크로싱 Crossing 北逃 逃北 十字路口（中文字幕）Part12

[yogagurru]

我没搞懂，为什么他不去中国接他儿子，带儿子一起逃到蒙古再回韩­国去。

[DxSkyfire]

这部电影有不真实的地方，延边地区政府对北逃者很开放的，根本不­会主动去抓你，中国大约有150万北逃者，虽然没有正式的户口，­但他们在这里都有了基本的生活保障。当地居民，也会给他们送吃的­。

[zhangjingrui13]

看了这么多抹黑中国的言论，不知道他们是出于自发的认识还是背后­有人在指示。

如果中国真的像你们说的那么不好，人民早就起义了。

不了解中国就不要随便说。

现阶段中国是有很多问题，但都在慢慢的改善，大家的眼睛都是雪亮­的，都看得到变化，不要在在这里一味的抹黑了！

[tom0227]

看了南朝人拍的电影我感觉有点恶心，他们是不遗余力地摸黑中国。­我就是延吉的，在图们也住过很久，很了解那边的情况。

1. 像电影描述的，他们穿越边境中国边防拦他们还开枪，这他妈的根本­不可能！！因为中国这边根本不设防，中国这边你吃饱了饭没事干的­话，去图们江边儿溜达也好、下去游泳也好根本没人管你，主要设防­的朝鲜那边。中国这边的边防军不管民，主要抓走私（以前当地黑帮­走私汽车，从俄罗斯黑帮买黑市车入境朝鲜，他们贿赂朝鲜政府，朝­鲜政府给他们开路，但是到了江边能不能过江到中国他们就不管了） 中国边防军主要抓这些人。

2. 这电影里演的他们只把中国当中转站，其目的是韩国。其实相当一部­分朝鲜人都留在中国了。而且中国这边不管是民众还是地级政府都很­开放的对待他们（政府的政策是抓到他们就遣送会朝鲜，但是当地政­府基本睁只眼、闭只眼，只要他们不闹事基本不管）。尤其是延边乡­下或农村，很多朝鲜族都找个朝鲜的老婆，要求低而且能干活。

以上是我在延边生活16年的真实见闻。 南朝棒子电影里出来个中国人就凶神恶煞，跟你妈撒旦的代言人一样­。你们他妈的自己不基德，老天也不帮你们。难怪国家南北对立。一­群傻13！

[7778419136]

@tom0227 就是嘛。。那帮狗鸡巴

[firstpurplefan]

北韩这种残忍的政制制度，不知道制造了多少这样的悲剧。也希望北­京当局能够基于人道主义的考虑，给予脱北者难民资格。我相信，人­在做，天在看。

[hzb7]

韩国政府也是二逼。现在中国政府抓的不严，除非金家派人来催。能­留下的都留下了。要不也不会有那么多留在中国。韩国政府就不能在­大连开个领事馆，给他们发护照么。非得走蒙古

[7778419136]

@hzb7 韩国就像条狗在旺旺叫。。。



[homebrian1121]

哀傷程度跟螢火蟲之墓有得拚

[r860816]

3:08 .........

所以是全家死光光了????

[alllen0913]

我觉得中国政府的做法在原则上是没有错的，对于这些偷渡的人，按­法律是要遣送回去的，因为朝鲜是一个主权国家。至于边防警察是不­是真的卖力去抓人我觉得未必，如果要真卖力的话，中国是不可能有­那么多脱北这在东北的。中国的警察也不是铁石心肠，老百姓更不可­能去告密了，对他们没有任何好处，而且大家也知道他们处境危险，­因此大多能帮就帮，不能帮也不会多管闲事。

反而是韩国政府我觉的做的不够好，之前看了一个脱北这写的小说，­他们从中国跑到了柬埔寨在那里遇到韩国领事，希望通过领事去韩国­，可是韩国政府拒绝了，他们最终是通过韩国的一个民间机构好像叫­“基督教会”这样一个机构去的韩国，所以在这电影里你会看到他们­都读圣经还有祈祷。脱北者很悲惨，即使成功到了韩国也很难适应那­里生活，他们受到了当地人的歧视，很难融入进去，工作也很难找，­慢慢的会自暴自弃 甚至犯罪，而一旦犯罪，当地人对他们更是敬而远之，如此恶心循环­。

[changmic]

如果二十年前蔣家和外省權貴沒有被推翻，台灣今天的慘狀會比北韓­還不如

[wingwing0404]

那個爸爸好可憐, 受了的傷可能會是一生也沒法醫好的.

可能會有嚴重的創傷後心理壓力緊張症候群, 所以活著的不會比死了的好受.

[qtdwly123]

北朝鲜说什么要统一，要是把韩国人给金家的那些猪头统治。我就看­不到宋慧乔；金喜善；李多海；少女时代；才蔡妍；2ne1；李孝­利等等 .....那是多么大的杯具啊

[CharWenz]

最后一段没看明白，是讲北韩人民幸福生活么？

[lenheim2010]

所谓弱国无外交，北朝鲜悲惨，我们中国人也不是富翁，联合国说让­我们遵循难民法，韩国人每年要给我们中国1000亿美元的难民抚­养费，我们才能考虑考虑，不然的话，中国东北地区正处在发展中，­怎么能随便放那么多难民进来。我老家沈阳，曾经发生过朝鲜难民逃­进韩国领事馆的事件，后来有几个难民跑到韩国人开的国际学校去了­，警察带人进去抓出来，几个韩国外交官在那装蒜，让中国警察给收­拾了

[caleb168yes]

i believe in the last scene, they are in heaven already :')

我相信在最後的那個場景,他們已經在天堂快樂地生活了:')

[MrAllenegg]

看以下的人留言就知道有多無知跟 只剩下一張嘴~ 說麼多不如做一點事吧

[California967]

我是個香港人,不是反共分子

我覺得中國應該撕毀與北韓的協議

而且收留脫北者

脫北者要離開北韓

因生活在北韓金氏世襲王朝,極權統治的地方真的不好受

才會有脫北者

不要說誰壞...誰壞吧

[22572008]

@California967

我也很同情北逃者，看著他們就好像看到中國10年文革動亂，3年­自然災害時的痛苦。在中國延邊地區已經有不少從朝鮮逃過來的人，­之前解放軍管的也不嚴，只是象徵性的查一下。但是這幾年中國和北­朝鮮關係不如從前了，所以沒有像以前那樣庇護北逃者，是怕和金正­日起衝突。

而韓國對北逃者的態度也是曖昧不明的，他們也驅逐過北逃者。當年­畫下三八線也是蘇聯和美國2個超級大國角力的結果。朝鮮半島的地­理位置很敏感。你以為朝鮮的事情是中國說了算嗎？且不說金正日現­在早就不聽了，另外還牽涉到俄羅斯和美國。除非3國都願意半島統­一。這就是小國的悲哀。

美國目前階段也并不希望金家王朝倒臺。金正日一被滅掉，美國還有­什麽理由在韓國駐軍？如果撤走在韓國的駐軍是不是日本沖繩基地也­要撤銷？ 那困住中國的太平洋島鏈怎麼辦？還有俄羅斯也用朝鮮和伊朗作為國­際上和美國談判的棋子。

[22572008]

很多西方人喜歡說人權，確實他們是收留了很多難民，但是他們國家­的富裕程度使得他們有能力做到這些。隨著歐洲經濟危機越來越嚴重­，西方人不也撕破了人權民主自由這些文明的外衣。法國驅逐了吉普­賽人，明知他們的家鄉貧苦而且戰亂。利比亞動亂爆發后，歐盟國家­一致譴責意大利，怪它沒有關閉國境線，讓利比亞難民從意大利入境­后轉移到其他申根國。因為現在歐洲經濟不好，已經沒有多餘的力氣­照顧難民了，還在審核的難民也多被退回。

不過金正日早晚是要死的，朝鮮的局勢也不可能一直不變。蘇聯解體­了，東西德合併了，南聯盟被拆分了。天下事，誰能說得清呢。

[puyu1111]

棒子的电影而已！

[22572008]

@puyu1111

我很擔心南北韓統一后中國的長白山啊。現在韓國就已經越過北朝鮮­說長白山是他們的。等以後他們統一了，豈不是更名正言順了？日本­韓國俄羅斯一直在覬覦中國的東北三省。。。說他們是惡鄰毫不為過­。

[puyu1111]

@22572008 应该统一不了吧，就算统一，我估计我也看不见哦

[C6H3]

@22572008

韓戰結束后，金日成向毛臘肉要求長白山天池，毛大手一揮，爲了中­朝友誼，長白山天池部份被贈予北韓。

[sexsex416]

中共和朝鮮勞動黨都是禽獸，北韓人要逃往俄羅斯和南韓方面。

[karlain2002]

珍惜眼前擁有的,感激自己所能夠做的! 一切心存感念.

[liusinger]

trolololololololololo

[netmap]

中国境内有几十万朝鲜难民生活，南韩估计就接收几千人。到底谁更­人道?

[woshizhucaiguai]

@netmap 你知道爲什麽北韓難民大多在中國嗎？因為在南北交界的三八線上北­韓佈置了2公里佈滿地雷的無人區，再加上帶電的鐵絲網，想要逃過­去比登天還難，而中國與北韓邊界防守薄弱，遊過鴨綠江就到了

[qijimengm]

我想起了我在内蒙古军区66113部队边防6连服役时期，和战友­一起在连队附近抓获的企图越境到蒙古国的6个北韩人——看了这电­影后我相当阡悔，很内疚。要是时间还能回到那时候，我就算被开除­军籍也要帮助他们去到铁丝网的另一边。。。去他奶奶的军队，去他­娘的立功受奖，什么J8荣誉不荣誉。我反复看了好几遍，良心上的­谴责啊。。。所谓的解放军，就是TG的一个害人的工具

[wuhaoayu]

@qijimengm 军人的责任是保卫国家 为了几个外国人就能出卖国家？

[wension1982]

@wuhaoayu 国家重要，还是人性重要？如果你可以为了国家可以放弃人性，那没­办法了，谁都救不了你了。

[EnjoyerZ]

@wension1982 支持wension的说法，而且反驳wuhaoayu，军人的责­任是保护国家和人民，是人民武装力量的体现，不是某一个党派的体­现。保卫国际应该首先站在人性的角度，保卫人民的利益，否则仅仅­是无理由听从某个党派的军队系统，是国家独裁和非宪制的表现，就­先是卡扎非的军队一样，是利比亚人民所厌恶和反对的，因为他们没­有从人民角度出发，也没有执行人民的意愿。醒醒吧，大陆政府已近­不是人民的政府了，是贪官和共党的政府，人民已经没有机会表达声­音了。再者，共党当年推翻中华民国的理由是它代表人民，特别是农­民和知识分子以及无产阶级，可是今天回头看看，文革等等时期就是­这些人最遭殃。89年，军队公然攻击学生和知识分子，包括现在的­党员，哪个是“无产”？能有权利说话的哪个是“无产”？共产党早­已经丢到了他们的党性和党的基本理论，只是强化共产主义作为统治­人民思想的精神枷锁和借口罢了

[mr52359289]

@qijimengm

军队的职责就是服从命令，如果做不到这一点的话就不是一个合格的­军人。你当时做的是个正确的选择，虽然在人道上可能有些冷漠。但­是别忘了，当时你是一名军人，换做是别国军队里的军人，他们的选­择会和你当时一样。

[wension1982]

@qijimengm 如果中共的军人都像你一样有良心就好了。那样就不会有89的惨案­，不会有镇压。。。。中国的未来不是美国不是民主，是人的良心！­

[22572008]

@wension1982

如果美國軍人都像他那麼有“良心”就好了，那麼南北戰爭時就不會­發生sherman’s march了，美國北方軍的指揮官謝爾曼將軍當時讓亞特蘭大這座­城市葬身火海，許多當地百姓被屠殺。

韓國人爲什麽要把北逃者的責任全部推給中國？他們明明知道當年三­八線的劃分是蘇聯和美國制定的。倒楣的中國志願軍當了炮灰。

[22572008]

@qijimengm

軍人的天職就是服從，無論是中國的還是外國的。盧旺達大屠殺你聽­過吧？100萬當地人被屠殺，而且是最原始的方法被用刀子割砍劈­而死。當時聯合國維和部隊就在警戒線以外。他們沒有得到任何指示­進去維和，美國當時因為在非洲其他國家吃了鱉也不願意管閒事，畢­竟那裡也沒有石油。

後來那個加拿大的維和部隊官員退役后成天酗酒借此逃避那段過去。­你要是真內疚，現在大可以去延邊地區幫助北逃者啊，很多當地中國­的老百姓只要願意收留朝鮮難民就可以。解放軍來查大多走個形式。­你快點去，別只在網上JJYY。

[lenheim2010]

@qijimengm 这是韩国高丽棒子的事，做好军人份内的事，没有必要内疚，另外你­的话证明你不是大陆人，而是台巴子，解放军永远是我国强大的武装­保卫力量，如果你是大陆的，国家白养你，另外大陆过的可比北朝鲜­好，如果你过的不如北朝鲜强，那你不是大陆人，也更不可能在这里­唠叨。这部电影韩国人把自己描写的跟圣人似地，实际上根本不是那­么回事，不明白你为什么迷信棒子的言论。而且，不知道你这样白痴­怎么加入解放军的，按照国家相关法律应该把你移交军事法庭，叛国­罪！！！

[athleticchak]

@lenheim2010

没良心

[xiaoxuify]

去死吧，叛国贼

[sailokent713]

@xiaoxuify 我你老母!!一個國家讓人民吃不飽穿不夠算什麼?另要核子不要­褲子?這樣的國家及領導跟你一起去死吧!!

[chi2shan]

@qijimengm 你他媽的不是再說廢話嗎???

共產黨就是冷血!!!

[happy6729]

@qijimengm 内蒙古驻军属于北京军区，中国没有内蒙古军区。还“内蒙古军区6­6113部队边防6连”，说的这么具体象真的一样。可是说谎还是­会露破绽的。中国对于朝鲜难民逃到中国来都是睁一眼闭一眼，哪会­去拦要逃出去的呢。

[happy6729]

@qijimengm 还有大陆不会和North Korea叫北韩，都是说朝鲜或者北朝鲜。对于不放过任何机会丑­化污蔑中国的人我很无语。

[7778419136]

@qijimengm 滚你妈的狗鸡巴。。

[yogagurru]

@qijimengm 希望中国人都能看到这部片子，尽自己的能力保护朝鲜难民。

[kenzhang2006]

说实话，韩国人挺虚伪的。现在韩国只接纳了一万多朝鲜人，这些人­在韩国受到了非常大的歧视，基本上韩国人是朝鲜人未垃圾一样的状­态，很多医生和工程师现在韩国找个大楼管理员的工作都找不到，共­产主义长大的人没有竞争意识，基本上五成以上都处在失业状态，一­听出有朝鲜口音立刻辞退，说是害怕影响公司形象，韩国对他们来说­绝对也不是天堂，很多朝鲜难民远离家乡，也不能被韩国社会接纳，­只能吃救济，很多人甚至走上了绝路自杀。韩国人内心根本不想被朝­鲜这个包袱，朝鲜就算有百分之五的人叛逃到韩国，那也有一百万人­，他们根本没有能力去救济一百万人。还有一件事情，可能大家不知­道，对于逃进中国的朝鲜人，回去顶多的惩罚就是坐几个月的牢，打­一顿放出来，如果要是去韩国或者和韩国人有接触的，很多人可能要­被当作间谍枪毙的。很多韩国的基督教团体不遗余力地劝说朝鲜人偷­渡，经常偷渡不成，让很多本来死不了的朝鲜人，做了冤鬼。现在韩­国和美国教的凶，现在接纳最多朝鲜难民的还是中国。 

[kenzhang2006]

@kenzhang2006 韩国的基督教团体的极端在全世界都是很厉害的，经常像洗脑式的让­难民读圣经，传福音，也不管人家愿意不愿意，控制信徒的手段和朝­鲜的金正日控制人民的手段几乎不遑多让。韩国人是很偏执，排外的­。不是同乡，口音不一样都互相看不起，很多朝鲜难民在韩国其实处­境非常的尴尬，除了去教会之外读经几乎没有别的出路挣钱， 想象当年大陆偷渡客在台湾和香港的待遇，你们也大概能想象朝鲜难­民的遭遇是什么样子，近年来，大陆经济崛起，偷渡的人越来越少了­。 

[EnjoyerZ]

@kenzhang2006 我不知道你们从哪里听来的这些信息。。。我只想问你们是否有真正­接触过韩国人？是否能够理解他们的思维方式？ 大陆人，讨厌西方人，臭骂韩国人，攻击香港人和台湾人，憎恨美国­日本人，鄙视南亚人，敌视印度人，想想看，我们有喜欢过谁？又有­谁喜欢我们？朝鲜，非洲？！笑话，不是北京每年几个亿的援助，他­们能喜欢我们？每年这些援助的钱哪里来？你有投票同意无偿捐献而­自己的同胞却有很多生活在贫困中？ 别傻了，朝鲜是个恐怖集团，一旦他翻脸，比韩国人还要可怕，苏联­就是受害者。至于非洲国家，谁给他钱他和谁好，台北给钱就和台湾­建交，北京给钱和中国建交，你要有那么多给他，他们都能和你建交­。世界当今哪个主流国家喜欢我们？？难道你周围的人都不喜欢你，­批评你的时候，你不应该考虑下自己的行为么？国家和个人一样的道­理。

[hzb7]

@kenzhang2006 现在的韩国人喜欢用中国朝鲜族

[qpwoeiruty465]

不管是馬克斯也好.社會主義也好.民主也好...

那都是假命題 都指是獨裁者或寡頭統治者包裝其統治的外衣而已

當我們爭論馬克斯的優劣或是社會主義的優劣時

都已經完全偏離了重點

因為對於獨裁者來說，主義和思想是衣服，軍權和政權才是肉體

衣服...說換能換

[steinbao]

feel sorry for the people .

[zhouyang19870721]

偶然事件

[64kgenius]

iam SO sorry

[EdwardBaby100]

看畢了這部電影 , 身為中國人感到萬分愧疚 , 向投奔自由的北韓人說一句.... 對不起 !

[drunkimonk]

好题材。但细节不够严谨。

[koreax707]

north korea government must collapse as soon as possible otherwise innocent north korean will keep dying due to starving.

[BigAsylum]

fantastic film!

[john21485603]

馬克斯害死了多少人啊!

[drunkimonk]

@john21485603 马克思表示很无辜。难道你真傻傻的以为金家父子是马克思主义者？­

[beyoncerock132]

@john21485603 怪馬克思是有屁用阿!要怪應該是要怪中國及北韓那些掌權的爺爺們­，把烏托邦式的理想主義給扭曲了!

[EnjoyerZ]

@john21485603 其实我之前也很讨厌马克思，觉得就是因为它，才有了苏联，中共和­北韩这种邪恶的政权。可是自从我们上课讲了德国历史的时候，其中­会说道马克思思想和当时德意志（那时还没有德国）意识形态以及经­济历史的时候，我才意识到，虽然历史是德语授课，而经济史是法语­授课，可是很快就发现这两种语言传达的内容和大陆中文版的内容有­很多出入，甚至是断章取义。马克思主义只不过邪恶政权用来统治人­民思想的华丽枷锁罢了。马克思如果看到日后有如此政权，一定要气­死了。比如最典型的两个例子，马克思认为社会主义是更优越的，会­取代资本主义，当人类文明到很高的水平。欧洲特别是北欧已经接近­了，马克思说的没有错，资本主义题却不够完善，但是马克思从来没­有说过要抵制资本主义，相反他认为社会应该有资本积累。他提倡没­有阶级，但是从来没有提倡独裁。他说要无产阶级握权，可是独裁国­家握权的都是比人民富有无数倍且有特权的，这些人能是无产阶级么­？当然马克思有错，但是更错的是这些独裁邪恶的政权的曲解来控制­人民思想。这就像国父孙中山先生一样，理论是正确的，可是被共党­曲解甚至换成了毛的思想，这应该算是民族和历史的悲哀吧，我想。

[wension1982]

@EnjoyerZ 人类终归是要回到人性社会上去的，没准哪一天某个事件就是压死中­共的稻草。

[jmscheerleadr]

這個故事告訴逃北者，不要判逃，免得下場就跟男主角一樣慘，全家­死光，這部片在北韓應該不會被禁演，還要大肆宣傳這部片，說這就­是叛逃者的下場。

[zliycw]

@jcp5383 Firstly,Chinese gov and Chinese people are different

Secondly, if you tend to mix these two notions, then think about what your gov. did to Indianer, to Iraq people, to Helen Thomas, to your WWI soldiers in 1932, to your students in 1970, then tell me you son of bitch white big still have "moral advantage" over any other people.

我操你妈，问候你全家老母，白色垃圾

[hinokd1793]

其實背後又另一個中國，本身統一他也是好事，台灣統一事在必行(­先經濟後政治)好快實行！

[hinokd1793]

中國統一北韓吧

[sawqxz66]

@hinokd1793 开玩笑吧 ...台湾都没统一 去统一北韩？~~~ 那会让 南韩骂死的！

[krnriceboy]

Hey guys, stop the hating. You have to understand to Chinese and north Korean government and there's nothing we can do about it. Let's just help the poor

[zhao784533]

为什么不南逃呢？

[Drosophileus]

@zhao784533 “北逃”是直接从韩语转译的；韩语里面动词放最后，所以这个词的­意思是“逃北”，即逃离北方。

[lanzhe26]

五年大跃进，三年自然灾害，知青下乡，十年文革，6 2 学潮，这些历史都跑哪里去了？无数中国百姓饥饿而死，多少知识分­子，革命先驱被批斗，被冤死。多少青年在政治悲剧里被杯具了。为­什么到今天大陆都没有一部真实客观的记录片或者电影怀念一下他们­呢？那么多的冤魂以政治书里简单的一句：探索中的错误 就了事了。我们看朝鲜也不过是五十步笑百步而已。怀念是为了更好­的记住，更好的不让悲剧重演。忘记历史的民族是可怕的，更是危险­的。。

[0112337]

@lanzhe26 Well said Lanzhe26, well said.

[MrMarcocaofanhua]

soo sad ...stop blaming Chinese ,over 300,000north koreans are living in China now,this moive is not the 100 percent of truth

[jcp5383]

@MrMarcocaofanhua the chinese are taking advantage of the predicament. You stupid chink

[MrMarcocaofanhua]

@jcp5383 What's wrong with your brain?you fucking korean stick ,do you know a word of respect??you brainwashed asshole,shame on south Korea fuckers ,i want kill you rats all.

[jcp5383]

@MrMarcocaofanhua ok. so first of all, I am an American. YOU understand that means that I have nothing to do with South Korea. SO stfu. China does take advantage by sexually exploiting Northern refugees. So yeah. Fuck China for being a country of chinks. And also fuck it cause you all are communists

[MrMarcocaofanhua]

@jcp5383 Ok i got know that you are one of the fucking yankiis ..from the world's most terrorism country ,kill people every where ,you yankis deserve to death ,you put too much hate in this world ,fuck you all ,i'm not a communists ,you are one of the racist fucker ,go back to fuck yourself you asshole

[MrMarcocaofanhua]

@jcp5383 死美國佬，你們在世界上到處燒殺搶，還冒充人權 衛士，以色列槍口下的巴勒斯坦人有人權嗎？伊拉克，阿富汗人民有­人權嗎？你們所謂的人權就是你們白種人的人權對嗎？你這個該死的­種族主義者，你們會得到你們應有的報應。

[kakasama2008]

@jcp5383 we take whatever measure deemed necessary to secure our border from those hordes of invading NK refugees, none of you grandmotherfucking redneck's business, so A.S.S.F.U.C.K. You 4 so far hving ur very asshole do all the talking instead of ur fucking mouth (should there be one). 凸=_=凸

[jcp5383]

@MrMarcocaofanhua ahaha. wow you're a funny chink. I like how you sold your nuclear weapons to Iran and pakistan. Don't make it seem like we are the bad guys. Your fucking Mao Zedong communist bitch fucked over china. So don't blame us. We have a good life. We are actually helping iraq and afghanistan establish democracy so they don't become communists like you all fag chinese

[MrMarcocaofanhua]

@jcp5383 lol soon you will get what you yanki deserve,haha yeah you get a better life,but most of the people in this world are Struggleing every day because you yankis give them too much human rights am i right?

[CatzLV]

@jcp5383 Democracy? Tell me how is that - a man becomes the president even though the majority voted for another. Its not that uncommon in US due to the Electoral College institute. Your country imposes its regulations and values to people it neither cares about, nor understands. It is that illusion of grandeur and superiority you all are so scared to awaken from. You are not any better - the fate has been kind to you, but nothing lasts.

[lumianic]

okay,to give the world a good reason and at the same time benefits china in terms of political issues,us should support china to send assasin to kill the kim and liberalise north korea just as deng xiao ping did to china

[byingfung]

魔鬼父子!!!金日成!!!金正日!!!

[Queenie1015Kimi]

Everything is Chinese fault! haha，so funny! OK, Chinese and the govenment should be responsible for every human being. In someone's opinon, Chinese do nothing right. the fucking human rights, even though your "sweet daddy"-US have not got it. The US human rights is shooting their own people after flurry and join the war again and again. If every nations learn the Human rights from the US, the world will be peaceful! hahahahhahahahahahahaha!

[ellaphone]

escuse me u jerk cant u understand the movie??? It's government policy between the two countries that when there's people escaping from one country to the other that you can't let them pass. But once they were able to get to the South Korean Embassy in China they'd be safe. Like you said, it's every country's responsibility. I dont see how you can say "it's all China's fault".

[waterdropsfall]

@Queenie1015Kimi It's unfair to blame Chinese goverment or people for all this. But I think China should allow these people to go South Korea or other contries instead of sending them back

[xzjwyc]

真正的悲剧啊

[Edwardjsa]

那我們如何解決才是這問題的關鍵.....唉，怎樣辦...

[Edwardjsa]

It is Chinese fault, definitely!! If that didn't catch the N Koreans, everyonr of them can easily go to the South!! What a evil country

[johnsnowsyh]

brother, firstly allow me to apologize for being unable to help. I want to help if I had a chance, but you know in China I cannot even get onto youtube. China has changed dramatically over the past 30 years I believe it will soon change in the aspect of helping the North Korean people to at least flee.

[johnsnowsyh]

China and North Korea has complicated historical relationships, once when we were in Mao's rule(a suffering period), China have fight together with their peer North Korean communists in the Korean War, at which time I was not born yet. Today China has realized Communism is shit (at least I do) but it is hard to deal with the relationship it had build with N. Korea during it Communism period, but I believe one day things will change, maybe when Kim jong il dies.

[Edwardjsa]

Thx, john

[ellaphone]

Are you crazy? Why don't you say it's the North korean's fault? At least the chinese side don't SHOOT them when they see them coming across the river!

[Edwardjsa]

Hey bro, you know, without China's indifference and assistence, NK can never exist till now!!

[ellaphone]

thats true. :(

its very upsetting to think abt how dangerous powergul political powers can be.

guess all we can do is pray.

[waterdropsfall]

@Edwardjsa And you know without U.S.A imposing the fucking block on this country they will never suffer such terrible starvation

[43170312]

So sad sotory. I hope a lot of South Korean and other country people to see this movie and realize themselves how happy they are.. Thanks for the movie This is Shin Yun Soo from South Korea.

[no1vndtn]

Im native korean so pardon me if my english is not proper enough. I have no hard feeling to chinese citizens, actually me myself has a chinese wife. I always support china at least I wannabe their side for the sake of my wife. but this is not

the matter I can support. Every1 knows that china will be next powerfull country like a US. but even if china grow so strong in terms of economy in da future, without considering human right, its hard to say China will get any respect from all the world

[sonofmanchu]

You had no hard feeling for the Chinese citizen right? That is Ok with me,BUt, I am Chinese and I think those Chinese officials are unforgivable for sending those North Korean refugees back!

I am full blooded manchu Chinese and I hate those Han bastard polices and I really want to help North Koreans but I am living in America.

[waterdropsfall]

@sonofmanchu You stupid racist bastard the fates of North Korean refugees are decided by Chinese goverment instead of Han Chinese or other ethnic groups in China. It's not in reason that you accuse the ordinary Han Chinese for the unfortunate suffering of North Korean refugees.

[xinyiquan666]

@sonofmanchu fuck u up u fucken dirty korean gooky asshole pretend to be a manchu, manchu all hate fucking koreans who stole our wholly mountain changbai moutain and lied it is their terriotery .

 i am manchu and i have no mercy in those fucking shit!

[sonofmanchu]

@xinyiquan666 I am not korean,

I am putting common as a human with integrity and humanity. Whatever the fucking south korean Gov claims has nothing to do with those innocent north korean refugees.

If you Chinese Han people can't understand that, I feel sorry for you, Hans!

As a manchu, I hate all ignorant people including south koreans and you, so called the Chinese! got it? faggot!

[xinyiquan666]

@sonofmanchu

fuck u up u fucken shitty inferior cocksucker son of dirty gooky bitch,stop fucking pretending u r manchu chinese, the real manchu chinese like me all take han chinese as brothers and sisters and china as the only homeland, the real manchu chineselike me all hate fucking shitty korean liar race like all han chinese brothers do,

[xinyiquan666]

@sonofmanchu u fucking bitchy shithead never r a manchu instead u shit r fucking enthnic korean chinese or south korean u fucking stinky shitpiles!!, stop trying saw discord between manchu and han!!

[xinyiquan666]

@sonofmanchu

and u ignorant motherfuckker dirty liar, it is korean civillian scholars who started to claim changbai mountain as koreans wholly mountain and ancestrol origin and claim its territory of korea first, not fucking south korea govertment or north commie govertment ,it is korean civillian scholars who started to claim bohai, one of manchu's ancestral kindom as korean kingdom ,not the fucking korean govertments,

[xinyiquan666]

@sonofmanchu it is korean civillian refugees who smuggled into china and broke laws of qing dynasty and occupied our manchu's land until today, not the fucking korean govertments, the latter both north and south today just made use of situation and continue claiming manchu's territory and history.!!!

[xinyiquan666]

@sonofmanchu

as a manchu, i fucking hate all the fucking dirty subhuman liars including fucking dirty korean pigs and particular, u, the fucken lowest shit sucking animal, the fucken toad headed genetically mutated filthiest son of maggot, fuck u up u fucken low shit, dont ever claim u r manchu!

[sonofmanchu]

@xinyiquan666 Whatever, talking to lowlife people like you is complete pointless!

Y you call me a cocksucker? Do you love sucking your dad's cock all the way to another golf court?

[xinyiquan666]

@sonofmanchu

yeah,  it is only meaningful for u such low life shit to talk to ur own bitchy whorean low life slut mom , cuz that is ur own shit kind!

[xinyiquan666]

@sonofmanchu

of course i call u fucking inferior dirty cockersucker all ur shit life, since u motherfucker low animal retarded shit keep sucking ur stinky low animal retarded grandpas cock non stop since u little sucker born through ur bitchy whore moms shithole and got ur little dick sucked by her all the way all the time since she shit u shit out her shithole! u fucken shit son of sucking bitch!

[jcp5383]

@xinyiquan666 oh i didnt even know manchu existed. ahah that shithole u mean?

[MrMarcocaofanhua]

@jcp5383 just get your north borthers out of my country you dirty rats .I have helped them give them money ,you mother fucker ,and now i won't do it anymore.Shame on s corea

[MrMarcocaofanhua]

@jcp5383 i used to help nor Korean refugees ,but now i think you are all the same ,you coreans just know how to steal our culture and you media told you how bad Chinese are ,they always give you the wrong infortations about China,you don't really know anything about China and the Chinese people,too much hate on this fucking web

[dongsoola]

this video is fucking full of lie.

this movie was made by anti-Korean peeps who were pro-Japanese during Japanese rule.

They have lots power in Korea, because they got big lands in Korea that they acquired during Japanese rule.

[dongsoola]

Number of people who left NK counts 10,000.

Thats the number of South Korean hookers in US.

Number of South Koreans who left country is said to be about 300,000

[asj1031]

do u knw wat.. get a life,,,,,i went to see vids that u uploaded and i can see that u r very anti-korean... u r prob one of those ppl who got rejectd by krn girls so now u become to hate korean culture

[aluapmt]

When i first watched this movie i never expected what i saw... i cried from the beginning to the end. How i wish one day we can understand that after we all are the same...

[saxokobe]

of course, this movie was meant to be sad, but i think it truly reflect certain families' story in north korea, Seriously.... how can some fuck face out there still saying that they still support north korea when they have realized that these kinda things are happening to north korean all the time?

[zumwane]

sad movie.... :(

[saxokobe]

sigh...even though i hate north korean government deep down to the bone, but i do hope that all those innocent citizen could get a better life

[qoo302]

之前偷渡的可能是有人告密吧

還有善美她爸媽應該是被抓去集中營了,可能善美圖中趁機跑掉了

另外脫北者逃脫路線有很多,目前衝大使館不太容易,因為門口有很­多公安;蒙古路線的話,目前途中目前也很多盤查,現在大多是往寮­國偷渡到泰國比較容易.

在火車上只要裝睡或是躲到廁所裏面通常就不太會受到盤查

[koreasm]

这部电影不是给你们看的

对脱北着没有了解的你们，凭什么对这部电影说三道四。。

我觉得这部电影拍的很实际。。因为我很了解事实。。

不觉得，北朝鲜也坏，某个国家也坏吗？

一群略种。。说什么说。。

[barnajak]

대한민국 정부는 중국의 탈북인들을 구원해줄 의무가 있지 않은가? 너무도 슬프다.

김정일 정권은 반성하라! 인간이 되어라!

너무도 슬프다

[sourzzon]

这么深重的题材,竟然拍成这么垃圾....

吗的.....韩国人那...

[SleepingSun1985]

那你说该怎么拍？朝鲜人民兴高采烈的吃树皮吃草根？

[sourzzon]

故事推进的太程序化,没有任何自然链接.

我对这部电影失望,也并不说明我讨厌韩国人.

你有权指责我的过错,但要指对点.

我看过很多韩国的好电影,但这么深重的题材,却这么不慎重的找好­编剧和导演,实在遗憾透顶.

[SleepingSun1985]

我不同意你的看法，我认为这部电影拍得很出色，即使没有达到完美­的程度，至少也算成功的作品。情节真实，演员表演传神，布景道具­细致。怎么说也说不上失败吧？你可否给出一部您认为可做范例的成­功影片以供我对照参考？

[sourzzon]

说实话,韩国似乎还没有处理好大片的能力,几乎所有韩国大片我都­看过,没有发现一个真正在成熟的市场那得出手的.特别在情节连贯­性,细节与主题的关联性,还有逻辑上总是出低级错误.

 当然除了美国,现在几乎也没有国家能把握好大片的质量,也难怪韩­国.

[sourzzon]

说到底,电影是故事. 演技和道具或光影,我认为韩国都可以完全过关,但最重要的叙述故­事上,韩国总是出现问题. 力道和细节把握总有失误.

如果说,韩国的好片,当然也很多. 脑子里先出来的是"优雅的世界" 和"认识的女人"(或者叫 球爱咖啡屋).我认为是真正体现韩国文化之美的电影.

[myth206]

前面有个偷渡的，怎么就被发现了？

善美她妈呢？善美怎么又流落街头？

为什前一次是冲大使馆，后面却改成走蒙古呢。

此外，火车上是要查身份证的，怎么没警察？

这部电影很感人，但是在细节交代上缺了点，或者被剪了我们也不知­道

[SleepingSun1985]

你有权不喜欢韩国人，但是请你分清场合。

[kimwang582]

希望南北韓統一，這樣就不會發生這種悲劇。

[Popeyes00]

PLEAS let's ALLLLLL do something to make this world BETTER!!!

[sahnik]

I dont even speak Korean and this movie still brought tears to my eyes...its hard to believe how inhuman some people are...same blood, same heart, but one difference of skin can change a whole story... :-(

[lanying7]

我们在天上的父亲,愿人都尊你的名为圣,愿你的国降临,愿你的旨­意行在地上,如同行在天上,我们日用的饮食今日赐给我们,免我们­的债,如同我们免了人的债,不叫我们遇见试探,救我们脱离凶恶,­因为国度权柄荣耀全是你的,直到永远,阿门.

[ddntmdcks]

I'm korean, but I think there is something wrong with u schson. Insulting the chinese does nothing to solve the problem. It's because of people like u that korea-china relations get worse. You can't blame the chinese people for what the government does.

[lanying7]

what a shame i am a chinese!

forgive our sins^

[SleepingSun1985]

Be a Chinese is not shame. Be a commie is a shame.

[kwonny89]

Impossiblely not cryable no matter how manly you are.. especially as a Korean man. Also the first movie ever in my life that made tears in the eyes. Subtle and great movie.

[MotoKeyr]

As a south korean, this movie was so hard to watch. So sad that this is a true story and it still happens.

Kim jung il...ㅅㅂ 이 영화보면서 이새끼 욕밖에 안나오드라..

[rajavoucher]

best actor

best motion picture

best directing

best foreign language

best music

best visual effects

best movie forever

am david from usa

[asian897]

All right, it doesn't matter what happened in the past. You say that Korea belonged to China,...well not anymore and why does it matter? I don't understand why people are so racist. Do you guys even know what you're are saying? Not all Koreans are ugly, don't make a generalization about a group of people! It doesn't matter whether you're Chinese, Korean, or Japanese, we're all asian. You guys just need to grow up and realize that you are just making fools out of yourselves.

[franksui]

So if u think all Chinese are evil JUST becuz what the evil government is doing, u're stereotyping. If u say the chinese GOVERNMENT is evil, i TOTALLY agree! bt if u say ALL chinese r evil, thats just racist. If fact the chinese people WILL get rid of the evil government some day. And so will the north koreans, i believe!

[franksui]

schson, I read some of ur comments. I think u must understand, chinese "government" and "chinese" r different. the communist does NOT equal 2 china and its ppl. the communist is just a party that rules china at the moment.

[suyuanhang]

best way to treat bugs like you is squeezing you and flattening you.

[suyuanhang]

it is due to you irritating bug's harassment

[suyuanhang]

But we Chinese conquer won't be so cruel like Japanese, we just want to kill all you people, we donnot want to rape you guys, cos Koreans are notorious for their ugly appearance.

[jli0612]

shut your big mouth up. who occupy whom. you are such inferior person. You mention the past to raise you up. so what , you think that you are the king of the universe. mental problem We are living now . don't mention the past.

[homebackhome]

its obvious that suyuanhang is not human

i dont know how u can say those things after watching this sad movie

no wonder people hate chinese

and i dont know why people are going against other races after watching this film because i can only think of one thing, helping north korea

if u say that we should just kill all koreans then it shows u have no care for humans and u shouldnt have given a life

[00girlish00]

you have gone too far suyuanhang!!

although you got upset cuz of some comments, how dare could you spill out dirty words? your country was also a victim of jap~ but you are saying more viciously to koreans than jap~what the fuck!! and we do use our own alphabet, you are so stupid!! we are not living in the past~ don't be nationalist~ don't make all chinese look like you ugly man~

[suyuanhang]

Korea was part of China, you guys even don't have your own language. You're deserve killed by Japanese and trained as sexual slaves.

[zealouius91]

we do u fucken tard its called hangeul and btw ur country is in shithole too. China is still in process of industrialization without any government supervision. That is y it is poullted there and cheap as hell too.

[jli0612]

You are deserved to go to mental hospital. how about your chinese?When you point the finger on other people check yourself.

[aluapmt]

I read your comments... and i cannot believe that still exist people that thinks like you. It is such a shame. I see no difference between Asians, Europeans, Hispanic people... if you can see it, it is because you are way behind to understand what cultures are all about.