were terrible
Haristarchan 2 years ago 11
I agree with you yet they give the best parts to Risako
kirari18 2 years ago
oooooNOES risako at 1:43
Haristarchan 2 years ago
Sorry but... Risako's suki... LOL HAHA It was like.. OMFG LOL
Xzaxie 2 years ago 10
I think they weren't the best in this concert, the song not-live is much better. I was just wandering, why are Miyabi, Risako and Maimi here? Isn't this supposed to be a Morning Musume song? Still, I think Maimi and Miyabi were the best. :)
AelitaAiri 2 years ago 5
It's a Morning Musume Sakura Gumi song. They are a sub group from Morning Musume and none of them that sing in this vid are in the actual group.
adynmoon 2 years ago
Miyabi se ve preciosa
me encanta como canta n_n
Ichitaka24 2 years ago
Maasa looks so nervous...
JessicaHeavenBlessed 2 years ago 5
Isn't the first girl form W?
monkeyrobin 2 years ago 6
Me and my sister was watching this and we both thought that Miyabi and Maimi were the best and saved thhis performance... no offense or anything...
xXAsumaXx 2 years ago 9
Only Aibon can sing the part of nee hare dooriame nochi SUKI. The best because she only have a high pitch voice
rodinoklijn23 2 years ago 3
@rodinoklijn23 Really? I thought Miyabi did it WAAAAY better than anybody singing the original song. Even Ai... XDDD
miyelleSEJI 1 year ago
Comment removed
HelloProjectLover2 1 year ago
@HelloProjectLover2 Well, I guess that's just a matter of opinion.
miyelleSEJI 1 year ago
NONO did amazing but could have done better
miyabi was clearly the strongest one in the group
overall it was a bad song for this vocal range group
AStarBellySneetch 2 years ago 13
whoah! ~ Miyabi did a very great job here! It just only proves her great singing capabilities... I'm really proud of her!
Maimi was also good here... I hope they could make a duet together..:)
tEtZ05 2 years ago 13
OMG! on the first Hare Ame Nochi Suki that girl did HORRIBLE
AStarBellySneetch 2 years ago 2
Tsuji can sing a lot better than she did here.. a *lot* better. Miyabi was really good with Takahashi's part at the end. As for Yui's high note.. eh.. I'm just gonna erase that from my memory.
EvileLlamaThingeh 2 years ago 22
Miya and Maimi should have done a duet of this song and it would have sounded MUCH better...
mickinorichan 2 years ago 15
Miyabi and Maimi were the best.
adynmoon 2 years ago 14
miya's high notes were amazing at the end!!
sanaplus 2 years ago 19
could anyone tell me the name of this concert i know hello project but what else and if anyone find the videos of this could u please send them to me
thank you
crystalfrgsn1 2 years ago
Hello! Project 2007 Summer Live 10th Anniversary Dai Kanshasai
2animerocks2 2 years ago
ok thanks 2animerocks2
crystalfrgsn1 2 years ago
they all need to keep singing!!!
shakiraluveryahoocom 2 years ago
Tsuji, Yui, Erica!!!!
i miss them so much!!!
i hope they all continue!!!
shakiraluveryahoocom 2 years ago
tsssssssssuuuuuuujiiii nnoooooozzzzzzoooooommmmmiiii!!!!
funkynippy785 3 years ago
Oh,this is so wonderful,can I get download link to this? Please,please! <33
SstrawBerryz 3 years ago
miyabi's high pitch is the best..`!
^________^
hakyna11 3 years ago 53
@hakyna11 1 year ago since this was commented, but I completely agree! It's giving me goosebumps when she sings that part!
ToriKya 1 year ago
OMG! Miyabi's last solo line was amazing! ^^
miyelleSEJI 3 years ago 16
No offence to any of them, but this song doesn't suit them. =/ I love them all dearly, but I think the original group is the only one that does this song justice, it's a powerful song and I found that the way they sang it was a little...limp.
I still love you Nontan. <3
Mayunator 3 years ago 6
Suki blja!
HowToWinGames 3 years ago
miyabi is always the best at lives *w*
Nanimox3 3 years ago 65
Yup, yup.. And Risako ! :P
SstrawBerryz 3 years ago
Sakura Gumi much more better...
T - T;
no offense~
KaNeaTieS 3 years ago 10
Tsuji is as good as usual. Maimi and Miyabi did great, I like the "I love you for what you are" bit a lot. the one singing 1:30 cracked the high note somehow. the rest... their singing isn't bad, but it sounds werid.
suiseiseki2007 3 years ago 5
Yeah that was Yui at 1:30. She isn't known for her singing that's for sure.
TsujixAibon 3 years ago
LOL. We all know what she IS known for, however.
mecchagyaru 3 years ago 2
Hats off to you good youtuber. That is too true.
TsujixAibon 3 years ago
Ahahaha, yay, I got a hap tip!
mecchagyaru 3 years ago
aerintwin:
The girl in the purple is Natsuyaki Miyabi from Berryz Kobo.
OgawaMakotoFan23 3 years ago 5
Tsuji was good in this, as usual. I don't know the girl in purple, but she was good too. But still, few could sing Kago Ai's part as well as she did.
aerintwin 3 years ago 7
totally agree :)
devak168 3 years ago
What happened here? They sing good, but here they sound... horrible. I'm sorry but I don't like the way they're singing, without feeling and out of tone.
Archejoiyo 3 years ago
kinds shows, noone can really come close to folks to orginally sang the song. i think the younger singers haven't really had that much vocal traning and i think morning musume members are mostly pushed beyond their limits at being vocally flawless. the original singers of this song were all morning musume members.
freeloaner85 3 years ago
Yui??O_O OMG that was actually embarassing~~Reina adn Rika!!~ xD they were like lauguhing!!~ xD good thing when Yui sang her "Ame Nochi SUKU"~~Part~~ Miyabi saved her with "Oh Yes i love you"~~parts x3
greencagalli 3 years ago 9
how in the world is this a bad performance?
the only bad thing i heard in the whole performance was risako's "suki" but thats pretty much it.
this was a pretty damn good performance.
sheesh.
SOSbrigadeee 3 years ago
miyabi totally saved this performance.
rainXVII 3 years ago 18
Maasa's "suki" is so lovely ... she improve a lot !!
titeliwou 3 years ago 6
who's the girl with short hair and the second singer?
they were ...ehr.... they arent bad but....
are they new?
that might explain everything ._.;
the second singer looks really nervous I feel bad for the poor girl
DaakuRyuusuke 3 years ago
Second singer is Okada Yui from v-u-den.
And not sure which short haired girl you mean, but it's either Natsuyaki Miyabi from Berryz Koubou or Miyoshi Erika from v-u-den. That depends on which girl though.
hermioneisinlove 3 years ago
Natsuyaki miyabi is the best ofcourse x)
I ment the vuden ones....they dont seem to perform well
DaakuRyuusuke 3 years ago 9
they are so beutiful<3
xStrawberryKissx3 3 years ago 3
no where near good as when Sakura gumi performs it.
I personall don't like other HP people performing Morning Musume songs....I don't know why
JamieStewart88 3 years ago
only miyabi was good
mochilliboo 3 years ago 12
that was horrific. Even though Tsuji sang in tune the song was just really bad. I love them all to bits but I don't like this. But they're still new. But no cover will ever beat the original I think. Thanks for the upload
kloverkorty 3 years ago
I definitely agree. This has got to be one of the worst performances ever.
silvatine 3 years ago
that was horrific. Even though Tsuji sang in tune the song was just really bad. I love them all to bits but I don't like this. But they're still new. But no cover will ever beat the original I think. Thanks for the upload
kloverkorty 3 years ago
love song! risa voice bad!
Zjenial700 4 years ago
For a second, I thought you meant Niigaki Risa! I would be like, "Dude, she's not even in this performance and she has an amazing voice!: Well, Risako's voice is unstable at times, but she has her good moments, too. ^_^
JPNSinger101 4 years ago 3
risako voice so terrible-_-
when yui sing'NEE HARE DOORIAME NOCHI SUKI'
is much teerible than risako
aichan teach 07 to do the action of this songXD
miyuaibon 4 years ago 9
When was this performance?? i just love it
KrasavitsaKoshechka 4 years ago
*lol* that's funny^^ great comedy
Celestres 4 years ago
which one is miyabi??the gil with the neck tie?
yukk1 4 years ago
yes, the one with the purple outfit + necktie
MomoNyappy89 3 years ago 5
^V^ miyabi 's so popular present
sayonara0011 4 years ago 6
nono really can sing better ! but that's so good ! love this song <3
titeliwou 4 years ago
Miyabi rockz~~~
TemariTheSandNinja 4 years ago 12
and did anyone see Nono winked at 2:40 - 2:41?
TemariTheSandNinja 4 years ago 2
i wonder who she was winking at though
ReikoTsunami 4 years ago
I love Miyabi's mezzo/alto so much! She should sing in that voice more often! <3
Iamet 4 years ago 8
More proof that the younger H!P girls are getting much better than some of their older counterparts! Miyabi was amazing in this!
ranma2chan 4 years ago 8
Well, it was crude, won't consider them better...
but i would agree if you said the younger girls who sang this outshone the older ones who also sang in this rendition. Nono looked... reluctant to sing
animemugger 4 years ago
I don't think this song was right Nono, Yui, and Maasa. But overall it sounded really great! 5/5 ~faves!
PinkArrow455 4 years ago
It's not bad, but a little weak for Yui and Nono. I would've liked to see Miyabi take Yui's part and Maimi take Nono's part.
JPNSinger101 4 years ago 4
I completely agree. Miyabi and Maimi would have been better in the front.
XxHitomixX 4 years ago 9
lol tanaka and rika looklike they where trying to say "OHGODTHISUSCKS JUST KEEP SMILING"
lucyyelding 4 years ago 3
LMFAO you're right!!! I didn't even notice them there! When Yui was singing, "Nee hare doori ame nochi suki" I thought my ears were going to bleed
XxHitomixX 4 years ago 2
Yesss it was painful to listen too i_i Tsuji's face just seemed to be like "e_e;; do i have to sing this.." all the way through.
lucyyelding 4 years ago 3
The only two that never fall flat are Yajima and Natsuyaki. They really needed another song for this lineup.
bytten 4 years ago 7
Maybe just people having different parts. This song was fine for Maimi, Miyabi, and Maasa. ^_^
JPNSinger101 4 years ago 6
Ahhh this was sooo bad :[
Kobolinear 4 years ago 2
Miyabi is great =P
o0Fuu0o 4 years ago 11
wow,miyabi sings really well ar
princessboobe 4 years ago 8
...it sounded like the battle of the nasally voices, compared to the original. I don't know why they chose Tsuji and Yui to be pretty much the two main roles--neither of them are particularly strong vocalists when it comes to this type of song, at this pitch.
Hakumei 4 years ago
Okada Yui wasn't really stable. ^^;; And a bit out of tune. I think that's her... The second one to sing. x__x;;
FeatherWing14 4 years ago
It doesn't really matter what Okada Yui sings, she always sounds terribly nasal.
XxHitomixX 4 years ago
Wow, these people suck even more than the Saturnine~Wedding version! =D
silvatine 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
better than the original!
yossui 4 years ago