As soon as you said you were a young earth creationist then i realised that you must have no understanding of the "science degree" that you were awarded with. you are right in that having a piece of paper does not make you smart. fundamentalist christians like yourself are making life for us normal christians a living hell. give us a break, put the bible aside and go and feed some poor people in africa.
I can't be bothered watching all of this as you've shown you have no idea what you are talking about.
So all, literally every single piece of evidence, points to god does NOT heal amputees, yet you're saying that it's an assumption god does not heal amputees? No. No it's not an assumption, all the evidence points to no amputees have been healed. A ridiculous amount of evidence points to no amputees have been healed.
So, after seeing the entire video, I notice that the question isn't a loaded question, as evidence leads us to believe the premise thus far. The original video maker didn't make an assertion without evidence towards the assertion being rather apparent to anyone.
Not a single false premise has been demonstrated. Though it'd be convenient for you to think that.
Unfortunately, as it stands, you've commited the fallacist's fallacy.
No, what he said is that there absolutely no evidence that god has ever regrown an amputated limb. Do you have any evidence that god has ever done it? Your fallacy is that you can't explain why god supposedly heals all kinds of mundane sicknesses, finds jobs for the unemployed, cures cancer ,yet has never restored an amputee. Find one case in the last hundred years!
No, what he said is that there absolutely no evidence that god has ever regrown an amputated limb. Do you have any evidence that god has ever done it? Your fallacy is that you can't explain why god supposedly heals all kinds of mundane sicknesses, finds jobs for the unemployed, cures cancer ,yet has never restored an amputee., then tell us how glorious your sky spirit is. Find one case in the last hundred years
Are amputees sinners? But the worst thing you could say is that starving people are sinners. That is disgusting, inmoral and irrational. So is your god, so I'm not specially susprised with that.
You started well and I thought you were going to give an interesting answer to that video from a chritian point of view, but you did not.
I'm not going to watch your other responses as I cannot stand someone explaining why babies starve to death because they or their parents are seaners.
@HuanManwe, you stated that my God is "immoral" (by the way you spelled immoral wrong). How does an Atheist account for morals in the first place? Can you show me by starting with atoms first? Morals are non material. Can you demonstrate that rape is immoral. By the way, if God has decreed you to be harden by my video. Then God will get the glory for it.
@MrClownpirate How can you say that rape is immoral? How can you morally explain Deuteronomy 22:28? Forcing a raped teenager to marry her rapist? Is that the book you say you take your morallity from?
Any person has a morallity. It comes from our genes and our brain, so does you. The problem is that some people believe that a certain book (bible, quran, torah,...) and say that it's all perfect. If they find something 'weird' there they say they just do it and don't question it. It's insane!!
@HuanManwe you stated "It comes from our genes and our brain" which genes in the genome are the moral genes? where is the rape is bad gene? What observed experiments show this and peer reviewed paper support this? Where in the brain are morals? I am guessing that you are stating that morals are material things. Before I answer your Bible objection, I want to see if you look at the side about the verse. Have you seen what Christian's response to this verse? If so give me a source?
You started very well, and I agreed with you mostly, but after the first question... So your god do heal from time to time many people, but not amputees?? I've never heard of an amputee having their members back. Have you? I'm sure that if there was one case, only one case, you could watch it on Fox News instantly :-)
@stinkpuppyohno , actually I don't know, now that I think of it. (by the way you spelled believe wrong) I don't know of a case in the Bible or in my life time. I have heard of claims and so forth (Yes, I know that does not mean proof). It does not matter to me, because God is not obligated to heal anyone from any health problems. I deserve to be an amputee or be struck dead and so do you. The Ultimate reason why that hasn't happened is because God has chosen to be graceful to us.
@MrClownpirate so god is gracious by not healing us. we deserve to come into this world with clubed feet before we have ever sined. is that our sin or the sin of our parents. if some one cuts his leg off while robbing a house ok but what of birth defects. is god able to heal aputies. if so why dosent he. he suposadly cures canser and why arnt those with canser not just gracious. and no i do not believe i deserve to be an aputie. nor do you.
@stinkpuppyohno You stated "so god is gracious by not healing us" I don't think you understand my last comment to you. (I am not good of explaining by writing text) God decreed to be less gracious to those are amputees. In terms of your physical bodys. you stated "we deserve to come into this world with clubed feet before we have ever sined" Yes, we do deserve it and NO, WE ALL HAVE SINNED BEFORE WE WHERE BORN. The whole human race sinned when Adam ate the fruit in the garden. ROMANS 5:12
@MrClownpirate what about the passages of the new testament that says "i will no longer judge the son upon the acts of the father"? now i cannot remember where exactly that is, but i will look it up if you want.
@MobileThinker Sorry, for not responding for awhile.(I hardly ever check my comments anymore) Now, No the passage you are thinking of is NOT IN THE NEW TESTAMENT. It is in the Old Testament. It is Ezekiel 18:19 - 20, Unfortunetly, many Christians and Skepics misapply this passage when attacking the doctrine of (original sin - whole human race sinned when Adam fell). The passage is applying to your "Daddy", not our federal covenant headship Adam or the Father of the whole human race. Thanks
@MrClownpirate now that really doesn't make sense. if it applies to your actual father, should it not also apply to your original father? i may be misunderstanding what you are trying to say, so i am gonna summarize it. you are saying that, a biological son cannot go to hell because of what is father does, but can because a man that live thousands of years before he was born ate an apple. think about that for a minute and it makes absolutely no sense whatsoever.
@MobileThinker Its Thanksgiving and now I have time to respond to some people.Now, you stated "should it not also apply to your original father?" No, the passages states the sins from your father singular not father(s) plural, meaning fathers in the past. Adam is your covenant headship and your Daddy is not therefor there is a difference and a difference in standards also.Now, your summary is correct from what I am reading. almost out of room so I will post another comment here.
@MobileThinker, Now you stated "Think about that for a minute and it makes absolutely no sense whatsoever" actually I know about this and thought about longer than you have. It makes complete sense to God and may never make complete sense to man but that does not affect truth in any shape. Truth is truth whether or not if it make sense to us finite humans.So, in summary, All of God's attributes are impossible for man to comprehend completely. Thanks you Mobile for your questions.
In light of the "god healing" for other affictions why hasn't there been anyone claiming to have had a limb grow back ? ? (I am not saying "ever" but please present a documented case if you want to say that god DOES heal amputees like the cancer claims)
You say they have to wait until the resurection??
So again they are somehow LESS worthy than the person "cured" that had cancer???
I've never really liked the "10 questions". I think the arguments that they hint at could be stated in a much better way.
That said "why won't god heal amputees" is not a loaded question. He means amputees in general. We can't know if god has EVER healed an amputee, but i think we can all agree that god does not heal amputees as a general rule. And that's what the question's getting at.
I made a response video, and decided that this one question shows that this man does not have any ability to make an argument without logical fallacy.
Oh I dont disable them, just remove the 12 blasts about how my rec room looks, but leave the 13th and 14th up to show why he is blocked. Everyone else can comment as they like.
A loaded question?! God doesn't heal amputees, that's a fact! Even if you turn it around and say "why can't God heal amputees" or anything similar the observation still stands. God has never healed an amputee. Of course he doesn't have to have seen every amputee in all history to know this - ONE documented case of this happening would be a scientific field day not to mention a media frenzy, and yet this has never happened.
I've never seen a video with no likes before.
DonaldHellsing 2 months ago
As soon as you said you were a young earth creationist then i realised that you must have no understanding of the "science degree" that you were awarded with. you are right in that having a piece of paper does not make you smart. fundamentalist christians like yourself are making life for us normal christians a living hell. give us a break, put the bible aside and go and feed some poor people in africa.
aden302000 7 months ago
I can't be bothered watching all of this as you've shown you have no idea what you are talking about.
So all, literally every single piece of evidence, points to god does NOT heal amputees, yet you're saying that it's an assumption god does not heal amputees? No. No it's not an assumption, all the evidence points to no amputees have been healed. A ridiculous amount of evidence points to no amputees have been healed.
BlueCosmology 8 months ago
Wow, not a single thumbs up.
So, after seeing the entire video, I notice that the question isn't a loaded question, as evidence leads us to believe the premise thus far. The original video maker didn't make an assertion without evidence towards the assertion being rather apparent to anyone.
Not a single false premise has been demonstrated. Though it'd be convenient for you to think that.
Unfortunately, as it stands, you've commited the fallacist's fallacy.
BigLundi 9 months ago
No, what he said is that there absolutely no evidence that god has ever regrown an amputated limb. Do you have any evidence that god has ever done it? Your fallacy is that you can't explain why god supposedly heals all kinds of mundane sicknesses, finds jobs for the unemployed, cures cancer ,yet has never restored an amputee. Find one case in the last hundred years!
JonKevinCherry 1 year ago
@JonKevinCherry I am sorry but I dealt with similar questions in the comments with other people and
I don't feel like going through this again. I made this video about a year ago. I am no longer
interested in talking with atheists. No offense, I suggest you go to venomfang X's channel. Thanks
for you comment however.
MrClownpirate 1 year ago
No, what he said is that there absolutely no evidence that god has ever regrown an amputated limb. Do you have any evidence that god has ever done it? Your fallacy is that you can't explain why god supposedly heals all kinds of mundane sicknesses, finds jobs for the unemployed, cures cancer ,yet has never restored an amputee., then tell us how glorious your sky spirit is. Find one case in the last hundred years
JonKevinCherry 1 year ago
Are amputees sinners? But the worst thing you could say is that starving people are sinners. That is disgusting, inmoral and irrational. So is your god, so I'm not specially susprised with that.
You started well and I thought you were going to give an interesting answer to that video from a chritian point of view, but you did not.
I'm not going to watch your other responses as I cannot stand someone explaining why babies starve to death because they or their parents are seaners.
HuanManwe 1 year ago
@HuanManwe, you stated that my God is "immoral" (by the way you spelled immoral wrong). How does an Atheist account for morals in the first place? Can you show me by starting with atoms first? Morals are non material. Can you demonstrate that rape is immoral. By the way, if God has decreed you to be harden by my video. Then God will get the glory for it.
MrClownpirate 1 year ago
@MrClownpirate How can you say that rape is immoral? How can you morally explain Deuteronomy 22:28? Forcing a raped teenager to marry her rapist? Is that the book you say you take your morallity from?
Any person has a morallity. It comes from our genes and our brain, so does you. The problem is that some people believe that a certain book (bible, quran, torah,...) and say that it's all perfect. If they find something 'weird' there they say they just do it and don't question it. It's insane!!
HuanManwe 1 year ago
@HuanManwe you stated "It comes from our genes and our brain" which genes in the genome are the moral genes? where is the rape is bad gene? What observed experiments show this and peer reviewed paper support this? Where in the brain are morals? I am guessing that you are stating that morals are material things. Before I answer your Bible objection, I want to see if you look at the side about the verse. Have you seen what Christian's response to this verse? If so give me a source?
MrClownpirate 1 year ago
You started very well, and I agreed with you mostly, but after the first question... So your god do heal from time to time many people, but not amputees?? I've never heard of an amputee having their members back. Have you? I'm sure that if there was one case, only one case, you could watch it on Fox News instantly :-)
HuanManwe 1 year ago
ok then do you belive god does heal amputees?
stinkpuppyohno 1 year ago
@stinkpuppyohno , actually I don't know, now that I think of it. (by the way you spelled believe wrong) I don't know of a case in the Bible or in my life time. I have heard of claims and so forth (Yes, I know that does not mean proof). It does not matter to me, because God is not obligated to heal anyone from any health problems. I deserve to be an amputee or be struck dead and so do you. The Ultimate reason why that hasn't happened is because God has chosen to be graceful to us.
MrClownpirate 1 year ago
@MrClownpirate so god is gracious by not healing us. we deserve to come into this world with clubed feet before we have ever sined. is that our sin or the sin of our parents. if some one cuts his leg off while robbing a house ok but what of birth defects. is god able to heal aputies. if so why dosent he. he suposadly cures canser and why arnt those with canser not just gracious. and no i do not believe i deserve to be an aputie. nor do you.
stinkpuppyohno 1 year ago
@stinkpuppyohno You stated "so god is gracious by not healing us" I don't think you understand my last comment to you. (I am not good of explaining by writing text) God decreed to be less gracious to those are amputees. In terms of your physical bodys. you stated "we deserve to come into this world with clubed feet before we have ever sined" Yes, we do deserve it and NO, WE ALL HAVE SINNED BEFORE WE WHERE BORN. The whole human race sinned when Adam ate the fruit in the garden. ROMANS 5:12
MrClownpirate 1 year ago
@MrClownpirate what about the passages of the new testament that says "i will no longer judge the son upon the acts of the father"? now i cannot remember where exactly that is, but i will look it up if you want.
MobileThinker 1 year ago
@MobileThinker Sorry, for not responding for awhile.(I hardly ever check my comments anymore) Now, No the passage you are thinking of is NOT IN THE NEW TESTAMENT. It is in the Old Testament. It is Ezekiel 18:19 - 20, Unfortunetly, many Christians and Skepics misapply this passage when attacking the doctrine of (original sin - whole human race sinned when Adam fell). The passage is applying to your "Daddy", not our federal covenant headship Adam or the Father of the whole human race. Thanks
MrClownpirate 1 year ago
@MrClownpirate now that really doesn't make sense. if it applies to your actual father, should it not also apply to your original father? i may be misunderstanding what you are trying to say, so i am gonna summarize it. you are saying that, a biological son cannot go to hell because of what is father does, but can because a man that live thousands of years before he was born ate an apple. think about that for a minute and it makes absolutely no sense whatsoever.
MobileThinker 1 year ago
@MobileThinker Its Thanksgiving and now I have time to respond to some people.Now, you stated "should it not also apply to your original father?" No, the passages states the sins from your father singular not father(s) plural, meaning fathers in the past. Adam is your covenant headship and your Daddy is not therefor there is a difference and a difference in standards also.Now, your summary is correct from what I am reading. almost out of room so I will post another comment here.
MrClownpirate 1 year ago
@MobileThinker, Now you stated "Think about that for a minute and it makes absolutely no sense whatsoever" actually I know about this and thought about longer than you have. It makes complete sense to God and may never make complete sense to man but that does not affect truth in any shape. Truth is truth whether or not if it make sense to us finite humans.So, in summary, All of God's attributes are impossible for man to comprehend completely. Thanks you Mobile for your questions.
MrClownpirate 1 year ago
@MobileThinker, Oh and lastly, have a great Thanksgiving week and weekend.
MrClownpirate 1 year ago
In light of the "god healing" for other affictions why hasn't there been anyone claiming to have had a limb grow back ? ? (I am not saying "ever" but please present a documented case if you want to say that god DOES heal amputees like the cancer claims)
You say they have to wait until the resurection??
So again they are somehow LESS worthy than the person "cured" that had cancer???
UberLogic 2 years ago
I've never really liked the "10 questions". I think the arguments that they hint at could be stated in a much better way.
That said "why won't god heal amputees" is not a loaded question. He means amputees in general. We can't know if god has EVER healed an amputee, but i think we can all agree that god does not heal amputees as a general rule. And that's what the question's getting at.
Zoetherat 2 years ago 2
I made a response video, and decided that this one question shows that this man does not have any ability to make an argument without logical fallacy.
jkeaty2 2 years ago 5
I suspect that you were not an A-student in high school.
goddeloos 2 years ago 10
Actually I did reply to her. I thought that she PM me. So, I gave her a PM back. I am still new on Youtube.
MrClownpirate 2 years ago
No, I will not disable comments, unless there are curse words. If I see cussing, then I will disable comments.
MrClownpirate 2 years ago
I never disable comments, cussing or no. Everyone has the right to say whatever they want whenever they want, and express their opinion.
Please don't be like all the other Christians on YouTube (it seems) and disable the ratings and comments, no matter what.
AtheistBrit 2 years ago 7
I only remove comments that are an ad nauseum personal attack. but leave a couple up to show why, then block the idiot that left them.
jkeaty2 2 years ago
Oh I dont disable them, just remove the 12 blasts about how my rec room looks, but leave the 13th and 14th up to show why he is blocked. Everyone else can comment as they like.
jkeaty2 2 years ago
A loaded question?! God doesn't heal amputees, that's a fact! Even if you turn it around and say "why can't God heal amputees" or anything similar the observation still stands. God has never healed an amputee. Of course he doesn't have to have seen every amputee in all history to know this - ONE documented case of this happening would be a scientific field day not to mention a media frenzy, and yet this has never happened.
Logic fail. One star.
AtheistBrit 2 years ago 6
Well said AtheistBrit...
Katalyzt
Katalyzt 2 years ago
One star...there is no logic in theology.
Killer0fTheSun 2 years ago 4