With or Without You- U2

[DirkjeA]

Even though it is shot some years ago, it has not lost anything of its atmosphere. Very well done. I work on the Academy of Arts in Groningen (Holland) we do have a faculty for video- art music and movie-art, you would do great there, that is what I wanted to tell you.

[alonsovaldes]

Nice! God Job. I LIKE IT!

[laptopdragon]

the artistic/melodic/ version and a deep pool of gray skies to not focus on.

[sisterhoodsweetgirls]

some good some not

[MrTonytiger2011]

nice job...awesome

[jdmac44]

meh

[Keithlynn5]

Nice very nice well done

[theGanzo57]

Well done!! Cheers to this Vid !!! 

[kellitown]

this is awesome. great work.

[kellitown]

Awesome. good work

[atlanticl]

you're nuts

[luxferre1975]

bravo pour ton clip il est génial.....magnifique....et bon choix musical....excellent

[gkram212]

i absolutely love it ! great job !

[Charlie16164]

Great Video :) Xx

[jughfreind]

it's so beautiful

[dillpickle7647]

it was a pretty good vid. actually

[fruitloopz4eva]

both the song and your vid ooze passion <3 the song and <3 your video well worth watching

[caestvs]

Did a good job!!! song reminds me of my better half who passed away. featured it on my channel for her. thankyou.

[IKariBills]

you really want a comment? allriiiiggggggghhhht.... First of all, you need to let that chick leave the trailer like you promised her! Second, that's not Joshua's tree! Thrid, seriously... you promised her she could leave if she just corroporated and made the video with you, her parents are worried, let her go home!

[ikhtear]

not bad.... @ 2:11 subject looks at the camera ...other then that not bad.

[sbloba]

che bella questa song!!!

[Sweetela3008]

bello!

[A026]

AWESOME!!!!

[Risenbullet]

brillliant best ever

[Miss09Georgie]

really great job ...

you should be proud of yourselff xx

this is an amazin song though x

[jaaaado]

and well done for the video man :]

[jaaaado]

i like shauns ''version'' of this song better, i think its jus the way he sings it.

[iamarock09]

Why the debates about Shaun Smith? The fact is, this is a beautifully made video. Kudos to the creator, five stars all around.

[pipirrin90]

simply, best song ever!!!!

[sethman53]

older songs are just that way. simply the best

[maria932]

beautiful

[Rudolphina17]

this is really good. :)

[Risenbullet]

i think shaun rocks so all ov you that think he is crap you shud all FUCK OFF if there was on person i could meet it would be him go shaun

[Declyn117]

U2 r better than shaun smith by far

[T0MMYELD]

Because U2 are the originals you doughnut

[Risenbullet]

shaun smith rules he shud hav won

[efc25fellaini]

shauns version was shorten and didnt seem right, he changed how the song is meant to come across n i have to say that u2 and bonos version is so much better than shauns

[ForeverBolton]

bono sings it the way the song was made . shauns was a diff version so how can it be better ?

[UrGatorBaitFLA]

your point cannot be beaten...

[123456789yummy]

video footage is a waste of 3 days .. but love the song both u2 and shaun but prefer shaun

[boylo10]

shaun sings it better

[xluvux4]

i love them both but i do prefer the way shaun sang it!

[OneMoreTimeXD]

bono all the way shaun smith i BAD cant sing to save his grannies life never mind hid own!

[16azzer]

shaun smith all the way x

[thatboffjosh]

Prefer bono, sorry :).

[TeeDoggee08]

Copy and Paste if you think Shaun Smith can sing better than Bono at 17!" actually at any age loll sorry guyss

[Alamir34]

I do think that Bono is a better singer BUT I prefer the WAY Shaun Smith sang it. No disrespect for either of them ; )

[neave1234]

"Copy and Paste if you think Shaun Smith can sing better than Bono at 17!"

[louiscoop1192]

how the fuck can shaun sing it better than bono did when bono wrote the song, he invented the way to sing it

[thatboffjosh]

It can still be song in a different style, and if that new style is interpretated by most as "better" i guess its better.

But i still prefer bono.

:)

[jimmyperugia]

love it!

well done...wait 4 another one made by u.

[Risenbullet]

"Copy and Paste if you think Shaun Smith can sing better than Bono at 17!"

[koolorwot]

Nice vid :)

And you're really pretty :)

[chansays]

"Copy and Paste if you think Shaun Smith can sing better than Bono at 17!"

[Seliumx3]

no way

bonos voice is amazing

[chansays]

"Copy and Paste if you think Shaun Smith can sing better than Bono at 17!"

[chansays]

OBVIOUSLY Bono has thousand years of experience singing millions of songs and Shaun rocked this for his first time*****

[darthfacultas]

seriously shaun smith didn't sing this as well as bono, any one hu says other wise is just weird, and if you didn't know such a classic before he sang it then where the hell have you been lol (great song btw love it one of me faves xD)

[monikclaudia]

"Copy and Paste if Shaun Smith Brought You Here!" bono is a legend. shaun just cannot be compared with bono. shaun only won it mostly because of his looks. yes, he does have a good voice, but let's face it... he could only do it on certain songs. anyway, I love U2!

[monikclaudia]

"Copy and Paste if Shaun Smith Brought You Here!"

however, shaun cannot be compared with bono... bono is a legend...

[xacratinwivmalignity]

"Copy and Paste if Shaun Smith Brought You Here!"

[Lizzzie1963]

"Copy and Paste if Shaun Smith Brought You Here!"

[Shiv080]

"Copy and Paste if Shaun Smith Brought You Here!"

[xBooshxLucex]

Of course he is.... ¬_¬

I still can't believe everyone keeps saying "Oh, he's better than Bono." As if!

Y'know, this happens every single year. Someone comes onto a talent show and sings, then every one finds the orginal and spams it saying "Oh, I saw this on X Factor/Britain's Got Talent or whatever, and they rocked it."

Yeah, yeah. Course...

God, it annoys me! >:(

[TwilightSLover197]

Shaun Smith Absolutely rocked the song, AND the crowd! He's absolutely great! Audition & Semi-Final! Now lets wait for the final!

[xBooshxLucex]

Shaun Smith RUINED the song!

How can you say he was better than Bono? WTF? Are you all deaf!

U2 are better at this song by miles!

[bal333ina]

shaun smith sang it better are u on glue its fuckin u2 for christ sake the original is the fuckin best

[zan606]

hey wait, who's shaun smith?

[zZ6754Zz]

shaun smith is this guy off britains got talent who sang this song very well and got into the finals with it

[jamieross1986]

who the hell is shaun smith

[NakedLegend]

He is off Britain's Got Talent.

[SuperFreddo2007]

Copy and Paste if Shaun Smith Didn't Bring You Here

[hasanjawadhajrah]

Copy and Paste if Shaun Smith Brought You Here

[xLozxBabyx9]

Copy and Paste if Shaun Smith Brought You Here!

[FluorescentColourZ]

shaun smith sang it better :]

[barnsley1000]

shaun smith sang it better my arse

[jimmymacd1888]

ure insane

[jimmymacd1888]

not the video maker.....just the shaun smith muppets....the video is awesome:)

[ROBOCOLES]

shaun smith didnt bring me here i just like this song

[Adiee321]

Copy and Paste if Shaun Smith Brought You Here :)

[shirty94]

"Copy and Paste if Shaun Smith Brought You Here! "

Good song :]

[eotman11]

Copy and Paste if Shaun Smith Brought You Here

[IFudgingHeartAckles]

Copy and Paste if Shaun Smith Brought You Here!

[iclenattypooh]

Copy and Paste if Shaun Smith Brought You Here!

[ni1991]

Copy and Paste if Shaun Smith Brought You Here!

[AriannaBabes123]

Copy and Paste if Shaun Smith Brought You Here!

[chloverandbeckie]

Copy and Paste if Shaun Smith Brought You Here

[ellie16xX]

Copy and Paste if Shaun Smith Brought You Here!

[omorgan22]

Copy and Paste if Shaun Smith Brought You Here!

[singerbbz]

Copy and Paste if Shaun Smith Brought You Here!

[perryizfat]

Copy and Paste if Shaun Smith Brought You Here!

[lozb11]

Great babess!

[sazzie14]

Copy and Paste if Shaun Smith Brought You Here!

[11gh11gh]

shaun did nothing haha,

he only sang it?

actualy love this xx

[mysteryalb]

Copy and Paste if Shaun Smith Brought You Here!

[RachiiBabees]

"Copy and Paste if Shaun Smith Brought You Here!"

I already loved this song but shaun smith reminded me how gr8 it was.

I also love Diana Vickers version from the x factor u shud listen 2 that :) xxx

[owen111286]

Copy and Paste if Shaun Smith Brought You Here!

hahaha

[xMackie07]

Copy and Paste if Shaun Smith Brought You Here!

[ricorickyS]

Copy and Paste if Shaun Smith Brought You Here!

I have to say he did :)

[cockertoncrew2k7]

Copy and Paste if Shaun Smith Brought You Here!

[RoRoTheGreat96]

you filmed this? pretty impresive i have to say...

[xBooshxLucex]

That was lovely honey. Well done =]

[BadlyDancingBean]

This brilliant. You've really got a talent for filming and editing in my opinion.

Thought the footage really captured to song well, especially the car journey and the trees at the beginning.

Fantastic :)

[viralpatel17]

lovin the video ...gr8 song ...awesome work....cheers !!

[marxistsoldier]

parts of this are brilliant (car journey) but the footage of u is a bit narcissistic and nauseating

[lumberjackconnor]

I like the start for some reason :) nice vid

[spudnato26]

great video. keep them coming. would you be able to do 1 for lighthouse family. high? it would be amazing if you could (Y)

[partypack08]

This video is Amaze :D

[winduptoyproductions]

You've definately got an eye and taste for editing. I'm impressed.

[Caandylips]

i loooove homemade music videos, ecspecially done right!:) ..but i'm sorry, your video didn't capture the magic of this song :/

[winduptoyproductions]

you've got to be kidding me.

[babyblueloveangel]

very nice!!! :)

[babyfacedsweety]

AMAZING VIDEO

!!!!

[kenny29544]

hey i love U2 and this video is really really good.

Kenny

[thehype93]

thanks! <3

[zemo84]

Molto bello! Tornerò presto per altri video. Ciao!

Very good, girl! I'll be back soon for more videos! Bye ;)

[thehype93]

thanks!

[DutchMacPhisto]

Very nice made Hype, this video is again proof that B&W is way better than color!.

Can't wait for more.

Greetings your new fan Joey.

[thehype93]

thanks!! i think i'm going to be making a video for verigo and/or the last night on earth soon, so you'll see it as soon as it's finished!

[U2fan003]

Great video!!! Very nice editing and b&w effect!

The 3 days of shooting * editing you did were well worth it!!

(Btw, cool shoes! hehe)

See you!

[thehype93]

thanks!! i had alot of spare time this week!

[U2fan003]

No prob!

Cool! This week I had exams, and next monday and tuesday too :S so the next video is going to take a bit long, first with the pc problem and now with exams grr...

See you!