Mariah Carey vs Christina aguilera `HIGH NOTES`

[xLynnLove97x]

XTina , definately.

[jezzi665]

damn xtina can sing! but mariah is the QUEEN of high notes. but xtina is very close! xtina is still the queen of voices though :/

[mlcampbell815]

Mariah but christina can sing!!

[13hitgirl]

christina ! she is the best

[JosephTheGrat]

I think Christina got a better voice than Mariah =/ Is more powerfull

[ZaiahRay]

superiority WINS the competition FLAT OUT. Mariah beats Christina and Whitney beats Mariah, Aretha Beats Whitney and so on :)) Mariah's been singing for decades and now she had a baby come on guys... And these celebrities arent trying to out do each other, I bet they're all friends lol

[nacho615]

I'm a Xtina Fan, but... I know that Mariah reaches high notes easily, but I still prefer Xtina's Voice... it's not so soft as Mariah's one

[patipatou79]

Even if mariah couldn't sing like she used to in her legendary debut,she's still far superior to any other  vocalist ,that's just the truth !

[28colombiano]

AGUILERA !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[fitjedessy]

damn i think mariah can talk to dolphins

[LushhLipz]

Mariah wouldve won back in the day but she cant even hit those notes anymore soooo Christina wins all the way

[patipatou79]

@LushhLipz

You are wrong.go and listen to Mariah's 2009 I Want To Know What Love Is at X-Factor in UK or in Italia.Or watch her ABC Special Christmas in December 2010 : Oh Santa, the last part of O Come All Ye Faithful,etc. Mariah is still untouchable.

[LushhLipz]

@patipatou79 No im not, she cant hit those note like she did in the 80s and 90s now, shes good yes but she cant do it like she use to

[piscisjo]

Christina❤❤❤❤❤❤

[mdcjebier]

mariah is better ?? fuck bitch christina is fabulous :)

[MissEpicFail22]

Mariah Carey is queen of high notes

Christina is queen at changing vocal levels in on note

[kalaigirl]

mariah is still the best high note hitter till this day

[EmoAngel645]

Christina Aguilera is like my Jesus, and I still think Mariah whooped her ass. Oh well, at least xtina can be around dogs XD

[TheMehakarp]

Mariah is better in every way, baybe Christina is better in one thing. Age

[Leftycam17]

theres a reason ms Aguilera focuses on that new tv show records not selling Mariah has an excuse she has twina

[danny85523]

lets face it Mariah carey cant sing anymore she lost it all !!!!! on the other hand chrisitina stilll sings great so for me christina wins

[BigBlyeEyes1234]

@danny85523 Huh? Christina's voice sounds really bad nowadays.

[gogo4gaga100]

@danny85523 actually mariahs voice is better preserved than christinas, the only difference is that mariah's been around since 1990 !

[TheMehakarp]

How can you not get aroused... This is very hot

[Tav0oH]

Why are u people always trying to compare artists, why can't they both be good at what they do???

Christina's voice is way heavier than Mariah's, and Mariah's voice way softer than Christina's. They are both great to me!!!!

[BWBMakeup]

mariahs whistles are all pre recorded :( she cant do them anymore, i was so upset when i found out

[rafaelhanlet]

christina aguilera is much better, she can holds the note more longer than mariah...

[k266597]

MARAIHA CAN HIT HIGHER SHE HAVE BIGGER RANGE BUT THAT DOESNT MEAN HHER BELTS ARE OR RATHER SOUND GOOD I MEAN THAT NOT SOUNDED BAD

[jazzySarah4]

Mariah definitely had better vocal quality. Her control is amazingly in tact and those high notes blow me away!!! Christiana is also great but she has lots of vocal maturity left to do. Her voice needs more power. :) both great musicians overall

[paeton1998]

mariahs note was higher but over all christina is a WAY better singer;

[Emotionsthatrun]

Xtina of course

[MrNattawood]

Of course Mariah Carey is the best lol :)

[TheMehakarp]

I imagine Christina giving me a handjob

[danny85523]

@TheMehakarp  wtf haha

[xtinabest]

Of course Christina aguilera is the best

[acuarius71]

Pra mim Christina é a melhor, mais em notas altas a Mariah vence com certeza

esses "gritinhos" dela sao muito Phodas, é uma pena q ela os use em todas as musicas, ficando até chato

[laviniapahulu]

christina is soo amazing but of course having a unique octave voice like mariah who can sing any of her songs ..thats the trademark

[roger8654]

i hate those high notes

[xXsemmiexDxX]

@roger8654 why?

[P33ZyQ]

MIMI alllllllll day WHITNEY HOUSTON WAS THERE TEACHER

[TheMehakarp]

now I have a sudden love for them

[brigakakiri]

Legendtina!!!!!

[MarcoXtina]

Christina >>>>>>>

[gsk39520]

Mariah has so much more control over her voice. I wish Christina would get some real vocal training to protect her beautiful voice, and give here that kind of control. (and do a blues album! =)

[Da1UrManWantz]

Mariah can without a doubt hit a much higher key than Christina but they are BOTH my idols so whatevss lol ^_^

[FUCKALLAHTERZ]

cristina hands down

[JacaSmile]

hahahah



[TheJolene52]

MARIAH !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[XxHoosierXHoosierxX]

Mariah fans are the worst.

I have news for you dumb bitches, there is more to the voice than range. Christina has soul in her voice that Mariah simply does not have.

[TheJolene52]

@XxHoosierXHoosierxX wow are you drunk or what? lmao!!!!

[2341kelly]

ofcourse mariah carey pitch is higher but they both sing high



[marterayakatata]

i think christina because she holds her note mariah stop repeating the note

[rafaelhanlet]

@marterayakatata i love your comment....its true she holds her note much better than mariah

[Amaury0913]

Christina Aguilera is better

[godfreewoman]

Minnie Ripperton beats them both.

[baibhavlr]

she is not singing in that octave, that is whistling not singing... even a baby can cry out higher than that note haha

[zmajcek11]

@baibhavlr lol right

[mysty0]

Mariah Carey can actually utilize 16 octaves to perform.., anyone can hit high octaves momentarily.

[AdrenalineCrush]

lmfao from 2007 time for an update

[dpierrearodrigues]

georgia brown SAMBA

[19MikeMartin]

I love me some Christina Aguilera but my girl Mariah Carey my favorite artist in the world will always be the best! :0)

[Mariahcareymichael1]

Obviously Mariah wins lol. Why does this video exist?

[patipatou79]

You're all all delusionals,come on ! denying the obvious truth is so ugly ! Mariah is the queen of high notes,Christina doesn't even come close.the whole world would agree that,except for you Christina Aguilera fans !

[marterayakatata]

@patipatou79  no chrtina is higher than mariah

[TheJoga18]

Christina wins!!

[TuberrLmaoo]

okay i love christina but mariah wins this one, but this doesn't mean that mariah is a better singer, cuss she could never hit the notes christina does!

[sandyzmz]

@TuberrLmaoo Uh excuse. Its Christina who has never hit the notes that Mariah have hit, especially in Emotions which mariah belted with ease even in live. Christina has a bigger voice but Mariah is the better singer and the one who has a higher range.

[hardcorl]

@TuberrLmaoo

In what world do you live????

[TuberrLmaoo]

@hardcorl SHUT THE FUCK UP, IN WHAT WORLD DO YOU LOVE, CHRISTINA WILL ALWAYS BE BETTER THEN THIS HOE!!!

[hardcorl]

@TuberrLmaoo

How old are you? 14?

[SuperLeslee3]

yea right mariah carey is still the best christina is okay but she dosnt know how to control it n if she did know how mariah would still win hands down!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[iLLusion625]

I want to be HONEST here... Ms. Christina Hurts my ear.. i don't know but when she sings mellow songs i don't like it.. i like her singing songs like Fighter, or any dance songs.. where as on the other hand, Mariah Carey's voice lift my spirit and hair up with her heavenly Voice.. pls. stop comparing these two. Xtina idolize and being influenced by Mariah and that Nobody, i say NOBODY can Deny that Fact.. Xtina is a great singer but Mariah is the Best..

[xIVIadamVx]

@iLLusion625 Well... you say Christina makes your ears hurt, but Mariah makes me wanna cut my wrists. You decide who is better...

[iLLusion625]

@xIVIadamVx ooooohhhhhs....??? Coooorrnyyyyy... if that so why are you still Alive.? hahaha... who's better? is that still a Question? ofcourse i Choose Christinaaaaa's Idol -Mariah Carey... hahaha

[MsPanda209]

i like em both

[karinaipf1]

Mariah

[math11as]

i liked christina more..

[MrPandaZen]

Why you people compare them?! Admit that Christina has really unique voice. I like her songs because they are so meaningful as so Mariah's. And the best voices of our world would be Whitneys , Mariahs and Christinas. :))

P.s. Sorry for bad english. PEACE!

[MyPeanut1991]

@Bchaqueco right Christina did a better job all live

[alejaun]

Christina is still in head voice clearly. This was a joke right?

[SuperShawnbell]

Christina Wins , All They Way !

[bchaqueco]

@MyPeanut1991 Hell YEAH!!!

[iMackid97]

Christina didn't whistlerr

[MsTinaChristina]

Christina of course <3

[khymcharllote14]

Mariah Carey for the win ! LOL's XD

[Tiffypeanut]

@303LILANGEL christina made mariah.... christina may may not be able to hit as high of notes as her but she has the better overall more reliable voice of the two.

[qtboy12o]

xtina hands down...mariah cant do it anymore and she got pretty ghetto...a mess

[KLIFF55]

mariah can hit them with ease, xtina has to be careful because she might not be able to hit them.

[LAgirls561]

do i have to replay for all the christina fans ?

[jomikimilover]

Christina is the best...

and that's it!!..

haha:P

[303LILANGEL]

Christina agulera sings like shit Mariah is still #1!!!

[Tammie082]

Okay first off, know this. You can't be BETTER than the one who MADE YOU. I'm done.

[OscaarXtina]

CHRISTINA THE BEST!

[anthuanrussia]

Christina is way better!!! There's a new list of the best vocal ranger singers and Xtina took number one and Mariah 2nd

[sandyzmz]

@anthuanrussia Which list is that? I would like to take a look at it. At this point I think Carey and Aguilera are on the same level, but Carey in her prime was unbelievably that good, its very sad that she lost all her power and intensity. Hope christina keeps her big voice for some more years to come. Do let me know about that list.

[Forever1Charmed]

@anthuanrussia Can you please give a link to that list? Mariah has always taken first places, just because she has the greatest voice of all time. I'm not her terrible fan, but she was called Songbird Supreme not just because of preference. She's got the voice that blows everybody away and even Christina Aguilera has said it so many times. Christina is a new-comer, who has already damaged her voice (by her 30s). Mariah's lost it because of vocal chord's nodules! Get it, please

[jeinsaravia]

CHRISTINA AGUILERA ES LA MEJOR VOZ FEMENINA DE LA HISTORIA TIENE UN TIMBRE DE VOZ QUE NADIE PUEDE IGUALAR Y MUCHO MENOS SUPERAR TE AMO XTINA ERES LA MEJOR

[XtinoBart]

christina aguilera por lejos..

[sandyzmz]

seriously this "whistle register" thing is overrated. i dont like it much on mariah nor on minna ripperton. but mariah can really do the whistle note though. i think christina's is not exactly a whistle register,it sounds more like a high pitched head voice.

[tom1yum2goong]

MINNE RIPERTON HAS THE VOICE RIP, THAN MARIAH DOES SORRY MY OPINION

[amberjwc2433]

Christina sounds great, but Mariah is better. Mariah's whistle register is clearer. and somewhat higher. Just saying.

[WeaponsOfSeduction]

Xtina rarely uses whistle register so it's always sooooo exciting when she does. Mariah's whistle is obviously higher. But Xtina's voice I prefer over any other singer, ever.

[javixupeke]

Christina hit hight notes, but Mariah can do thats notes ALWAYS! and sing a song on whistle register and christina not!

[sussi1605]

I love Xtina no doubt about it she is my all time favorite singer she touch me in to my very soul, but if i have to decide from this to clips i´ll vote for Mariah. There bough great singers and my heart will always be with Xtina <3

[WhatsUpManHAAA]

they both are amazing singers, but their songs are just horrible, especially mariah's, i guess she is one of the most vulgar women on earth (sorry)

[sandyzmz]

@WhatsUpManHAAA admit it already you totally hate mariah. far from being vulgar, she is a beautiful,soulful, and intelligent woman. and if u call her songs horrible, then u dont know what music is.

[WhatsUpManHAAA]

@sandyzmz

i don't hate her, i just think that a singer like her can sing much better songs, i know that she has good songs as well, but c'mon she always looks and acts like a slut in her later music videos and she sometimes sounds like she is having orgasm XDDDD (lol, don't kill me XDDDDDDDDDDDD)

[braian685]

MARIAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH

[aleck281]

christina aguilera she sing it live...

[TheGeorge130]

mariah wins

[katarinamarie22]

Mariah all the way!!

[flashtvcolombia]

Xtina The Best Voice!

[cowboyjc100]

maria iiiiiiiisssssssssss so number one



[bellaheuser]

OK, mariah is higher but i still love christina aguilera

[NadyaLuqyana]

Of course Mariah wins.

[tippyphl404]

Both, hands down I feel are great singers, probably some of the best of my generation. I love and admire both, but I feel like Christina has this one in the bag ! The one choosen for Mimi is slightly tuned out due to the roar of the crowd I guess. P.S. why did BigBlyeEyes1234 try to make it seem like a grammar contest? Lol..

[SuperPianogirl123]

@AnonymousXtinaSinger You are obviously retarded

[GaGaChristinaBritney]

CHRISTINA IS THE BEST F... THE REST

[gary924102]

Pls, Christina is doing falsetto not whistle register. Christina cant do that.

[wakawaka12328]

mariah all the way ... i love chistina though

[deonoxivar]

MAINSTREAM MUSIC NEEDS MORE REAL SINGERS LIKE THEM TODAY. not shitty artists like justin bieber / lady gaga / rihanna etc

[esralautner]

LMAO one thing they definitely have in common: eminem fukt them both up in his songs SNAAAAAAAAAAAAAAP!

[wakawaka12328]

@esralautner loool yep so true

[BigBlyeEyes1234]

@esralautner Actually, Eminem got 'fukt' up by Mariah+Christina and then had a strop about it. He tried getting it on with both of them but got rejected twice, SNAP!

[esralautner]

@BigBlyeEyes1234 ACTUALLY FUCKTART! First of all Eminem 'fukt' up Christina in his songs ("the real slim shady") due to her putting him on blast on MTV saying "yeah his cute but i think his married to Kim *ehhee*" and she got what was coming for her. SO HE NEVER TRIED GETTING IT ON WITH HER SMART ASS.

Secondly DICKHEAD, EMINEM 'FUKT' MARIAH CAREY SO CLEARLY HE WASNT REJECTED FROM NEITHER OF THEM. and she then shut the fuck up after his "warning" cos he had evidence. YA FUKHEAD

[BigBlyeEyes1234]

@esralautner Evidence? LOL. And where's that? He said he'd leak photos if she continued to deny they had sex, WHICH SHE DID, yet no photos. And Eminem got rejected. He said him and Mariah were an item, she said they weren't, he felt embarrassed, mentioned her in like seven songs, cried about it on tour, HEHE. LOLATYOU.

[esralautner]

@BigBlyeEyes1234 SNAPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPP­P! BITCH

[BigBlyeEyes1234]

Mariah wins. The only person that has ever equalled Mariah is Whitney.

Also, why do all Christina fans have terrible spelling and grammar?!

[babylovemeonemoretim]

@BigBlyeEyes1234 Maybe because they have lived under a rock for almost 20 years so they don't know about Mariah's success.

[Anime00Freak]

@BigBlyeEyes1234 to see that she has fans all over the world >:) , lol jking, but why the hate on christina everyone ? .. they both are successful artists and loved by everyone, stop hating for gods sake !!

[tmarkable]

I really don't like either one, if you want to hear an singer check out Lisa Fischer. Grammy winner, backup singer to the Stones and duets with Tina Turner. Now that's entertainment.

[gabriiel91zamudio]

las dos!!!! perfectas!

[rafaelhanlet]

the thing is that christis does it in live....but mariah always used playback when she does the whistler.....

[FLIP6925]

richzero0 ya damn skippy i think shes never don it as high as she can but christina is good just cant fuk wit M.C. at all

[theblondie1107]

um, it's a close call. i couldn't really hear mariah.

[megaloveyou89]

MARIAH CAREY DUH

CHRISTINAS FAT ASS ANNOYS THE SHIT OUTTA ME

NO ONE BEATS MC NO ONE!!!!!! SHE WILL ALWAYS BE ON TOP SHE'S BEEN IN THE INDUSTRY FOR AS LONG AS I CAN REMEMBER AND SHE STILL GOT IT

I LOVE HER!!

[mmqpichardo]

@megaloveyou89 i don't agree! 

[MrVanteyng]

@megaloveyou89 Obviously you're not a real fan. She uses playback and lip syncs everything. DISMISSED/

[babylovemeonemoretim]

@MrVanteyng If you notice carefully, Xtina almost never uses whistle register in her prime. She always uses falsetto instead. And the thing is she has to build up to the notes instead of hitting them head on like Mariah. Xtina's top notes sound painful. Face it, Mariah owns Xtina in any note, any kind of music, any year and anywhere

[megaloveyou89]

@babylovemeonemoretim THATS RIGHT!!! AGREED

[s331052]

@babylovemeonemoretim @MrVanteyng just got his ass slayed!!!

[babylovemeonemoretim]

@s331052 Did you just mock me?

[s331052]

@babylovemeonemoretim no I was saying @MrVanteyng just got his ass slayed

[babylovemeonemoretim]

@s331052 I'm sorry. English is not my mother language^^. So sorry

[megaloveyou89]

@MrVanteyng WHO GIVES A DAMN SHE'S STILL BETTER THAN CHRISTINA BY FAAAAAR. FUCK THAT ANNOYING BITCH CHRISTINA SHE SOUNDS LIKE A DYING DOG. SHE'S DONE, HER VOICE IS SO DAMN UNBEARABLE. FOR ME ITS MARIAH ALL THE WAAAAY WHETHER SHE LIP SYNCS OR NOT, CHRISTINA AINT NO SAINT EITHER I'M SURE THE FAT BITCH DOES THE SAME!!!!

[MrVanteyng]

@megaloveyou89 Mariah was ALWAYS bigger than Christina!Yea Mariah is smaller now but Christina is going thru a divorce so she is dealing with things her way christina was ALWAYS skinny even after her pregnancy so what makes you think she can't lost the weight now?When her album releases next year I guarantee she will lose the weight just like Mariah always does before an album. Mariah is ALWAYS FAT before an album but she loses it before a album. Christina is ALWAYS skinny before & after

[jherch30]

@MrVanteyng in the rolling stone's 100 best singers of all time, mariah is at #69 while christina is at #58..

[tclxy194629]

@jherch30 couldnt agree more. Mariah indeed sings higher, but Christina's voice no matter its fulsetto or low keys they all sounds beautifull!! Mariah, can u singer as yummy as christina does in lower keys? guess not xD

[KabbalahWestCoast]

@megaloveyou89 rude

[Getskidup]

@plateir4ever blind huh?

[sazu777]

Mariah .. Unbeatable ;p

[firdyXIAOs]

<3 mariah careyyy ...

[kennaaB32]

in the first christina note she is jus imitating the whistlse register with her fallestto lmao..

[xtinasfighter]

QUEENTINA ! <3

[FullofAwesomeness101]

Christina's sounds more like singing. Mariah's sounds more like just sound...

[sinsombra2012]

Christina is the best

[ericsinlimite]

Why's this a contest? Mariah will always have a higher pitch..

[thesofia9]

Christinas is better cause even these super high notes are soo strong!!! i mean..you cant even hear Marias:SS..and also Christina was toooooooo young!!she could do it since 17 years old!!!come on!Christina is way better!!

[Trezon09]

Mariah all the way!!!!!!

[steinbeck19]

CHRISTINA AGUILERA PERFECTION :)

[mariahphilmrazem]

Mariah has perfect control of her high notes and they are perfectly clear and effortless. i say Mariah is still by far the best in this category. people can argue that they like christinas belts and whatever but in the whistle Mariah all the way!!!!

[AnonymousXtinaSinger]

As Far As We Know This Clip Of Mariah Probably Isnt Even Live

[TheCarlosgta]

Mariah could be the teacher of Christina...

[lorrainela11]

christina can go longer and cann still do it till this day but mariah carey is one of the best of all tikme but she doesnt do it anymore