Melanie Amaro, Top 7 Perform ~ The X Factor USA

[iBaNezRG95]

Melanie is too fat to be any successful in the today's music.

[Nonoko4girl]

@iBaNezRG95 WTH ??

[maketake]

@iBaNezRG95 I dont agree with you. I mean who cares about your opinion? She has amazing voice! You only think that body sells and music doesnt? She just won x-factor because most people voted for her, this might tell you something already, ANYWAY. There is only your small opinion and you seem to be not so musical person!

[iBaNezRG95]

@maketake You didn't notice that even my account is named after a guitar brand. I've played guitar for 5 years, and btw, if you reckon that in today's music sexuality, looks and overall all the shallow things doesen't matter, I wonder which cave you have spent the last twenty years, kid.

[maketake]

@iBaNezRG95 okey sorry for my misunderstanding with your musicality! You should take account of that there are also Britney Spears kinds of way of selling music and you think its the only way. okey for example Whitney Houston and other great singers didnt make money with their bodies, the music did.

[maketake]

@iBaNezRG95 Haven´t you noticed, millions of people watch x-factor and the winners of all kinds of singing competitions have been voted and loved by a group of millions of fans, that means they are loved, can you see, that sells fucking much.I think Melanie is gonna sell millions of albums. As L.A Reid mentioned on the show, she is gonna sell like 50 million albums. Ha!. Is more convincing to hear an opinion of the x-factor judge's mouth than your mouth.

[PanzerChip]

@iBaNezRG95 Fat is only temporary....

[SeniorBaybee03]

@iBaNezRG95 Really? I'm pretty sure that Adele would disagree...

[mysportbuddies]

This is a song you just don't touch! Melanie rocked it!!!

[QbnVoiCe]

A STAR IS BORN LADIES AND GENTLEMEN.......... Melanie you are the champion!!!

[1979Ginagee]

Talking about not only throwing it down !!!!!! BUT HOLDING DOWN!!!

[ortalyonani89]

Amazing singer!!!

[Mraugje]

What a great singer. But not refreshing enough. When i was a teenager and heard Whitney Houston for the first time i was blown away. Now when i hear Houston i get bored. Celine Dion, Mariah, Beyonce, you name them and Melanie is just the same voice in that category of power singers. Great singer, but no thnx.

[taylor26101]

Josh sound is much older than his age group, Rachel is good but still need time to develop her voice, Marcus is good ententainer but not very good singer and Chris cant hold a tune. Melanie is best suited to represent X factors first winner and by far the best singer and in my humble opinion total package. With the right direction I see no reason she cant be as big as Leona or Kelly!!

[yakiisuperstar]

I love her<3

[MrJas2241]

@13sinclair , Jealousy and ignorance all wrapped up in one abused child.

[MrImsokewl]

WHO WOULD WANNA PAY TO SEE A FAT COW SING WITH A CHEAP FAKE WEAVE ON

[greg31592]

@MrImsokewl i would like to see your fatass get up there and do what she does. put up or shut up.

[taylor26101]

@greg31592 agreed, those who can DO those who cant criticize!! guess we know which one of those you are "Mrlmos not so kewl'

[MrImsokewl]

MELANIES BIG AS A WATER BUFFALO

[bonesbaby18]

lol she looks so different than when she first auditioned its crazy

[Labyrinth1959]

Melanie’s performances: 1. Audition: Listen by Beyonce’ 2. Judges House: Will You Be There by Michael Jackson 3. Top 17: I Have Nothing by Whitney Houston 4. Top 12: Desperado by the Eagles 5. Top 11: Man In The Mirror by Michael Jackson 6. Top 10: Everybody Hurts by REM 7. Top 9: The World’s Greatest by R Kelly 8. Top 7: Earth Song by Michael Jackson She’s nailed every one of these. None of the other contestants can say the same. She is definitely special.

[jbeth2014]

I wish that Chris Rene guy would go home. And that Marcus dude reminds me of usher by his style.. I'm sorry but we don't need the same thing over and over again. We need diversity and neither of them is giving it to us! I'm not a huge fan of Rachel Crow either. Melanie and Josh alllllll the way!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[SuperFarmdog]

ya your probably right

[SuperFarmdog]

@AHakeem88 LOL no he stole 3:16 from the Bible and Steve Austin from the 6 million Dollar Man, but that was probably from before your time.

[brymaster18]

Josh vs Melanie.........can't wait!

[skeenyBeeny101]

Her accent's sexy. 

[foreveryoung202]

not only is she an A.M.A.Z.I.N.G singer , she is beautiful !

[Cecilliaogvictoria]

Rachel Crow shut wind this :-)

[rzross]

She's got a good voice.....so? There are others with good voice.....Mariah Carey....etc.... But I thot this show is about the X Factor....that's what it's called right? So....what's the X factor for this girl? Seriously....other than her good voice.....what is so different about her?

[AzriOfficial]

@rzross her personality...

[MrJas2241]

@rzross last time I looked this was a singing contest, duh.

[TarillaO]

she looks like a super star already

[pianogal1010]

even if drew stayed in she couldn't beat this girl right here ^

[illestflipmamii]

woooooooow 

[MrShriepshroepshrap]

a michael jackson is always very diffucult to sing because mj had a amazing voice en he emote end i never si somebody dowing it better,really nobody but this girl is a good singer

[haltmich83]

why all she sings is so slow /; love rachel much more

[nadz1232]

i love her

[i0001w]

4:09 >>>>>>>>>>> oooooooo

[cherylkhan78]

amazing who cares about the change of voice if she does the song justice which she did good for her and wish people will keep their crul opitions to themselves about the jackson kids none of our business.

[sunkissedbeach]

I think Blanket was sad and missing his Dad. Why wouldn't he? The entire night was filled with his music and his photos.

He is a small boy missing his Daddy so much.

To the haters think about that.

[gwaladrielle]

i came here because i wanted to make sure...yep she really sound awful

[MrJas2241]

@gwaladrielle ,Another deaf mute from the planet Zeno.

[Octavian951]

Once this chick decided she had a different accent and was going to pimp this story as she was "bullied" for it and she went on a crying icoherent rant about the invisible man in the sky that has never let her down, throwing her "muddah and faddah" under the bus, she lost all credibility in my book.

[SuperFarmdog]

@Octavian951 I'm sure she was bullied by people like yourself, that's why she changed her acccent. God who is not a man He is God. He is not invisible He reveals himself to those who seek him. He is not just in the sky, He is everywhere except in your heart. There is a book that He has, it's called the book of life and you won't find your name there with your hate for him and his people. God is love and expects love from us.

[Octavian951]

@SuperFarmdog Any God that would create or allow for the notion of Hell so that his children could suffer eternal damnation earns no respect in my book. I respectfully return the invitation. This is my stop and where I get off. Grow up and take a realistic look at how the world works and what we can prove scientifically.

[SuperFarmdog]

@Octavian951 God created heaven for his children John 3:16. Hell is seperation from God's love and grace. I did grow up that is why I don't have to insult people to make my point. As far as science many scientist believe in God along with 90 % of the worlds population. As far as how the world works there is science on both sides. I believe they call it theory, does that mean fact? I guess it takes a lot of faith to be an athiest too.

[MrJas2241]

@Octavian951 you're so confused.

[MrJas2241]

@Octavian951 , another insensitive, immature, narrow minded miscreant. The type of animal that spreads hatred and starts wars. You wouldn't recognize credibility if it stepped on your face. Go buy another white hood and put another nazi symbol on your arm.

[Octavian951]

The strangest example of reality based competion tv ever seen. From the complete dirge of talent on the show, to the worst host on tv, to the utter bizareness that is Paula and her accolyte Nicole, to the constanst (why?!?) shots of Michaels' "kids", Blanket looks like a grade school serial killer, the other two zombified children of the corn. Simon throwing a hissy fit cause (the copse bride, yawn!!) Drew was sent home, as well as Asstro (every rap is done at the same flow and tempo) Bradley.

[sunkissedbeach]

@Octavian951 How cruel and mean of you.

These children LOVED their DAD Michael Jackson!!!

It must have been hard to sit there and be reminded that he is no longer in this world alive with them as their Dad.

I am sure Blanket was holding back tears all night long.

[rzross]

I think Paris is beautiful. I think Michael would have been so proud of his children if he was still alive.

[MrImsokewl]

SHE SURE AINT MISSED NO BISCUITS AT THE TABLE OR NO MEALS LMAO

[MrJas2241]

@MrImsokewl , you must be an English major at Yale.

[MrImsokewl]

WHO WOULD PAY WATCH THIS FAT COW SING ITS LIKE GOIN AFRICA AND WATCHIN WATER BUFFALOS MOOOO LMAO

[AffiaDaBoss]

@MrImsokewl ...obviously you..dumb ass...learn how to write you ignorant whore...

[MrJas2241]

@MrImsokewl you're about as "kewl" as the red hot poker that should be rammed up your father's favorite sex object.

[Pitonisayox2]

she prooves that she can sing, but i still dont beleive in her , in her interpretation at songs, and also simon , always give to her the bests songs, in rock like example, why she performance rem ~ but not at rly rock son~ why dont put her to rly at a big work : example: Evanscence or alanis morissett, or the idol janis jopplin. Now in Michael again, a song that we know that she can sing but nothing new, nothing that we can beleive in her.

[MrJas2241]

@Pitonisayox2 , why are there so many ignorant uneducated miscreants on this web site who don't have a clue as to how to write or speak English in complete sentences ???

[Pitonisayox2]

@MrJas2241 i type like i want :) ur Melanie have nothing new to show up.... JOSH OR RACHEL are the rly XFACTOR!

[MrJas2241]

@Pitonisayox2 , You write just like another genius masquerading as William Shakespeare.

[Liviasantos9]

i got goose bumps..omg!the best tonight!

[JollyRodger39]

Melanie and Josh all the way

[cinthyanj]

me encanta esta canción y esta super bien cantada!!!



[outsidedark]

wot about the manitees?thats wot i want to know

[nanasanju]

never enough to watch / listen to her singing... again and again, more and more!

[andwoahapple]

she is breathetaking <3

she is a winner.

I LOVE MELANIE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[ilikecheese766]

She's so incredible and breathtaking.She's been my favorite since her audition.Just...amazing.I can't even...

[thisguyinmiami]

wack!

[musickluva01]

she's so talented! im thinking her and josh or her and chris are gonna make it to the finals

[SnowGigi]

Glad that she made it through....

[belinuskoify]

MY favorite! You Melanie YOU Will WINNE!

[Redman5175]

Simon was right, save the best for last. Everybody else besides Melanie and Marcus sucked. Get it girl. I bet she's going to win the X Factor

[gloriajeanray]

Magnificent Way to go girl........you also look awesome.......I can see you winning !!!

[TheZubie1]

She's Been my Favorite the Entire Competition, She was Outstanding with her Voice on this Song & to be able to Perform in front of MJ's Mom & Kids, Brothers.....Wow, She is going to Win The X-Factor.......Also to the Person who did the Video on this, why so much info underneath the Pic, Why didn't you just say Melanie Amaro "Earth Song" (just a little tip)

[MJhotflame]

BEST performance of the night hands down! This girl can sing!

[adcnortty]

HOT!

[andy316800]

omg. so strong!

[annabananazz]

@drkevincampbell  I would say Josh, Melanie, and Rachel have the vocals. The past few weeks, Drew has missed sooo many notes...

[bluepeas510]

Man I thought the kid who rapped black nd white was good ..this lady killed it!! No wonder I just read MJ's moma cried when she sang this

[perferstrategy]

man its like a baby with Astro everyone is feeling upset its not like you guys know him. Tbh Astro is a great rapper he remains poetry, he does have hs own feelings. I'm not saying he's going to win or not he's a bit young and still needs maturity and growth, so hormones can kick in and he'll know how to come first. AstroGoing to go along way anway. 

[perferstrategy]

I have to say Melanie best performance of the night, it was like a big shout out to this is "MICHAEL JACKSON!". She was the only one who ment the song, great vocals, very powerful but I think the other guys don't really know how to sing Michael Jacksons songs.They don't uplif it. But here is our winer of the night she can't go off. No she cannot!

[miritavirgo]

best performance and best singer in this competition melanie the best..!!

[drkevincampbell]

Josh, Melanie and Drew have the vocals

[Tulip5358]

Another amazing performance. Melanie's beautiful voice with it's incredible vocal range did justice to this song. She is a joy to watch.

[Tulip5358]

Another amazing performance. Melanie's beautiful voice with it's incredible vocal range did justice to this song.

[AndreyZidaneTM]

Easly one of the best renditions of Earth Song EVER!

[eleanorayoulateagain]

Melanie is an incredible singer!  Wow!!

[MrDinoslav88]

best performance of the night, she and josh are in the finals and then who cares :)

[vkendriv]

She looks like Alexandra Burke

[charmanderblitz]

it dosent matter if she voted the bottom 2 the judges will save her against ANY OF THEme EXCEPT maybe JOSH.

[missstacey22]

love her

[princessoffire1107]

Simon was dead right on this one " I gave her a song you just do NOT normally touch". And it paid off 10fold. I am so proud of Melanie. The hardest thing for me to deal with, is knowing it will be her and Josh in the finals.. and trying to decide whom to vote for then. They both deserve to win this.

[igorsutak]

HD? not really ...

[madgirlportugal]

A-MA-ZING!!!!!! 

[dbailey888]

Amazing and incredible! her voice transcends into the 5th dimension..God Bless her

[fawnie1208]

She has that WOW factor for sure. She did MJ proud on Earth Song. Fawnie

[IslandShugga]

AMAAZZZING!! Melanie Amaro... Tears Everytime!!

[taralo16]

I've known from the 1st time I heard her sing she is the one! I cry everytime she performs because she touches a place in your soul that is very vunerable..I can't explain it but if you're moved as I am, you'll know what I mean.

[MrJas2241]

@taralo16 yes I am, she makes us cry every time because everything she sings is so close to perfection. Technically she's about as good as it gets. Whitney, Celine, Barbara, Charice, they can do it to you too.

[qtal2010]

Wow! Wow! Wow! She was brilliant!!!

[NICA92880]

Is it me or did Blanket looked more like a Dirty Rag tonight...What I mean Blanket showed no respect to the Contestants. Had no smile, clapped only because he saw himslef on the screen but when caught off guard he looked like he didn't want ti be there and was not clapping while everybody was clapping. What I'm saying BLANKET was plain RUDE!!

[marjanf56]

@NICA92880 blanket is just a child if he seemed distant maybe he was just bored..thats not rude..leave the kid alone

[openearja]

@NICA92880 Stop judging. He's been through a lot, and you don't know what's going on inside his heart. He may have felt completely out of place, he may have been bored--which as a young kid is quite possible and okay. Leave him alone!

[twinkles48]

@NICA92880 Well Blanket is only 9 years old and you are about 10+. Maybe Blanket was tired or likes them but didnt have the time to clap. I mean really. Leave the poor kid alone.

[mapletrips]

What about.... MELANIE! She's simply stunning and absolutely deserves to win.

[1greenbrown]

Tremendously talented woman!! Fiancee and I think she stood out from everyone from the very beginning. I really believe that Simon and all the judges knew this too and they are playing it down. She blows the whole concert hall away. How could anyone not recognize this? I also think the other contestants know this too. If they don't, their in denial or don't want to admit that her voice is supreme.

[MrStreetsofgold]

THE MOST TOUCHING AND MOST TALENTED EVERY WEEK HAS BEEN EASILY MELANIE AND ASTRO, THE WHOLE WORLD CAN CLEARLY SEE THIS, EVEN IF A PERSON DOES NOT LIKE THEM BECAUSE OF THEIR JEALOUS OR ENVY OF PRIDE.

[sanbrawn5]

@MrStreetsofgold I agree on everything you say here, but Astro. He has zero talent and his voice sucks...I don't know why he's made it this far. Of course I hate rap with a passion, it's absolute shit as far as I'm concerned!Melanie's voice is absolutely the best, she's right up there with Celine Dion. I wish her the best.

[skyassume]

@sanbrawn5tcomparing her to Celine Dion? I thinks thats a little to much.Celine is on her own stage right now.

[sanbrawn5]

@skyassume Yes, Celine is on her own stage of course, but Melanie can easily stand next to her.

[MrJas2241]

@skyassume Make you a little bet that when this is all over Melanie is invited to be on the stage by Celine, with Celine at Ceasar's. Celine did it with Charice, and she'll do it with Melanie.

[openearja]

@sanbrawn5 I am not a fan of rap myself, but that being said, Astro is *extremely* talented.  To craft the poetry he does. then learn and perform it...all in less than a week...I'd say that's talent, and whether it's one's cup or tea or not one needs to give credit where credit is due.

[MrJas2241]

@MrStreetsofgold Melanie yes, Astro is a rapper NOT A SINGER. L.A. Reid wanted to give him as much exposure as possible to sell albums to rap fans, he would NEVER appear on American Idol.

[SnowGigi]

Wow! The best performance... When she came out.. It was so amazing.. Got the aura of a star.. Plus, there is no need to hide that accent... I think it is cool that she speak with that accent...

[JusBCos]

After tonight the vetting is over and the only real singer here is Melanie Amaro. It is now time to take of the gloves and see just how good this girl can be. Time for a really big song for this really big voice. I would love to see her sing something like " I See You" from the movie Avatar which was sung by Simon's other amazing find, Leona Lewis. This girl is the genuine article !!!!!

[sessylipz]

You Brilliant Melanie....You deserve to win!!!

[nanasanju]

OMG! She looks so daring with curly hair! And her emotion she put in the song is excellent! <3 Mel

[maxi9viper]

Best Performance of the Night!!!

[semiastephly]

spectacular!!!! :D

[Bkg581]

Wow ! She did an awesomw job once again. This makes 3 of Michael's songs that she has done, and she nailed it with a perfect voice every time ! Love this girl's voice' think she just won tonight with this performance.

[shaqimianj]

Thanks for the upload.

[Endocrine1]

she did magnificent!!! wow i felt her