Martina McBride- Independence Day CMA Music Festival 2006

[pmedic5133]

I have seen Carrie and her StarRise band I do not know how many times , Carrie deserves everything she has gotten . Fort Smith misses Carrie .Carrie why do you not load up and come do some shows here in Fort Smith or or at least Poteau!! Have you forgotten where you came from ??

[justanotherrater]

Stop comparing Martina and Carrie. They are both very talented and both do a great job on this song. Can we just leave it at that? Ofcoarse Martina is better, she has more experience. Carrie is a great singer though and I think Carrie sings this song beautifully too. I know I enjoyed listening to it.

[mewc402]

There is no comparing. Martina is an artist with a gift and has spent her entire life earning her success. Carrie is no more than an overated karoke singer that won a tv contest out to make the record company and simon cowell lots of money.

[CuteCookieL]

Martina is the best female singer I've ever heard of! I love love love Carrie but I have to admit.. Martina is better. :)

[chessse]

Dude, this is what is wrong with America. To compare Undercarriage with Martina is like trying to compare a 1987 Elcamino with a 2008 Ferrari. Carrie can born 100000 times and still won't be half as good as Martina. There, done!

[teeftaller7]

Carrie is awesome people need to stop compring carrie & kelly & martina carrie is her own artist.

[teeftaller7]

Carrie is awesome people need to stop compring carrie & kelly & martina carrie is her own artist.

[sheridawnhayden]

Martina has a warmth and depth to her voice that is very hard to achieve. She is one of the great vocalists of our time, and she didn't have to be on a TV show to attain it.

[macmartharm12]

Until Carrie wins the same amount of awards as Martina then I will be impressed... Martina has 7 female vocalist (CMA-4, ACM-3)of the year wins... Carrie wont ever match that b/c she is not Martina

[bajikjik]

well now carrie has a total of 9 female vocalist award..

3 CMA, 3 ACM, 3 Grammy best country vocal..

all of them are consecutive wins and you say carrie can't match that hahaha...

[mewc402]

The difference is martina can sing in tune unlike carrie. Every single live performance on youtube shows her struggling to sing, stay in tune and in pitch. Her fans always blame it on illness. I guess she sure must be sick a lot - like everytime she performs . . .

[bajikjik]

oh really?!!!

hahaha...

[logotgr]

@mewc402 wow someone's bitter. Carrie sounds amazing live and manages to hit all the notes even when she's sick; I actually can never even tell she's sick. Carrie's won 6 Top Female Vocalist awards to Martina's 7, and 2 Entertainer of the Year Awards to Martina's 0, all that in only 5 years compared to Martina's 18 years in the business. Talent is talent no matter where it comes from. You need to learn some class. I can like Carrie without dissing Martina, you stupid bliksem.

[logotgr]

@mewc402 If you have that to falsely say about Carrie, I wonder what you think about Taylor Swift; you probably think she's the best thing to come from America since sliced bread.

[macmartharm12]

No contest... no one can sing ID like Martina.. Carrie has a long way to even be Martina caliber-Carrie has a very pretty voice but nothing like Martinas.

[akusukamu]

o yeah carrie won female vocalist of the year

[Jmmet15]

I think she is better

[Jmmet15]

i think Carrie song it better and it wasn't even her song

[tak178]

Um...not quite. Carrie still hasn't developed her head voice to Martina's extent.

[icheer4les09]

NO ONE can sing a Martina song better than Martina!! That is a proven fact! DUH!

[xoxJanellexox]

Martina = breathtaking!! An amazing song sung by an amazing women!! Thanks for posting!!

[domodouls]

What the heck happened to the Pat Benatar/Martina version? It was taken down.

[nightripper2010]

It was taken down because it was copyright infringement, but as always on youtube, it was put back up by the copyright infringer under another name.

[greekamerican]

Now this is what I call a CAREER HIT!

[Wicked1972]

I was at this and Martina was AMAZING!! She always is, :) Thanks for posting! Great times, :) :)

[hobbiteen]

Her voice is so melodic:DI can't believe we had the pleasure to meet her!Anyways great video!Rated 5 of course!