I like old folk songs delivered raw, unwrapped, unpolished, the way there were written to be sung. Your phrasing and delivery is so clear and engaging...a born storyteller. I bet kids love to watch you.
@NOTABOOS yeah I know...now LOL! I will do it again it's a terrible version done in a rush I didn't expect folks to actually watch it :-/ but thanks for watching anyway!
I must admit, I don't really know why, but my American ears have always felt this tune was always better when sung well by a native Brit/Irish speaker. The tale just seems to sparkle more. You do a good job wtih this, glad I've seen it.
Not to worry, though. On this side of the pond we have the Americanized "Shady Grove", usually done in bluegrass/clawhammer style, to keep us happy. I enjoy doing that one myself as a pro musician.
I must admit, as an American (and a pro musician who studied for awhile in Britain) for whatever reason I love this tune sung by native Brits. The accent/inflection just sounds better. You did a good job with it. It just has a haunting quality that American singers (to me) can't match (unless they try to fake the accents, which usually sound horrible).
That's okay, though. We always have our Americanized "Shady Grove", complete with good clawhammer banjo, for ourselves! :)
Thank you :). You did a really good replica!!! :]]]. Beautiful voice. i cannot stop listening to this version now. its almost better than the original :D.
Thank you :). You did a really good replica!!! :]]]. Beautiful voice. i cannot stop listening to this version now. its almost better than the original :D.
Great to hear your version . I never saw this written down . Its interesting to hear it is Lord Dona not Lord Donald . I did a version of this for a request on clawhammer banjo last night . All the very best , Yours Guy
Hi Guy! It seems that their is a lot of confusion about the name of the Lord in the song, is it Donald or Dona? I've always heard it as Arnold, some say it's Darnell, i think Arnold works better, trip's of the tongue easily.
I really really wanna learn this song , I dunno how though, any method you might suggest ^^; and Lovly playing, your voice song just like the orignal XD awsomeness
I have previously heard the Joan Baez and Freeport Convention versions of this song. Your lyrics are a bit more modern. I like them, and its very well sung.
It's not in the least "noobish". I find the delivery and face-pulling extremely irritating and a distraction from an otherwise good voice. Just my opinion.
If you had sung/played yourself you would have known that face expression is an integral part of every performance, very personal and largely subconscious. To criticise it is about as meaningful as criticising someone for his pimples, and it's also pretty rude, but that you already knew, didnt you?
You'd prefer it if her diction were murky? I'm sick of that; I have to endure muddlers most of the time. A folk ballad requires no folk accent, especially not if assumed; the ballad is about the tale, not about the singer!
I'm grateful to at last hear an enunciating singer, so that I need not open more windows to fetch lyrics.
Besides the skills you praised, I applaud facial expression and judicious use of recitative and dynamics. This I judge the best of the solo versions I've heard.
Wonderful indeed! You have a great English folky voice. Please do the entire Steeleye Span and Fairport Convention repertoire and make us all happy. Well done.
I was brought up with folk music and a large part of my life I have spent listening to folk musicians and singers. So I feel qualified to say that this was one of the best folk renditions of the past decade. I really enjoyed it and I have to say that I am so impressed with you as a folk singer. Absolutely first class and 5 stars.
thanks for all your lovely comments x
catuvellauni1 2 days ago
this is a beautiful song. i play a song on the banjo that is very similar sounding, called shady grove. anyways, great job!!!
Pilgrim041588 2 days ago
Thanks for a great version of this haunting song !
SixDayWar67 5 months ago
Nice work. Very nice at that. I had thought that charming understatement was a dead art.
wizenedgoatbeard 7 months ago
Great!
axolotlium 10 months ago
" he stabbed her through the heart and pinned her against the wall "
don56texas 11 months ago
Pleased that I somehow found this wonderful singer! Thanks artist for posting and now I'm awaiting more of your ♪♫♫♪♪♫♪
chinzebo 1 year ago
@chinzebo thanks so much (-:
catuvellauni1 1 year ago
Such an honest voice. Love Sandy but you get the nod.
wabdatl 1 year ago
Absolutely lovely!!!
doyle47446 1 year ago
very ver nice
therisingofthemoon 1 year ago
I like old folk songs delivered raw, unwrapped, unpolished, the way there were written to be sung. Your phrasing and delivery is so clear and engaging...a born storyteller. I bet kids love to watch you.
donrocin 1 year ago
A rousing tale of feudal chivalry, social transgression and rough justice!
levdt 1 year ago
nice voice!
f1intstone 1 year ago
i love your version,cant wait till you do a remake
bigfellethanks 1 year ago
@bigfellethanks
oh thank you very much, hope to do it later this week with mandolin and flute maybe...a little help from my friends :-)
catuvellauni1 1 year ago
@catuvellauni1
I've redone it now (-:
catuvellauni1 1 year ago
Good job. One of my favourite songs- Sandy's version is of course sublime.
pleopod 1 year ago
Great voice! One o' me favorite songs. : )
SheepOfVengeance 1 year ago
목소리 참 곱다. 삽자루에 방울 단 것네~ 노총각 심금을 울리네.
balsemi 1 year ago
Lord Donald
NOTABOOS 1 year ago
@NOTABOOS yeah I know...now LOL! I will do it again it's a terrible version done in a rush I didn't expect folks to actually watch it :-/ but thanks for watching anyway!
catuvellauni1 1 year ago
@NOTABOOS Not true... Many names have been given to him.
mmasny 1 year ago
complements to you for this lovely song ... i'm trying to work it out now seeing your chords and trying to sing in sync with you...
paritoshpant 1 year ago
complements to you for this lovely song ... i'm trying to work it out now seeing your chords and trying to sing in sync with you...
paritoshpant 1 year ago
Very well done. I truly enjoyed listening to it. Thank you for the post.
Rikki0 1 year ago
wonderful!!! you really have a sweet voice!!!reminds us of sandy..
paritoshpant 1 year ago
wow great job!!!!
shovelheadshawn 1 year ago
wow great job!!!!
shovelheadshawn 1 year ago
wow great job!!!!
shovelheadshawn 1 year ago
Matty Groves, essa balada sombria, ficou ainda mais linda na voz pequena dessa simpática cantora.
Fenhir35 1 year ago
Complimenti, molto brava.
marinobugatti 1 year ago
I must admit, I don't really know why, but my American ears have always felt this tune was always better when sung well by a native Brit/Irish speaker. The tale just seems to sparkle more. You do a good job wtih this, glad I've seen it.
Not to worry, though. On this side of the pond we have the Americanized "Shady Grove", usually done in bluegrass/clawhammer style, to keep us happy. I enjoy doing that one myself as a pro musician.
Love the "accent.!" :)
mikeaustin1 1 year ago
I must admit, as an American (and a pro musician who studied for awhile in Britain) for whatever reason I love this tune sung by native Brits. The accent/inflection just sounds better. You did a good job with it. It just has a haunting quality that American singers (to me) can't match (unless they try to fake the accents, which usually sound horrible).
That's okay, though. We always have our Americanized "Shady Grove", complete with good clawhammer banjo, for ourselves! :)
mikeaustin1 1 year ago
wonderfull, thank you
fishtankbank 1 year ago
Brilliant! Do you do any more stuff from Fairport, Trees, Fotheringay, Trader Horne etc?
alfrunrig 1 year ago
Nice. I like your phrasing and energy.
JoBrownMusic 1 year ago
loved it xD
crazyacea 1 year ago
Thanks, guys! This was a bit of a rough and ready recording when I first learnt the song, got loads of words wrong etc!
catuvellauni1 1 year ago
Thank you :). You did a really good replica!!! :]]]. Beautiful voice. i cannot stop listening to this version now. its almost better than the original :D.
esotericfortress 1 year ago
Thank you :). You did a really good replica!!! :]]]. Beautiful voice. i cannot stop listening to this version now. its almost better than the original :D.
esotericfortress 1 year ago
i like this song but i only like ONE version...i cant find it anywhere! you're good though!
iFawkChu 2 years ago
I am really impressed. And surely I would come to your concerto if you would give one in Kito Vegesack.
Blaufrigg 2 years ago
yeah, well sung, i like it
betover68 2 years ago
I´m in luv
cyraobatera 2 years ago
Thanks guys, I wish I'd done it better now LOL! Glad you enjoyed though!
catuvellauni1 2 years ago
Claire, Quite wonderful rendition. Thank you!
peterpreta 2 years ago
Great Job
terrylee47 2 years ago
probably a norman slut 'lady' arnold
atfatw 2 years ago
Yep.........reckon so.
MITCHWILD 2 years ago
wonderful voice! i really enjoyed this, thank you.
smudger1973 2 years ago
for an english girl you are kinda cute
atfatw 2 years ago
Great to hear your version . I never saw this written down . Its interesting to hear it is Lord Dona not Lord Donald . I did a version of this for a request on clawhammer banjo last night . All the very best , Yours Guy
guywolff 2 years ago
Hi Guy! It seems that their is a lot of confusion about the name of the Lord in the song, is it Donald or Dona? I've always heard it as Arnold, some say it's Darnell, i think Arnold works better, trip's of the tongue easily.
MITCHWILD 2 years ago
Wonderful - enjoyed this so much I will try to learn it.
TheMankyProfessor 2 years ago
My father used to always sing this song to me when I was little, and it was always my favorite.
You sing a great rendition of it! So much different than the lyrics my papa sang to me, which were based off of Paul Clayton's I believe.
muffinlovah 2 years ago
Great song ive been listening to Liege & Lief lately, fairport convension seminal LP, which fetures this song.
you do sing this well, particulaly the passion and emotions you ad,
great stuff.
gd303uk 2 years ago
hello dear Claire, great song , bravo, compliments, friendly & kiss , patrick
yarods 2 years ago
Fantastic - thoroughly enjoyed that. You have a wonderful voice!
valcot 2 years ago
you're good :)
tatamarero 2 years ago
nice voice i really like how unique its is dont hear a voice like that to often so job and keep singin!!!
macdaddy69992001 2 years ago
very nice version love this song
amethystmyst 2 years ago
I really really wanna learn this song , I dunno how though, any method you might suggest ^^; and Lovly playing, your voice song just like the orignal XD awsomeness
gothicgirl64 2 years ago
beautifull
Ultimoexilio 2 years ago
Fantastic performance!! The old time folk songs are still the best I think.
coolanddark 2 years ago
Thanks, yep they are timeless songs!
catuvellauni1 2 years ago
I have previously heard the Joan Baez and Freeport Convention versions of this song. Your lyrics are a bit more modern. I like them, and its very well sung.
moongoyal 2 years ago
Thanks(-:
catuvellauni1 2 years ago
Thanks! You are very kind.I hate listening to myself but I'm glad other people enjoy the songs.
Cx
catuvellauni1 2 years ago
Great. I like the song a lot and your voice is so clear.
JanaMoravia 2 years ago
whooooo the first song i ever learnt on guitar!
Thanks for posting
meandmymandola 2 years ago
really amazing!
Takelot64 2 years ago
Thanks!
catuvellauni1 2 years ago
sorry if I rekindled the fire, wasnt my intention, if it makes you feel better, be free to put the blame on me! :)
jonasjar 2 years ago
Ha ha! no worries! and thanks (-;
catuvellauni1 2 years ago
I am enjoying this "floor spot" and the rest of your collection. Many thanks.
FolkieMacc 3 years ago
Thanks!
catuvellauni1 3 years ago
It's not in the least "noobish". I find the delivery and face-pulling extremely irritating and a distraction from an otherwise good voice. Just my opinion.
MrRik2 3 years ago
If you had sung/played yourself you would have known that face expression is an integral part of every performance, very personal and largely subconscious. To criticise it is about as meaningful as criticising someone for his pimples, and it's also pretty rude, but that you already knew, didnt you?
jonasjar 3 years ago
Stop singing it like you're performing for toddlers and drop the face pulling and this could be good.
MrRik2 3 years ago
Thanks for your comment and for listening!
I am like this all the time I'm afraid, call it expressive or insane LOL. (Don't think I'd sing this for toddlers though, bit too violent!)
catuvellauni1 3 years ago
what a noobish comment dude
FANDANGALUS 3 years ago
ohhhhhhhhhh this is sooo good!
letsbestrange21 3 years ago
Haunting...Beautiful!
agricolaterrae 3 years ago
I love your voice! thank you.
kmsssn 3 years ago
I like your version a lot!
May be a couple of pints of guinness caould make it even more authentic ;)
14tpus 3 years ago
whoops...on the eye
reedykilowat 3 years ago
Aye..Good song and she be easy on eye too.
reedykilowat 3 years ago
nice to listen to, although sounds a bit like mary poppins does folk... ;-)
steppinrazr190e 3 years ago 2
Yep, I am the reincarnation of Mary Poppins LOL Cx
catuvellauni1 3 years ago
adoro questa canzone, complimenti per la tua versione!
tuttubi2 3 years ago
Very good but I would prefer it if your diction was a little less precise. Everything else - tone, guitar, tuning - was amazing.
Inkyspot3 3 years ago
Thanks! I could try drinking a few pints of cider I suppose! All the best, Claire
catuvellauni1 3 years ago
You'd prefer it if her diction were murky? I'm sick of that; I have to endure muddlers most of the time. A folk ballad requires no folk accent, especially not if assumed; the ballad is about the tale, not about the singer!
I'm grateful to at last hear an enunciating singer, so that I need not open more windows to fetch lyrics.
Besides the skills you praised, I applaud facial expression and judicious use of recitative and dynamics. This I judge the best of the solo versions I've heard.
ClaireConrad 3 years ago
at least she's better than maddy prior whose muddled up diction is closer to dog barks than english in the classic "700 elves"
atfatw 3 years ago
Oh no. The diction is perfect. I'm not a native speaker and it's very easy for me to understand.
JanaMoravia 2 years ago
Great!
beccawecca1987 3 years ago
Thanks!! Joan Baez sings yet another version. You did a very nice job. I enjoyed it.
familygenealogy 3 years ago
Thanks everyone, you're very kind!
Cx
catuvellauni1 3 years ago
well done..very like the original
SpliffPete 3 years ago
MMMMM...interesting....mmmmm..very interesting..
menatol 3 years ago
This was beautiful, Thanks for doing such a nice rendition of one of my favorites!
skabibble 3 years ago
Wonderful indeed! You have a great English folky voice. Please do the entire Steeleye Span and Fairport Convention repertoire and make us all happy. Well done.
FoliesEspagne 3 years ago
Glad you enjoyed it! That's quite a feat but I will try and do a few more! Thanks for listening and your kind comments.
Claire
catuvellauni1 3 years ago
wonderful version, realy enjoyed it
TheHarriets 3 years ago
A lovely performance Claire. I'd like to hear that without being miked up - in a pub environment maybe.
Oh and it's 'Lord Donald' by the way... LOL
feckwitklown 3 years ago
Thanks a lot!
Yes it is Lord Donald in some versions but not in this one. (;
Claire
catuvellauni1 3 years ago
Great to see more of you on ewetube! Encore! Encore! Encore!!!
key2kingdom 3 years ago
Thank ewe steve!
Baa bye
Claire
catuvellauni1 3 years ago
Brilliant Claire,your best yet. You have such a beautiful voice. I am so lucky to have such a talented wife.
1967ajg 3 years ago
An excellent rendition of one of my favourite Child ballads. I look forward to hearing more of your songs.
raymondcrooke 3 years ago
Thanks Raymond! I like your version too.
Claire
catuvellauni1 3 years ago
I was brought up with folk music and a large part of my life I have spent listening to folk musicians and singers. So I feel qualified to say that this was one of the best folk renditions of the past decade. I really enjoyed it and I have to say that I am so impressed with you as a folk singer. Absolutely first class and 5 stars.
cjwaywell 3 years ago
Blimey, thanks Chris I'm so pleased you enjoyed it!
Claire
catuvellauni1 3 years ago
Wonderful Claire! Bravo!
That was a very entertaining song, I smiled all the way through this.
Great to see you develop and gain more confidence.
Well done indeed, and thank you for sharing
Paul
PaulSaywood 3 years ago
Cheers Paul!
Thanks for the encouragement, glad you enjoyed it.
Claire
catuvellauni1 3 years ago