I couldn't agree more. Two different singers, two different style. I must say though, that I like Eason's interpretation of this song better. He's more... "fong", as in... open.
I think Eason sang like a friend trying to comfort you and tell you to relax. His version carries a warm feeling. Leo interpreted the song like it is Buddhist teaching and tried to express the sense of isolation. The two versions give us different feelings. But personally I think Leo has overdone a bit and Eason's version also fits sing live much more.
Great cover. He really knows how to make a seemingly plain song touching. I also think he's more mature to handle this particular song, no offence to Leo.
The fact is that Eason is more talented,while Leo put a lot of emotion in his songs,which i appreciate so much. Nevertheless i still think Eason sings this song better.
對不起,我真的比較喜歡eason的版本^3^
lingpakkei 1 week ago
叫eason唱惡搞同選秀唔知會點呢.
MegorMegor 6 months ago
基仔唔係冇感情...只係好細膩...用喇叭聽唔一定聽到..
eason就係感情一聽就聽到..so大家都好易feel到eason的感情
beenochow 1 year ago 4
2:40-2:47真係好正...
chak1126 2 years ago 3
I'd prefer Leo's version. he perform this song better...
11070905 2 years ago
2個好唔同...=______='''
2個都好鐘意...只可咁講
leochan1993 2 years ago 3
好歌齊齊唱亦無不可
sa00123456789 2 years ago 6
其實古巨基以前咪幾好~
d歌好聽~又演繹得好~
上次moov佢唱返以前d歌, 聽到我幾開心~
至於eason, 佢有本事紅到台灣, 就連個邊既天后梁靜茹同蔡健雅都做左佢既小fans, 真係無野好講~太強~
gladys2b 2 years ago 22
我覺得eason既感情用得比較岩
Macycy 2 years ago 25
This has been flagged as spam show
古巨基把聲冇乜變化,唱咩歌都係同1個風格..
但係eason成日好多風格,而且佢把感性帶磁性既聲音,可以適 合好多歌!古巨基把聲點變都有限度!
唔信你試下叫古巨基唱浮誇and時代巨輪!淘汰都唔知唱唔唱到. ...呢d只係我個人意見..
nevermind0302 3 years ago 12
其實各有各好
kbpkabba 3 years ago 2
同意expiredoldbiscuit. 其實基仔同Eason都係唔同類型既歌手,各自唱歌都有自己既味道,唔可以一味話邊個最好. 基仔把聲較soft,適合唱d抒情, 甚至有d純真既慢歌, eason把聲就比較磁性,蒼桑. 冇錯基仔唱浮誇, 時代巨輪可能唔夠eason好, 但要eason唱第二最愛, 大雄, 恐怕亦唱不出味道.
kittyhaha2003 3 years ago 3
Comment removed
taki651227 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
說話又唔係咁講
基仔係把聲決定歌路
但係eason係自己創造好多條路出尼囉...
基仔唱尼唱去都係果種風格...
eason呢?
taki651227 2 years ago 8
I couldn't agree more. Two different singers, two different style. I must say though, that I like Eason's interpretation of this song better. He's more... "fong", as in... open.
TiptheJester 2 years ago 2
I think Eason sang like a friend trying to comfort you and tell you to relax. His version carries a warm feeling. Leo interpreted the song like it is Buddhist teaching and tried to express the sense of isolation. The two versions give us different feelings. But personally I think Leo has overdone a bit and Eason's version also fits sing live much more.
expiredoldbiscuit 3 years ago 19
This has been flagged as spam show
呢首歌唔應該咁演繹
BL3001 3 years ago
Eason 真係唱出 R&B 既味道 , 基仔只係流行曲歌手...
基仔一日唔覺悟都無得同 Eason 鬥... 你聽 eason 唱歌時見佢高潮位都好有魅力
crywinds 3 years ago 20
personally i like eason, but i wouldnt call him an "R&B" singer...do you even know what R&B is?
holkn 3 years ago 12
你知唔知咩叫r&b呀...
chanjoho2517 3 years ago 3
crywinds 你意思係呢首係r&b???
wtf???
harcnir 3 years ago
Actually, Eason once explicitly claimed that he never really likes R&B.
ttcsuck 2 years ago 2
機仔 好D
fungsiu2676 3 years ago
eason sings this song better.
jeffysk 3 years ago 20
叫jecolam果位, 唔該聽多幾年eason既歌先出黎丟架啦!
cminglap 3 years ago 19
陈奕迅就是台唱歌的机器
iristreet 3 years ago 7
This has been flagged as spam show
Disgusting!!!
rinasusilawaty 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Disgusting!!!
rinasusilawaty 3 years ago
Great cover. He really knows how to make a seemingly plain song touching. I also think he's more mature to handle this particular song, no offence to Leo.
ttcsuck 3 years ago 28
我鍾意 eason 多d
aRKin1109 4 years ago 54
The fact is that Eason is more talented,while Leo put a lot of emotion in his songs,which i appreciate so much. Nevertheless i still think Eason sings this song better.
petercow2000 4 years ago 22
古巨基把聲冇乜變化,唱咩歌都係同1個風格..
但係eason成日好多風格,而且佢把感性帶磁性既聲音,可以適合好多歌!古巨基把聲點變都有限度!
唔信你試下叫古巨基唱浮誇and時代巨輪!淘汰都唔知唱唔唱到....呢d只係我個人意見..
chungs0302 4 years ago 44
totally agreed... (my personal opinion also)...
bubblechi 3 years ago 10
This has been flagged as spam show
totally disgree with ur shitty opinion
eason singing style doesnt fit 花灑
he made this song weird
jecolam 3 years ago
@chungs0302 --"
你睇2009個時古巨基eye fever 演唱會 佢都唱得好勁好高音
高音個時都hold得好令, 好好
我返而覺得eason 係 2:44 個part 好似上得有少少勉強 - -"
Bryanluk2007 10 months ago
@Bryanluk2007
古巨基把聲本身就係高音過eason
而且eason根本就係中低音強...佢吾係sell高音
MrMh23 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
唱的毫无感情,像白开水,还有人说唱的好??!!这首歌他唱的真不怎么样,比LEO差太多!
better than Leo?? are you kidding me?!
LEO is much better!
freyjaaa1 4 years ago
基仔同eason有得揮都已經前幾年既事啦..
人地陳奕迅拎埋亞太區男歌手同埋最受歡迎男歌手啦..
基仔1早冇得再鬥..距離差太遠了!
chungs0302 4 years ago 16
This has been flagged as spam show
唱的毫无感情,像白开水,还有人说唱的好??!!这首歌他唱的真不怎么样,比LEO差太多!
better than Leo?? are you kidding me?!
LEO is much better!
freyjaaa1 4 years ago
真係唱得好過古巨基!
espn2204 4 years ago 24
勁,呢首歌應該係佢唱先岩! 個feel 好唔同
petercow2000 4 years ago 23
This has been flagged as spam show
Worse!!!!!Y he sang other's song without
any feeling at all????how disgusting....
rinasusilawaty 4 years ago
GD!!!
promiseyou0060 4 years ago 9
yes, the whistling!!!
K0502 4 years ago 14
This comment has received too many negative votes show
good singing... Perhaps Leo is the original singer, Leo is able to grasp the emotion part of the song more...
Jennaluen 4 years ago
eason is such a good singer xx
selinamiffy 4 years ago 17
好過原唱﹒﹒﹒
mcse404 4 years ago 26
better than Leo
VIPVICT 4 years ago 22
This has been flagged as spam show
not that good
theresa818 4 years ago
The whistle <3
honeycloversmile 4 years ago 17