Outlawed: Extraordinary Rendition, Torture and Disappearance

[Geddajunior]

It's horrible that innocent ppl are tortured but doesnt it say a lot that the nations that do torture are the lands of PEACEFUL muslims...the religion of PEACE we keep being told ...yet almost ALL Islamic nations , run by ppl educated in Islam are dictators , facist Kings ...Hmmm something rings a bell....WHY ARE ALL ISLAM NATIONS RUN BY EVIL FACISTS ? I aint gonna be fake PC..its the TRUTH all muslim nations are f*** up and so the ppl all wanna migrate to bad old CHRISTIAN west..funny huh

[Maat922]

All the terrorists come from Washington DC and London.

[TheFinlandnator]

Suck it G.W. Bush.

[KeswickCamp08]

1:25 "July 21, 2002"  my 9th birthday!

[amannvig]

@KeswickCamp08 kid contemplate . FUKeR this is no birthday bash ass hole

[KeswickCamp08]

@amannvig -_- i hadnt watched the whole thing yet when i posted i just saw the date posted. who is saying its a birthday bash? since you want to swap a few swear words, how about this: your a dumb ass if you siriously think im a kid then call me a fucker. why would you call a kid a fucker?

[amannvig]

@KeswickCamp08 apologies

[linewire1456]

Us as human beings must stand together. why? BECUASE WE ARE THE SAME NO MATTER WHAT! WHATEVER RACE,COLOR,ANCESTRY YOU HAVE DOESN"T MEAN YOU ARE NOT HUMAN! WE SHOULD HELP OTHERS THAT ARE INNOCENT!

[savoysouth]

Oh! Boo Hoo!

Maybe you should have thought about the consequences BEFORE you joined the Taliban.

Shit Head!

[amannvig]

@savoysouth boo hooo fucking terrorists , ure a bigger terrorist than ure mom

[lushfauna]

@savoysouth none of the terrorist where from the Taliban they where mostly from Saudi Arabia- Your a Moron

[injerreau]

lol bush ;lie more

[earthlycolorbrown]

I wonder if he is yet alive...

[beba0447]

This is totally f..... up, very sad story I hope he's freed soon.

[painkillerzman]

You guys think we should stop torturing the "poor guys" who are suspected of being part of an organisation who killed thousands of people ?

And torturing him into giving away information might save lives.

They're going to suffer, Boo fucking hoo ? Dogs, all of them.

[pRmiScUoSpRoDiGy]

I'm neutral about the concept of torture but..

what? a diary....so the FBI spared this guy after carrying out inhuman torture.

If they dare to take interrogation to that extent, i doubt they would let him live to write a diary.

[hawakeita]

like they say sometimes" the criminals are NOT those who hold weapons but ARE the one who jugde upon them"

[im4wur]

It's a mistake to become your own enemy. Torture is WRONG!

[FireMage666]

Quote from Whoo69: "Why do you give a shit if these bastards get tortured?"

I care because, as an American, i stand for freedom.

I care because no matter who you are, you have the basic rights as a human being.

I care because it isn't the terrorists that are being tortured, it's the innocent middle eastern people.

I care because by torturing innocent people, we aren't any better than the terrorists.

[alacranmann]

Hey pricks how about saying something about the torture in communist,muslim countries.You idiot liberals love to dump on the US,the greatest beacon of freedom in the history of mankind.GOD BLESS president BUSH and vice president CHENEY,and all the American service men and women who are only trying to protect us from this animals(terrorists).

[getamessay]

he just one innoicent litte poor Ethiopian,good job CIA or FBI...WOW!

[TheTalentedMrBrooks]

I believe it was Nietzsche who said: "Who so ever fights with monsters should see to it that he himself does not become a monster."

[hello1231000]

As an american i have one questing for these people because our image is bad enough "Why you stupid fuck, Why" why did they cut his dick and why do they do this, and another thing if you say you hate all americans you are a racist considering we are a race, just thought i'd throw that in there. Do you think though that once in a while your governments will do something like this though, britain, russia, france and mexico and all those others, do you?

[detailsinthefabric]

I know that they do torture to get information out of people. But sometimes its unfair, because they dont listen but they just torture them straight away. the innocent people.. its sick and cruel

[brian8793]

10 out 10 terrorists agree, ANYBODY BUT BUSH! lol

Sometimes drastic times call for drastic measures. Freedom will reach every inch of this planet, it's just a matter of time.

[ChainbladeVideos]

5 out of 6 dentists recomend crest..

im swtiching to colgate they have 9 outta 10 !

[Limesjolund]

amazing grace how sweet the sound

[Whoo69]

And those people who are for the death penalty for terrorists but are against torture are actually pretty hypocritical. How can you say it's ok to kill people for terrorism, but if you give them a little pain for a prolonged period of time but keep them alive, it's somehow not ok?

This really isn't as big a deal as people make it out to be. They're just using more fuel to attack the administration. I hate Bush, but we don't need to lie and make things up to do so or overreact.

[Whoo69]

If you're a terrorist who gets away with killing hundreds, if not thousands of innocent people, I don't wanna hear any fuckign complaints from ultraliberal pussies in the ACLU or Human Rights WAtch or whoever. Those people are SCUM (al Qaeda). They deserve full justice and punishment! How is that so hard to comprehend? Why do you give a shit if these bastards get tortured?

Of course, torturing is not a good way to get information out of them, but I think it would be good as a punishment.

[FireMage666]

I hope I don't know you personally, because anybody that can justify torture in any way is scum. My uncle was questioned by the CIA and taken into custody because he went on a CATHOLIC MISSION to south america. He could have been shipped off to guantanamo bay just because they suspected him. Luckily, a friend of his is high-ranking in the police department of that city.

How is he a terrorist? How can they take him into custody for nothing?

[toofingerz]

hmmmm

[Whoo69]

When you think about it logically and don't resort to knee-jerk liberal reactions, it's not that big a deal, really. Only a relative few (very few) of the people taken by rendition are innocent and mistakenly captured. It's not like we're just taking anyone off the streets to justify the war on terror and torturing them. I mean, come on! As for the torture, sure it sucks if they're innocent, but if they're guilty, I say amen.

The West has gotten too soft.

[FireMage666]

Where did you get your facts? You are saying that only "very few" of the people taken by rendition are innocent. Let me correct you: MOST of them are innocent. An MIT student (whos AMERICAN) was taken by rendition when she wore a tshirt with lights on it to pick up her friend at the airport. Does this justify your war on terror?

[zillabong420]

this is a good video

[sunbear18]

ok i live in america but thats pretty creul

[samieldarklord357]

as an american this brings tears to my eyes. no one wether they are a murderer terrorist or anyone deserves this. if it can happen to him it can happen to you.

[DeathDogg]

yes but one of the biggest shame's is how people can so easily judge everyone who lives in a country over the actions of polotical, presidental and goverment org acts, example

darkfro +1

SHAME ON YOU AMERICA

As you can see he comments shame on america which inclides everyone within it, yet saying that makes him just as bad people who assume someone middle eastern country is a terriost.. you dont kill the flower, you fix the seed and help it grow better ^^

[darkfro]

SHAME ON YOU AMERICA

[rblwoaclu]

SHAME ON THE CROWN!!!!!!!!

[johnnywhiteshoe]

yes shame on our goverment and those that are collaberating with it.. but america has nothing to do with this... in fact, our president may not even know the extent of these actions. he has done some foolish things, but our military has him by the balls.

[timur1lenk]

how to bring to justice those in the govermant who broke the Law

[JTokko]

What was he doing in Pakistan? Why was he using a fake passport? He was being tortured yet allowed to keep a detailed diary of it? I need the whole story before I jump to conclusions.

[druidess01]

There seems to be alot more to this story than is being told on this very short vid. I didn't see how the U.S. was "justifying" torture. Why was he using a fake passport? I can't say that I see the injustice with this vid. because it leaves too many questions unanswered.

[Gamesfan107]

dunderri this is to you,nobody is perfect,everyone does make mistakes but everyone dosnt act like they are the best in the world either but america does,if america so wants to rule the world well then why dont they live up to it and not make mistakes and anyway america is the most corrupted country in the world,look at the smile on bushes face at 3:02 he is fighting to hold back his laughter.

[HarjasKaur]

America will have a civil war. Who can tolerate injustice?

[tsarita]

why was he using a passport that was not his? this is not touched on in the video which makes this story very unbalanced. In this political climate why would someone from an arab country try to get into the UK using false ID??? not smart. It's like those tourists who get caught with drugs in Thailand and cry about human rights when they get life imprisonment. i don't feel sorry for him because his actions were very suspicious

[Lackeira]

Not really, thats a bias claim in itself, i mean it couldve been a total accident, for all we know they could look a like and or he simply just picked up the wrong passport and didn't look at it properly, accidents like that do happen... AND either way i cant see how anyone can justify his "suspicious" actions by everything he went through anyway.

[tsarita]

why was he using someone else's passport as identification to get back into Britain? That's a big no no, everyone knows that. If you are not a criminal why behave like one and use false I.D?

[timur1lenk]

it is not the point of film. He could be a terrorist but he shouldnt be tortured as it is forbiden by law and against humanity. We are surpose to talk about that and somebody in the government is doing that in our name....without our permition.

[eaglepies]

This whole video makes it very clear that general US thinking is that Arab lives are worth so little compared to American lives. I hate America so very much.

[bigcboyfan]

eaglepies how is it that you can deduce from this propaganda what the general US thinking is? And then claim that you hate America so very much? Afterall this kind of HATE you speak of is what perpetuates these alleged attrocities against humanity.

[highlandislander]

do you realize that your doing exactly what you say you hate? your saying americans shouldnt hate another group of people when your doing the same thing

[yourandy]

Odd...How could you write a diary in such conditions???Surely you could not have been given a pen or paper. Or was this from memory after the fact? In which case boy, that is one detailed memory. Sounds a little fishy.

[eaglepies]

Obviously narrative accounts can never be considered 100% reliable, but there's no reason why he shouldn't have had a paper and pen in a Karachi jail...

[catrionaheather]

u seriously think u get luxuries like dat in pakistan? ur off ur head boy!!

[Advtise]

very sad

[dunderri]

the united states makes mistakes just like everyone else. no one is perfect.

[Dealinfreak1]

If you ask me, America is no better than China or any other under the rule of a dictator. Bush had the choice of abolishing these violations of the human rights, the US government supported it but he used his Veto to prevent that from happening.

[halfeatenface]

Its very sad. Unfortunately, we in America will have to pay the price for our government's war crimes. Empires don't last, and the past 8 years have had a devastating effect on the U.S. Constitution. It may be years before American citizens even realize how long we've been trending towards fascism.

[kannibees]

revolt.

[Katlunn]

We are all so blind to the big picture, by we I mean the majority. When I say "big picture" I mean, what our world COULD be like. People so often fail to see action and reaction. We only think about our actions. The word Humane will soon no longer have meaning, because it is failing to be practiced. We as human beings have even more cruel and selfish. Stop and think about each individual, and how every action we take as individuals, spirals into the masses... practice some philanthropy America.

[rlynchier]

Gaprielll, I'm not disagreeing or agreeing with you. I just want you to know you sound very uneducated. If you're going to make a statement of that calliber, think it out.

[AnaMurida]

Australia is also becoming scary.. people dont have rights anymore.

[sioc88]

woo look at that thing on his neck.........

[Gaprielll]

Look every one, I am just gonna say my opinion. I don'think that bush has a power at all, thats the plan, that way hi is president, there is Higer and more much more powerfull people,and it's them how's controling and cmanding every thing, even Bush.

[penfolduk78]

who are 'them'?

[Nolimit4show]

as if every middle eastern is a terrorist, they comment on stupid/ignorant beliefs. PSYCARNE, you can try, but they wont see the light, especially on youtube. There are a lot of Patriotic Morons(not to be confused with Patriotic people) who just make them and the US look bad because of their Arrogance. They say these Videos are trying to make USA look bad, WHY would they when USA is already bad in many countries eyes already.

[ben5017]

Rendition is illegal and immoral ... Any so-called civil govt that performs this is as bad and the worst govts!

[AnaMurida]

the whole iraqi war is illegal

[optifog]

'...When they came for the Jews, I remained silent; I wasn't a Jew. When they came for me, there was no one left to speak out.' Has everyone forgotten the importance behind these words? I hope the people that support this policy will still do so when it's them being tortured into a false confession next time their government wants to look more successful.

[optifog]

Protecting innocent people from danger by torturing innocent people until they long for death is like chopping off someone's head to cure a toothache.

Irrational and more evil than the original threat.

[Monocromagnum]

What the president or government says to the media doesn't always mean it is true. In time of war torture seems to be the only option for them.

[hocotra]

I feel sorry for this dude, but sorrier for the people that had to either jump from the WTC or burn to death. Be glad it's not me in charge: most of the Middle East would already be a glass parking lot.

[keza94]

You'd rather be tortured to death or for maybe the rest of life than have a relatively quick death? I'd rather die quickly myself, and I'd prefer to know that someone I knew had died than think they were being tortured to insanity with no hope of fair trial. How are the people behind this protecting us, when what they're doing causes even more suffering to innocent people than terrorist strikes have done?

[Svyatiy]

wait.. why did Mohamed use his friend's passport for identification? Did he loose his own or something? thats fishy... i don't really know the whole story though... but still thats like getting pulled over by a policeman and saying that you are the policeman's father... WTH? can some one elaborate on the whole passport thing please if you don't mind.

[jabel5]

Bush lies... or maybe he just doesn't know what is going on. Which one is worse?

[Psycarne]

Also, the vast majority of people held under accusations of 'terrorism' by the US and people held under the terrorism act here the UK are not charged with any crime.

Making blanket statements along the lines of "they are terrorists so they deserve it" is nonsensical. The whole point in legal proceedings and the right of habeas corpus is to discover whether someone has committed a crime or not and many people are being denied this.

[Psycarne]

Beheading a few people does not compare to the illegal invasion of a nation and the murder of one million people, or the kidnap and torture of thousands of people.

Evoking the fact that some people have been beheaded does not wash away the crimes of the US. Atrocity is no answer to atrocity. If you believe in eliminating terrorism you can begin by not engaging in it.

[tduke65]

lets see no one has heard from him ? not like he had his head cut off with knife for all to see. we as americans need to get some balls and do wath is needed

[esolidarity]

pathetic comment.  i guess that took a alot of thought

[newport084]

nice far left propoganda. If you are to stupid to remember, terroist were taking british and american CITIZENS and beheading them for the world to see. just remember that.

[esolidarity]

are you always so ignorant. so that give you the right to torture innocent human beings. how stupid. people with that opinion should be the on the next extrordinary rendition plane

[rscatnavinet]

It is hard to understand what has happened to our country. It is as if everyone was drugged, and hypnotized, to such a state where they do not act with widespread repugnance towards the likes of George Bush and Dick Cheney. The future will look upon these two men with the same disgust we presently look at Stalin and Hitler. Guaranteed.

[Shairing11]

Please Dear God... help this man! Humanity should be ashamed of itself. Where are your hearts, your empathy?