My friend im realy sorry for your cat i hope he is good where ever he is.You seei had a dog i used to play when i was young.His name was Renos and it was the best dog i've ever had.His last yapp was in 11 May 2007 when a dog hit him.His murderer didnt stop to see what happened to the dog.THE ONE I WANT TO SAY IS THAT I I FIND THE BASTARD WHO KILLED MY DOG,ILL MAKE HIM PAY AND THAT WONT BER GOOD FOR HIM....................................
Thanks for this video.. it really helped. My cat just died yesturday while I was at school and I miss him very much. His pancreas was very bad and we think he developed diabetes and died from it. Charlie looked just as sweet as my poor kitty :"")
Im so sorry about your cat. my dog also died a few months ago an now my mom's cat passed yesterday, But im sure god is taking care of them now and they will never hurt or suffer under his watch. Great tribute video.
your cat was beautiful and reminded me of aan orange tom that used to live on our street at our old house. his name was tangerine. i hope you'll be okay without charlie-he'd be happy if you are happy.
our cat bootsie had to be put to sleep due to stomach cancer and lymphnodes, and i remember i said when we took her to the vet tht she was gonna come home alive. unfortunately she didnt-she couldnt. she was terribly thin, wasnt eating, and was having trouble breathing. she lived with us for a good 6 years-we never knew her age because she'd been a stray, but she wasnt very old. i miss her so so much and watching this made me think of her and cry for the first time in a little while.
I am sorry ive lost 3 cats and i still have 4. I got 2 more to replace their cats but my cat p.j. Is taking place of my cat rowan who died in front of a heater and onyx whos replacing midnight who always fell asleep on my mom and loved my mom very much but was very old and my first cat lucky who had seizures
im never getting another animal so long as i live, or am going to give one to my future children...its just to painful..there taken away from us too soon, i just asked myself..why the hell do parotts live for 40 years? and cats and dogs live 15-2o years?
I feel your pain more deeply than you can even imagine. I lost my friend of over two decades old, to old age. She was my first and favorite pet. I'm barley over half her age, so she was there my entire life. It's only been a few days, but she's all I think about. The heartless morons who trash videos like this have never felt pain.
I feel your pain more deeply than you can even imagine. I lost my friend of twenty-four years to old age. She was my first and favorite pet. I'm only fourteen, so she was there my entire life. It's only been a few days, but she's all I think about. The heartless morons who trash videos like this have never felt pain.
I feel your pain more deeply than you can even imagine. I lost my friend of 24 years to old age. She was my first and favorite pet. I'm only fourteen, so she was there my entire life. It's only been a few days, but she's all I think about. The heartless morons who trash videos like this have never felt pain.
I feel your pain more deeply than you can even imagine. I lost my friend of 24 years to old age. She was my first and favorite pet. I'm only fourteen, so she was there my entire life. It's only been a few days, but she's all I think about. The heartless morons who trash videos like this have never felt pain.
Omg I had a cat named Scruffy, and he seemed to be ill. So I placed him in the cage to go to the vet and, suddently, I heard him meuw very loudly. Then he spinned around in the cage and wham! He was just dead!
I got so shaken up that I didn't do anything for the rest of the day, and it was in the early morning. God bless you Scruffy and may you live forever......
maybe it's luck, but my cat charlie, he was just walking around when he saw ur cat and then, he jumped on my worktable every moment you'r cat was on the screen, he licked it, exactly on the place you'r cat was on it. he never does that.
6 Idiots dont know how it feels to lose the most wonderful pets. We had a cat called cheekie, she had lung disease and had to be put down. Me and my family love her still, wherever she is. We love her, and we know how you feel, but I cant stress how much I hate people who would dislike such a touching memorial.
I am so sorry for your loss and also sorry that some Young American's like myself were so idiotic to force you to change the song. I'm not sure what they did but please believe that not all of us are like that. Then again, I'm not the "typical" American. Haha. I'm gonna stop crying now and go hug my 3 kitties.
thank you for responding! sorry it was too late!god bless you! he was in your life for a reason.we will all be together someday! until then take care love! he is watching over you! trust me.
I had 6 cats now four one Kally she was just a runt that made it about half a month one of my cats Oliver loved her so much and after she died he didn't understand and thought she just went away for a little bit and for 6 months he went to the lake shore where they always were together when they were sad or just wanted peace and quiet and he stood in the water crying out fir her as if saying where have thy gone sweet love? Where have thy gone? He still visits her grave behind the barn where the
I am sooo sorry to hear that!! I really hope my cats don't die soon because I barely see them, my mom is allergic to them so they have to live with my dad. I love them unconditionally and I am going to cry for at least a year when theyre gone
My first cat i had since i was young she was 14 when she died she was a red tabby, she died from natural causes and old age mainly kidney failure was sad when she went i really loved her, since then i have had 3 other lovely healthy rescuse cats
Brought teats to my eyes. I lost my beautiful calico cat, Pixie, in 2004. I believe she went off to die somewhere on our property. It's horrible to never have closure when you lose a pet. I wonder every day about her. She was almost 14 years old. She will always be my best friend.
What a beautiful video of such a well-loved pet. Charlie certainly had a wonderful home and was deeply loved, as this video clearly shows. Thank you for sharing Charlie's tribute; it has helped with the pain I am trying to endure over losing my own beloved 16-year-old cat Fritz two days ago.
am sorry about your cat! my heart goes out to you!i lost my baby girl cat(nappa) i lost her on new years day,1-1-2011 i spent all night at the vet,the vet said i couldn't do anything for her,her little heart,grew out of her ribcage.i ran out of the vet crying,i could not control my self.it's hard breaking .i miss her so much.you will meet charlie again!,he's looking down on you!-take care.
@napastar100 Am very sorry for the loss of your baby girl cat(nappa).I also lost my beloved kitty friend-Tiggy on1-27-2011,so i know what you are going through! Yes i to believe with all my Heart that our God will reunite us with all of our loved ones,be they Animals or Human!
the pain is unbearable, but it does get better. Feeling your pain. Reminds me of my cat Khan who we had put to sleep a few days ago, he looks similar to Charlie x
I cried through the whole video. I lost my Angel from Feline Leukemia about 6 years ago, and I still cry for him. I also lost my Missiemo 3 years ago. I had her since she was 8 weeks old. She was 12 when she passed. I have one precious baby left. He is doing real well. He looks just like your baby. My heart felt condolences for your loss. Your precious baby is in the arms of the angels now. God bless your loving heart!!
Im really really sorry I had a cat about 4 weeks ago and it ran away it usually can back but it didn't I've cried since I hope every day I look out the window I will see him with his big blue eyes open his name was sox
I lost my Charlie Cat yesterday. He was diagnosed with end stage renal failure 15 days ago. My heart aches with an unbearable sadness. I know the pain that you feel for the loss of your friend. I can only hope that my Charlie's passing and the ease of his pain will one day put a sense of peace in my heart where the pain is now.
I thank you for your video-it made me smile for a while.
He looks just like my cat Hippy..this really made me cry, he was beautiful . I feel your pain in this video, I know you miss him so much. My Hippy is my best friend and I can't imagine my life without him...beautiful dedication to your cat, I'm moved. So sorry for your loss:(
I love cats, and this video made me cry. I'm so sorry you lost Charlie. I don't know what I will do when my cat passes on. I have had her since I was 8 years old. I am now 22 and she is still a wily cat. Thank you for making such a beautiful video.
I stumbled upon your video because my cat died this morning. It truly is painful. I feel sorry for those jerks who leave immature comments. Truly, the joy found in the companionship of a pet is a blessing not given to everyone. :(
im sorry for ur loss, but i too lost a cat, she was white as snow and we named her Tiffany, she had to be put down by a gun from one of our friends, i never got to say goodbye, she was dying from cancer, and she laid down for the blow
Charlie truly was a beautiful cat, so regal. All of us cat lovers/owners know what you went through in Charlies last months. So sorry that some misguided kids have not matured enough to understand love. My 3 seniors have the illnesses of their advanced age. I lost their sister last year to cancer. I am very sorry for your loss.
Awesome tribute to Charlie it's hard having to say goodbye to our animal freinds.
When i had to put my dog Tweed to sleep it was the worsed day of my life.
I rescued him at 4 weeks old and he lifed life to the fullest .
The last two weeks of his life was when he got sick with kidney failure just shy of 13 years old .
Before i took him to be put to sleep i took him to Mcdonalds and gave him all the cheese burger junk he wanted . He eat the lot wasn't going without his cheese burger :-)
My heart just broke while watching this video. I wanted to offer condolences on the loss of Charlie who looked like a very sweet boy. I know it has been a few years since you posted this but we lost our Calvin back in 2004 but my heart still hurts whenever I think about him. Regarding the jerks that troll You Tube, just ignore, delete and block them. They want the attention.
i feel lucky seeing all these parents losing their babies because mine are 11 and healthy and i really hope that dosent change i cant remember when i didnt have the seeing as im now only 14 and got them when i was three there are 2 of them they were rescue kittens out of a trash can and the had so many worms and fleas and sicknesses that we didnt get to take them home till they were 6 months old but they are the best cats that an owner could ask for. my respects for charlie but im glad he had u
We have two female cats that we love very much. When I watch these video's on cats that were loved and died, it make me appreciate the time we have left with them and never take them for granite. Its to bad that cats don't live as long as humans so that they wouldn't die before us.
We have two cats that we love and when I watch these video's on cats that have been loved and die, it make me fully appreciate the time we have left with them and never take them for granite. Its to bad that pets can't live as many years as humans so that they don't die before us.
Penolva: years ago I posted to you that I loved your video (and Charlie too), and you told me to take care and join my cat while she lives. I think three, maybe four years ago.
Now, my cat is dying because of a tumor, and the vet says "it's time to take decisions". We both know what he means. I'd really appreciate some words from you. I can't believe my baby is dying. I can't believe the pain that surrounds me.
@Bondcrow I am so sorry. She must not suffer but if she is comfortable and without pain then she can stay with you a little longer. She will tell you when the time comes. I was told this but I didn't believe it, but Charlie did come to me and look into my eyes and let me know I had to let him go. I did the best for him but the worst for me, you will be strong for her and she will remain in your heart forever. I will think of you both. Pen
penolva im sorrry for your loss i miss my cats too they were killed bye 3 dogs but it will get better if you just keep their thing away from you it wont be as depressing if i evedr get a cat im naming it charlie so i will always think of you when i see him
aww how sad D': I've had a-lot of my cats die before so I know excactly how it feels to lose something thats really important to ya :'( :'( well at least now they're all in a better place
we are just about to lose our beloved persian cat (rhapsody) its his fourteenth birthday today. his liver is failing,he has a heart condition and has gone completly blind so we are sending him to god tomorow even if it breaks our hearts. he will always be remembered he was such a lovely pet
@penolva .i want to write you a e mail.i we had same race white european male cat
he picked us.he had kidney cancer.the second vet put him to sleep.was 1982 1983
i know evry one has a huge pain might take long time.
let me body was disbaled body did t work but soul is stil a life.when i go to bed i feel a warm body on mi head sit here i feel his presents.just a dead body
my cat almost died of poisoning. he was gone for 3 days which scared me enough but it was worse when we found him half dead. he was so close to dieing i cryed with even the slightest tought of him passing. but he pulled through and now i drown him in love, every day, all the time. cats are such presious things. things to love every chance we get.
@sarahhauffen The song was 'Over the Rainbow' by Eva Cassidy and you could also hear Charlie 'talking' to me, He used to miaow 'Hello'. Yes a girl can be called Charlie so that would be very nice. Cute kittens!
charlie was a great friend for u penolva charlie shall rest in peace forever in your heart everytime watching this makes me want to be by your side so much with charlie RIP beautiful charlie :]
this is so sad i loved my cat and im thinking about him right now but charlie and my cat karly they will be there together so bless them with love and they will look down at us and hope we r doing good our selfs and they will always be with us in out hearts
I am also in grief today, I just returned home with my Ying-Yang, she was with me for 16 years, she became paralized in her hind legs and could not stand. She will be burried, as all of my animal friends are, in my garden, she was a good girl, and my heart is breaking. I am so sorry for your loss, it is my hope that they will never actually leave us, their spirit will always be with us.
@TOMAN4EVER 'she was a good girl', this brought the tears back after all this time, I always said to Charlie 'you are such a good boy'. I am so sorry you have lost Ying-Yang, she is still walking beside you. take care Pen.
@penolva ...thank you for the heart felt response, we burried Ying-Yang, this evening, it was raining here in Va., but, I carried her to the place where she knew, my garden, how many little birds she stalked there! My husband has MS, so it was hard for him to dig her grave, but we managed. She will forever be with me in her little spirit. Peace, light and love!
@TOMAN4EVER My niece has MS so I know that it was an act of love for your husband to dig her grave. You can rest assured she is near you and you will see her again one day. Love never dies. Pen x
@TOMAN4EVER it was an act of love for your husband to dig her grave. You can rest assured she is near you and you will see her again one day. Love never dies. Pen x
@TOMAN4EVER My niece has MS so I know that it was an act of love for your husband to dig her grave. Never forget because the love never dies and we will see them again one day. Peace, light and love to you. Pen
@TOMAN4EVER My niece has MS so I know that it was an act of love for your husband to dig her grave. Never forget because the love never dies and we will see them again one day. Peace, light and love to you. Pen
While watching the video (and emptying the buckets of tears), I heard my cat, who is also an orange tabby, jump on our piano & hit the same note that was being played in the song.
Wonderful tribute & it looked like Charlie live an amazing life. I must go hug my cat now. I'm very sorry about your loss even though this video is 3 years old. :(
@webdesignhints Thanks so much for the message, your orange tabby must be very musical! Three years and I still think of him every day but Jennie has brought such fun and laughter into our lives. Pen
a very sad moving video it seems charlie was a very quiet dignified old cat .u can tell he's sad and in pain. Very sad video. U just feel like cuddling him when u see his sad face. God bless him.
i know how you must feel i lost one of my cats named cody he had bone cancer and he always bit me when i tried to pet him but we all forgive him my grandma took him somewhere i asked her where she said its a secret then she took him home still warm lay him on the floor i wrapped my arms around him all night and cried i screamed a i trembled i pet him i put my face in his warn fur and he soaked in my tears the next day we creamated him this took me alot of tears to write
My daughter & I are so touched by your video & song. We have a cat of our own & have a hard time when we have to go places without her. We pray your life has found another cat to fill your life with unconditional love & happiness. We are very sorry for your loss. In Christ, Paula & Hope
@Hisshep1 I did get another cat 2 years to the day after Charlie died. She is called Jennie and I made a small video of her, you can see it if you like on my channel. she doesn't replace him but is her own little bit of sunshine in our lives. Pen
Good bye Charlie...you have been loved. The sight of him standing alone under the tree by the corner is heart wrenching yet it he seemed to be in peace.
Your video is very sweet, beautiful, and touching. The song is perfect, and Charlie was sweet and beautiful. I've just lost my kitty 3 months ago and just started to upload videos in tributes to her when I came across yours. I can't help crying and can relate to your pain and sadness because I'm still in pain. Our pet will always be in our heart, and our love for them will last forever.
Your video is very sweet, beautiful, and touching. The song is perfect, and Charlie was sweet and beautiful. I've just lost my kitty 3 months ago and just started to upload videos in tributes to her when I came across yours. I can't help crying and can relate to your pain and sadness because I'm still in pain. Our pet will always be in our heart, and our love for them will last forever.
Your love for Charlie and his for you flows through this video. Watching your memorial is heart wrenching, beautiful, and something that can touch everyone who has ever lost a beloved cat. Thank you so much for creating and sharing this.
this made me cry so much!!! Remember that you will see him again. He must have been a really nice cat. I had to put down my cat a couple years ago and i miss him soooo much. Rest In Peace Charlie!!!
I just finished uploading my memorial and came across yours. Such a beautiful tribute to a cat that was obviously loved! I have a softspot in my heart for orange kitties! Note to self: TAKE MORE VIDEO! I, sadly, barely took any video of Whisky. That won't happen again.
I miss my Sherman. I always will. Thank you so very much for posting this video. It gvies me closer. Sherman Look 6/23/06. My baby. RIP I miss you so much,
thank you for sharing this video with us. i understand your heartache. my beautiful kitty, Mittens had to be put to sleep last year before christmas which was heartwrenching. she died of Pyometra. She was 13 years old, just 3 months shy of her 14th birthday. I had her since I was 5 years old. We'll be reunited with our loving pets someday, Charlie loves you and he's waiting for you, his mommy, to see him in heaven one day.
my cat just died today, i know how you feel, i just came home and my dad told me the bad news, had the cat for 5 yrs, dont even know the cause of death
Charlie is a beautiful cat. I promise that one day you will see him again. Just remember that God is taking care and loving him. He is your Guardian Angel. I Just got cats, and seeing this video made me cry, and think of what life would be like without Twilight and Micki. Have a great life, and treasure every moment, just like you did with Charlie. =]
We recently just lost our cat Tigger who was 14 to blood cancer, he look a lot like Charlie. He was our little trouble maker, but showed love to our whole family. Charlie, just like Tigger was not just your cat, he was part of your family, your friend. This a very nice tribute, glad I found it.
Thanks for sharing this beautiful tribute. Charlie was a beautiful cat. I can tell you were very close to him. I just lost my cat today :( His name was O'Malley. We had to get him put down because they found out he had cancer. This is going to be very hard for Im so used to him being with me all the time. He even slept with me every night. Sometimes he slept right on me. Im gonna miss him alot :(
And i lost my cat ,when her vet said she die ,i still can't be happy ,wat i do it's only sitting alone and try to forget about her ,but i can't ...T^T
my "son" died last night. Hit and Run.He came to us as a kitten 5 years ago. He knocked on our door and made it known that he was here to stay. I can't take it. He meant the WHOLE WORLD to me and my husband. He was our child. I could never go to bed without him snuggling in between us. I don't know how to cope. How do you cope with the loss of a "child"?
my cat looked just like that and died because another cat bit him..."sniffles" he was thirteen yrs old.R.I.P Jack.i feel the same way about your cat..i hate the cat who killed jack!
Im so sorry bout Charlie
Jessiegirl2945 3 days ago
My friend im realy sorry for your cat i hope he is good where ever he is.You seei had a dog i used to play when i was young.His name was Renos and it was the best dog i've ever had.His last yapp was in 11 May 2007 when a dog hit him.His murderer didnt stop to see what happened to the dog.THE ONE I WANT TO SAY IS THAT I I FIND THE BASTARD WHO KILLED MY DOG,ILL MAKE HIM PAY AND THAT WONT BER GOOD FOR HIM....................................
GerakarisSteve 3 days ago
@GerakarisSteve i made a mistake sorry my dog was hit by a car not by a dog xDDDDDD
GerakarisSteve 3 days ago
Comment removed
GerakarisSteve 3 days ago
Thanks for this video.. it really helped. My cat just died yesturday while I was at school and I miss him very much. His pancreas was very bad and we think he developed diabetes and died from it. Charlie looked just as sweet as my poor kitty :"")
PinkstripedZebras 1 week ago
Im so sorry about your cat. my dog also died a few months ago an now my mom's cat passed yesterday, But im sure god is taking care of them now and they will never hurt or suffer under his watch. Great tribute video.
5drell 2 weeks ago 6
your cat was beautiful and reminded me of aan orange tom that used to live on our street at our old house. his name was tangerine. i hope you'll be okay without charlie-he'd be happy if you are happy.
lexxyhunt 3 weeks ago
our cat bootsie had to be put to sleep due to stomach cancer and lymphnodes, and i remember i said when we took her to the vet tht she was gonna come home alive. unfortunately she didnt-she couldnt. she was terribly thin, wasnt eating, and was having trouble breathing. she lived with us for a good 6 years-we never knew her age because she'd been a stray, but she wasnt very old. i miss her so so much and watching this made me think of her and cry for the first time in a little while.
lexxyhunt 3 weeks ago
I am sorry ive lost 3 cats and i still have 4. I got 2 more to replace their cats but my cat p.j. Is taking place of my cat rowan who died in front of a heater and onyx whos replacing midnight who always fell asleep on my mom and loved my mom very much but was very old and my first cat lucky who had seizures
ndog102396 1 month ago
Very emotional movie.....
thiletut 1 month ago
My cat died awhile ago. I miss him much. He always knew when I wasn't feeling well....... He was 18 human years old.
Hermione101400 1 month ago
btw: ur cat is beatiful and def did not look like he was ill! it looks as tho u did a good job in caring for ur cat, and im sorry for ur loss
tupac4life1989 2 months ago
im never getting another animal so long as i live, or am going to give one to my future children...its just to painful..there taken away from us too soon, i just asked myself..why the hell do parotts live for 40 years? and cats and dogs live 15-2o years?
tupac4life1989 2 months ago
I feel your pain more deeply than you can even imagine. I lost my friend of over two decades old, to old age. She was my first and favorite pet. I'm barley over half her age, so she was there my entire life. It's only been a few days, but she's all I think about. The heartless morons who trash videos like this have never felt pain.
BioofaPissedOffNerd 4 months ago
I feel your pain more deeply than you can even imagine. I lost my friend of twenty-four years to old age. She was my first and favorite pet. I'm only fourteen, so she was there my entire life. It's only been a few days, but she's all I think about. The heartless morons who trash videos like this have never felt pain.
BioofaPissedOffNerd 4 months ago
I feel your pain more deeply than you can even imagine. I lost my friend of 24 years to old age. She was my first and favorite pet. I'm only fourteen, so she was there my entire life. It's only been a few days, but she's all I think about. The heartless morons who trash videos like this have never felt pain.
BioofaPissedOffNerd 4 months ago
I feel your pain more deeply than you can even imagine. I lost my friend of 24 years to old age. She was my first and favorite pet. I'm only fourteen, so she was there my entire life. It's only been a few days, but she's all I think about. The heartless morons who trash videos like this have never felt pain.
BioofaPissedOffNerd 4 months ago
This is so sad I started 2 cry chz I miss my lil lexe she was a part of me till she ran away o lexe o how I miss u waaaaaaaaaaaas waaaaaaaaaaaa
painfulpokemon 4 months ago
Believe me, I know how it feels. My sympathies.
mfreeman313 4 months ago
Its always hard to lose a pet :(
Losersarelovely 5 months ago
I'm very sorry for your loss.
Losersarelovely 5 months ago
where can i find this song?
ImSureYouWillForget 5 months ago in playlist Blah :D
@ImSureYouWillForget it seems that you cant find this song anywhere
but if you want I can PM you the lyrics
TheMysteriouswatcher 4 months ago
Don't worry Penolva I managed to write lyrics down as I listened to the song
Ps. God bless your cat Charlie, and may he live forever
TheMysteriouswatcher 5 months ago
Hi I don't know them either as it was a song from YouTube free music library when I had to change from Over the Rainbow. Sorry
penolva 5 months ago
Hi, Penolva.
Could you give the lyrics to this song?
I can't find this song anywere
TheMysteriouswatcher 5 months ago
This is the saddest cat video ive ever seen in my life. Im so sorry about your loss. This makes me cry, everytime. :(
ImSureYouWillForget 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
What a beautiful video you made for Charlie. It made me cry alot. He was such a sweetheart bless his soul. :'-)
EftahYaSemsem1991 6 months ago
iam sorry for your loss your cat was wery beutifull be strong charlie your best freinds is gonna come
emilmilan100 6 months ago
Omg I had a cat named Scruffy, and he seemed to be ill. So I placed him in the cage to go to the vet and, suddently, I heard him meuw very loudly. Then he spinned around in the cage and wham! He was just dead!
I got so shaken up that I didn't do anything for the rest of the day, and it was in the early morning. God bless you Scruffy and may you live forever......
TheMysteriouswatcher 6 months ago
I am crying right now. This video has touched my heart. I am sorry for your loss.
peachygirl510 6 months ago
am sorry for your lost i lost my cat tom cat his name :(
kaylacook1234 7 months ago
maybe it's luck, but my cat charlie, he was just walking around when he saw ur cat and then, he jumped on my worktable every moment you'r cat was on the screen, he licked it, exactly on the place you'r cat was on it. he never does that.
i hope you'r cat has a great life up there.
INippleTwistYou 7 months ago
Sorry for your loss, what a beautiful Cat, this is a very moving tribute, I have tears rollin down my cheeks. R.I.P Charlie. xxxxxxxxx
MultiKez2010 7 months ago
Wow, Why? Why? Your Video Just Made Me Cry :3
KyleIsHappeh 7 months ago
I'm crying 4 u right now,I love cats n have 3!I'm so sorry 4 ur loss nothing every takes away the pain it's like losing a relative RIP Charlie x
JDcakes1 7 months ago
Its OK those people don't even deserve a mention here. I am glad you liked watching Charlie. Pen
penolva 7 months ago
6 Idiots dont know how it feels to lose the most wonderful pets. We had a cat called cheekie, she had lung disease and had to be put down. Me and my family love her still, wherever she is. We love her, and we know how you feel, but I cant stress how much I hate people who would dislike such a touching memorial.
AchievementPwners 7 months ago
farewell Charlie...
arroyo3rd 8 months ago
im crying right now because i have a cat and i do not want anything to happen to him
Maxusmaximus 8 months ago
I am so sorry for your loss and also sorry that some Young American's like myself were so idiotic to force you to change the song. I'm not sure what they did but please believe that not all of us are like that. Then again, I'm not the "typical" American. Haha. I'm gonna stop crying now and go hug my 3 kitties.
ajSo0o0fly 9 months ago
I lost my Siamese TJ last year, he was the best I MISS YOU TJ AND I LOVED YOU SO MUCH!
holmeed 9 months ago
He looked a bit like my Tiger. So sorry for your loss. R.I.P. Charlie.='( I will now go hug my Tiger.
ylvira 9 months ago
AND IT WAS THE LAST CAT TIL NEXT WEEK >:(
Legometallica09 9 months ago
>:( I was so close to getting a cat but some jurk pushes me out of the way and asks to have the cat >:O
Legometallica09 9 months ago
thank you for responding! sorry it was too late!god bless you! he was in your life for a reason.we will all be together someday! until then take care love! he is watching over you! trust me.
napastar100 10 months ago
I had 6 cats now four one Kally she was just a runt that made it about half a month one of my cats Oliver loved her so much and after she died he didn't understand and thought she just went away for a little bit and for 6 months he went to the lake shore where they always were together when they were sad or just wanted peace and quiet and he stood in the water crying out fir her as if saying where have thy gone sweet love? Where have thy gone? He still visits her grave behind the barn where the
littlefluffeetalks 10 months ago
I am sooo sorry to hear that!! I really hope my cats don't die soon because I barely see them, my mom is allergic to them so they have to live with my dad. I love them unconditionally and I am going to cry for at least a year when theyre gone
girlshow101 10 months ago
My first cat i had since i was young she was 14 when she died she was a red tabby, she died from natural causes and old age mainly kidney failure was sad when she went i really loved her, since then i have had 3 other lovely healthy rescuse cats
fadwa1979 11 months ago
I'm so sorry for your loss. I love animals !
HDOnlive 11 months ago
If only all animals were appreciated so much :-)
andwilmor 11 months ago
Brought teats to my eyes. I lost my beautiful calico cat, Pixie, in 2004. I believe she went off to die somewhere on our property. It's horrible to never have closure when you lose a pet. I wonder every day about her. She was almost 14 years old. She will always be my best friend.
anic18 1 year ago
What a beautiful video of such a well-loved pet. Charlie certainly had a wonderful home and was deeply loved, as this video clearly shows. Thank you for sharing Charlie's tribute; it has helped with the pain I am trying to endure over losing my own beloved 16-year-old cat Fritz two days ago.
12XOR34 1 year ago
Comment removed
12XOR34 1 year ago
So sorry, what a terrible start to the New Year for you. Pen
penolva 1 year ago
am sorry about your cat! my heart goes out to you!i lost my baby girl cat(nappa) i lost her on new years day,1-1-2011 i spent all night at the vet,the vet said i couldn't do anything for her,her little heart,grew out of her ribcage.i ran out of the vet crying,i could not control my self.it's hard breaking .i miss her so much.you will meet charlie again!,he's looking down on you!-take care.
napastar100 1 year ago
@napastar100 Am very sorry for the loss of your baby girl cat(nappa).I also lost my beloved kitty friend-Tiggy on1-27-2011,so i know what you are going through! Yes i to believe with all my Heart that our God will reunite us with all of our loved ones,be they Animals or Human!
UrsusSpartacusIII 10 months ago
Made me cry I have my cat she is 7 and she is deaperst :(
emilymycat77 1 year ago
made me cry .. i have 4 cats love them all x
weepixie1 1 year ago
the pain is unbearable, but it does get better. Feeling your pain. Reminds me of my cat Khan who we had put to sleep a few days ago, he looks similar to Charlie x
Emerlad75 1 year ago
@Emerlad75 I am so sorry to hear about Khan, great name! Ginger cats are so special. x
penolva 1 year ago
the pain is unbearable, but it does get better. Feeling your pain x
Emerlad75 1 year ago
im very sorry im making a video of my cat when she dies shes ok right now
bmxer237 1 year ago
my cat died yesterday im very sad
re49991 1 year ago
I cried through the whole video. I lost my Angel from Feline Leukemia about 6 years ago, and I still cry for him. I also lost my Missiemo 3 years ago. I had her since she was 8 weeks old. She was 12 when she passed. I have one precious baby left. He is doing real well. He looks just like your baby. My heart felt condolences for your loss. Your precious baby is in the arms of the angels now. God bless your loving heart!!
TheAnn1948 1 year ago
Im really really sorry I had a cat about 4 weeks ago and it ran away it usually can back but it didn't I've cried since I hope every day I look out the window I will see him with his big blue eyes open his name was sox
jmanvideos1 1 year ago
I lost my Charlie Cat yesterday. He was diagnosed with end stage renal failure 15 days ago. My heart aches with an unbearable sadness. I know the pain that you feel for the loss of your friend. I can only hope that my Charlie's passing and the ease of his pain will one day put a sense of peace in my heart where the pain is now.
I thank you for your video-it made me smile for a while.
reilly810 1 year ago
@reilly810 I am glad we helped, even if it was in a small way. Pen
penolva 1 year ago
@reilly810 i lost 2cats and 2 dogs when i was a kid but they are in heaven sooo they are happy but not as happy as with their owner ;(
ashbuggy1234 1 week ago
Este mês meu gato faz 11 anos.
Não esta mais com toda saúde.
Cuidarei dele tds os dias.
Pois eu o amo.
Parabéns por tanto cuidado com seu filhinho de pelo.
InesAbritta 1 year ago
what is the name of the song thats on here now?..i cnt find it anywhere..
timesmyenemy 1 year ago
@timesmyenemy Its called 'Tears are falling' by Rozalind Macphail.
penolva 1 year ago
He looks just like my cat Hippy..this really made me cry, he was beautiful . I feel your pain in this video, I know you miss him so much. My Hippy is my best friend and I can't imagine my life without him...beautiful dedication to your cat, I'm moved. So sorry for your loss:(
martitalovesmj 1 year ago
Your video was recommended to my by the YouTube system - because I watched Charlie Says I don't like bubblesin my bath.
I am sorry for you loss - we had a ginger cat who looked just like Charlie.
I am sure Charlie was a very happy cat and one who was loved.
Malcos68 1 year ago
I love cats, and this video made me cry. I'm so sorry you lost Charlie. I don't know what I will do when my cat passes on. I have had her since I was 8 years old. I am now 22 and she is still a wily cat. Thank you for making such a beautiful video.
WarpedMindedYaoi 1 year ago
whats the name of the songs plz and i feel for you so bad!!
Geo7814 1 year ago
Thank you, Penolva, for sharing this special tribute <3
RafaelApollo 1 year ago
I stumbled upon your video because my cat died this morning. It truly is painful. I feel sorry for those jerks who leave immature comments. Truly, the joy found in the companionship of a pet is a blessing not given to everyone. :(
Larynxyn 1 year ago
@Larynxyn I am sorry your cat died. You must still be feeling very sad.
penolva 1 year ago
I had a cat that looked just like yours. Big orange thing. I'm sorry for your loss, your cat is in kitty heaven.
timeintopixels 1 year ago
im sorry for ur loss, but i too lost a cat, she was white as snow and we named her Tiffany, she had to be put down by a gun from one of our friends, i never got to say goodbye, she was dying from cancer, and she laid down for the blow
Bullet2Bit 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
): im sorry i had a cat that looked exatly like this his nme was butterscotch he got eaten by a cayote and i miss him dearly
butterscotch545 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
): im sorry i had a cat that looked exatly like this his nme was butterscotch he got eaten by a cayote and i miss him dearly
butterscotch545 1 year ago
): im sorry i had a cat that looked exatly like this his nme was butterscotch he got eaten by a cayote and i miss him dearly
butterscotch545 1 year ago
): im sorry i had a cat that looked exatly like this his nme was butterscotch he got eaten by a cayote
butterscotch545 1 year ago
I just finished this video,and i'm crying.he's beautiful.very sorry for your loss.let charlie rest in peace.
kittyyourock 1 year ago
got tears into my eyes...the look in his eyes...i think at 5.40..the end of the video...so touching
sujamohan6 1 year ago
got tears into my eyes...the look in his eyes...i think at 5.40..the end of the video...so touching
sujamohan6 1 year ago
Parece a minha Chuiquita....
zitalinha 1 year ago
Charlie truly was a beautiful cat, so regal. All of us cat lovers/owners know what you went through in Charlies last months. So sorry that some misguided kids have not matured enough to understand love. My 3 seniors have the illnesses of their advanced age. I lost their sister last year to cancer. I am very sorry for your loss.
frodo08830 1 year ago
Awesome tribute to Charlie it's hard having to say goodbye to our animal freinds.
When i had to put my dog Tweed to sleep it was the worsed day of my life.
I rescued him at 4 weeks old and he lifed life to the fullest .
The last two weeks of his life was when he got sick with kidney failure just shy of 13 years old .
Before i took him to be put to sleep i took him to Mcdonalds and gave him all the cheese burger junk he wanted . He eat the lot wasn't going without his cheese burger :-)
kellascat1 1 year ago
My heart just broke while watching this video. I wanted to offer condolences on the loss of Charlie who looked like a very sweet boy. I know it has been a few years since you posted this but we lost our Calvin back in 2004 but my heart still hurts whenever I think about him. Regarding the jerks that troll You Tube, just ignore, delete and block them. They want the attention.
PeteRFNY 1 year ago
i feel lucky seeing all these parents losing their babies because mine are 11 and healthy and i really hope that dosent change i cant remember when i didnt have the seeing as im now only 14 and got them when i was three there are 2 of them they were rescue kittens out of a trash can and the had so many worms and fleas and sicknesses that we didnt get to take them home till they were 6 months old but they are the best cats that an owner could ask for. my respects for charlie but im glad he had u
7pinkdanigirl7 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
We have two female cats that we love very much. When I watch these video's on cats that were loved and died, it make me appreciate the time we have left with them and never take them for granite. Its to bad that cats don't live as long as humans so that they wouldn't die before us.
appollo300 1 year ago
We have two cats that we love and when I watch these video's on cats that have been loved and die, it make me fully appreciate the time we have left with them and never take them for granite. Its to bad that pets can't live as many years as humans so that they don't die before us.
appollo300 1 year ago
I'm sorry about the jerks from the states too.
iowanative 1 year ago
sorry :(
NotTooObvious 1 year ago
I'm sorry for the jerks from the states being like that. I'm from the US and don't represent the negative comments that you are getting.
7redsox46 1 year ago 2
@7redsox46 I understand, its just a minority and they post those comments for fun I suppose. I had another just the other day, sad really.
penolva 1 year ago
@penolva my cat lived for 19 yrs... he died march 1st 2009 he died in my arms i watched him in shock crying
cincameron 1 year ago
I miss my sherman.
7redsox46 1 year ago
Penolva: years ago I posted to you that I loved your video (and Charlie too), and you told me to take care and join my cat while she lives. I think three, maybe four years ago.
Now, my cat is dying because of a tumor, and the vet says "it's time to take decisions". We both know what he means. I'd really appreciate some words from you. I can't believe my baby is dying. I can't believe the pain that surrounds me.
Bondcrow 1 year ago
@Bondcrow I am so sorry. She must not suffer but if she is comfortable and without pain then she can stay with you a little longer. She will tell you when the time comes. I was told this but I didn't believe it, but Charlie did come to me and look into my eyes and let me know I had to let him go. I did the best for him but the worst for me, you will be strong for her and she will remain in your heart forever. I will think of you both. Pen
penolva 1 year ago
RIP Charlie....I can't believe I'm crying over a video.
rvpKellz 1 year ago
I"m sorry for your lost but he is in a better place.......It just made so sad i cant stop cying my heart hurts....RIP Charlie
Geo7814 1 year ago
penolva im sorrry for your loss i miss my cats too they were killed bye 3 dogs but it will get better if you just keep their thing away from you it wont be as depressing if i evedr get a cat im naming it charlie so i will always think of you when i see him
pangi20 1 year ago
aww how sad D': I've had a-lot of my cats die before so I know excactly how it feels to lose something thats really important to ya :'( :'( well at least now they're all in a better place
lilprincessemily8 1 year ago
we are just about to lose our beloved persian cat (rhapsody) its his fourteenth birthday today. his liver is failing,he has a heart condition and has gone completly blind so we are sending him to god tomorow even if it breaks our hearts. he will always be remembered he was such a lovely pet
379woody 1 year ago
@379woody I am so sorry to hear such sad news. I hope rhapsody's suffering is over and he is waiting for you over the rainbow.
penolva 1 year ago
@penolva .i want to write you a e mail.i we had same race white european male cat
he picked us.he had kidney cancer.the second vet put him to sleep.was 1982 1983
i know evry one has a huge pain might take long time.
let me body was disbaled body did t work but soul is stil a life.when i go to bed i feel a warm body on mi head sit here i feel his presents.just a dead body
koioo2 1 year ago
Ive shot a lot of cats in my day, just sayin
SaigaPhoenix308 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
What an affectionate, handsome boy! It's easy to see why you loved him so much.
scottithan 1 year ago
sad im soooooo sorry
ShawntelSuper 1 year ago
my cat almost died of poisoning. he was gone for 3 days which scared me enough but it was worse when we found him half dead. he was so close to dieing i cryed with even the slightest tought of him passing. but he pulled through and now i drown him in love, every day, all the time. cats are such presious things. things to love every chance we get.
FlammingPuddles 1 year ago
@sarahhauffen The song was 'Over the Rainbow' by Eva Cassidy and you could also hear Charlie 'talking' to me, He used to miaow 'Hello'. Yes a girl can be called Charlie so that would be very nice. Cute kittens!
penolva 1 year ago
charlie was a great friend for u penolva charlie shall rest in peace forever in your heart everytime watching this makes me want to be by your side so much with charlie RIP beautiful charlie :]
Hacker2424 1 year ago
this is so sad i loved my cat and im thinking about him right now but charlie and my cat karly they will be there together so bless them with love and they will look down at us and hope we r doing good our selfs and they will always be with us in out hearts
ShawntelSuper 1 year ago
thats so sad and i just lost a cat thats y i look this up im also crying right now
ShawntelSuper 1 year ago
I am also in grief today, I just returned home with my Ying-Yang, she was with me for 16 years, she became paralized in her hind legs and could not stand. She will be burried, as all of my animal friends are, in my garden, she was a good girl, and my heart is breaking. I am so sorry for your loss, it is my hope that they will never actually leave us, their spirit will always be with us.
TOMAN4EVER 1 year ago
@TOMAN4EVER 'she was a good girl', this brought the tears back after all this time, I always said to Charlie 'you are such a good boy'. I am so sorry you have lost Ying-Yang, she is still walking beside you. take care Pen.
penolva 1 year ago
@penolva ...thank you for the heart felt response, we burried Ying-Yang, this evening, it was raining here in Va., but, I carried her to the place where she knew, my garden, how many little birds she stalked there! My husband has MS, so it was hard for him to dig her grave, but we managed. She will forever be with me in her little spirit. Peace, light and love!
TOMAN4EVER 1 year ago
@TOMAN4EVER My niece has MS so I know that it was an act of love for your husband to dig her grave. You can rest assured she is near you and you will see her again one day. Love never dies. Pen x
penolva 1 year ago
@TOMAN4EVER it was an act of love for your husband to dig her grave. You can rest assured she is near you and you will see her again one day. Love never dies. Pen x
penolva 1 year ago
@penolva thank you for the encouragement, last night was the first night I have had without her, but I know that she is not far away.
TOMAN4EVER 1 year ago
@TOMAN4EVER My niece has MS so I know that it was an act of love for your husband to dig her grave. Never forget because the love never dies and we will see them again one day. Peace, light and love to you. Pen
penolva 1 year ago
@TOMAN4EVER My niece has MS so I know that it was an act of love for your husband to dig her grave. Never forget because the love never dies and we will see them again one day. Peace, light and love to you. Pen
penolva 1 year ago
Awwe!<|3Dhiss Made Me Cry:[
l0v3girl123 1 year ago
While watching the video (and emptying the buckets of tears), I heard my cat, who is also an orange tabby, jump on our piano & hit the same note that was being played in the song.
Wonderful tribute & it looked like Charlie live an amazing life. I must go hug my cat now. I'm very sorry about your loss even though this video is 3 years old. :(
webdesignhints 1 year ago
@webdesignhints Thanks so much for the message, your orange tabby must be very musical! Three years and I still think of him every day but Jennie has brought such fun and laughter into our lives. Pen
penolva 1 year ago
Man... :,( Cried sooo much
I have cats, I know the pain...They're just like family members ´`
So sad
But he's feeling much better now and he will wait for the day you will reunite, you will see him again and then you'll have an eternity to play ^^
That's what I think whenever I think of some of my cats who are no longer here with me, we'll meet up again :)
SolidMike84 1 year ago
a very sad moving video it seems charlie was a very quiet dignified old cat .u can tell he's sad and in pain. Very sad video. U just feel like cuddling him when u see his sad face. God bless him.
boswellperkins 1 year ago
i know how you must feel i lost one of my cats named cody he had bone cancer and he always bit me when i tried to pet him but we all forgive him my grandma took him somewhere i asked her where she said its a secret then she took him home still warm lay him on the floor i wrapped my arms around him all night and cried i screamed a i trembled i pet him i put my face in his warn fur and he soaked in my tears the next day we creamated him this took me alot of tears to write
Rockhoppr454 1 year ago
@Rockhoppr454 I am very sorry your cody died. You must have loved him very much.
penolva 1 year ago
Awesome was cat, I'm so sorry for your lost...
MaxRideWizardLord 1 year ago
Awh im verry sorry for you,
ArielAshely 1 year ago
my cat died lately,im so sad,so when i watch this video i really reallyfeel sad
yuihoriemsh 1 year ago
My daughter & I are so touched by your video & song. We have a cat of our own & have a hard time when we have to go places without her. We pray your life has found another cat to fill your life with unconditional love & happiness. We are very sorry for your loss. In Christ, Paula & Hope
Hisshep1 1 year ago
@Hisshep1 I did get another cat 2 years to the day after Charlie died. She is called Jennie and I made a small video of her, you can see it if you like on my channel. she doesn't replace him but is her own little bit of sunshine in our lives. Pen
penolva 1 year ago
poor fella............
excelerater 1 year ago
Good bye Charlie...you have been loved. The sight of him standing alone under the tree by the corner is heart wrenching yet it he seemed to be in peace.
whygothic 1 year ago
im sry for you
my cat just looked like Charlie
it go roadkilled right in front of my house
i hope they are now on a bether place
rip
123456789Anarchy 1 year ago
your video made my cry a little. My cat is 10 and I don't want to think at my life without him... I really love him a lot. :(
georgiana2282 1 year ago
rip
GummiGym 1 year ago
this vid was so moving i am so sorry for your loss charlie was a beaufiul cat anmd my own cat is my best pal he is a black tom cat and old
rob39uk 1 year ago
Your video is very sweet, beautiful, and touching. The song is perfect, and Charlie was sweet and beautiful. I've just lost my kitty 3 months ago and just started to upload videos in tributes to her when I came across yours. I can't help crying and can relate to your pain and sadness because I'm still in pain. Our pet will always be in our heart, and our love for them will last forever.
MissDCKitty 1 year ago
Your video is very sweet, beautiful, and touching. The song is perfect, and Charlie was sweet and beautiful. I've just lost my kitty 3 months ago and just started to upload videos in tributes to her when I came across yours. I can't help crying and can relate to your pain and sadness because I'm still in pain. Our pet will always be in our heart, and our love for them will last forever.
MissDCKitty 1 year ago
I cant stop crying now that was the cutest thing ever. Words cant even explain.................
KyliehDearest 1 year ago
very beautiful and loving...
archer57 1 year ago
very beautiful....
archer57 1 year ago
Your love for Charlie and his for you flows through this video. Watching your memorial is heart wrenching, beautiful, and something that can touch everyone who has ever lost a beloved cat. Thank you so much for creating and sharing this.
jamiedrilling 1 year ago 2
@jamiedrilling thank you for your kind words, he will always be in my heart.
penolva 1 year ago
@jamiedrilling I could not agree with you anymore!!!!!! it is HEART WRENCHING!!!!
Geo7814 1 year ago
This made me cry, I'm still grieving my own cat :(
Charlie was beautiful!
lydiaoc26 1 year ago
take comfort in knowing that CHARLIE is with the lord and my MUM is taking care of him now.
renolda 1 year ago
r.i.p. Charlie
FreeHorrorMovies 1 year ago
this made me cry so much!!! Remember that you will see him again. He must have been a really nice cat. I had to put down my cat a couple years ago and i miss him soooo much. Rest In Peace Charlie!!!
computerfreak52 1 year ago
I just finished uploading my memorial and came across yours. Such a beautiful tribute to a cat that was obviously loved! I have a softspot in my heart for orange kitties! Note to self: TAKE MORE VIDEO! I, sadly, barely took any video of Whisky. That won't happen again.
shuckymomo 1 year ago
@shuckymomo Thanks for the kind message.
penolva 1 year ago
aw poor charlie i hope your doing ok its gonna be ok take care friend!
TheAndrew7899 1 year ago
I miss my Sherman. I always will. Thank you so very much for posting this video. It gvies me closer. Sherman Look 6/23/06. My baby. RIP I miss you so much,
7redsox46 1 year ago
Until one has loved an animal, a part of one's soul remains unawakened.
abra819 1 year ago
thank you for sharing this video with us. i understand your heartache. my beautiful kitty, Mittens had to be put to sleep last year before christmas which was heartwrenching. she died of Pyometra. She was 13 years old, just 3 months shy of her 14th birthday. I had her since I was 5 years old. We'll be reunited with our loving pets someday, Charlie loves you and he's waiting for you, his mommy, to see him in heaven one day.
beedela 1 year ago
my cat just died today, i know how you feel, i just came home and my dad told me the bad news, had the cat for 5 yrs, dont even know the cause of death
snksbgstfn 1 year ago
beautiful tribute,made me cry
iambunyon 1 year ago
My cat is 15 years old and im afraid of the day she will die.... I love her so much, but some day its time to say goodbye :-(
NisiNecro85 1 year ago
Charlie is a beautiful cat. I promise that one day you will see him again. Just remember that God is taking care and loving him. He is your Guardian Angel. I Just got cats, and seeing this video made me cry, and think of what life would be like without Twilight and Micki. Have a great life, and treasure every moment, just like you did with Charlie. =]
JazeeLuv 1 year ago
Thankyou for your kind message.
penolva 1 year ago
No problem. I saw some of your other videos, you are a really great editor!
Sending you my sympathy,
~Jazee
JazeeLuv 1 year ago
Your tribute to your kittie is so wonderful!!!
I understand so much how you feel about him!
swizzletik 1 year ago
My cat Stanley recently passed away due to cancer and he looked almost exactly like that cat
shannonandmackenzie1 1 year ago
We recently just lost our cat Tigger who was 14 to blood cancer, he look a lot like Charlie. He was our little trouble maker, but showed love to our whole family. Charlie, just like Tigger was not just your cat, he was part of your family, your friend. This a very nice tribute, glad I found it.
1118marko 1 year ago
Thanks for sharing this beautiful tribute. Charlie was a beautiful cat. I can tell you were very close to him. I just lost my cat today :( His name was O'Malley. We had to get him put down because they found out he had cancer. This is going to be very hard for Im so used to him being with me all the time. He even slept with me every night. Sometimes he slept right on me. Im gonna miss him alot :(
KISSMEMYFOOL69 1 year ago
I wish I had the time to make a video like this for my pets that have passed away.
xchronox0 1 year ago
And i lost my cat ,when her vet said she die ,i still can't be happy ,wat i do it's only sitting alone and try to forget about her ,but i can't ...T^T
Elfeliaify 1 year ago
my cat died recently and i miss her. Her name is Couilo 1988-2010
nemo34561 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
my "son" died last night. Hit and Run.He came to us as a kitten 5 years ago. He knocked on our door and made it known that he was here to stay. I can't take it. He meant the WHOLE WORLD to me and my husband. He was our child. I could never go to bed without him snuggling in between us. I don't know how to cope. How do you cope with the loss of a "child"?
valledesma 1 year ago
my cat looked just like that and died because another cat bit him..."sniffles" he was thirteen yrs old.R.I.P Jack.i feel the same way about your cat..i hate the cat who killed jack!
webkinz205 1 year ago
im so sorry u will see charlie one day :]
Hacker2424 2 years ago 9