Added: 4 years ago
From: MACINTOSHallTHEway
Views: 237,506
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (1,055)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • the notes dont match the sound. anyone who knows a bit of the song would understand that...

  • not like he didnt put the mp3 in the description. Jeez relax haha

  • trololololololol

  • Who cares if this is fake or not, enjoy the music ("being payed by the video creator to post this comment"). lalalalalalalalala, you didn't hear anything

  • well your a liar and you suck at piano 

  • A bit strange this is your only piano video????

  • I honestly don't see the point, if it's fake it's fake if it isn't it isn't. Honestly who cares? The only person that's getting cheated is really the guy cause he's claiming he can do something he really couldn't do (if it's fake). No idea why you people care so much about 1 person.

  • @PrincessNaeNae People are just pointing out. No need to start an arguement. People just find it irritating that people claim they can do it when others spend ages playing the piano and can do it. It's annoying. I would know of all people.

  • @lmprintProductions When was I ever trying to start an argument? I'd get annoyed/irritated as well but it's still not that serious. 

  • it's a grand piano. look at the notes his fingers are hitting too. wow guys, wow. you really think it's fake?

  • the guys not a fake just the audio

  • what a joke! 163, now 164, people aren't blind

  • Song and feelings matters the most.

  • It doesn't matters who is playing the song,its the song and the feeling in your heart when you hear this song ;)

  • SORRY SORRY THIS IS FAKE FOGET ALL THE STUFF I SAID THIS IS SO FAKE ITS NOT EVEN FUNNY YOU SUCK!

  • @LtGenHaden What is supposed to mean "Foget" are even in our world.You uncivilized punk shut up.

  • never mind i watched it again and if you people no any thing about the piano it makes that sound because he has a grand piano its very expensive so sorry dude but i take it all back hes playing it for real i can tell hes hitting the right notes half you people probably have never played this song

  • yea the piano does not make that sound, but even if you recorded and faked your way out it looked like you hit the right keys but it was kind of hard this is probably the song ill be playing for my school concert and i really like it so i wanted to listen to it.

  • BLUFF

  • um 1 those aren't the right keys 2 that piano CAN NOT make that sound.....

  • BRAVO MAESTRO!

  • it even says artist Mitsuko Uchida.... Not him playing.. hhahha

  • Amazing.

  • What else can be said but WOW!!! . . and then some . . . Thanks for sharing this clip.

    Truely amazing and talented Brava!

  • @jcjrc33 ... lol do people really believe its him playing?

  • i love playing the piano but i dont get how anyone could hate piano videos

  • fake or not. I like the song :)

  • <3

  • F.A.I.L....Mozart does not like you

  • Have you guys ever stopped to think that maybe he is really playing it and you are just confused? 1 or 2 notes different?? how do you know? did you look up the music then compare how you played it to him and listen to a different audio and study there hands? i didnt think so. i dont know if he is playing it or not. my guess is as good as yours but dont skip to conclusions and make yourself look like a jackass.

  • There are some real idiots commenting on here. A note or two different? Who gives a fuck, it sounds great regardless and the pianist knows what he/she is doing.

  • AHHH... THAT'S SO .... BRILLIANT!! I want to play like that too. I think it's the original version.

  • can't wait for your next video where you would lip sync to an audio of Pavarotti and put a title to it " Me singing Ave Maria"

    Pathetically low.

  • BRAVO BRAVO!!!!!!!! Epically spectacular!!!!!

  • I don't know a lot about playing the piano, I was looking for a long time for a good version of it, I found it only here. Maybe it's fake, maybe that person is only pretending but the sound, the speed of it, is the best I could get on youtube. If it's not fake then that guy is really tallented. I admire..

  • him playing the piano may be fake, but quite frankly, i dont give a damn. i look up piano versions to hear piano versions, not to watch someone play the piano. the sound is all that matters to me.

  • are you joking! you are not even playing it's someone else recorded on a mp3 and you say it's you! who are you trying to fool?!

  • Fake.

    Why you ask?

    It has the iTunes link to the actually song being played right in front of your eyes. (=_=)

  • fake.

  • HQ here ! watch?v=L3b85WDa2Do

  • beautiful! I would love to learn how to play this song and as well as you.

  • Well...I didn't notice of course. But who cares? No one could even see his face, and i guess only few paid attention to his name. This is the version that I like best. I wanna know who's playing it, but no matter who's playing, this is the best.

  • It's fake people would know that if they knew how to play the actual song..!!!

  • golden hands

    

  • Nice piano!Like!

  • oh my god, If only I could play this song perfectly like this TT_TT

  • Fuckin' great!

  • what is the difference between Rondo Alla Turca and Turkish March?

  • lol 1070 people are idiots

  • I don't care if pple spotted his deception, Still better than I can do! lol

  • @reinoheya Agreed.

  • 不是他弹的,最后那个音不是他弹的音

  • Great job! :)

  • He is very bad. Even the piano he tricked society! If he has a job, he can trick workers and boss for money. If i were a boss of the company i wont accept this man to come. Have u ever asked yourself that r u proud of being a liar? Have u ever been taught by parents? or this behavior is inherit from adult? This kind of behavior is look like an orphan!

  • are you guys srsly that stupid?

  • GUYS THIS MAY NOT BE THE REAL VERSION BUT I ADMIT HES PRETTY GOOD I USUALLY GET REALLY TIERD WHEN I PLAY THIS SONG! ESPECIALLY THIS FAST!!

  • whether or not this is fake, i think this has definately got a little out of hand

  • Owatta~

  • Anyone question if this is fake by watching the fingers.......don't watch but LISTEN!! The acoustics of this recording are not consistent with how a piano would sound in a living room next to blinds and a floor lamp! There is a slight hall reverb, no piano hammer strikes and a clear bright softness to the sound. A piano recorded in a house will not produce this sound. Video was shot in a house. The piano you hear on the video was recorded in a studio or an empty concert hall.

  • Seriously, i agree with you guys about Kvikzor! He is the biggest idiot in this Youtube communication! He told me to commit suicide and told me that i was "not worth being a human"! ROFL how fucking lame is that?! The only thing i had done was to think that a x factor participant were a better singer than the original artist. When i defended myself, he kept saying that shit and said that i couldn't have an opinion, but he could indeed! He is sick in his head...

  • Bueno primero quiero agregar que soy latino mexicano y bien yo me he dado cuenta que en cierta parte lo que toca no concuerda es un engaño realmente a mi no me parece correcto este tipo de cosas para ganar fama

  • man who give of shit. i dnt play piano but i love this song. Sounds good enough to me, even if it is or not the original version. Its abit quicker but whatever.

  • The music appears to have an echo (correct me if I'm wrong); this echo I find hard to believe sence he/she appears to be playing in a small, closed room, but, otherwise, this is still an excellent piece to listen to regardless.

  • I LOVE THIS SONG SOOOPO MUCH!!! IT REMINDS ME OF MY BEST FRIEND WHO PLAYED THIS SONG EVERY DAY AND I MISS IT!!!!='(

  • DYNAMICS!

  • Hi,

    Interesting new piano learning device featured in Gizmag

    Google “gizmag pianomaestro”

    Just wanted to share

    

  • Are you really playing that? How come it's all out of sort, maybe the person above was right.

  • at least the music is a nice clear version. i was looking for it :)

  • Haha, but admit it, most of you wouldn't know this was fake just as you wouldn't have all hated Rebecca Black (as much) if someone didn't tell you first!

  • ...Really?!?, Im 11, been playing for 1 year and Even i can tell its fake, Listen closley and u can tell...

  • you suck turtles

  • whoever posted this is liar.. learn to actually play...

  • Looke the way u commented!!!! @conmeomecapconmeocon why u just stupid person because u never accept yourself that u can tokay it well. U can play but not good just bad and worst . Does your family have a mirror in your house? Why u never look yourself in the mirror and think. Or maybe u don't have the mirror because u might not have any money in your pocket or no chance to buy a mirror ! thats why u don't accept yourself

  • Okay its obviously fake, and yeah I disliked it, and yes its on my favorites, but I don't care about the video, I care about the sound, so well if I can listen to this beautiful song, then nothing else matters :D

  • its realy really really hard. my cousin is playing it now and she says its annoying. she says the tocata op60 #4 is hard too o.o i can play tocata

  • i don't know if this is fake or not.. but he's really great and i really like turkish march :)

  • How could you give this a thumbs down? It's beautiful Bravo!

  • you are the best . !

  • For those who play this piece, if you listen carefully, it's not the usual version that 95% of the people play here. The chord pattern is different at some parts. The finale melody at about 3:15 to 3:20ish is one note different. His finger movement reflects he is playing the regular version. For sure he fooled thousands of people but not me and a few others who really watched and listened. Come on, if he was that great, just one piano video in how many years? I think he's a thief.

  • @x3Hanabira It also sounds different on a variety of different parts. But who cares if it is fake? At least it is the best sounding turkish march on youtube......

  • @x3Hanabira You are absolutely right. Also did you notice the part that goes a-A-b-B-#c-#C... where the notes go in pairs in octaves, I don't see his wrist rotating accordingly with the music, that also tells you its fake.

    10evilmonkey01 if you have any talent please show us. don;t baffle us with your bs.

    At least learn to spell first.. haha

  • @x3Hanabira id could be that... or just a bad camera ;p

  • @x3Hanabira Does it matter if he showed that he can play the whole melody? Relax and enjoy fine music.

  • @x3Hanabira im pretty sure the chord he played at the end was an accident, excited to end it with so little mistakes he relaxed and made a major one and missed a note. he also changed the chord progression like u said at the fourth phrase with constant 16th note part in right hand. he played F#m)||C#Mm7/G#|C#Mm7/G#|F#m instead of F#m)||C#Mm7/G#|C#/E#|F#m-in the third chord, he didnt remove the m7th and add the M3rd(leading tone) making the E# in the right hand the only thing saying its major

  • @XtraAngrySnowman since, at that part, its in F# minor the ear wants to hear C#m7, not C#Mm7. aka you imagine E♮ instead of E# in the left hand making it seem out of place with the actual E# played in the right hand.

  • @XtraAngrySnowman Listen carefully at the finale, at about 3:18, the audio played "E" A #C A E AAA. BUT his right hand played "#C" A #C A E AAA. You can see this clearly as E is a white key but #C is a black key. Also the chords in the audio as pointed out by many others, are not exactly those of the regular version of Turkish March, yet his left hand just plays the chord notes of the regular version. If you know and play this piece well enough you will see it instantly.

    Mocking FAILED !!

  • @TheDonutring You are right on this one. He did not play it at all. He just took someone else's hardwork and claimed credit for it. He thinks he is smart and can fool people. Unfortunately he did to the great majority of them. A dishonest person with the right skill will always await the right opportunity to cheat, in virtual world or real life. Worse, others will follow. Should this be encouraged ?

  • @XtraAngrySnowman hi, glad you also noticed the chords and chord patterns being different in this video than the version we are all too familiar of. I think he knows how to play the common version of this piece, as I can see his fingers are hitting the right notes according to the music sheets of the common version. But those notes he hit would not generate the sound that we heard. He just stole someone's commercial recording to be used in his video and took credit for it. Plagiarism it is.

  • This is one of the cleanest interpretations on YouTube. It deserves more views. 

  • Too bad this is fake =\

  • Wow That's great and what the HELL there are dislikes this music

  • nice.

  • It's really good. Although it does look kinda fake and too good.

  • very nice...

  • 91 people are filled with jealousy XD

  • How's big... Mozart...incredible!

  • omg. is this really a hoax? thought i found the one who could perform turkish march as good as mozart's :(

  • It's true that the people who can see this aren't the idiots here. And if anyone says that we are, well I am far mor advaned than this and could pwn this guy even if he was really playing.....

  • @bluehaze1029 doit. i will be tracking your channel for a video of you playing Turkish March.

  • @Kronikwookie Okay, I'll post it when I can, but it will be difficult because my camera is a video cam. Anyway, I am a musical person and I am trying out for MSM young musician's program for your information, and being musical I have studied the piano some. I don't really play it as my primary instrument, but I could still play this.

    Plus, your being an idiot. THIS IS FAKE!

    I'll tell you when I post the video.

  • OH MY GOSH ARE YOU STUPID!

    IT'S FAKE; STOP THE PRAISE.

  • Incredible !!

  • best alla turca performance i've ever seen. wow.

  • You're really good! I hope one day I could play like you :D

  • Why dont people just accept the fact that there are really talented people who can memorize and can play piano very well than them? lol i can play piano as well but not as good as this :3

  • This is the fakest thing in the world!!!

    You people seriously buy into this???

  • Can you see the sky? Mozart is the sky.

  • this is really good did u have sheets with the notes on or did u memorized the whole thing? either way its amazing that u can play that i wish i could

  • I AM SO ANNOYED WITH THESE DISLIKE COMMENTS. BRING BACK THE STARS, YO.

  • wowowow nice!!!

  • This is soo good, that I signed in just to like it

  • THIS SONG IS TO DIE FOR!!!

  • I used to know how to play this... ugh i hate myself for forgetting

  • This may not be the original piece... he is playing the simple version... (if he is playing real...-_-!!!)

  • 1% of the people did not like it. Those probably are the 1% who actually knows how to play this piece well enough to spot his deception. Please don't call those people stupid. They are actually the ones who's got sharp eyes and ears.

    If you listen, his fingers are not playing the notes that you hear, at many many places during the piece. Those 1% are masters, not idiots. Face it, most people are easily fooled. Geniuses are few and far in between.

  • @x3Hanabira im glad you think you are a musical genius jewtube would be a sad place without ignorent people like you haha who cares watch the video, listen, and move on

  • @x3Hanabira 10%

  • @x3Hanabira NOw listen up. Again youre mistakin something.. He is playing this.. I can see it is recorded with a bad quality Webcam og Cellphone But it is him playing... He is doing the notes. You are jusat jealous because of the lack of talent. Get ur head outta ur ass plz

  • @kvikzor

    How did you know he is playing? Are you an expert in piano playing or some stupid kid does nothing but just playing video games. Or you're that stupid kid who posted this shit wannabe video?

    Ignore this idiot x3Hanabira, your observation is correct. I agree 100% this is fake. How can it be real when the key is pressed doesn't even sound like the pitch it is being played?

  • @ikickyrass First of all. What qualifications do you have to classify as an Expert in anything. i can tell you, that you do not know anything about what youre saying.. Your a disaster to human beings. And should therefore do all of the human race a favor and take your own life.. Please. youre nothing.. So Dont go around in the internet Trying to impress people that you cant impress in the real world. you suck. Now go hang yourself. Free the world from jerks like you. you pushover

  • @kvikzor All you have said is indeed a reflection of your own self. All your comments and arguments are of no substances and are as empty and worthless to any logics and senses. Get educated, get help, and learn to judge based on facts and shut your mouth when the knowledge is lacking. On no... don't take you life, but get one.

  • @kvikzor Take a deep breath and slow down man. People can have different opinions and I have heard all kind of arguing on the internet. BUT to persuade someone to commit suicide is a new low. It is a chargeable offence in many countries. Not sure what your culture and background is but how would you feel if he /she did kill him/herself?

    Get over it.

  • @kvikzor

    I have provided numerous speculations to conclude that this is a fake. Just "Doing the notes" as you've stated, doesn't really cut the line that he's truly playing. Clearly, you are just another one of the gullible majority. Please learn to spell and support your facts before starting things controversial subjects.

  • @x3Hanabira For those fucking smart-wannabe's, why dont u all just shut ur mouth, sit back, relax and enjoy the music?! First of all, he never said in the title "ME PLAYING turkish march"...so the video may look like its trying to mislead you into thinking its him playing, but if u r normal like most ppl who liked this video, you'd come here for the music and not try to prove u r smart and identify flaws in the video, he could put a cartoon of Homer Simpson playing it 'n no one would say a thing

  • @perfectionist04 If you were "like the most of the people who come here for the music and not try to prove ur smart....." then why did you care? hahaha hypocrite.

  • @perfectionist04 I'd just like to point a small detail out. Although the title never says, "Me playing Turkish March" as you've said, it says that in the description. So, yes, he IS trying to mislead us into thinking it's him playing.

  • @x3Hanabira its the quality of his camera

  • You play the wrong notes on your left hand

  • 86 peoaple are stupidt's

    verry good nice

  • eyyy my shit

  • The audio doesn't match up with the video. The amount of echo in the song doesn't add up with the size of the room.

  • Wrong bassline at 0:19 and 0:33.

    I'm not saying this to hate, but because it's a shame you play it so well with such mistakes :(

  • so hes not playing it wow thats dumb

  • Good job very good i'm learning that song now

  • woah.

  • for 3 seconds i honestly thought this was from a cd XD AWESOMEEEE!! XD

  • may be they want to see his face

  • lowkey, my fingers would of been tired. hahaa.

  • that was beast!!!!!! 8D

  • OHMYGOD. i fail.

    i thought the reflection was really you playing @_@

  • i can play everything except for that last bit.... just cant get it right

    beautifully played. well done keep up the good work

  • very good ;) I invite you to check my cover of this beautifull song in my channel ^^

  • I This is such a great song By the ways, what is the 82 people's problem!

  • one word: BEAUTIFUL!

    i'm so jealous!

  • This song played at my house once and my pet birds danced to it when I had them.I have had birds since I was in 4th grade until october of my 5th grade year.

  • how could a humanbeing create such a beautiful song?

  • kickass.

  • this is one of my fav classical songs... dont get me wrong tho i still love my hiphop and metal and all that to my blues and reggae im abit of everything :)

  • Even with the evolution, 81 people are still little monkeys

  • Oh man, I really love this song. It's amazing how so many people will recognize a classical piece such as this, but won't know the name to it. I very seriously want to learn how to play this when I get better at piano. Can play Fur Elise slowly with a couple mistakes, I'll have to be able to play it with my eyes closed at lightning speed if I hope to compete with this xD

  • Nice ..

  • be careful with your left hand

  • 81 Greeks disliked this video.

  • @NickForelli why are you using the word GREEK you idiot? i don't get you....fucking prejudiced....you only know how to blame anyone else but yourself...you should be grateful instead of being racists..any kind!

  • @maroulistupify I wasn't being racist..... I only said that because the Greeks and Turks went to war :/ I love both nationalities just like all for each unique culture.

  • @NickForelli i am sorry for using such words(sorry for my poor english) i just got really mad and fed up of this story...

    i completely agree and support this comment of yours " just like all for each unique culture" but i can't help being mad because apart from the war this period then the greeks did important things and efforts too..although we have reached here nowadays.being shit as a country and you have to know that greeks especially appreciate a lot true/real music..

  • @maroulistupify It's okay, I myself am sorry for targeting an individual nationality instead of any other nation that had feuds with Turkey. Your English is great.

    From your perspective if I saw someone say something about Americans then I'd feel offended off the bat so it's understandable. I admire a lot of different cultural like your Greek arts, Olympics, architecture and admirable philosophers Greece has had in the past.

  • @NickForelli thanks a lot for your understanding and your comments..anyone would feel insulted even a little if inappropriate commentary was made for his nation and culture etc...and i have to admit my apologies to for my outbreak(?) :P but i am unstoppable when i see -generally speaking people ungrateful especially the ones that have a bad opinion for Greece and it's whole population ..blah blah blah..anyway i am sorry and a good morning *kalimera...apo tin athena(from athens )

  • @NickForelli your comment is still being racistic and very wrong..

  • @NickForelli I am half Greek and that is offensive.

  • Sorry but its sooo fake, i actually know how to play the song and you hit no similar notes..

  • @Luxifer5 The video and audio aren't synced.. ^^

  • you played this masterpiece really well! :) thumbs up for you!!

  • beautiful 

  • Bad notes at 2:40 and 3:13?

  • @Tomiitoz

    No you are supposed to play it like that

  • Comment removed

  • I have to learn this

  • @conmeomecapconmeocon u never learn it becus u have no emotion and skill at all. u can play only stupid pop song "river flow bra bra bra......." piano is not for u . u should go find something to occupy yourself instead of being useless and burden to society.

  • Comment removed

  • eh..i give it a 8 :)