Please don't ever remove this video. I am very blessed and thankful to have been there that very day. It was such a beautiful performance and dream come true to hear my favorite song of many years in person. <3
Exactly. And I don't think anyone should compare the two - it's like comparing two chapters in the book. I regard the two as just one story, one song, split into 2 different ambiances. Coma White is about using drugs to attain an infinite happiness (which fails, of course), and Coma Black is about the torture and depression that leads one to use the drugs.
its werid, his voice wasnt very good live during the golden age of grotesque tour and and 2007 part of the eat me drink me tour, then twiggy gets back in the band its like his good old holy wood voice
I wouldn't say as good as that, but the song change might have helped out a bit, lets him use a larger variety of vocal chords so some don't get all rusty. :p
I was at this very show. I will never forget when he played this live. It brought me to tears. So beautiful. This song means a lot to me.
SpyraAndoverOfficial 8 months ago
I love this, I just wish he sang all the lyrics to Coma Black instead of just singing the chorus :( it's my favorite of the two :(
BenjaminAtticus 1 year ago
i wanna die cause i missed this show. I was supposed to go but shit came up :(
THEmiz908 1 year ago
I was here that night with Helena!!!!! Watching this live was one of the greastest natural highs I've ever had... LOL
xjasonmgx85 1 year ago
Please don't ever remove this video. I am very blessed and thankful to have been there that very day. It was such a beautiful performance and dream come true to hear my favorite song of many years in person. <3
SpyraAndover13 1 year ago
i love MM but now his voice suxs preaty much:S thats from drug use ...
181jose 2 years ago
Fact: Marilyn Manson kicks ASS.
Lemonhead86 2 years ago 2
i love this song (L)
mmsidwilson 2 years ago 5
how does one sneak in camera?
Killstrument 3 years ago
you can hide it in your shoe most places dont make you take your shoes off
navonod1981 3 years ago
Great camera.
dmcpro23 3 years ago
when he sang coma black he look emotional,
dita von tese perhaps
sanguina555 3 years ago
dita....this bitch smashed him. and now, hes not what he was once. poor brian...
ForgottenxWords 3 years ago 2
i agree
stadiedude 3 years ago
coma black was a much better song than coma white i thought!
oxrjbizzle1984y 3 years ago 2
both are great songs though, and the combo is really cool!
oxrjbizzle1984y 3 years ago 4
Exactly. And I don't think anyone should compare the two - it's like comparing two chapters in the book. I regard the two as just one story, one song, split into 2 different ambiances. Coma White is about using drugs to attain an infinite happiness (which fails, of course), and Coma Black is about the torture and depression that leads one to use the drugs.
Beautiful story, great song(s).
DarthKrattus 3 years ago 9
a beautiful story it is indeed
stadiedude 3 years ago 2
Bravo.
gothmusic11 2 years ago
I think so, too!
elfef 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
goth is taking over noooooooooooo
luisen199504 3 years ago
good to see them performing these songs again.
Alianger 3 years ago
I think he is trying to make the song both screaming and singing.
LOve him A LOT but I thing poor Brian is out of breath!
This song ROCKS!!!!!!!!!!!
IndulgeHypocrites 3 years ago
great job...what kind of camera did u use thanks
youandme352 3 years ago
I wish they would make a studio version of this like as a bonus disc for the new album for a bonus disc for pre-ordering the new album or somthin
AgentKujo 3 years ago
I wish he did a remake of these two songs meshed together like he does it live here. Esp. coma black...sounds much better with the screaming.
kiddfridge80 3 years ago
favourite song ever.
shellxlynne 3 years ago
This was one of my favorite songs off Mechanical Animals.
alexvoz 3 years ago
amazing.
can NOT wait for the next album and the fucking tour !!!
somebodysomeone69 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
sorry but manson won`t have a new album =(
jasso199123 3 years ago
Check the MySpace, retard.
Astrocreeper07Alt 3 years ago
why will he not have a new album?
texas10RAW 3 years ago
Don't worry he is having a new album don't believe jasso199123
navonod1981 3 years ago
Your a dumb ass, its coming early 09
AgentKujo 3 years ago
oh how wrong you was....
spitfirepete2007 3 years ago 2
its werid, his voice wasnt very good live during the golden age of grotesque tour and and 2007 part of the eat me drink me tour, then twiggy gets back in the band its like his good old holy wood voice
WHYCANTIFINDONE 3 years ago 2
I wouldn't say as good as that, but the song change might have helped out a bit, lets him use a larger variety of vocal chords so some don't get all rusty. :p
Astrocreeper07Alt 3 years ago
personally I think it was at rock bottom during hw, at least from what I heard of the bootlegs.
Alianger 3 years ago
fuckin awesome set list glad Twiggy's back
zimzepp90 3 years ago
thats awesome how coma white transforms into coma black :)
gothicgeek14 3 years ago
LOVE this song...love how twiggy sings with him too ^^
MarilynLove90 3 years ago
Coma White 4ever!
meikokajix 3 years ago
damn he gets better at singing when he gets older, but hes always awsome
r6o6n6mm 3 years ago 4
Coma White 4ever!
DisposableTeen911 3 years ago 7
Awesome Video there, I saw him when he came to phoenix
MisunderstoodXG 3 years ago 3
He played this song live when it was my b-day =/
And I didnt see this lovely performance... </33
Kakkakoulu 3 years ago
I love this video <33
inkognituuu 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Coma Black isnt here!!!
realmooex 4 years ago
at the end 4:00
buttholesurfer666 4 years ago 4
Great quality. Thanks for the vid. I just love how Manson transitioned Coma White into Black.
SlaTeScenT 4 years ago 5
i was there and forgot my battery for my camera :(
He is the master of performance and he sound good live.
BklynRockChic 4 years ago
awesome vid men
great quality
dantranxx 4 years ago 3
awesome vid men
great quality
dantranxx 4 years ago 2
awesome vid men
great quality
dantranxx 4 years ago
I would give anything to see this 2 songs live :´)
Thank you so much for uploading this!!!
Babydolly 4 years ago 2
great footage thank you very much for uploading this. great performance.
SomeguyThere111 4 years ago
I love this song. This is the first live concert i've seen with this song, since his new album! hes so amazing. X3
marilynmansonDK 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
you need to commit suicide motherfucker.
justinsane61c 4 years ago
i still cant believe he brought this song back
cant wait till the 20th of this month
san francisco
grotesquehydra 4 years ago
im going to that concert to going to be awesome
darknessstare666 4 years ago
Twiggy looks a bit Trent Reznorish with his cool get-up. :P
Steelspoon 4 years ago
i love how hes doing coma black as an outro for coma white, so incredible
crazywhiteboy2006 4 years ago
I love it how he's looking down at the beginning.
KickstandInYourMouth 4 years ago
couldn't you just e-mail it to me?
KickstandInYourMouth 4 years ago
theres a 10MB limit on emails i can send.
gangstasimba69 4 years ago
Thanks a lot for this video mate, its incredible. Did u say u could send it over e-mail?
JVmate 4 years ago
fucking AMAZING
great video too
hobbesdream 4 years ago 2
Is there a way I could get the actual file for this amazing video?
KickstandInYourMouth 4 years ago
wow amazing performance!! Manson is really on fire right now. Welcome back!
kinderfeld1 4 years ago 3
i was here! this song is fucking amazing. i'm so happy to have finally heard it live.
xsweetestt0rment 4 years ago 2