Melanie Amaro - Man In The Mirror - X Factor USA (Top 11)

[mizzbrains]

Thumbs up if you are watching this in March

[ZzTheSingerzZ]

No words can describe her voice! =D

[NeaBieber]

Michael would be proud :')

[killedmycat]

She is so genius. Simon should STFU though.

[XxgirlwithtalentxX]

i love you and your voice dont be afraid to speak the way you normaally doo

[churchpeppergirlful]

love her voice and outfit of choice because it looks like Micheal Jackson

[chrisarmy1998]

14 people thought Conrad Murray was not guilty...

[ZzTheSingerzZ]

14 People think that they can sing better than her?

[ZzTheSingerzZ]

she is the best! she made Micheal proud!

[karenZmusic]

L.A. was jealous becaouse Justin Bieber can't sing this!

[lildiva79]

i love her she can forreal

[lifeline1702]

I'm so glad she's the winner !!!

[theamerican123]

This song is beautiful! In her voice was more beautiful.

[twirlaholic1983]

This was beautiful and inspiring.

[therealPRINCESSNAT]

*@horseitout15

[therealPRINCESSNAT]

@horseitout I thought I was gonna die to if she didnt win!

[75AMALKA]

Let the critics of critics,you are to have criticized,Melanie came as an amateur singer and showed what he can do,to sing a song from the Whitney´s art,and she gave her to me,as an amateur without errors,it is a great and deservet to win

[jalene360]

when she tried to do the song with R Kelly to try and change it up LA said it was bad -.- after all the other times he said she's been doing the same type of music. like for real -.-

[Triqaeon]

What I do not understand with L.A. Reid is that when he critiques Melanie, he says it's either 'predictable' or if it's something completely different and out of her comfort zone, which he keeps saying he wants to see from her, it's 'not her style'. You just cannot win with him.

[ARZULOVECUTE]

LA: WHY DID U SAY THAT IT IS THE SAME SONG

ME: PLUS WHEN ASTRO DOES HIS RAPS IT DONT EVEN MAKE SENICE AND PLUS MABEY YOUR JELOUSE ON MELINE BECUSE SHE IS TO GOOODDD AT SINGING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! BOOO U

[ARZULOVECUTE]

I love you omg i love your voice your AMAZING I LOVE I LOVE YOU. I HATE HATERS IF PEOPLE HATE YOU DONT LISTEN TO THEM YOU ARE BUTILFUL JUST THE WAY YOU ARE TRUST ME I LOVE YOU I WANNA BE YOUR FIRST FAN I LOVE UUU>>>> AND I AM REAAALLYLLY YOUR FIRST FAN BIGGEST BIGGESST!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­LOVE U

[Straczynskiify]

I gotta wonder, is there out there a Melanie Amaro fan club already?? Cause if not, then maybe I should start one!

[IdolXfactor2]

@Straczynskiify There is like 5 of them on Twitter & a whole bunch on FB!

[whitesoxfanforsure]

My fiance better be making a change or else I am leaving his behind!!

[whitesoxfanforsure]

Another Michael Jackson....I am sure he is proud of her!!  She will advance world wide too.

[keli1024]

U FUCKEN ROCK!!!!! U KILLED IT U BLEW THEM ALL AWAY U GO GIRL!!!

[famousd0816]

this is a true winner one who can perform and has an amazing voice i mean she was sick during this song she lost her voice and had to save it and look she was straight boss

[phooar]

I could listen to her every day. Inspirational.

[OneDharmaYouMovement]

im starting with the man in the mirror.

Michael jackson!....

[cleopatraXIII]

oh please let her win. please.

[naruto2775]

she looks like Raven Simone



[SolidShinoda]

She's another Mariah, Chris is another Drake, Josh is unique. My 2 cents.

[1wishfulthinking1]

@SolidShinoda Oh well, Melanie won

[SolidShinoda]

@1wishfulthinking1 Exactly what I predicted, since she has the most fans on twitter. Now, this doesnt mean anything, I think Josh is on his way to grabbing a better contract, since his name wont be linked to The X Factor and Simon Cowell forever. Congratz to Melanie.

[Rectb]

best voice of x factor



[healthhavencom]

LA is the coolest judge. Knows just what to say to push everyone's buttons.

[0oEmiilyo0]

IM HER FAN!

honestly i'll cut my veins if she doesnt win!!!

[xxangie12196]

L.A. has a stick up his ass!!!

[gshawtymane]

I love not only a brilliant voice but also her strong attitude! Star has born!

[gshawtymane]

Good for you, Simon, that you got Melanie back. Good for you!

[ginnet31]

she and marcus looks like superstars



[2michieu]

Chills up and down! BOBBIN MY HEAD! Gone on Melinie do the damn thang!

[suddenlink3]

This is probably my favorite song that she has done, but it is so hard to have a true favorite because she has done a fantastic job with everything Simon has given her!!!! But, this one shows her stage personality so well. She gets the messege out, and has me wanting to "look in the mirror~" Love Melanie!!!!!!

[adgarza15]

You know, I usually hate Micheal Jackson covers, beacuse i love M.J. and I really don't think anyone else can measure up to him using his songs, but wow. This girl has major talent. I really believe she made Micheal proud.

[rudinas]

omg i love it

[LoveMine1DM]

<3

[18ksrm]

LOVE IT

[FOT2010]

Conclusion: Nobody does it like MJ. PERIOD.

[sarazoarleyva]

Simon looks like a proud poppa :)

[xDdarryDx62]

MELANIE ALL THE WAY <3

[tillerman002]

has anyone else noticed a lot of people with those truly moving voices are black?

[rockman0809]

Is it just me, or does she kinda look like tia and tamera?? :-P

[cdpw007]

Yes she can sing very well but Drew has such a unique voice, I have not seen the uniqueness in Melanie like I have Drew. For the 2 female judges not to leave it up to America to make the choice on Drew, then after Nicole for Paula not to follow what she has said in the past about Drew was a injustice to a 14 yr. old star. America should have had the say no matter which way it would have went. But Drew will make it even without staying.

[Cmpunk472]

who hoo and she live likes 10 minutes away from me!

[cattmugga]

Melanie will win. Her raw talent is unmatched.

[musicx33love]

her or rachel need to win.

and they both need CDs out asap.

[Wellenreiterable]

She is verry good

[SuperYesz]

oh yeah, That's what I'm talking about!, Good Job.

King Of Pop for ever!

[BELTED007]

holy crap i stumbled onto this and I am speechless. Amazing!

[TheRocKYaSiR]

Melaine gonna win :)

[yogetle123]

L.A: She does the same type of song every time

Me: GOD!!! and your best performer RAPS. Isn't that the same thing EVERYTIME, L.A? ISN'T IT?!

[tipangawal11]

@yogetle123 aGREEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE­ED!!!!!

[musicx33love]

@yogetle123 LA doesn't have a clue what he's talking about. he told drew skyscraper was an old person song...an 18 year old sings that originally.

[ConnorTheBrit986]

@yogetle123 you have no idea how many times I yelled that to my mother. I called him a hypocrite every week because he said that every week. Astro rapped every single performance. He didn't even stick to the theme, he just rapped. I'm glad he went home and Melanie is still in it

[Triqaeon]

@yogetle123 Pretty much.

[XxM1L4GR1T05xX]

her voice is so beautiful

[horseitout15]

Seriously, if she doesn't win, I will die.

[judey2008]

@horseitout15 please don't die,you family still needs you lol.

[ConverseSisters11]

@horseitout15 OMG, she is the best singer in the WHOLE SHOW!! I really (x1000) want Melanie to win!!!!

[AM33ZY]

@horseitout15 if her or josh doesnt win the world is deaf

[tillerman002]

@horseitout15 I know! her or Rachel Crow have the most talent. well, so did Drew, but other than Simon, the judges are stupid.

[JaesDa14u]

@horseitout15 i will to she is incrediable



[MeggyNicole]

@horseitout15 hey. she won. guess u arent dying this year. :p

[talisraeli776]

She won :)

@horseitout15

[cbworld2008]

@horseitout15 good thing she won :)



[whitesoxfanforsure]

@cbworld2008

glad you are alive. She won because of her outstanding quality!!

[gulsherjan]

I've a feeling she's gonna win...seriously

[sarazoarleyva]

I like the fact that Simon looks like a proud poppa, cute how he is so protective of her. He knows she can go really far. :)

[sarazoarleyva]

I loved this song! She is amazing, definitely the best in X factor :)

[timsleee]

the red bar for dislike is the size of LA weewee

[higor7144]

ela canta muito bem, se Deus quiser ela vai ganhar .

[aldinefuracao]

aprende sandy como se canta MICHAEL JACKSON !!!

[thesleepyguy5]

but L.A. is right, she sang very well but it was expected from her already. she needs to change it up a little. she has a beautiful voice but she does the same kind of song all the time.

[zeke257]

@thesleepyguy5 every singer thats makes it sings with the same style..Carrie underwood witney houston janet jackson lionel richie prince ETC the have their own style ....And singing songs from Whitney Houston,Beyonce and Micheal Jachson doesnt sing the same kind of songs..lol.And she sang a song from each 1 of these singers..And when an amatuer can sing songs from these 3 they are damn good..

[sweetie15marzie]

LOL. people are booing LA. *booo*

[anagalhardi1]

loved



[sandrashecat25]

michael miss u

[muddabish]

At least he apologized the next day & admitted he was jealous cause she's amazing.

Melanie should just win this competition hands down.

[barys9]

Goood!!! this is awesome!!!!

[aleksa68442]

STFU LA.!!!!! :///

[Nunu489]

i love her

the best

[Nunu489]

i love her



[zeke257]

Simon should beat his ass..

[zeke257]

LA Ried is an uncle Tom

[ferocious67]

@zeke257 Really? Do you have to go there with that Uncle Tom comment, you stupid KKK fuck.

[zeke257]

@ferocious67 I am far from the KKK..And I guess since you got like that about my comment you must be a HOUSE NIGGA then!!!!!!!!

[ferocious67]

@zeke257 You claim not to be KKK, but yet you use the N word. So which is it, you fucking Imperial Dragon bitch, or whatever term it is you fucking klansmen use. I know you know this already or have been told numerous times, but you are one stupid mother fucker.

[sweetHonesty500]

To be honest, Melanie is too far from Leona Lewis because she has no octaves and whistle registers. Also, she has no star factor or she just look average. That's why she was almost sent home by Simon Cowell during the top 8 girls in his house in France. Simon gambled by choosing Tiah Tolliver and Simon Battle over her because the "diva" singing is not the trend now in the music scene. What happened to the careers of Jennifer Hudson, Fantasia, Jordin Sparks, Alexandra Burke, etc.

[zeke257]

@sweetHonesty500 To be honest..you dont have a damn clue what the hell u r talking about when it comes to music...

[zeke257]

@sweetHonesty500 You have 4 people that has been very successful in the music industry saying how much of a great singer she is and how her voice can heal the world bloody fantastic can sing the phone book ETC..And then you make a stupid comment like that. No he realized along with the other 3 judges that they made a big mistake.Them 4 girls u mentioned is not even close to her vocals..These 4 judges has more knowledge about the ind in 1 of their pubic hairs than ur family tree TO BE HONEST!!

[sweetHonesty500]

@zeke257 Melanie's singing of every song doesn't excites me compared to other divas

[zeke257]

@sweetHonesty500 I can respect that..All of us has are likes and dislikes..Luther vandross didnt move me like freddie jackson did..But doesnt mean Luther was not a very good singer just means like you said he didnt move me like freddie jackson...

[babz888]

I hope she wins!!



[TonyClarkNZ]

nasal

[Maryam4e]

she's very good, and she looks cute :) :D

[MarisolDeVino]

I comletly disagree with L.A

She did an amazing job !

Love her, and so does the rest of America !

[kathyqz]

Everyone.... we have to be voting for her... every week. I am. No one else. Hands down, she is the best and deserves to win.

[danieliszha]

OMG¡¡ ... this girl is amazing ... I love his voice ... is undoubtedly the best¡¡

[EmmA33865]

She deserves to win....(my opinion)

[bbreezer]

she's SO good i got the shivers! Go Melanie, go Drew!!

[hoanguyen1101]

what was wrong to L.A, both Drew and Melanie did really god jobs. I think the comments that he gave for them should be given to his own student, Astro..., there was no different in him too, what the heck

[joseAvilaDiaz]

I don't understand why but I do not like her at all

[Streichholzli333]

@joseAvilaDiaz

Hm, I feel the same way about her. I mean, she obiously can sing and belt, stays on key, but somehow her voice just seems pretty plain to me. Nothing I could recognize again.

[wetwetu]

WOOOOOOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!

[jazzymom218]

she sangs go girl

[dagrimmone88]

she has a great voice and she's HOT TOO!!! :D

[frecklycheeks]

The audience loved it and it was a beautiful tribute to Michael Jackson, she really pulled this off

[drayham]

This girl has vocals that are over the top!

[IanHoopz]

Great performance, however it really bugs the crap out of me, when the Judges pick songs for thier contestance, without taking thier gender into consideration. How does a female sing about talking to the man in the mirror? just implies she's transgendered ><

[smith3922]

i get shivers every time i hear her sing.

[bronzekitty26]

The thing that pisses me off about the X Factor is the "judging". I'm happy L.A. said what he said because even though Melanie is my favorite, Nicole and Paula are always like "You were beautiful, you are like a gift from above, made me cry blah blah blah..." and of course Simon is biased. It is true, you can expect what she's going to sing, but so can you for all the other contestants.

[willardrmiller]

why oh why is everyone so damn stupid i mean enough already melanie is and will be a mega star iam glad she does the same kind of song each time. all the divas are the same very famous in the end

[Calendyr]

Wow. I don't see the other judges complain about Astro and Chris Rene doing Rap week after week. She has the voice to do big songs, why would she do something else? Unbelievable.

[olguits09]

L.A, come on... look at your team. Astro and his annoying attitude, Marcus Canty showing nothing new... the only good contestant you have is Chris Rene and even him can't beat the girls on Simon's team. So quit INVENTING excuses to criticize Melanie.

[TheLanzani90]

she is sooo good! i love her i almost cry with this song!

[icimj23]

the best singer of the x factor chooses the best song of the history by the best entertainer in the world

resuming: IT WAS AWESOME

(L.A. is so stupid, he shouldn't say that)

[olguits09]

L.A is just jealous 'cause he doesn't have a strong team like Simon.

[4vlam]

@olguits09 Your right. He knows that one of the girls will win the x factor.

[amartinez343]

L.A Reid is a fuckin Hater

[swaggaqueenism]

8 people dont know what good music ....wait let me rephrase that..............8people dont know what great music is.Thumbs up if u agree 8D this is music not like selena gomez and them other people shes the stufff. She just made my day thumbs up if u agree 8D

[redwine12roses]

Like if you think L.A. Reid is an ASSHAT!

[kikiriki9996]

i love you Melanie.........

[willardrmiller]

amazing she has fans thoughout europe

[willardrmiller]

wonder how she will sound in a studio..................live she is excellent

[Kelztje]

i wish the audience would shut up

[PrinceofPeace9957]

We all knew in the first audition she was getting the contract. Mature,poise,beautiful, and a very strong voice with range and solid as a rock. Nuff said?

She owns the audience every time she sings!

Hands down the winner.

Peace.

[aforalvin]

She's younger than Stacy Francis, but she acted more likely a star than Stacy. It's been 10 years, seems anyone can singing quietly in the darkness, Simon'll go crazy abt it.

[yhmuh5]

LA is a fucking moron!

[RandomEdges]

I seriously can't stand LA, he is always saying stuff about how Simons girls don't have variety in their song choices...have you looked at Astro's songs, they all sound the same too!

[MsSandiiiie]

@RandomEdges Astro is rapping. A rapper need's a song with similar beats that he is familiar with, otherwise they won't do such a good job as they do when they are familiar with the beats. Same beats, different lyrics.

[hristina1978]

@RandomEdges - i agree ... i would never understand why he chose all the hip hop and r'n'b performers, and all the talented country singers he just blew away ... he was a bit right about Drew though - she starts to sound a bit boring ...

[lashturner]

I just LOVE ME SOME MELANIE!!!

[MegaMaria2209]

Melanie is doing a fantastic job. Her mentor knows exactly what he is doing. LA just did not know what to say because each week Melanie keep giving them more. I cant stop listening to her.BEAUTIFUL,BEAUTIFUL,BEAUTI­FUL

[925lexi]

She is a great singer snd i'm voting for her as well as some others, but nobody can sing that song like MJ.

[ChrisssyE]

Melanie, Rachel and Josh. <3

[notabadguy06]

I didnt like it.....This is a song you dont touch unless you nail it

[Narutokun991]

@notabadguy06

That's ALL of MJ, pretty much same as Freddie Mercury, but she did pretty well. Did not like her version of Will You Be There though.

[ronhep49]

I just went to re listen to the original with Michael Jackson, and after listening to it. I have to say that Melanie defintely puts her own twist on it. Love the smoothness of her version and actually prefer it over the original

[clydeivanty]

melanie...stacey...rachel and marcus...i love their voices....:)

[zeke257]

This is the best version of this song that I have heard from someone other that MJ

[Cubbysmum]

L.A is a total tit head!! Melanie can sing anything. Good call Paula ' she can sing the phonebook!!' Sack L.A.

[mtjproducer2008]

I hate to say this but LA is right. I would like to see simon push her. She has sung the same type of songs the entire competition. Simon should have her try to sing Rock. Have her sing Kelly Clarkson's Since You Been Gone. she wonderful TEST HER. Stop playing it safe

And for all of you talking about Astro. He is being tested harder than the rest because HE has to WRITE a new song EVERY WEEK. imo he has the hardest task every week

[broesie60]

@mtjproducer2008 he revoked ;) michael jackson performed this song uptempo... melanie gave the song a new dress. Last week she performed a song from the eagles ... no trendy for the young voter, a very brave song choice. It's right, she favored ballades, but she isn't boring in her way, because the kind of the ballades are very different.

[winnie16star]

@mtjproducer2008 People don't get it Astro is the most original person in this competition he has to come up with his own raps.

[Johnass4]

r.i.p MJ

[mrsninazinha]

She is amazing!

[ireemoo]

O M G. i love her voice. she should totally win.

[esantana35]

I just LOVE MELANIE!...she is wonderful...GOD BLESS!

[moezayko2]

Listen- She is as good as Beyonce

I have nothing- She is as good as Whiteny

Desperado- She is Melanie

Man in the Mirror - She reminded me Kelly Clarkson

She is the combination of artists I expressed above.

[ZainurSingapore1999]

@moezayko2 is whitney lol

[moezayko2]

@ZainurSingapore1999 LOL sorry lah.....Typo lah....haha :P