Beautiful...for some unknown reason the melody reminded me of The Resting Chair by Tom Anderson...diff.tune though...I can't put the link here but if you look under "Fiddles & Mandocello" on my channel ..........
@jpachechek/ wow- I'm trying to make it about the girl- and you're making a soap opera about it, calling me names, and telling me to take a music-appreciation class...sorry to offend you(the care-taker?) of this video- you have some videos? I'll make every effort NOT to watch them, if you're this avid about someone elses business. Jesus loves you too!
Anyway getting it back to being About the girl fiddle playing in the video... Way to go! I feel that your talent in this song is explosive! Your style is clean and polished. If you happen to post a version of this song with your honest personal interpretation(possibly without rhythm), it would be top-notch! I hope you do, because your style speaks louder than most fiddle players I've heard playing this song...keep it up!
@nccfiddlar / Obviously, you've never heard of Paul Tilman on Bass or Bob Wills on Guitar, who provided in your words the "constraining rhythmic box". Yes Katie did a great job, along with her accompaniment. Your comments remind of the Nashville "Rash" that emphasizes individual stardom, to sell commercial records. I suggest you take a music appreciation class to learn about the effects of harmony using a variety of instruments. That is necessary to create a tasteful piece of music.
I have fiddled along with her and appreciated the "rhythmic box" despite the possibility of baptist roots. I feel glad if she has a religious upbringing. I like blending in with other musicians regardless of their religious upbringing. Maybe you should try it, it might make you less cynical.
Mit abstand das best gespielte Ashokan bei Youtube. Ich liebe diesen Song, er wird seit 13 Jahren als opener zum Civil War History Ball in Kassel gespielt. Einfach nur schön zu hören.
though this piece will never make one person famous in their own right...by far the best soul i've felt...i mean...given the rhythmic box she was confined in...slow it down? or possibly less guitar itself???? this fiddle, true fiddle player might have a chance in the music world...shoot, i bet she is working for less than what she is worth now...??? c'mon, this girl has rhythm and skill, why contain it to a metronome that possibly her family contains her baptist-roots to..? she has talent!
@nccfiddlar /Your "insight" is amazing. I never realized that the purpose of music was to make one individual famous. Maybe that is what is wrong with so much of the commercialized so-called "music" coming out of Nashville.
@nccfiddlar The rhythmic box she was "confined in" is due to the song being a waltz, which was played in 3/4 time. If she went out on her own, the dancers would be stepping on one another's shoes.
This was also a song Sean played at Amy's celebration of Life. Since it made everyone cry he played Chicken Reel right after and Had everyone Laughing I wish he didn't smash his Violin
Not sure when Jay Ungar wrote this but I used to hear my great uncle play an almost identical melody on the fiddle....he told me that he learned it from his grandfather who came here from Scotland.
Thank you for the introduction Buella and Flossy. Now Sissy and Bobby will entertain us with an old but true rendition of Ashoken Farewell. "Lawrence Welk"
Seems like you can't post a video without all the armchair critics coming out. I accept no criticism unless the critic posts the link where he has his video showing how its really done.
She's a very good violinst. The violin is a bitch to master. Simply fretting a guitar in time will make a passable sound, but a violinist has so many other factors to put together, otherwise the thing sounds like a cat fight.
This was the theme to Ken Burns' series on the Civil War. I thought it was a Civil War tune, but of course, it's not. The series used to be on YouTube,but the lawyers got a hold it, so of course it's gone. I recommend it highly.
Again, Jay Unger wrote this song as a Scottish lament. "lament" meaning an extreme feeling of sadness or loss. He wrote this song after the end of a summer camp at Shokan, one that was extremely intense and moving to him. The song was intended to express how sad he was. I dont think a waltz is how he intended this song at all.
In reference to SloverJD's comment, this song was NOT written as a waltz. If you pay any attention to Jay Unger, this song was written as a Scottish lament.
@pogeybait4883 A waltz musically refers any song written in triple meter (3/4, 6/8) as well as the specific dance which is performed with such a song. "Lament" refers to any song (regardless of time signature or tempo) written to convey grief or sadness. Ashokan Farewell is both a waltz and a Scottish style lament.
Hey, this is a really nice version! I myself like the country flavour it has, although I also like the version for example that the Nashville chamber orchestra plays.
A single piece of black cloth behind the performers would have not revealed this was taped in someone's living room. None the less, a good performance.
This is one of those songs where no one ever replicates the original, but where it does not matter: The various attempts and interpretations are as touching as Unger's original is. Very nice.
Did you learn this song through sheet music initially or are you so talented that you can just pick up the violin and play the song without sheet music?
I like the country touch you put on the song.
Makes me want to go out to the ol' fishin" pond, with me ol' hound dog Guss, sit on the ol' log, watch the sun go down as I smoke me corn cob pipe.
This fine young lady sounds as impressive to me with her wonderful skill on the instrument as Mark O'Connor did at around the same young age - and that is about the highest of all praise that I can think of offering up. Beautifully done !!
A highly impressive rendition of Jay's classic tune .. I love the tone you pull out of your fiddle especially the flawless double stops ..10 out of 10.
Excellent rendition! This lady is fantastic! Its hard to beleive this tune isn't a period piece from the Civil War. Old Jay Ungar must have had revealed to him in a dream by UCV and GAR veterans. It really evokes all of heartache for family and friends that fell in the conflict as well as longing for the comrades who made the Great Voyage together.
Little dead behind the eyes there. Anyone else channeling The Culps from SNL during the intro?
Thi5i5MyUniqu3N4m3 1 week ago
Now I remember it was used as background music for "Makem and Clancy" record. You play it beautifully.
clarebannerman 1 month ago
Beautiful...for some unknown reason the melody reminded me of The Resting Chair by Tom Anderson...diff.tune though...I can't put the link here but if you look under "Fiddles & Mandocello" on my channel ..........
clarebannerman 1 month ago
lovely
ScottishFiddleLesson 1 month ago
One of the nicest arrangements I've heard!
CarrickSam 4 months ago
Nice version
axeholme2 8 months ago
@jpachechek/ wow- I'm trying to make it about the girl- and you're making a soap opera about it, calling me names, and telling me to take a music-appreciation class...sorry to offend you(the care-taker?) of this video- you have some videos? I'll make every effort NOT to watch them, if you're this avid about someone elses business. Jesus loves you too!
nccfiddlar 9 months ago
OK, I suppose it is pointless to help someone who is a ignorant as you.
jpechacek80 9 months ago
My favorite song. Thanks for posting this!
MrJCinLA 9 months ago
Very talented young lady. Plays effortlessly and beautifully.
flunkyjo 9 months ago
@jp...something, well it doesn't matter/
Anyway getting it back to being About the girl fiddle playing in the video... Way to go! I feel that your talent in this song is explosive! Your style is clean and polished. If you happen to post a version of this song with your honest personal interpretation(possibly without rhythm), it would be top-notch! I hope you do, because your style speaks louder than most fiddle players I've heard playing this song...keep it up!
nccfiddlar 9 months ago
@nccfiddlar / Obviously, you've never heard of Paul Tilman on Bass or Bob Wills on Guitar, who provided in your words the "constraining rhythmic box". Yes Katie did a great job, along with her accompaniment. Your comments remind of the Nashville "Rash" that emphasizes individual stardom, to sell commercial records. I suggest you take a music appreciation class to learn about the effects of harmony using a variety of instruments. That is necessary to create a tasteful piece of music.
jpechacek80 9 months ago
Comment removed
ckcradio 9 months ago
I have fiddled along with her and appreciated the "rhythmic box" despite the possibility of baptist roots. I feel glad if she has a religious upbringing. I like blending in with other musicians regardless of their religious upbringing. Maybe you should try it, it might make you less cynical.
jpechacek80 9 months ago
so well played! :)
RedHeadRadulf83 11 months ago
Ohhh.... absolutely gorgeous. :')
puppylove8997 1 year ago
Mit abstand das best gespielte Ashokan bei Youtube. Ich liebe diesen Song, er wird seit 13 Jahren als opener zum Civil War History Ball in Kassel gespielt. Einfach nur schön zu hören.
19asterix65 1 year ago
though this piece will never make one person famous in their own right...by far the best soul i've felt...i mean...given the rhythmic box she was confined in...slow it down? or possibly less guitar itself???? this fiddle, true fiddle player might have a chance in the music world...shoot, i bet she is working for less than what she is worth now...??? c'mon, this girl has rhythm and skill, why contain it to a metronome that possibly her family contains her baptist-roots to..? she has talent!
nccfiddlar 1 year ago
@nccfiddlar /Your "insight" is amazing. I never realized that the purpose of music was to make one individual famous. Maybe that is what is wrong with so much of the commercialized so-called "music" coming out of Nashville.
jpechacek80 9 months ago
@nccfiddlar The rhythmic box she was "confined in" is due to the song being a waltz, which was played in 3/4 time. If she went out on her own, the dancers would be stepping on one another's shoes.
Dooglie1 7 months ago
This was also a song Sean played at Amy's celebration of Life. Since it made everyone cry he played Chicken Reel right after and Had everyone Laughing I wish he didn't smash his Violin
hawaiihomeelectronic 1 year ago
Not sure when Jay Ungar wrote this but I used to hear my great uncle play an almost identical melody on the fiddle....he told me that he learned it from his grandfather who came here from Scotland.
benkit49 1 year ago
Great job on a wonderful song!
marinadedave 1 year ago
This sounds really good! You make playing the violin look so easy!
TennisChamp59 1 year ago
Excellent!!! I always respect & admire those individuals who preserve our American heritage/roots thru music. My hat is off to you!!!
halbie71 1 year ago
Beautiful, you and the music you create. Thanks.
rskurow 1 year ago
Does anyone know of lyrics to this song? I have heard there are lyrics.
ke4bss 1 year ago
Comment removed
Destiny4511 1 year ago
I would totally marry this lady. Id bake her pies and bacon, and flap jacks and goober peas., and fat back...and then we wuld make White children.
ke4bss 1 year ago
Thank you for the introduction Buella and Flossy. Now Sissy and Bobby will entertain us with an old but true rendition of Ashoken Farewell. "Lawrence Welk"
ke4bss 1 year ago
Seems like you can't post a video without all the armchair critics coming out. I accept no criticism unless the critic posts the link where he has his video showing how its really done.
mnpd007 1 year ago
She's a very good violinst. The violin is a bitch to master. Simply fretting a guitar in time will make a passable sound, but a violinist has so many other factors to put together, otherwise the thing sounds like a cat fight.
mnpd007 1 year ago 2
the waltz version RUINED the song.
eastoff1 1 year ago
Comment removed
BdaChange 1 year ago
@eastoff1 Ashokan Farewell IS a waltz -- yes, "in the style of a Scottish lament", but a waltz nonetheless.
BdaChange 1 year ago
This was the theme to Ken Burns' series on the Civil War. I thought it was a Civil War tune, but of course, it's not. The series used to be on YouTube,but the lawyers got a hold it, so of course it's gone. I recommend it highly.
accuratedude 1 year ago
Loosen that bow a little and let that axe talk. Like your playing.
stevesprinceofsteaks 1 year ago
Again, Jay Unger wrote this song as a Scottish lament. "lament" meaning an extreme feeling of sadness or loss. He wrote this song after the end of a summer camp at Shokan, one that was extremely intense and moving to him. The song was intended to express how sad he was. I dont think a waltz is how he intended this song at all.
pogeybait4883 1 year ago
@pogeybait4883 Strange then that he recorded it on "Waltz of the WInd" long before PBS got hold of it.
BdaChange 1 year ago
In reference to SloverJD's comment, this song was NOT written as a waltz. If you pay any attention to Jay Unger, this song was written as a Scottish lament.
pogeybait4883 2 years ago
but dos'nt it work so well in the waltz time..
Mr9111950 2 years ago
@pogeybait4883
exactly! :-)
FeSo4man 2 years ago
Comment removed
SloverJD 2 years ago
Comment removed
SloverJD 2 years ago
@pogeybait4883 A waltz musically refers any song written in triple meter (3/4, 6/8) as well as the specific dance which is performed with such a song. "Lament" refers to any song (regardless of time signature or tempo) written to convey grief or sadness. Ashokan Farewell is both a waltz and a Scottish style lament.
BdaChange 1 year ago
Nice work! One of the nicest presentations of this song that I have heard. Thank you!
geologydotcom 2 years ago
Hey, this is a really nice version! I myself like the country flavour it has, although I also like the version for example that the Nashville chamber orchestra plays.
karlkaki 2 years ago
Comment removed
ThePurdude 2 years ago
A single piece of black cloth behind the performers would have not revealed this was taped in someone's living room. None the less, a good performance.
drivebytruckerz 2 years ago
Katie, you play awesome! Keep up your good work and thanks for sharing your talent with us on You Tube.
nottingham209 2 years ago
i dont like that she plays it with a waltz beat. that just doesn't sound right.
FeSo4man 2 years ago
@FeSo4man Not sure why you don't like that it is a waltz beat. The song was originally written as a waltz.
SloverJD 2 years ago
@sloverJD
Read my reply to pogeybait4883
FeSo4man 2 years ago
my one problem with it is that it sounds like country. this song in my eyes mind should sound irish
Theatrebythebell 2 years ago
the man had scotland in mind when he wrote it...
Mr9111950 2 years ago
...My favorite version of Ashoken's Farewell. I like your embellishments and trills. Great job.
fiddlewatcher 2 years ago 2
Are there anymore songs of Katie playing the violin to other civil war/military type songs on youtube or eleswhere?
sanfranciscobay 2 years ago
Outstanding! This lady has REAL talent!
TennesseeShine 2 years ago
Nice version. The trills give it a little more country feel. Thanks for posting.
stevesprinceofsteaks 2 years ago
This is one of those songs where no one ever replicates the original, but where it does not matter: The various attempts and interpretations are as touching as Unger's original is. Very nice.
cmc10101 2 years ago
i like your version!!.. nice playing (:
Valandil793 2 years ago
Beautiful
Paulmuiron 2 years ago
Katie,
Did you learn this song through sheet music initially or are you so talented that you can just pick up the violin and play the song without sheet music?
I like the country touch you put on the song.
Makes me want to go out to the ol' fishin" pond, with me ol' hound dog Guss, sit on the ol' log, watch the sun go down as I smoke me corn cob pipe.
sanfranciscobay 2 years ago
NIce job Katie on the violin. How long have you been playing the violin for?
What's it called when you play two strings at one time?
If you could improve the audio recording of your violin, it would sound better.
The other version I like is the one called:
songs of the civil war
posted by:
albertdelreal
It has 4 violinists and a guitar.
sanfranciscobay 2 years ago
When You play 2 strings at one time Its called a "double stop". Its a technique used alot in fiddle music.
CatlyCat 2 years ago
Double stop. (2 strings)
TheGhettoSymphony 2 years ago
great. truly a blessing. thank you wonderful folks again. G d bless you and keep you. Peace, in His love
opntheirhartzJesus 2 years ago
This fine young lady sounds as impressive to me with her wonderful skill on the instrument as Mark O'Connor did at around the same young age - and that is about the highest of all praise that I can think of offering up. Beautifully done !!
colindominy 2 years ago
A highly impressive rendition of Jay's classic tune .. I love the tone you pull out of your fiddle especially the flawless double stops ..10 out of 10.
alt2ooning 2 years ago
One of the best performances of Ashokan farewell on youtube. good job
metaweLOL 3 years ago
Wonderful....thank you!
craziechrissy1hpfan 3 years ago
Very nicely played.
bsam20uk 3 years ago
So graceful....You seem to be playing it effortlessly. Excellent job!!!
anvivo08 3 years ago
gorgeous
junkmailboy1000 3 years ago
Thanxs, I loved this piece! Excellent!
adadses 3 years ago
I loved your version and style of this song! 5*
Gretsch'n
BluegrassForte 3 years ago
Very nice.
TJDOZIER1 3 years ago
Very nice Ashokan....thanks for posting.
mrsmops2 3 years ago
Thank yew this fiddle is veryy pretty as well!
fiddles15 3 years ago
Super good plaing and nice harmony. Thanks!
contactviolet 3 years ago
Excellent rendition! This lady is fantastic! Its hard to beleive this tune isn't a period piece from the Civil War. Old Jay Ungar must have had revealed to him in a dream by UCV and GAR veterans. It really evokes all of heartache for family and friends that fell in the conflict as well as longing for the comrades who made the Great Voyage together.
TennesseeShine 3 years ago