Added: 5 years ago
From: rocknrollmusic
Views: 85,349
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (247)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • OMG what the fuck whit Axl's voice? sounds like Mickley Mouse

  • watch?v=kpC5ANLC6Kg

  • axl rose and slash forever

  • Salsh we need you !!!

  • BUMBLEFOOT THE BEST!!!

  • It's a fact the original line up is way better than this.

  • Bring back GnR from 80' :(

  • slash fans relax, i know it's hurt this band is great and the solo kick ass. I love the solo on this better than slash.

  • @sugarwolf8 and what about the voice???

    WANKER!!!!!!!

  • Slash is +++ > all this fuckings stupids guitars

    4:32 WTF?? this guns n roses are shit

  • very good voice axl :)

  • I miss Slash's bluesy taste in music, he was a great guitarist. Axl's voice isn't there for me anymore. Buckethead was amazing, but I'm glad he quit this band, because people were starting to get arrogant. This new guy is good , no where near Buckethead good. I miss the old GNR'

  • Couldn't agree with you more-

    GNR are nothing without slash,duff,izzy and matt/steven.

    I miss the old GNR back at the days when they where the best!!

    GNR 1987-1993 forever!!

  • que vuelva los guns verdaderoos !

  • Has axl always been a christian?

  • He isn't a christian. He likes crosses and the many different designs of them though.

  • thats not what i read in his biography. look it up on wiki

  • He was religious as a kid. Not anymore, now-a-days he is not a christian, he just likes the design of the cross. Wiki isn't always reliable.

  • Talk about guitarists with no taste

  • Si seulement ils refaisaient ne seraissent que un concert avec tout les membre d'il y a 20 ans!

  • Comment removed

  • @Metal93Rules i need your mom to suck my dick

  • han pasaoo mil guitarristas ninguno ha logrado lo que izzy y slash hicieron

    one hundred guitarrist never sounds like izzy and slash

  • Axel rocks but the NEW GNR really really SUCKS

  • axl's a diva -.-

  • man this fool youtt have some robotic sound of giutar and youst playin no ritham shit better with slash

  • nobodys voice sounds the same 15-20 years later hetfield, vedder , cornell etc they all change.

  • your just jumping on the bandwagon, if you listen to any live version with Slash it dont sound any better you just like looking at him bender

  • u relly compare this crap to the live era one dude u need to get ur ears checked axls voice has been in the wrong key since 94' and he cant seem to get it back and shit the guitarist has no ryhthem his just bangin notes thr all shit and i dont think thy deserve the name of "guns n' roses" i would hav been happier if they broke up and axl never did this that way thy would still have rep. and not be shit like this is ^^^^^^

  • Watch the Rock Am Ring nightrain performance, or even Donnington from 06. His voice is perfect and in key the entire time.

  • god there not the same with out slash :(

  • the only real member is axl

  • Thal was great in that final solo, he nailed it.

  • han pasaoo mil guitarristas ninguno ha logrado lo que izzy y slash hicieron

    one hundred guitarrist never sounds like izzy and slash

  • terrible. no slash, no guns n' roses.

  • solo is sucks is better with slash

  • sounds better with slash..

  • ahora GNR tiene 3 guitarristas y los 3 se quieren lucir todo el tiempo...son basura de esos que se encuentran en la calle todo el tiempo, quieren hacer solos mas rapidos que Slash para querer demostrar que son mejores, pero en realidad Slash tiene algo que se llama gusto para tocar lo que ninguno de esos guitarristas tiene, por eso ni ellos ni Buckethead podran reemplazarlo nunca. Es totalmente otro estilo. GNR es rock n roll!!

  • Kick ass band

  • 3 guitarrist so replace just one!?

    i wonder how slash thinks "Yeah... I really was pretty good on that band"

  • Finck replaced Slash, Buckethead was brought in to add to Chinese Democracy, Fortus replaced Paul Tobias (Rhythm guitar) and when Buckethead left Bumblefoot was brought in. So its 2 'replacing' one, because the stuff on the album is very complex and takes different styles to work.

  • actually the solo is rather good, its just not being done by slash and thats the real problem

  • pathetic solo and, axl lost the sing

  • Most pathetic solo ever! Jesus...

  • pathetic

  • this is great i just wish slash was back and i think duff

  • Very good performance

  • U must be happy from see at axl singing and stop saying bad thigs about this guns

  • haha idiots this sucks. I don't know how can you tell that the guy at guitar plays better than Slash. Look at that idiot. He looks like a fool. You need to have style to be in GnR and that guy is there only for money.

  • what happened to axl (this is the first time i've seen his newer stuff)

  • axle was good in that perfomans

  • the solo did not feel right to me. eny one agrey with me???

  • awesome band,awesome frontman, awesome guitar players 3R!!Ron robin richard!!!

  • they sucked at rock in rio, but proved themselves at rock am ring for me.

    axls still got it!

  • buckethead is an insane guitarist in his own right, but slash is 75% of guns n roses, its just aint the same w/o him

  • Actually, thats not Slash dummy, thats Ron Thal "bumblefoot"

  • Although he is no Slash, I thought the guitar sounded pretty good. As for Axl, his voice is not what it used to be, but he sings better than I thought he would at this stage of the game. Axl is pushing 50, that amazes me.

  • LOL

    Watch rock am ring

    And you´ll find the best version of nightrain

  • goddamnit......axl sounds like hes dyin out there. what the hell happened.

  • fukin emo tryin to pose as slash he needs to get his ass kicked

  • They should try and get slash back.

  • Man, without Slash, there is no soul to these songs. These guitarists dont have that same vibe, At ALL

  • Axl: We all want you back on the road, please, listen to your fans

  • These solos are really fucked up!!!!!!!

  • No, no....

    ...watch Rock AM Ring instead.

  • Very good performance, axl has greatly improved his voice since 2002. But i prefere the omg solo of Buckethead instead of this in this song.

  • I WAS THERE

  • (Note that my post was in response to Smoke onTheWater01)

  • the new guns n roses is better then this crap and if axl wants another band he cant call it call it guns n roses, he should make a name other than that

  • new gnr sucks big balls axl sucks now if he wanted 2 get a band he jus cant call it gnr

  • okay motherfucker, now you're gonna tell me why he cant? is there any particular reason you can come up with? Do you even know that he is one of the original founder of that band? I'd doubt you dont ...

  • ya i did no that listen 2 this this aint gnr axl sounds like shit n the rest of the band there aint evn a wrd 2 say how band they sound rite now its washed up axl n some wannabes butcheruin gn songs o n dont evr question me on my rock knowlagde dumbass

  • And my god, Axl looks like a has-been, and he cant even dance anymore. He cant hit high notes, he doesnt interact with the band and its just so sad...

  • I am a huge GNR fan. Read slashes book, have tons of songs and vids. Let me just say this isn't GNR. This is Axl and the only people on earth that will work with his over inflated ego. Don't get me wrong, i love Axl, but this isnt GNR. GNR is Slash, Duff, Izzy, Axl,and Matt (cuz Steven got fired)

  • this is not a rock n roll band... this is the mickey mouse thingy like that i dunno ;p

  • Holy son of A?.. 

    SLASH cut his fucking cum hair damn!!

    nice voice AXL really love it =9

  • wow!! not bad

  • That ain't too bad performance but i prefer the original one.

  • he finally got he's voice back!!

  • Theres no way you can say this guy is a bad guitar player, but he has nothing on slash. Once Buckethead joined the group the whole band went to hell

  • You can't be serious.

    When Buckethead joined he IMPROVED the solos that Slash had previously written.

  • Kid, I would beat your ass if you said that shit around me. Fuck BucketHead. He plays then WAY too fast. Slash plays them where you can enjoy his solos.

  • AHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH­AHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA­HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA­HAHAHAHHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAH­AHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA­HAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHHA!!!!!!!!

    You're so funny acting tough over the internet.

    Anyways Buckethead doesn't always play fast, I've compared the solos and Buckethead plays so much better than Slash ever could.

  • Bullshit, he improved Slashes solos

  • Buckethead is nobobdy but a shredder. As lilpufj said: he plays to many notes, and there isn't anything nice in that. He's like Petrucci. Sad.

  • Even so hes still one of the greatest ever, definitely better than Slash.

  • It's your opinion. And I don't agree with you. Buckethead is playing really fast (but not faster than other shredders) - that's true. But he's doing it without any feeling.

  • I've seen all of Rock In Rio and he only played fast when the solos required him to.

  • Compare this video to "Nightrain" with Slash and think about what you're saying... Buckethead is trying to play so many notes in the moments, when Slash is keepin everything slow & fresh. It's a difference between craftsman and artist.

  • Back in the day Night Train was a slow song, now Axl sings it fast and more powerful. Thats why Buckethead had to play it fast, anyways at the Boston show he improved the hell out of the solo.

  • i'm missing something kiddo. What do you mean by "better". I get a headache when buckethead plays a trillion notes in a second during the nightrain solo. But wheres that bluesy feeling that slash implanted? Gone! Nothing. So tell me what am I listening to? Headache music. and what's the point of arguing who's better. the real point is that buckethead takes out the feeling and put's some more technique. Fuck that!

  • So what?

    Buckethead IMPROVED the Nightrain solo during his run in GNR, a perfect example of this was the Boston 2002 one.

  • .. more like fucked them up

  • You're obviously too far up Slashes ass to see Buckethead is better.

  • buckethead is a fucking loser not bad at guitar but hes actually fucking useless unless hes on his own slash fit the part so much better

  • Wow, you're really ignorant.

    Just because he isn't Slash, doesn't mean he can't play the solo.

    Infact, he played the solos better than Slash ever could.

  • does it matter? neither are in gnr now.

  • You call that better than Appetite for Destruction? SmokeOnTheWater01?

  • I call this better than the old GNR :)

  • never

  • Too bad, it is better than the old.

  • amazing!

  • well, although this is axl and co. this sounds better than the velvet recreation -guns stuff., not messing w/ the originals ´cause velvet has 2 albums out there and axl none, so my point is only on who´s doing a better cover act of Guns n´Roses. merry xmas.

  • axl didnt kick them out the left cause axl is an ass and the new gnr sucks....i love their old stuff but with out slash they are nothing...... who over is on guitar in this needs to go home cause no one can take slash's spot.....

  • Fuck this shit man!

    Axl is one big dick that he throwed out all the others! Stop the bullshit about saying this GnR is better cause it's not!

  • This is better than the old

  • come back ritz 88... you are forgiven, lol

  • Who the f are these jerkoffs...sounds like shiit...looks like shiit... then its shiit...what a fing SHAME!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    1 of the Greatest Rock and Roll Bands EVER turned into a shiity fing side show....what a bunch of douches!!!!!!!!!

  • I'm sure that Buckethead and Slash had their shitty moments like Bumblefoot did in this. The only difference being that it wasn't a video on Youtube that has been watched and laughed at around 50,000 times. Things fuck up live, it happens. To EVERYONE. Someone earlier said the Rock AM Ring version was awesome, they were right. I still prefer Bucketheads Boston (2002 or 3) version, but only because I don't care for the Super Mario noises.

  • this isnt guns and roses!

  • Its the new and 'better' GNR

  • bull shit! its is a shadow of its former self

  • it bumblefoot slash is the man but bumble does this nice

  • shitty effect on bumblebees guitar

  • lol, noise always has been an unwanted effect! some players just have to live with that

  • both guitarists slash and this guy are really great but he didnt write that solo he just shredded it up which i feel doesnt fit the song at all. oh well cant stop axl rose from being himself.

  • And as for the rest of you, if you play a song by another band then ye aren't copying, you're playing the solo as it is because that is how it is. For proof that he hasn't lost his voice, see Nightrain @ Download or Rock Am Ring.

  • The one at Rock AM Ring is unbelievable, its probably my fave version of Night Train ever.

  • i love guns n roses, but axl now thinks he's 25 again, and sadly he isn't. he's lost his voice too, i wish we could get him back.

  • has he lost his voice or am i deaf? i don't know,he looks kinda silly jumping around,he's not 25 anymore... even tho i LOVE guns 'n' roses,i think they're one of the best bands ever

  • Ditto. I was looking for the soul version. A great heavy rock classic. A little gem. Quality.

  • Was lookin' for the jazz/blues version of night Train!! But i have stumbled across a great piece o rock n roll!!

  • agreed..Slash is the man ..stupid ..i hate the new GNR..Copying his axe..and copying his stuff

  • lwshien that was hilariously stupid thing to say, if they're playing a song from when Slash was in the band then how the hell is it copying? Copying his axe?! Just HOW MANY GODDAMNED PEOPLE do you think use LP's? idiot.

  • The comment was split in half Vr is doing good but axl isgoing downhill

  • I love this song & I love The old gnr Axl is too old to be singing the high pitchcause he drank to much vodka & Axl looks better w/out botox Slash is a rock god bumblefoot butchered slashs solo Each of the original gnr members are good now you cant say they suck even izzy came out w/ an album a year or 2 ago that is awesome

  • gay fuck that shit they're copying slash's solo

  • axl aint got that axl-voice anymore... bimble is good but Slash plays in a different style.. cant say "Bimble is better than Slash".. thats just stupid to say

  • axl's hair looked better in the 1980s and 1990s

  • Maybe lol but it wouldn't match with his new style xD

  • axel  axel axel man !!!!!!!!!!!!

  • slash = god

  • wow guns n roses sucks ass now. velvet revolver is where its at. axl lost his singing talent, and its not worth watching if axl is the only remaining member. ill admit that the guitar players they have now are okay, but nobody can top slash. they also started making shit up along the way that sounded terrible and didnt go with the song at all. if ur going to play someone else's song, then play it right. gnr was amazing w/ the original members, but they suck cock now

  • dude, these guys sound awesome are u kidding?

    yeh old gnr were awesome

    but these guys are fukn insane!!

    i saw em live in concert and it was amazing

    but axl is shit haha

    hes totally lost it

    and slash is not better than bumblefoot

    as much as i LOVE slash

    he cant top bumblefoot

    both mad guitarists tho

  • slash would be nice but finke and thal &fortus got it under control as for Adamremy sayin they need bucket head instead of slash I do not know what your smokin but you MUST BE FUKED UP! THE BUCKET STOPS NOW:)lol...

  • Axl's Voice Still pumps me up!

  • Agree 'bout Slash, but i still like Axl's voice! It's good!

  • definitley need slash izzy duff and matt

  • izzy is there

  • that sounded like crap, they need slash, izzy, matt and duff

  • Screw Slash, they need Buckethead again.

  • na slash has way better style

  • i hope you were NOT serious dude. LOL

  • They need slash...

  • GNR - Nightrain on Rock AM Ring is much better than this. Sounds like their givin' up. Sad, really sad!

  • umm...ya...the original gnr broke up in 1994...im sorry..but the new band kinda sucks...i definitely like slash, izzy, duff, steve, and axl 2gether way better...but wutev

  • where the FUCK is Steven Izzy Duff and Slash

  • WHERE HAVE YOUE BEEN FOR THE LAST 14 YRS

  • boom shakalakaboom

  • they have been out of the band for a long time now.

  • izzy is there im pretty sure

  • :( This is sad man.

  • Axl still is a great front man and has a great voice he just doesnt have the band behind him like he did when they were at there best.

  • só a letra sobreviveu

    only the lyrics survived

  • The greatest band in world reduced to garbage.......

  • are you talking about velvet revolver?

  • No I'm talking about GN'R. Why would I post a comment about VR under a Guns N'Roses Video?

  • because you obviosly know nothing about the greatest band ever.. this is GNR and they are amazing

  • What is there to know....they WERE great, now they SUCK. That's the only thing there is to know.

  • you have a limited mind.. that's ok.

  • I have a limited mind? You are the one who can let go. The one who can't admit that it is over. You are one of those who thinks you can mix water, lemons and salt; and still call it lemonade. Do you actually believe that what they are doing is exploring what's out there? broadening GN'R's horizons? If you do, then you are a fool.

  • yes you have a limited mind.. probably because you can't see what's real and what's not

  • You're like those 12 year-olds who post on forums: "Who would win a fist fight between John Mclane and Jack Bauer"

  • John Mclaine would win a fist fight with his hands tied behind his back

  • honestly, just check out nightrain from rock am ring

  • his voice was so strong and awesome when he was in brisbane on the Chinese Democracy World Tour 2007, shitloads better then this performance...and up there with his vocals from the original years live performances

  • la voix d'Axl est vraiment pourrie m1tnant

  • guitarists are bumblefoot, richard fortus, and robin finck.

    i saw him last month in melbourne and he was fucking awesome, voice sounded much better.

  • i was very coservative didnt wanna knoe new guns but this is some good shit...ok voice is a bit rough but its good enough and never can anyone take slash's place but this guy he is good diff to slash but he is good....

  • who is in this line up

  • Axl Rose, Dizzy Reed, Robin Finck, Ron Thal, Richard Fortus, Tommy Stinson, Chris Pitman and Brain.. today it's frank ferrer instead of brain because brain is with his family

  • axel is getting so shit at singing

  • No way man. I've got both copies of "Use your Illusion: Tokyo" and he's always moving, yet his voice stays constantly strong. It sounds like he really is losing his voice.

  • dont worry!! i saw him in dublin, and he was great!! touring does that to the voice!! he's out of breath cos he wont stop movin!!

  • axel sucks

  • Oh my God, he lost his voice! i hope he's not always like this

  • sounds like he's constantly out of breath! I've heard him sing alot better in the old days I dont know about now

  • Axl and those other fuckheads need to get a life

  • great german band

  • Ron Thal is a excellent guitar player!!!

    He is a legend men! The master of tapping too!

    He, buckethead, paul Gilbert, excellents