I love the softness, the quiet tragedy of the song. The way he manages to humanize someone we see as a monster, treating him with empathy but not forgiveness, it's breathtaking. I wonder at what painful secrets he has that has given such wisdom.
@benegeseritwhore What makes everyone think he's gay? Seriously, I don't think that one bit. Just because he treats people with empathy does not mean he's gay. I'm sorry, I respect your opinion, but find that ignorant and do not agree with you.
@natattack96 I guess you might describe us gays as particularly empathetic, but that's not why people think Sufjan's gay/bi. Predatory Wasp and Futile Devices both detail his loves with guys that haven't ended up so well.
@benegeseritwhore But people should still know that his lyrics (obviously) use deep symbolism. The song To Be Alone With You upfront sounds like it would contain such subject matter, but if you dissect the lyrics a lot of people found it was about Jesus. So with Sufjan there isn't a real way to tell by his lyrics alone. And nothing will change the fact that he is brilliant.
Haunting on its own, but after reading up on JWG, it's terrifying. Much like Tori Amos' cover of 97 Bonnie and Clyde, these soft, almost lullaby songs can be horrifying in ways that in-your-face music can't. You're drawn in by the beauty, shaken by the ugliness.
music shouldn't always have to be at 120 db. And especially the kind of music Sufjan is playing. People at his concerts respect that, and that says a lot!
120db is not a reference to tempo, it would need to be 120bpm. db is a abbreviation for decibels of sound. 120db and above could cause irreversible devastating hearing damage
No matter how many times I listen to him, everytime he sings live, i'm WOWED. Just in awe, his voice is stunning. It's very soothing and effortless, very pretty. Can't say it enough!
my body becomes cold as soon as I hear his voice. I get goosebumps. chills up my spine. its remarkable.
dcboy98 4 months ago 2
did Michael J. Fox record this?
chefchris 7 months ago 8
@chefchris Ruuuuude. But probably.
mmmbopgirl123 6 months ago
I bet he fuckin loves all the coughing in the audience
arvydas0069 8 months ago
So quiet but it makes you listen and wonder
pleaseletmeswim 10 months ago
wave after wave of shivers
skywalkerac 1 year ago
I love the softness, the quiet tragedy of the song. The way he manages to humanize someone we see as a monster, treating him with empathy but not forgiveness, it's breathtaking. I wonder at what painful secrets he has that has given such wisdom.
benegeseritwhore 1 year ago
@benegeseritwhore
He's gay. He's totally gay. That's the secret.
CardPiranha 1 year ago
@CardPiranha Ha, that's what I was getting at.
benegeseritwhore 1 year ago
@benegeseritwhore What makes everyone think he's gay? Seriously, I don't think that one bit. Just because he treats people with empathy does not mean he's gay. I'm sorry, I respect your opinion, but find that ignorant and do not agree with you.
natattack96 10 months ago
@natattack96 I guess you might describe us gays as particularly empathetic, but that's not why people think Sufjan's gay/bi. Predatory Wasp and Futile Devices both detail his loves with guys that haven't ended up so well.
benegeseritwhore 10 months ago
@benegeseritwhore But people should still know that his lyrics (obviously) use deep symbolism. The song To Be Alone With You upfront sounds like it would contain such subject matter, but if you dissect the lyrics a lot of people found it was about Jesus. So with Sufjan there isn't a real way to tell by his lyrics alone. And nothing will change the fact that he is brilliant.
natattack96 10 months ago
@CardPiranha haha! Ya he's gay.
CrimsonEmpire 1 year ago
Haunting on its own, but after reading up on JWG, it's terrifying. Much like Tori Amos' cover of 97 Bonnie and Clyde, these soft, almost lullaby songs can be horrifying in ways that in-your-face music can't. You're drawn in by the beauty, shaken by the ugliness.
tuber33 1 year ago 4
Let me guess. His tickets for this show sold out in 1 sec?
homogenic97 1 year ago
I like the shakyness of the video it really adds to the song imo
JaydWin 2 years ago
This song is so hauntingly beautiful
voluptamors 2 years ago
i got chills
urbittergdbye89 2 years ago
thank you so much for uploading this!
contempt2600 2 years ago
That's Bryce Dessner of The National on guitar
johnielsen08 2 years ago
A so great artist in a so little room....
pouidg 3 years ago 5
is english your first language?
iloveken222 2 years ago
No it's not.
I'm french.
I know I've made mistakes. I 've try to say that sufjan was a great artist but the room seems very small. Correct me if I'm wrong.
pouidg 2 years ago 3
lol i did wonder!
yeah sufjan is a very great artist!
you could have said "such a great artist in such a little room". but it's not a big mistake. i understood what you were saying.
iloveken222 2 years ago
Ok, thanks :)
My first sentence seems weird now :)
Bye !
pouidg 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
Simple music for simple minded people.
LOL. LONG LIVE IGNORANT SHEEP...
ruleoforder 3 years ago
oh please guide us, shepherd of youtube. let us drink from the infinite well of your musical knowledge.
rbktendie31 3 years ago 11
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Is this a joke?
moozoonsii 2 years ago
youv demonstrated your own ignoranc in this coment, its actually a realy a deap song if u bothr t listen to it
elleisimo 2 years ago
@ruleoforder What shepherd do you follow?
johngeetar 1 year ago
I love this man :°°
OrfeoEmerso 3 years ago
I absolutely love this song. Dark, twisted and beautiful.
tmoney1987 3 years ago 3
This song is soooo unsettling.
guitarWMfoshiz 3 years ago
why is it always so quite at his concerts?
x9x9x9x9x9 3 years ago
music shouldn't always have to be at 120 db. And especially the kind of music Sufjan is playing. People at his concerts respect that, and that says a lot!
Phthgn 3 years ago 8
what does the tempo have to do with the noise level in the room?
peskasker 3 years ago
120db is not a reference to tempo, it would need to be 120bpm. db is a abbreviation for decibels of sound. 120db and above could cause irreversible devastating hearing damage
tmoney1987 3 years ago
got it, thanks man.
peskasker 3 years ago
its funny, i like this song.
whats funny though--
well, you know.
IAmLollos 3 years ago
dB is the symbol for decibel.
schlegelt 2 years ago
It's a haunting song, I think the pump organ makes it more-so.
DetroitBurbanite 3 years ago 3
I was there. GOD! Fucking amazing concert!
XxCrazySocksxX 3 years ago
hmmm?
is it just me or does he have different shirts on different videos.
like in this one and then
the video for the avalanche.
:D
gb215 3 years ago
I love how his voice squeaks a little. It is adorable. This is a great performance.
guitarbuddy27 3 years ago
He is so incredible sexy...
Forsythie 3 years ago 4
No matter how many times I listen to him, everytime he sings live, i'm WOWED. Just in awe, his voice is stunning. It's very soothing and effortless, very pretty. Can't say it enough!
SovietVV 4 years ago 31
i cried. its so beautiful.
supradude7891 4 years ago 3
this is easily the best version of this song i have heard
ElDudeBrother 4 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
he's the one who wrote the song.
ruiner1 4 years ago
didn't say he wasn't did i? this is still a version of it.
ElDudeBrother 4 years ago
didn't say he wasn't did i? this is still a version of it.
ElDudeBrother 4 years ago
i disagree, the rhythm of the organ isn't right for me. i still like the original better.
fr3d3r1ck84 4 years ago 4
nice whispering
sufjan16919 4 years ago 3
Sufjan is a genius. He is easily one of the best artists around today.
StaikerAndDestros 4 years ago 32
that was incredible
notcoolmy 4 years ago 5
love love
CorbynCrow 4 years ago
love
bohodance 4 years ago 2