Phish - In The Aeroplane Over The Sea - 6/26/10 - Columbia, MD

[elmobrother]

In what universe is this doing that song justice? Yes they are playing it, but the fact that they are feels like an afterthought. Phish needs to keep their grubby hands off this music. I shake my head "no" to this.

[AnotherMe21]

He totally fucked up the words.

[ohahoypolloi]

meh...trey can't sing it. NMH is one band that should remain uncovered.

[AubynStafford]

eew no thank you please.



[Ch3fr3ddy]

This is p. fucking good

[arjackan]

sweet jesus i think i just threw up

[clashcityrocker1221]

Phish suck, this is an awful cover

[facesplosion]

So this is Phish playing NMH at Merriweather Post Pavilion... this is a hipsters dream

[psocidae]

@facesplosion Phish are not hip.

[branfransisco9]

@facesplosion Phish is too mainstream to be considered hipster

[TheJoeyTaylor]

@facesplosion Phish are pretty much the least hipster thing on the planet...

[Phished123]

@TheJoeyTaylor Have you been to a show since the return?....

[RMPalm2000]

fuck Phish, they ruined this song. Just because they cover credible bands does not mean they are a credible band. Fucking hippie scum!

[maaaaaaatt1]

@RMPalm2000 you're a faggot.

[captainpanic08]

@maaaaaaatt1 There's no need to be homophobic.

[branfransisco9]

@RMPalm2000 NMH made one album that's widely enjoyed and that's overrated as fuck. Just because a bands fanbase doesn't wear a cardigan or suck cock you automatically write them off. Fucking hipster scum!

[RMPalm2000]

@branfransisco9 Are you fucking kidding me? This version sucks. Maybe if you stopped taking LSD and actually listened to something that was a well written song and not just endless pointless riffs you would understand how ABSOLUTELY FUCKING HORSESHIT PHISH IS.

[branfransisco9]

@RMPalm2000 You have grindcore in your favorites, you have no legitimate opinion in anything. Also I do not take LSD. You should learn what riff means because you are using it incorrectly.

[xBillyTheKidx]

@branfransisco9 what a bullshit first half of this comment.

go take your hipster douchebag elitism elsewhere, jerk off.

[xBillyTheKidx]

@RMPalm2000 this version really is terrible and completely loses what was so great about the original.

[corinthecat]

Torture

[MarcoEsquand0las]

This is the most vile piece of shit i have ever heard. Jeff Mangum deserves better.

[MarcoEsquand0las]

@CaptainHollyShort i aint even mad tho

[MarcoEsquand0las]

@CaptainHollyShort lol u mad dog

[dolcevespa1]

this is the first time I've heard someone make this song theirs and that's pretty fucking hard to do. I don't love it more than Jeff's but I respect this version.

[dolcevespa1]

It's "I love how you love me" and Rosie and the Originals. BEYOND BRILLIANT!!

[adstoneable]

oh my God, my favorite band doing a cover of the best bands song ever, couldnt ask for more

[PhishB0wl]

was present for this, what a great and obscure song for the boys to cover.

Can't believe how strange it is to be anything at all

[Nemmet]

"what a curious life we have found here tonight" what a perfect song to see performed at merriweather. wow.

[bblokes]

at 3:35 - 4:35 is Rosie & the Originals - Angel Baby.

[couchpotato679]

so bummed out that i missed this show

[toddod87]

it's weird cause he has such a jazzy voice to his singing and i liked it better with brushes

[mileschris]

I actually like Phish's cover of this NMH song, but I'm a huge Phish and NMH fan, so it's hard to be impartial. I do agree with @phunkyphish3 though; Page should've sung, not Trey. Still like the cover.

[deadphish09]

This was a big surprise. Two of my all time favs.

[sirbrofistington]

why would you combine two terrible things

[phunkyphish3]

This is really bad. I love that they decided to cover it but damn is it terrible. Page should have sang, I don't care if Trey was the one that picked it. The way he kills it sounds like he's only heard it a handful of times.

[007lysol]

hound79, you know naught of what you speak. Usually a good idea to just stfu when you don't know what you're talking about.

[spacegodessey2001]

I think this was pushed by Fishman as well as Trey. Wonder if this can spark a reunion tour for NMH.

[spacegodessey2001]

Seem to be pulling out all kinds of songs on this tour. Can't wait to see what's next.

[ndeyesso]

this is f'n awful. phish should leave good music alone and stop murdering other peoples songs

[TheCavern2009]

@ndeyesso WHY ARE YOU HERE THEN??? WATCH OTHER VIDS...people like you are funny....you hate on phish, and yet, YOU'RE HERE!!!!!!!!

[ndeyesso]

@TheCavern2009 Im only here because my fishhead friend sent me the link because I love NMH. I do like phish as well but they can not replicate the sincerity that Mangum can demonstrate. Also, Trey's voice always sucks. I wish he would go mute and let his guitar speak for him.

[TheCavern2009]

@ndeyesso they are not trying to do it like them or anything like that....they are really honoring the band if they cover a song....sad you missed that....and by the way PHISH slays NMH....just saying

[ndeyesso]

@TheCavern2009 phish and NMH are not even in the same genre you dummy, so you cant compare them. Put both lead singers in a bar with only a guitar and mike and Jeff mangums lyrics and style would skull fucks trey's weak gibberish crap.

[TheCavern2009]

@ndeyesso what did my comment say....come on man....and by the way musicians are the total package...meaning playing, singing, etc.....well you know trey SLAYS the other.....i know you know that

[ndeyesso]

@TheCavern2009 you have no idea what i know and im done. enjoy your ignorant shallow life and stupid unoriginal web name based on a band song that was created with no relevance to you.

[Nycholai]

@ndeyesso Classic. 7/10 times, when you open a video on youtube, there will be a fragment of what is clearly a stupid argument that has no real relevance to the video. Thank you, both of you guys.

[ndeyesso]

@Nycholai wow, a third party response to a three month old argument. STFU!!

[spreadneck7]

I bet Trey pushed for this.

[HarpuaND84]

Nice I can't believe they covered this song.

[mahaffey6]

ya trey can't compare on Jeff's own song but if you listen to 5+ songs of NMH Jeff Magnum's voice it gets so fucking annoying from hearing him crying into the microphone.

"I LOVE YOU JESUS CHRIIIIIIIIST I LOOOOVE JEHEHEHeSUS CHRIST!!!"

[Grumbot]

hound 79, eat a dick. Jeff mangum rules and so does NMH. I love phish but you must be a fool if you think trey sings better than jeff.

[universalmind81]

@hound79 dude, god your gay.

[meshgearfoxx]

Terribe cover. They should have learned their lesson after Gold Soundz.

[hound79]

jeff mangums voice is not good...unless you like a whiny coffee house voice painfully pouring through his tightly wraped scarf soaked in wine and tight jeans and black rimmed glasses....Trey blows that guy away anyday....milk is not good music to listen to but they do write good songs others play well

[kinkykathy]

@hound79 - hear hear

[Grumbot]

wow. i cant believe they covered this. I love phish and i love neutral milk hotel. treys voice cant step to jeff mangums but it still sounds great.

[tedradey]

how come phish covers indy bands, but none cover phish?

[nathanjrod]

@tedradey - because Phish can play anyone's music, but hardly anyone can play Phish's music

[themarsist1]

@tedradey

Spiral Stairs from Pavement's other band Preston School of Industry covered Axilla on the "Sharin in the Groove" tribute to Phish album

[CushionConvector]

That sounds way better than I thought it would.

[JonEdens]

5 days until Charlotte!!

[mcd995]

love NMH. Good job Phish, i'm not surprised by their taste in good music.