Let the artist miss one or two notes, I don't think Debussy would mind that if he heard her playing... But thank you for shedding some expert light on the subject matter...AND THANK YOU MADAME ONAY FOR BEING SUCH A MARVELOUS MUSICIAN
i hate how hipsters scour youtube just to point out mistakes, fudges, memory lapses of musicians and how hipsters themselves have not mastered any instrument because being good as something is soooo mainstream..
@lovellespice Right, hipsters scour youtube to listen to Debussy, not other pianists and musicians trying to find good versions of their own repertoire. Feeding the troll, I know...
@lovellespice Sorry mate, I'll clarify my fairly unkind reply from earlier. I guess my point was just that most people who would post critically can probably play this piece almost as well as the listed performer. They are likely mostly people who have a similar mastery of the instrument, though that's just my personal opinion. I probably misunderstood your original post, sorry for being sarcastic.
@petitemoineau It is quite pretty. I like how it does not become a sort of Romantic piece, though she plays it sensitively, but she transforms the work into a simply more tender Impressionist piece. Not very many musicians can do that.
@takkutakiainen yes u APPRECIATE art. art includes paintings, sculptures, music, film, photography, and literature. preformance is expressing music, hence it's expressing art. if u dont appreciate "art", as in my opinion u mean sculptures, painting, anythin visual, then u might as well as not listen 2 this performance, therefore dont comment on somethin u dont appreciate.
@vistastructions well, I did comment, because the performance is a fail, and it's allowed and preferable to say it's a fail when it is a fail, that's one reason fom commentary. When I see fail I comment accordingly, and there is nothing you can do about it except to post a messy countercomment that doesn't make any sense defending the performance. It seems you are also a fail. I can see why you take a quest of defending fails. Carry on.
@takkutakiainen look. im not defending her at all. i know that she missed notes and whatever, and i c ur point of sayin she's a fail. im just tryin to ask: y r u so critical about them? i just think that she gets the image of the goldfish from debussy to the audience and that's all. u kno, ppl back then in debussy's times werent really carin bout mistakes: they were expressing music. take an old recording 4 example: Hofmann's Chopin Op48No1. He made a lot of mistakes, but he expressed music.
@takkutakiainen mayb u do hav a point, mayb u dont like her interpretation, do u? if thats da case, i cant do anythin' bout it. if its notes, mayb thats just da way u r. mayb learn somethin' from this performance. sometimes great art opens 2 chosen ones only - those w/ kind hearts, open minds and clean hands. it doesnt seem that u deserv it.
@vistastructions actually Im not one to screw mistakes.Philippe Entremont is in my opinion perhpas best ever, who cares about his misnotes. But in THIS performance the wrong notes were in crucial places. I'm pretty exact about the piece because I like it. "great art opens 2 chosen ones only - those w/ kind hearts, open minds and clean hands. it doesnt seem that u deserv it."< you have kind heart open mind and clean hands?Does it take being full of bullshit to be a Chosen?are you a fucking jew?
Very good and brilliant rendering of the piece, except a memory lapse at ~1:49-1:50 where she completely missed Bars 48, 49 and 50 (the single passage where the LH overlaps the RH entirely from the above). Fortunately she managed to cover it up almost seamlessly.
poissons do''or is debussy at his very finest. Like all great music it is forever new. And three cheers for gulsin onay!
alanblackwood1 1 month ago
Let the artist miss one or two notes, I don't think Debussy would mind that if he heard her playing... But thank you for shedding some expert light on the subject matter...AND THANK YOU MADAME ONAY FOR BEING SUCH A MARVELOUS MUSICIAN
ALPMANAN 8 months ago 3
i hate how hipsters scour youtube just to point out mistakes, fudges, memory lapses of musicians and how hipsters themselves have not mastered any instrument because being good as something is soooo mainstream..
lovellespice 10 months ago
@lovellespice Right, hipsters scour youtube to listen to Debussy, not other pianists and musicians trying to find good versions of their own repertoire. Feeding the troll, I know...
twicethrice87 3 months ago
@twicethrice87 actually, i never said they listen to just Debussy :) read again..
lovellespice 3 months ago
@lovellespice Sorry mate, I'll clarify my fairly unkind reply from earlier. I guess my point was just that most people who would post critically can probably play this piece almost as well as the listed performer. They are likely mostly people who have a similar mastery of the instrument, though that's just my personal opinion. I probably misunderstood your original post, sorry for being sarcastic.
twicethrice87 3 months ago
I love her sensitive interpretation. Absolutely beautiful.
petitemoineau 1 year ago
@petitemoineau It is quite pretty. I like how it does not become a sort of Romantic piece, though she plays it sensitively, but she transforms the work into a simply more tender Impressionist piece. Not very many musicians can do that.
HappyGoldenDuckling 1 year ago
ouch performance
takkutakiainen 1 year ago
@takkutakiainen and y do u say that?
vistastructions 1 year ago
@vistastructions because of the errors. I notice them because I've played this (it's easier than it looks like)
takkutakiainen 1 year ago
@takkutakiainen if u r going 2 listen & learn from this vid, you need 2 APPRECIATE ART. ive played this piece too. so what if she misses notes?
vistastructions 1 year ago
@vistastructions I appreciate art, that's why i dont appreciate every performance.
takkutakiainen 1 year ago
Comment removed
vistastructions 1 year ago
@takkutakiainen yes u APPRECIATE art. art includes paintings, sculptures, music, film, photography, and literature. preformance is expressing music, hence it's expressing art. if u dont appreciate "art", as in my opinion u mean sculptures, painting, anythin visual, then u might as well as not listen 2 this performance, therefore dont comment on somethin u dont appreciate.
vistastructions 1 year ago
@vistastructions well, I did comment, because the performance is a fail, and it's allowed and preferable to say it's a fail when it is a fail, that's one reason fom commentary. When I see fail I comment accordingly, and there is nothing you can do about it except to post a messy countercomment that doesn't make any sense defending the performance. It seems you are also a fail. I can see why you take a quest of defending fails. Carry on.
takkutakiainen 1 year ago
@takkutakiainen look. im not defending her at all. i know that she missed notes and whatever, and i c ur point of sayin she's a fail. im just tryin to ask: y r u so critical about them? i just think that she gets the image of the goldfish from debussy to the audience and that's all. u kno, ppl back then in debussy's times werent really carin bout mistakes: they were expressing music. take an old recording 4 example: Hofmann's Chopin Op48No1. He made a lot of mistakes, but he expressed music.
vistastructions 1 year ago
@takkutakiainen mayb u do hav a point, mayb u dont like her interpretation, do u? if thats da case, i cant do anythin' bout it. if its notes, mayb thats just da way u r. mayb learn somethin' from this performance. sometimes great art opens 2 chosen ones only - those w/ kind hearts, open minds and clean hands. it doesnt seem that u deserv it.
vistastructions 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@vistastructions actually Im not one to screw mistakes.Philippe Entremont is in my opinion perhpas best ever, who cares about his misnotes. But in THIS performance the wrong notes were in crucial places. I'm pretty exact about the piece because I like it. "great art opens 2 chosen ones only - those w/ kind hearts, open minds and clean hands. it doesnt seem that u deserv it."< you have kind heart open mind and clean hands?Does it take being full of bullshit to be a Chosen?are you a fucking jew?
takkutakiainen 1 year ago
diva
assroads 1 year ago
I wonder how Pollini would interpret this piece.
MrAkihiros 1 year ago
I can definitely imagine the goldfish
RJLDG666 2 years ago
SHE IS ROCKING THE FUCK OUT!! This video is awesome. SPELLBINDING!!!!!!
markofevil 2 years ago 2
great facial expressions:)
KkatiesMarkerss 2 years ago
@KkatiesMarkerss - I agree, I love watching the expressions on her face, it's like the music is flowing through her body.
buffalocrotch 1 year ago
awesome work
gassyjeff 2 years ago
Very good and brilliant rendering of the piece, except a memory lapse at ~1:49-1:50 where she completely missed Bars 48, 49 and 50 (the single passage where the LH overlaps the RH entirely from the above). Fortunately she managed to cover it up almost seamlessly.
Otherwise I love this performance ^_^
pchk1 2 years ago 14
In fact... little memory lapse:)!
frncgrc 2 years ago
@pchk1 You are so cool to have noticed that, just saying...
missacejay 1 year ago
Vivacious playing.
narrator1982 2 years ago
Incredible brilliant
ibook4113 2 years ago
Wow, incredible. I don't know much about classical music, but I love this piece!
buffalocrotch 3 years ago 10
bartocristofori: Beautiful, & 3rd of Images II. Believe or not, inspired by Debussy's Goldfish! True. Magnifique! - Penny,Prof.Pianist
pennymusicMAma 3 years ago