Added: 4 years ago
From: MissFortuneTheFirst
Views: 132,661
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (108)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • The best version of this song, hands down.

  • kelly has a great voice but im a huge bob dylan fan and the way Adele sings it hits his poetry and brings this song home kelly sings it to as i would say understated and as if was to easy to feel her love but great song great song and if anyone listening to this has never heard dylan please do some songs are acquired but you'll find out how many songs of his were covers

  • kelly's voice completes the perfect song, it doesnt have to be about a boy/girl that you are in love with, it can be anybody you care about. This suits Kelly perfectly, simply because all her songs have such meaning and depth to them, they can be about anything, but she means it with her whole heart, and even if her voice wasnt as amazing and beautiful as it is it would still be the best version because of how much she means it

    this is for anyone you care about

    this is for you, ash, my brother x

  • I love Adele and all but nothing will beat Kelly Clarkson's voice with this song...xxxx

  • when did she record this?

  • Timeless.

  • Seriously you killed that song kelly

  • @DJCDAD2004 is that a good killed?

  • this song really touches my heart...i just wish a guy would sing this to me...<3 so I wait for him...but I'm afraid he'll never come...and in the meanwhile I'm lonely and full of pain and confusion about this guy who I hate but I like and he seems to like me...but he's not what I'm looking for...

  • Kelly's voice is like that of an angel...

  • I really loved this video and Kelly clarksons version. She has a beautiful voice... Thank you...

  • I love this song. I love your video because you have compiled a series of visuals that each of us can identify to a particular one and relate to it on a personal level. You have done yourself proud!

  • thank you ; )

  • damn i love this beautiful voice. kelly ; you're so spectacular ♥

  • What album is this song on?

  • @Sparkles1819 It's a demo haha, it was never released.

  • Her voice is so beautiful, I love Kelly Clarkson. <3

  • ur going TOO fast so no one can really see the pictures. i mean i guess it's good... but you should try a little harder to make it better

  • WOAH. at first i didnt hear the whole phrase of a part.. so i just heard "id go hungry id go black" .. i was like WOAH!!!

  • I like Garth Brook's version better, but your vid kicks serious ass. Good... no EXCELLENT job!!! 

  • i think she has a wonderful voice. my favorite version of this song

    i think adele is shit cause she's got a VERY annoying voice, i just don't get why everybody loves adele soo much if there's a kelly clarkson. adele's just a fat woman with a screaming voice while kelly clarkson's a very good singer and a very beautiful woman<3

  • so good. this was only a demo recording for kelly too

  • where can i download this song please?!?!?! i have searched everywhere!!

  • @Simplypure1 if you don,t have it yet you can get it off ares

  • I don't see any mention of the writer of the song.One of Bob Dylan's finest compositions in recent years.

  • BETTER THAN ADELE FACT!

  • Hope Floats. We don't need to fly WE ALL FLOAT DOWN HERE. That's Penny Wisdom.

  • it's okay, but not a patch on adele's version

  • any version of this song is beautiful. It's the lyrics not who's singing it <3

  • Beautiful song. Personally I avoid comparing but different covers can make u feel different things and for me .. this one does it!!

  • A superb version of a heartbreakingly beautiful song. Does it really matter if Kelly's or Adele's version is better though? They are both fantastic, although I happen to like Kelly's better. But it won't stop it from being beautiful whoever is singing it.

  • I prefer Kelly's version than Adelle!

    It has more soul and it makes me smile.

  • So it's hard for me to prefer someone's version over Kelly's. I just really like Kelly's voice, but check out this version: watch?v=bs8IR_5dv_8

    If nothing else, it is damn good.

  • Personally I prefer the Adele version.

  • adele has the better version imo and the better voice

  • @TheJada001 - DITTO!!

  • @MsDottie09  Ditto

  • I do love this version. Kelly's sings this with a lot of emotion and she was much younger at the time she recorded this. I did listen to Trisha (love her) and Adele's performances but still think that Kelly's is best. Hard decision!! LOVE THE SONG!!

  • Trisha Yearwood did it better!

  • Between her and Adele.. Who do you think sang this song better..? Thoughts..

  • @big80 They are both amazing versions of a beautiful song x

  • @big80 The better technical singer would have to be Kelly Clarkson, with that said however, It's two different styles. One is Indie-ish, and then there is this one that's traditional. It's like comparing apples and oranges. Personally, I like both versions, and realize that both artists are accomplished, and have amazing voices.

  • What a beautiful song & a great video to go with it :)

  • It's beautiful...what's not to like?

  • Like your video it goes beatifully with Kelly Clarkson's rendition.

  • i love the video :)

  • You did really well with this video. LOVE this version!

  • people often "tweak" a song when they cover it. we don't always agree with it, but it happens quite a bit with covers...that's why they're covers. and I think sometimes covers are better than originals...that's why they are called opinions...we all have a right to our own. My personal fav is Kris followed closely by Garth!

  • Huh, she sings the wrong lyrics?!?

    It's " the storms are raging on a rolling sea"

    haha... she repeats "wild and free"... I understand that you can make a mistake, but can it passes on a recording??? Nobody in the studio noticed????

  • Pretty good version of this, but a little too slow, check out Billy Joel's version..he puts so much heart into his version, Garth and Dylan both sound like flat beer taste when they do this one...needs some heart behind it!! And MissFortune, very nice slideshow...keep going!!

  • Love this!!

  • touches so deep.......when you love deeply for the first time in your life...........

  • Garth Brooks? Rubbish. This is a classic Bob Dylan tune.

  • I hate how Dylan sings it - my favourite cover is Adeles

  • hating the original, how nice.

  • Yes I feel the same way...its beautiful all round...xxx

  • The more & see this this I am soo amazed,,incredible..I hope someone feels the same way...

  • What a wonderful song & beautiful video clips...well done..Thanks

  • I actually never heard this song before Kris Allen...and I honestly prefer his version...but this is nice..and something very Kelly Clarkson...although her version of Why is her best cover

  • Yeah, I love Kris's version, but Garth Brooks did the original I think.

  • I was about to thumbs up this...and clicked the wrong one :( lol but yeah same opinion here! haha

  • I salute to the one who made this video and yeah, Kelly's version is great..but, I think Brian Ferry's version is the best. It's more romantic and meaningful..

  • A difference of opinion is what makes us Human; Be a dreadful existence if we were all the same, all the time. Diversity is great. This song is great. Well done with the video; It's great. NOW: listen to Billy Joel's version. I think it's great. Adversely, I wouldn't if you paid me listen to that out of worker Farmer's version again...... I'd rather hear Cattle sing it. Great, aint it, diversity?/

  • are you sure this is Kelly?? It doesn't sound anything like her IMO...

  • People who say this isn't good are morons. Kelly did a fantastic job.

  • The video is great...new meaning to the song. Are the images your art??

  • Listen to 'em all and then listen to Kevin Skinner's version on America's Got Talent website. He's better'n 'em all, imo.

  • When i listen to this song, it makes me think of my little boy who has cystic fibrosis, i would do anything for him he is my life.!

  • @cojavk i have a friend with cystic fibrosis. its horrible watching that kid cough his lungs up/blood mucus running out of his stomach tube to. i wouldnt wish cystic fibrosis on my worst enemy. but i live with very bad lungs myself and i couldnt imagine h

  • @cojavk

    All my good thought are with you and your little boy, dear!

  • i like also kris allen's version than kelly. but kelly did an amazing verion of it.. good job

  • Kelly may not be the greatest artist to ever sing this song, but you did an awesome job w/ this video...I loved it!!

  • this is an awful version of this song..

    it does not have the feeling bob dylan created it to have. Which adele did capture.

    this sounds so overproduced and it's just a disappointment

  • Your video is good, but I like Adele's new version better. But no one tops Bob.

  • The words hit home and I can listen to most artists singing this time and time again---but Kelly seems to have the edge ! Possibly one of the greatist songs ever written.

  • wow i didn' know she recorded this song. It's really beautiful! Actually i love all versions of this song.

  • eh... actually Bob Dylan owns it

  • thumbs down?? why? this is a fact

  • adele OWNS kelly clarkson.

    she owns every vesion of this song.

    adele.<3

  • Comment removed

  • i like kris allen's version better than Kelly's.

  • This song has spoken to me in such volume. It's chillingly beautiful, and Kelly's voice suits the style she's gone for on this song. I really like this song, and I'd put it on a par with Billy Joel's version which is my absolute favourite. I don't know about all this Adele fuss though, I think she butchered the song personally. ;)

    Anyway, thank you for posting this up.

  • i like the video but i think shes trying a bit hard!

  • wow! is loev it (L)

  • this is one of the creepiest things I have ever seen. Way too much blood and ethereal, angelic stuff going on. Really, this is pretty scary.

  • it doesn't have the same soulful beauty as Adele's version. Kelly's version is a bit try hard.

  • I hate the Clarkson rendition, but I am touched by the video you made to go with it. It tells me so much about yourself, I can 'read' your story behind your love for the song. And it moves me. Really. Coming from one of the biggest assholes on Youtube's comments, that must mean something :)

  • She tries to hard to let it sound dramatic.. Adele's version is so sensitively..

  • this is a very good song. i believe the original is so much better, but she does a good job nonetheless. i am glad she felt she could sing this.

  • Billy Joel does this song best.

  • no, adele does it ways better

  • Music is good, but it seems like she's trying to hard............. DON'T LIKE IT VERY MUCH. I COULD DO BETTER...

  • Really? You could do better? Do you have a camcorder? Let's see...

  • yes! , I am better then this version. Not stateing that I am better then kelly. "Remember" she the American Idol Champ.!

  • great song, Great Video

  • Realy nice!

  • this version is good....i love kelly for me she is one of the best singer in town...i would like to dedicate this song to exerly encallado and peter hirsch ....hope this time all for real....good luck to u both!!!

  • i love this song but the Adele version is much better

  • A friend showed me it was a demotape of her or something!

  • OMG!! I love this song! I didn't even know that Kelly sang this song! How did you get this song?

  • I love this version f this beautiful song...Esteban I love you now and forever...beautiful video and nice additional text...its all true for the ones we love OXOXOXOXOXOX

  • very nice!

  • :]

    nice so ;)

  • very nice video

    and i love

    this songg!!

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more