Added: 4 years ago
From: PowerPowerx
Views: 80,162
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (262)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • ..but... they can't sing? I bet if these girls would use their normal singing-voice it would sound really good. But this?

  • nadine does the only decent vocal again.

  • My favourite version of this song is the stripped-down one Robyn did in Radio1 Live Lounge, about a year before GA recorded this in the Live Lounge. This isn't the worst thing i've ever heard, but let's be honest, it's not great is it.

  • They sound like a drunk hen party singing karaoke. Could be worse, but they're not real singers and their voices clash against each others.

  • They sound like a drunk hen party singing karaoke. Could be worse, but they're not real singers and their voices clash against each others.

  • HAHA THIS IS FUCKIN PISH!

  • This is no cover, it's called plagiarism.

    They used Robyns song without asking her of permissions.

  • @MultiUlme actually they did get permisson

  • @MultiUlme It's a live lounge cover, Radio 1 got the permission

  • They are really doing too much of this song. Too much wailing, vibratos and stuff. It shouldn't be sung like this. Sorry, but no one can beat Robyn.

  • I actually like this and the original version by robyn,

  • NADINE JUST SOUNDS AMAZING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I can't get enough of her!

  • i used to really dislike this song, until i heard girls alouds version, its so much better than robyns version i think, i thought all the girls sounded amazing on this

  • @KiRsTy01234 yes! love thier cover!! amazing!

  • i thought it was amazing

  • omg! robyn's version is way much better!!

  • seriously, almost alt f4'd after the first 10 seconds

  • @lory2608 I actually prefer this one!

  • @Maaian Hi, it's ok for me if you like this one! it's a free world my dear!! But I still and always will like Robyn's version much much more!!!! ; )

  • Comment removed

  • Robyn's version är många många gånger bättre!

  • SHOCKING!!

  • I don't really like Robyn's version. However, I love this one! Nicola and Kimberly were BRILLIANT! The way I see it, Girls Aloud give the song some happiness and life, you know... I just didn't love when they sing together, but i liked it anyway.

  • the saturdays could nail this song better i reckon and robyn version is better than this one by a mile

  • i think robyn did this the best but nicola sings this bloody perfect if it was just her singing shes do this better than robyn and girls aloud would never be pussy cat dolls they r totaly crap dont sound even close to girls aloud . noone will bebale be like girls aloud its the one and onl and always will be and if they did try make another girls aloud it just fall in like 2 singles later

  • Comment removed

  • You are kidding right? Girls Aloud were formed in 2002 and PCD were formed as a singing group 2004. So that's jus bullshit. This is Jo Whiley's Live Lounge, in this show you are supposed to sing a cover of a song. Everybody's has done it; Take That, Leona Lewis, Snow Patrol etc. Just look it up on Wikipedia.

  • This was so much better than Robyn's.

  • hahhaha... i can't stop laughing...

  • It's not as good as Robyn's but you do have to admit, it's a good attempt and I love it :D

  • G8240 - stick it up your arse . Girls Aloud's version is brilliant

  • do you mean tone DEAF?

  • Nadine is from NORTHERN IRELAND which is part of BRITAIN. If she HATES BRITISH people than she hates herself! Contradiction huh? She is probably not Catholic since she supports Glasgow Rangers! So...............

  • Yes she is from N.Ireland, and she is a Catholic , i dont know who your source is ,but what i do know is cause i live in the same town she was born in , so i think i should know a good deal about her . believe what you want, am telling you what i know . I dont thinki she supports rangers either lol, supports rangers and lives in the Creggan. that be like me supporting Celtic and living in Shankill Road

  • Oops, i take back she supported Rangers, she is definitely a Celtic fan. It's a shame but i guess i got to believe it. But still being born in a British country and hating British people would be hating herself, which is purely stupid if she is stupid enough to be racist...

  • Thats the kinda place n.ireland is not very open minded most. It hard to explain but you are on th eright line there :)

    I dont like this cover, i do like girls aloud bar Nadine, she can sing al give her that, but her up bringing i dont like. thats all :)

    peace

  • love them♥

  • this is amazing i love it and i love girls aloud they r amazing (L)

    love cheryl she is so pritty (L)(L)

    xx

  • i love girls aloud

  • excellent cover. (Y)

    but yeah, to all the people insulting the girls cover of this song, id like to see you get up and sing it as well as them (:

    amazing cover

    xx

  • i really like it.

    its not going to sound *good* as its not their song but i love it.

    took some time to get into it i think..

    but yanoo what..

    they are jsut amazing tbh! :D

  • proper goood song,, realllyyy good cover! x

  • nicola n kim's voices r so much better than i thought - love the ending 2 - vid bit pointless soz

  • I like the end. The beginning is a bit shaky. Nice cover, though! :)

  • It's good, but it lacks the originality of Robyn's.

  • this is a brilliant version, the begining is strained though, shes trying to put on a voice

  • not their best song ...

    but still i luv them

  • this is terrible

  • Shut up All Ov You ..Its Amazing ..Girls Alou Are The Best So...Jus Get A Liife

  • Shut up you tarts......girls aloud rule!

  • What I know is that they used the song without Robyns approval and is not allowed to perform the song. I think they got into trouble. I have to say this version is bad.

  • most moving song of the decade my arse

  • horrible

  • roflmao!!!!!!! this is a mess!!

  • what is this, they just turned Robyn's version into a dull, blunt, piece of nonense.. the music sounds out of place with their voice. Sorry girls but this is really really bad.

  • WTF? just when i thought they couldnt get any worse! they've ruined probably one of the most moving songs of the decade,they ought to hang their heads in shame.

  • OMG, how awful! It hurts to hear such a great song by so awful singers!!!!!!!

  • what a fuck is this?

  • Soz- but can not stand it- It's not original enough. :)

  • OMG! They sound loveley. They really should relese it as a single. Unfortunatley, Nicola wasn'y great at the beginning but everywhere else was perfect.

  • This has to be the worst cover ever....they sound awful :s

    this was nothing to the original...

  • nah i like this one better

  • Well done girls another song turned into a cat song Bahhhh

  • What Swill

  • there good

  • oh dear start sounds like screaming cats

  • lol harsh!

  • true

  • yep its awful

  • nicolas voice absoulotly beautiful in this, sounds amazing and her name is NICOLA!! she has a name so cna people stop referring 2 her as the'ginger one'

  • Robyns version is so much better.

  • learn to sing this first, robyn does it so much better.

  • outch, this hurts! What an insult to the original version by Robin...

  • I AGREE!

  • the ginger one

  • its not the ginger one u fucking kunt its nicola roberts and shes amasing u def freak

  • Who sang first? Was it Sarah or Kimberley?

  • nicola

  • Well, that was a massacre of the original. :(

  • i think there status in the world says it all

  • wow, this is a great song!

  • Wow, wtf happened on 1:01?!

    I prefer Girls Aloud singing songs with less long notes (to say it politely) <3

  • The can't please everybody. I love them and I think they sounded amazing. People who complain about holding notes need to get over themselves. Let's see you try!<3

  • robyn's version's so much better

  • i love this song so much, i love all thier songs and it gets better ech time

    :)

  • God knows why your all complaining

    I'd love to see you try it.

  • I think the fashion for not holding a note without wobbling is annoying, very noticeable in the first singer. Why doesn't anyone hold a note cleanly anymore? I blame Whitney, bless her coke ridden self.

  • Alot of people think GA are crap, but they are the most successful girl group ever with 18 top ten singles !! so they must be doing something right

  • love it!

  • That was crap, the singer at the beggining was shitttt.

  • love them♥

  • utter shite

  • they could keep trying but "things will never change... they should have looked back, they get worse with every heart beat!"

  • such a crap!!!

    burn them like in the middle ages!

  • better than the original

  • In fairness i've seen it live at the o2 and it was much better.

  • Such a waste of the original song!

    These girls should stop doing music!

  • beautiful =D

  • Awsome! Love GA! Cheryl rocks! She cried at Newcastle Arena when she sang this! Bless XXXXX <3 XXXXXXX

  • i think they did a gr8 job its not easy song to do as a five part, and all those people who r huge fans of da original will think anyone who does a cover of it will think it was crap.

  • ahh come on thats not that fair!, its live- i think their doing a great job!

  • i neeeeeeed this song

  • OMG

  • Sucks ass, original song is so much better than this shitty cover.

  • I don't look beh? roflmao. Fucking shit cover of a great song. Glad Robyn forbid them to continue using her song on their tour, making the song painful to listen to. Shit singers really, fucking awful.

  • what you chatting on about, they did the song on everynight of their tour.

  • i went to see them on saturday and they were brilliant and they sang this song!! and i only just discovered then how much a good singer nicole is!! shes got the best voice but i love then all! poor cheryl was feeling a bit ill though but she battled on through and they were all amazing!! my second time seeing them!!

  • beautiful

    i love cheryl shes so amazing

  • omg this is awsome why are people so negative.

  • ew what the sound fucked at the start shes like tim-Mm-MmEE-mee sounds so retarded

  • love it its ma fave song ever!!

  • They're amazing. =]

  • I really enjoyed this cover, put a bit of a girlie spin on the song!

  • Horrible and I like GA.

  • Good in general, but I hate Sarahs' bit. Someone should have a word! It is "I don't look back", not "I don't look beh-yeah-yeah-yeah." She's not Amy Winehouse.

  • Robyn is fugly but she bloody rocks this song

  • cannot sing....apart from nadine

  • 1st singer has horrific vibrato... sounds like a sheep

  • They really crapped up this song. Cunt traps.

  • The way they sing sound like what vaginas would make if they could scream because they are in dire need of Monostat or other forms of yeast infection creams.

  • Who the fuck was singin the 1st part LOL

  • that vid really soots the song. dat should be a single

  • basically if it was just cheryl, nicola and nadine singing, it would have been alright.

  • this is amazing :):):)x

  • lol, that was horrible!

  • This one is better? They ruined the beat, and they try too freaking hard with their 'pretty voices'. That's always the problem with a cover, they try too hard making it sound better while it just can't. The part 0:00 - 0:40 is sung SOOO FALSE! OMGGG!! Ah well I'll just let people be untastefull.. Robyn ftw <3

  • They're amazing! <33 So heart warming.

  • i like this version more than that from robyn

    but i think girls aloud can better=P

    much better

    but is is better than the version from robyn

    and the version from robyn is not live and from girls aloud is live

    girls aloud i luff you=)

  • oh no they ruined a great song :(

  • oh shit they sound so awful Im gonna have to hit stop im sorry but this is terrible

  • Comment removed

  • you should remember though that this is live, and robyn's version was done properly in a studio. i liked robyn's version, but prefer Girls Aloud lol.

  • Search for Robyn live transmission.

  • that was awfull

  • love every bit of it and when i saw them on the 13th may 2008 at brighton center i still talk bout it now and i sometimes even cry when i listen 2 it coz i got a text from my bf that it was over then 3 days l8er we got bk together and now we have split again and it is the same some song i got a text i got the fist text during the concert my heart was broken

  • they sound TERRIBLE in this song...

  • they really do! i dont know whats wrong with everyone...

  • much better then robyn realy more emotions

  • i love this version - i think they sing it really well

    xx

  • better than robyn so much more emotion

  • They do!! this was only for fun that they sung this at the concerts on tour!

  • four of my mates saw them in aberdeen, they loved it, they still won't stop talking about it!

  • Beautiful Song!=)♥

  • Girlz aloud have mad rapping skillz!

  • I thought this song sounded very good live, but it still sounds atrocious here. I wish they released a polished version with a bit fuller background and better vocal performances.

  • Oh i wish people would stop going on about how they murdered this song. This was done for the Live Lounge radio show in which everybody sings everybody else's songs. Of course it's not going to be as good as the original. Nothing ever is. Robyn herself done a version of Since U Been Gone which had Kelly Clarkson diehards up in arms. And remember Artic Monkey's version of Love Machine. It's all a bit of fun. If Robyn didn't care why should you. So grow up and get a life

  • i love this version better than robyn's version! GA are fab!

  • nadine is grate

  • i agree mate,saw them perform this in glasgow,awesome!!nadines the chebs!

  • This song is fantastic live! Nicola is such a good singer. this is so so much better than robyn's Version!

  • This is Atrocious! How can one ruin such a wonderful song...

  • Ugh.... no

  • at least they look good ...

  • OMG They ruined it! D=

  • nah.....not going to watch the whole thing...

  • I llooovve this cover dont care what anyone else thinks. There might be a few hiccups but id like to hear you try and sing the way they do !!

  • Grief! this is shocking. there's only one half decent voice on key.

  • That was horrendous! it offended my ears big time

  • the very begining was painful,, i think the first singer done the best job i hear their voice throughout i thihnk it might have been nicola not sure... bt boy could they improve :(

  • This is S H I T! They totally wrecked the whole message, the whole meaning with Kleerup's version. And on top of all, they can't sing... With this song they want to prove their talant and of course become famous and get great f*cks.

  • this sucks ass compared to Robyns!

    i dont care if you guys spam my comment

    this sucks