Added: 4 years ago
From: pbaylis1
Views: 294,068
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (252)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Any idea on the details of the secrets, or release dates? The visions (while awake and standing) are likely real, and only because it is God who controls the veil. Dreams and imaginations are another story altogether (interference).

  • And where is the picture of Jesus on toast sandwich? :(

  • No person that has gone there and came back was ever again the same!I know because I was there myself!!The Gospa IS THERE just like everywhere in the World...we just don't want to let Her into our everyday life us "normal" people...If you don't want to believe in Medjugorje DO GO THERE AND CHECK IT YOURSELF! Do let her to call you...The Holy Family is waiting for us all sinners,with the LOVE you have never-ever experienced before!!!

  • Bow

  • Another child visionery took a Polaroid picture of Mother Mary as She appeared to him and this exact same picture appeared. She is so beautiful ..

  • jajaja !!! en el segundo 0.31 la palabra CHRIST escrita es mas falsa que billete de 3 pesos !!! son tan idiotas los de ahi y los q creen q no saben q existe un programa llamado PHOTOSHOP con el q se hacen estas cosas, por favor... es igual q Roswell: desde q en teoria cayo el ovni el pueblo levanto economicamente, aca paso lo mismo, eran super pobres y ahora hasta tienen hoteles, casas buenisimas, etc... TODO ES UN NEGOCIO TURISTICO PERO LOS IGNORANTES NO LO VEN. TIEMPO AL TIEMPO, YA LO VERAN...

  • Profound messages given to us so we can lead a holy life. No more arguing, lets just begin to show love and tolerance even if we don't believe in the miracles.

    Right now need a real miracle see willann54 Miracle Prayer.

  • Pray for Medjugorje!

  • Those are some quite interesting photos. I am not arguing, and do believe in miracles, but would like to know if this had been photo shopped.

  • fantastic jesus crist

  • ah ah ah..."You can provide them with all the proofs in the world and still they don't believe", it's funny because it put it as if You are providing "proofs". Now, even if I was a believer, I would refrain from believing that "CHRIST" written in the sky: it's a very bad offense to human dignity. It's stupid even only the fact that is written in english... bah.... Anyway, it's 2011 guys, for your own sake it's better if u start thinking about "aliens", rather than "angels"

  • I'm a Catholic and I dont believe in these thousands of apparitions and secrets also that the visionary asked the virgin to write down in paper as there are so many dates, then the virgin gave her a special paper from heaven and she keeps it in her draw.

    If this is true the Pope should have this paper with the secrets dont you think so?

    Well in spite of my disbelief I am glad that there were many conversionsWe catholics are not obliged to believe in any apparitions of the virgin unless approved

  • @rosamcgoum You have a deluded vision about the Vatican. The Pope is like the president or the CEO. The Councillaries and even the Guard are the real power of the Church.

  • @Katazka I do believe in some apparitions, like Fatima, none of them are telling you to do anything wrong, only to please God obey commandements and love one another as yourself. All Mary wants is to pray for us in order to be saved. I have my doubts about Medugorje,but I really hope its true. I think someone having a vision from heaven, will live a different life, never be the same person.Do lots of works of charity for so many abandoned children, somethng like Mother Theresa from Calcutta.

  • @rosamcgoum Well I think most people would not dispute many of the real proven miracles like at Fatima, but merely just what their significance is. As for evidence of Medjugorje, well we'll know within the next 20 years. The priest meant to announce the secrets is over 60 now I believe, so it's within his lifetime. I truly do believe , and it's more than just hoping that it will happen, I just have a feeling of 'how can this stuff be faked?'

  • @Katazka Well, legally the bishop of the region is the person who should have the secrets and not any priest.. Its hard for me to believe in it. The catholic church does not oblige us to believe in any apparitions. I read the messages every month though. But I am neutral as I dont see

    much positive results. We should have more charity from Medugorje, not only hotels and ths visionaries shedding tears.We dont know where we will be in the next 20 years.We need some more clarification now.

  • @rosamcgoum Legally? Since when did law have anything to do with it? Was it not Saul who persecuted the disciples first, yet became the real leader of the Church? Just because someone is not the best candidate does not mean they wont do the job right. Why should a bishop be the one to know? Considering that the majority of the region is in Orthodox jurisdiction too...

    And who are you to tell God we need clarification now? If it happens it will, if not then nothing changes...

  • @Katazka You dont seem to be a catholic, so you wouldnt understand clearly. I am not asking God for clarification now. I only would like those visionaries to visit the Pope and clarifty what really is going on there. I only ask God to enlighten all of us to know what is true and what is not. If the vsionaries are Roman Catholics they must obey their Bishop and the Pope. They cannot just do what they wish, that is disobedience. And the virgin mary wouldnt like that.I'm sure

  • @rosamcgoum that was very judgemental. I am catholic. always have been, always will be. The miracles at Medjugorje have already been accepted by the Vatican as real, just as the miracles of Lourdes, and of Knock have. The church has accepted that the apparitions are real. That fact is well published. And the Church is not our masters. It's not disobedience. The Church is very far from perfect and it accepts that. "If it is of men, it will fall apart, if it is of God, then we only fight Him".

  • @Katazka I didnt read anywhere that these apparitions have been approved by the Vatican. If so we are not even obliged to believe. Anyway I will await the official approvement of our Pope Benedict XVI who, as a catholic, I consider representative of Jesus Christ, on earth . that doesnt mean I consider him a saint. In the meantime I feel glad for all the conversions even if it is true or not,these people will be blessed.This is my belief and people are free to believe what they want to.Goodbye

  • @Katazka - You are woefully misinformed. The Vatican has NOT approved the alleged apparitions of Medjugorje. The Bishops of Mostar & the former Bishops Conference of Yugoslavia have investigated it three times and in all three cases have found NOTHING to prove the alleged apparitions are of a supernatural nature.

    You have been duped by the Medjugorje Industry's propaganda machine.

  • @pjb1983 Propaganda? Say what you will, but be careful because what you say may be proved false.

  • @Katazka - "What you say may prove to be false." Tell me one thing in my post that is not true. The Vatican has NOT approved the alleged visions of the so-called "Gospa" and the Bishops of Mostar AND the former Yugoslavian Bishops Conference have ALL investigated and found NOTHING of a supernatural nature concerning alleged apparitions in Medjugorje. It is you who have made these false statements, not me. Your "Gospa" sows disobedience and scandal within Christ's Church. Satan is quite pleased.

  • @pjb1983

    I think satan is more pleased that people like you are spreading dissent about what may be proven to be valid. What's worse is that you are spreading half-truths all throughout your posts and seem completely unaware of the facts. The fruits themselves are the best proof of validity. And God can reap even where He does not sow. So, even if the apparitions are deemed false, God will still get his harvest. You are doing nothing useful by speaking against these apparitions.

  • @pbaylis1 - What we have here folks, is a classic case of what psychologists call "projection" on the part of pbaylis1, attributing to another his/her own faults/shortcomings/errors...

    Satan rules in Medjugorje, not God. Any one who says or thinks otherwise is fooling themselves.

  • @pjb1983

    I suppose if you can't beat them, cast aspersions on them. Tactic of losers. Rather, admit your own faults and simply stop demonising what is good. You don't know it's evil, yet you fiercely affirm that it is. I'm not sure what diagnosis a psychologist would give YOU, but it won't be too flash.

  • @pbaylis1 - The fault lies with those who have a fanatical devotion to a condemned alleged apparition rather than a humble obedience to authentic Church authority (Bishop Peric.). By not heeding the requests of Bishop Peric, adherents are breeding a spirit of disobedience in the Church, which always leads to heresy and schism. St. Bernadette, Sister Lucy, St. Padre Pio & St. Faustina ALL showed perfect OBEDIENCE to their spiritual superiors in the Church. Not so for the "seers" of Medj.!

  • @pjb1983

    You'll keep. Let's see what the Vatican says. I wash my hands of you. You'll need to answer to God, not me.

  • @rosamcgoum ... and the hotels are there to provide pilgrims places to stay. It may well be profiteering, but that happens anywhere, whether it is a Holy Place or a natural wonder, it happens.

  • how stupid you are,you mean christ come back?no he shit down his shit!

  • Most of these "visions" I believe are imagined or fabricated. We have to be very careful about this though. Being familiar with Medjugorye I can say I really believe that all the visionaries are telling us the truth and I am a sceptical person. May God bless them and us as well.

  • Ahahahahahah!! :))) Simply ridiculous!

  • Ave Maria Gratia Plena

  • Very, very, silly! If you beleive this folks you need to see a doctor or get an education!

  • The jesus have the big busines

    this is fraud of umanity

    Fuck you artis this is shit your work

  • After Christ, there won't be any prophets anymore. What He has taught us is more than sufficient for mankind's salvation. These visions at Medjugorje, Fatima, and like so many others are probably works of the devil to distract people from the original path made for us by Christ. If one would only be critical, what message is being transmitted accordingly? To pray the rosary, to be good, etc. Nothing really. If one would seriously read the Bible, so much is being said in it about salvation.

  • @271828183141592654 Friend, read Acts Of the Apostles 2-17: "AND IN THE LAST DAYS IT SHALL BE, GOD DECLARES, THAT I WILL POUR OUT MY SPIRIT UPON ALL FLESH AND YOUR SONS AND DAUGHTHERS SHAL PROPHESY AND YOUR YOUNG MEN SHALL SEE VISIONS AND YOUR OLD MEN SHALL DREAM DREAMS........We must pray to God to enlighten us to know what is true and what is not. Also Chris said:

    IF THERE IS TWO OR THREE REUNITED IN MY NAME, I WILL BE WITH THEM. God bless you

  • oh wow so if a conflake looked like peter or mary you would bow before it ot worship it ...talk about being sucked in by the most dumbest things but this is just rediculious

  • 0:58 how is she? that don't look too good!1;14 looked like bones.

  • idiots...who would believe this??!

  • ha ha, worst video ever. Christ written in the sky (in english), ha ha ha...

    "We need more tourists in this region"

    DEFINITELY FAKE ! ! !

  • Whatever !!! I'm a christian and faithful to the Church. As long as the church thinks of this as a lie, it will be so. Medjugorje is no sanctuary, no holy place but a great fraud.

  • people want to believe so badly they come up with all this bullshit evidence.. its called faith for a reason .. stop looking for evidence .. that just proves you have no faith

  • If you believe this nonsense you'll beleive anything. What absolute stupidity!

  • If you believe this nonsense you'll beleive anything. What absolute stupidity!

  • there where u live at there are no drugs no bmw etc. lol so if there are any of things above u would still found something else to comment etc, why dont u talk about healings,convertions, confesions etc,cause wherever is good there is evil,anyway it will come the day that all of US will believe in what is happening in Medjugorje.....and what is happening is the fact that the heaven came down on earth,and if u dont believe I respect that but look in the good things that are happening there.......

  • Bollox............

  • I didn't see that one.

    Was it before or after the "christ" written in the clouds - the one that made me guffaw :D

  • madonna mia porta la pace l'armonia il volersi bene la comprensione l'unione della famiglia il lavoro x tutti nel mondo amen

  • Mutombe: A certain percentage of kids everywhere get into drugs & most get out when they grow up & are responsible; Medjugorje is still in the world, kids are still kids & people are still people; there is no perfection in this world; so many in Medjugorje are good, kind and caring people who are grateful the Blessed Mother of God has chosen this place to bring people closer to God. Makes no sense to throw stones. There but for the grace of God go I.

  • The whole picture the spear is needed to see Jesus, im sure it can be found online somewhere.

    I would post it but im not into this tecno stuff.

    Maybe one day if i have time to learn.

  • The photo with the spear is real, a friend of mine was stood next to her friend when she took it. Top of the picture centre Jesus can be seen with His right hand out blessing Viska.

    Things have changed over there, it is sad to see the youth becoming corrupt, satan offers materialism sadly it satisfies them more than the Word of God.

    Pray for them.

  • People of Međugorje are looking you ''tourists'' only through your fat wallets ! Their kids are hooked on heavy drugs now, driving expensive BMW and Mercedes and cursing GOD and MARY and JESUS on daily basis. Sad but true.

  • faith is not for every one. it's not see to believe, it's believe to see. Love to every one!

  • ok i am Bosnian and i lived beside medjugorje listen:

    MAYBE IT DID HAPPEN A LONG TIME AGO.

    BUT IT IS ALL BUSINESS NOW

    BELIEVE ME IT IS TRUE

  • pur di fare apparire "scritte" miracolose nel cielo...fate di tutto! e c`è gente che "cade" in questi stupidi trucchi! è facile "ritoccare" le nuvole in una foto! fate invece una ripresa con la telecamera dal vivo!

  • I honestly have to say that with these people you are arguing with, its a complete waste of time, there beliefs are set in stone, in scientific proof, its just they don't believe full stop, you can show them all the pictures and videos that exist of apparitions and Miracles, and they will STILL try and find some excuse, they try and disprove it all, little do they know though that even through science God can be found, as he created even the atoms they examine.

  • @ferretmaster22 Boy are you dumb! Get an education!

  • @masala505 what are you talking about, firstly im not a Boy, im sure im wiser than you are, and secondly get an education?.....what do you mean by that?.....your probably another one of them Athiests, what are you even doing looking at this video?

  • Show us the proof that this is just business or simply be quiet. I don't know if you're a Christian, but if so surely you have heard of the 8th commandment about bearing false witness. This is YouTube - possibly millions of people witnessing your statements and who may think ill of the visionaries because of what you have said. And to the extent that you judge another person, you yourself will be judged, even if you are 100% correct.

  • @pbaylis1  well said my friend... peace and happiness

  • @TheMoncheri86 shutnup u fool

  • @TheMoncheri86 its true i have been there and i didnt feel any holyness at alll , and im catholic ,its alll business

  • @TheMoncheri86 I'm totally with you. It's just a tourist business, and all that fools go there to leave money for them ... but soon going to realize that all of it it's FAKE, is a matter of time ... (sorry my poor english).

  • Uh I think exiledfenian you need a reality check here. Mom (The Blessed Mother) has stated that "Not all religions are equal, but EVERYONE IS EQUAL AS THEY STAND BEFORE GOD." So this my church vs your church adds not to forgiveness, love and service to each other but rather separation, hatred and

    insanity. Work on your heart and how Jesus is reflected to others as opposed to worrying about who has a union card to what church. By the way I'm Roman Catholic if you must know. God bless!

  • IamFromPoland, Christian dont HAVE to believe in God or anything. We CHOOSE to. because its the truth and others that dont believe havent found the light and the truth yet.

    These pictures are little miracles from God reminding us, thus the world that he loves us just the way we are: with all our faults.

  • Ohhhhh people wake up!!!!

    I believe in God but people are used to exaggerate. Christians have to believe in God, love each other but stop thinking and believing in this shit!!!!!!!!!

  • all of you totally miss the point ,you are to love not quarrel, what is this bantering about, you totally dont get it ....I feel sorry for you, there are many ways to God, all religions lead to him, one God many ways to worship=LOVE God Love others! stop fighting enough already!

  • @LoveNFaith07 WELL SAID BROTHER

  • sry 2 say dis nd sound so mean bt U ALL HAVE NO RITE 2 JUDG ANY1 Like wat is said in da bible "take the log out of your eye before you take the splinter out of anyone else's"

    no 1 has rite 2 jdge nt even da chrch in excomunicating ppl ONLY GOD nd dat doesNOT incld us we wer taut by Jesus 2love1anothrND FORGIVE wev takn his wrds nd trnd dem around

  • It's crap like this that gives disbelivers amunition to distrust us. clearly anyone can see anything in the clouds they want. and anyone can photoshop any picture they want. Angels or demons, or aliens and UFO's it's a sin to lie even if it's FOR God.

  • Right....

  • Maria Regina della Pace, prega per noi.

    Mary Queen of the Peace, pray for us.

  • Beautiful!

  • what is the name of this music?

  • Mary has been very specific about what she wants people to do. They have become known as the 5 Stones:

    1) Prayer

    2) Fasting

    3) Bible

    4) Confession

    5) Holy Eucharist

    No wonder the Vatican has never said uttered a negative word about Medjugorje, when you consider what this, along with all the conversions and thousdands of new vocations to priesthood, have done for the Church.

  • Cardinal Schönborn told Cardinal Ratzinger that if Medjugorje were closed, he would also have to close the Seminary in Vienna, because the majority of those candidates had received their call to the priesthood through Medjugorje. To this, Cardinal Ratzinger replied: "Closing Medjugorje is not even a question!"

  • @pbaylis1 - This just proves how many misguided Catholics like Cardinal Schonborn & his seminarians have put their faith in an alleged apparition (which has been condemned three times by the Bishop(s) of Mostar and the former Yugoslavian Bishops Conference) rather in Christ and His One True Church.

    Sad...

  • The Madonna always stresses that there is but one God and that people have enforced unnatural separation. One cannot truly believe, be a true Christian, if he does not respect other religions as well." "Seer" Ivanka Ivankovic

    "The Madonna said that religions are separated in the earth, but the people of all religions are accepted by her Son." "seer" ivanka ivankovic

  • Question: "Is the Blessed Mother calling all people to be Catholic?"

    Answer: "No. The Blessed Mother says all religions are dear to her and her Son." "Seer" Vicka Ivankovic

    i think that says it all, complete apostasy. the holy mother would never make these statements or claims, Medjugorje, Bayside, all works of Satan as they contradict the infallible teaching of the church.

  • The Catholic Church agrees. People who are converted by Medjugorje make their own choice. I don't think Our Blessed Mother has ever asked that anyone become Catholic. But anyone converted through Medjugorje would NOT be likely to continue to hold such beliefs as:

    1) Mary is just a woman, no-one special and certainly not the Queen of Heaven.

    2) We don't need the Pope (remember, Mary also said "Have him consider himself the father of all

    mankind and not only of Christians.")

  • the message of medjugorje is heretical. it contradicts the infallible teaching of the catholic church. our holy mother would not say that all religions and churches are accepted in heaven. this would cause the destruction of the catholic faith because it would no longer be needed. it would also mean that christ lied when he stated that only through me can you find salvation. it would make his holy sacrifice and communion null and void.

    THIS IS THE WORK OF SATAN, NOT GOD OR MARY.

  • I doubt it. I just gave you a quote where she says that the pope should consider himself the father of all christiains, indeed mankind. If that's not good for the Catholic Church, I don't what is. Look, Mary doesn't need to tell people to come to the Catholic Church. It's an automatic response to anyone believing in Medjugorje.

  • The Church says that we should acknowledge the seeds of truth in all religions. That's essentially what Mary's reiterating. People are usually in a particular religion because of family or cultural situations. God understands if you were born to a household of 20 generations of Islam. I'm sure he looks at the heart. And if He thinks they're in the wrong religion, He's capable of leading them, don't you think? We are not the ones to judge on these matters. I think the RCC realises this now.

  • Probably the most important thing is that Our Lady actually mentioned particular religions, when she said: "We are all children of God. The Moslems and the Orthodox for the same reason as Catholics are equal before my son and me. " She didn't mention Buddhists or Hindus or Scientology. But three particular religions. Why? (continued)

  • We need to remember the political climate in which Mary made these statements. Our Lady has made it clear that the apparitions and messages of Medjugorje are not limited to Catholics only. We are all her children, she tells us. She made the statements when pressed by the Croatian visionaries about the oppression and persecution of the Serbian Orthodox and Muslims in their own country.

  • The Franciscan Fr. Jozo Zovko has become known as the Eucharistic Priest because he never stops proclaiming the Eucharist as the solution to everything.

    So, people who are going to Medjugorje are being expose to the Catholic Church and to the Eucharist as well as all the other sacrements and prayer of the rosary.

  • I think people now know this is not an apparition from God and those that do are still disobeying what Benedict said in the 80's - DON'T GO ON PILGRIMAGES TO MEDJUGORJE! What more do they need?

  • You are evidently just starting out in this aren't you. You really do need to get your facts straight. It is very embarrassing to keep seeing these new people come along all excited about what they've been reading on conspiracy theory websites and start splurting all over YouTube and everywhere else, making the problem even worse. Look, I will personally correct every lie you've been told, with evidence not hearsay. Let's start with what you've just said:

  • Please provide the document or website where it is said that Benedict told everyone not to go to Medjugorje. Don't you even know what the official pronouncement of the Vatican is? We've known it since 1991. The Zadar declaration of 1991 clearly permits pilgrimages to Medjugorje. Not only that but the Vatican made a provision that every pilgrim is entitled to receive pastoral care while on pilgrimage. So, why, oh why, do you think Benedict doesn't want people to go to Medjugorje?

  • happy people. but why is Hristos written in English?

  • its funny how "christ" was written in english...when people there dont speak that language lol....

  • my thoughts exactly... although some quite a few speak english

    and if i saw anything written in the sky i'd be freaking out no matter the language lol

  • Christ is Christ ..His name is the same in any language ...

  • no its not....christ actualy has nothing to do with Jesus btw.

    christ started to be used long after his death, and it has greek orgins...christ means prophet in greek....that proves that christ is not the same in every language and that it has nothing in common with jesus....

  • For stunning images of the Virgin Mary and Christ in nature see my You Tube channel 'gerendazee' - the best show I made is 'Dominatio Iudicium Per Deus.' Leave me some comments. Professional Color Prints of my work at the 81/2 in. x 11in size are for sale and even available to potential retail venders at wholesale and very affordable prices... If you're interested, if you email me I'll offer samples and pricing... See all 7 of my YT videos on my channel and let me know your thoughts~ C.D. Clay

  • 1) - That is not Christ in a cloud formation! - Looks more like Alan Sugar! - But Our Lord wil come in the Clouds of Heaven on the Last Day to judge these deceivers!

    2) That is not an Angel in a cloud formation - some people have seen Homer Simson in the clouds!

    3) "Christ" written in the sky is OBVIOUSLY FAKE!

    4) That is Vicka but no angelic fiery arrow! She is a false visionary!

    5)"Photo of the gospa" is another Fake!

    Medugorje is a FALSE apparition!

  • Medjugorje is a TRUE apparition .. Writing " fake" without saying how , or why , and in fact sayiing nothing ..doesn't cut it mate .. Medjugorje is REAL ..deal with it

  • I have made it intrinsically clear many times, on many pages, why Medjugorje is a false apparition!!!!

  • Direct me to a few

  • Try other Medjugorje videos, I can't remember which ones I have commented on. Also, see the comments on my channel.

  • VIDEO PROOF THAT "SEERS ARE NOT IN ECSTASY!!!!

    PASTE INTO YOUTUBE:

    Medjugorje senza maschera. 14 gennaio 1985 (video 2)

  • Sorry, three scientific teams have all separately studied the visionaries and proven that they are in an ecstasy state.

  • You're talking about the Jean Louis finger poke incident. So, are you saying that Mary did not allow Vicka to move her head backwards in self-defence even while in ecstasy? Note that it was not a violent jerk backwards, just a gentle rock and then she carried on as if nothing had happened. Regardless, three scientific teams have studied them over a period of YEARS (not just one apparition) with all kinds of electric shock and light tests and they all agree that these visionaries are not faking.

  • You are obviously just of bad will!!

    The video is clear a reaction to a finger poked in the eyes and cannot be mistaken for a movement to "prevent Mary from dropping the child Jesus"!!!!

    Your attempt to justify the "visionary" by saying that Mary allowed "Vicka to move her head backwards in self-defence" is refuted by the story concocted by Vicka herself!!!

  • People must be doing a lot of things around Vicka. Surely, God has the power to simply allow Vicka to rock her head backwards while allowing her to continue her conversation with Mary.

  • Conspiracy theorists love to say that Vicka "concocted" a story. As I understand it, Vicka attended the question and answer session directly after the vision, with no time to concoct. The question asked was whether she could recall anything that would make her startle. She was not asked "why did you rock your head back and blink?" Naturally, you would try to think of something that concerned you during the apparition. Maybe she WAS honestly concerned about baby Jesus falling from Mary's arms.

  • I believe Vicka really didn't see Jean Louis' finger consciously. I believe she was allowed to rock backwards. However, I can't be sure about whether she was coached by a Franciscan. After all, they were young and impressionable in 1981. But, regardless, THREE SCIENTIFIC TEAMS HAVE STUDIED the visionaries with much more conclusive tests that Jean Louis' test. None of them concluded fraud.

  • "I believe Vicka really didn't see Jean Louis' finger consciously" - That she did, is evident from the video, even a child could see that!!!!

  • You seem to be ignoring the three scientific teams whose tests were a good deal more scientific than Jean Louis' little test. And they were conducted over MANY apparitions and several years. The scientific facts point to them NOT being frauds. So, I'll believe the scientists and, consequently I'll also give Vicka the benefit of the doubt and come to any of the following conclusions:

    (continued next paragrah)

  • 1) Vicka DID see the finger poke, but God or Mary allowed her to, without interrupting their communication too much.

    2) Vicka did NOT see the finger poke CONSCIOUSLY, i.e. her entire conscious focus was on Mary, but she was subconsciously involved in getting out of the way.

    3) if she was lying about what happened, then she may have been coached by a Franciscan to respond a certain way against her own better judgement. To me, that's human error and doesn't stain the visions.

  • This simple test was used by the Church before technology to test existed, and it clearly exposes the "visionaries" for the liars that they are!!!

  • "Maybe she WAS honestly concerned about baby Jesus falling from Mary's arms." - Of all the idiotic attempts to defend the obvious and blatant deception, this has to be the most ridiculous!!!

    Since when has Our Lady ever been about to drop the Child Jesus. The very notion borders on heresy!

    Also, why did this happen at the exact moment the fingers were pushed towards her eyes? Conincidence - I think not!!!!

  • Well, I think you're rushing to judgement. You remind me of the chanting crowds during the witch hunts of the middle ages "Burn them! Burn them!". Why not ask Vicka herself what really happened. You may indeed get the reply "I lied and I saw Jean Louis finger." But, what would that prove? Simply that she lied on THAT occasion and probably regrets it. does that make them full-time liars and frauds? Well, hardly. Remember, this video was in the very first years, back in the early 80's.

  • That the "visionaries" are lying is evident to all from the video. A good tree cannot bear bad fruit. To say that she may have faked some apparitions, is to admit that she is a liar. If she faked one, she faked them all!!!! St Bernadette, or the seers of Fatima did not fake apparitions.

  • I seem to remember that the visionaries of Fatima were hardly saints either. I think Our Lady said to that the little boy Francisco would have to say "many rosaries" before going to heaven. Children are children. Now, the Medjugorje visionaries are all adults and bear great fruits. Look at some of the recent interviews with Vicka and see for yourself. They all have stopped smoking and spend their days in God's service.

  • @pbaylis1 if the children of Fatima were not saintly, why did Venerable JP II declare Jacinta and Francisco Blesseds?

  • @pbaylis1 if the children of Fatima were not saintly, why did Venerable JP II declare Jacinta and Francisco Blesseds? also why is Jacinta incorrupt?

  • "Why not ask Vicka herself what really happened" - Vicka is on tape (Video & audio) saying in the presense of witnesses that Mary was about to drop Jesus, and that she pulled away from the fingers of the frenchman at exactly the same time out of coincidence. (If you believe that, you will believe anything!)

    Anyway, this evidence is only the tip of the iceberg!!!!

  • I mean ask her TODAY. You can actually do that. Go to Medjugorje. Vicka accepts pigrims every day. You can ask her personally. How about doing that before jumping to any more conclusions. Because until you know the truth, you aren't doing anything else except breaking the 8th Commandment - Thou shalt not bear false witness against thy neighbour. I don't think Jesus has ever behaved the way you do. At the moment, you're a bad example of a Christian.

  • hold on for a second, you call me a bad christian because i am willing to speak the truth? now who is bearing false witness? i come her not to attack personally but to warn. the messages at medjugorje go against fundemental catholic teaching. the church is INFALLIBLE in its teaching of the faith. there is no truth outside the catholic church, sounds like you have been corrupted by v2 and its heretical teachings.

  • every church council and papl encyclical prior to v2 called and required that people profess and hold the catholic faith, because with out it you go to hell. outside the church their is no salvation. prior to v2, other religions where considered to be creations and lies of Satan. these are all infallible church teachings. that means they are true and cannot be contradicted, and must be believed without question. only through a belief in christ and his church will you be saved.

  • a true apparition of mary or any other holy figure would not contradict infallible teaching because infallible teaching comes from god and god does not contradict himself. these are the works of satan. as our lord stated many times, many will be decieved by many signs and wonders, so great as to decieve EVEN THE ELECT.

    i was never talking about the person recieving the messages, if other people want to bash them, let them confess and do penance. all i am saying, is that this is a deception.

  • EXILEDFENIAN......sometimes it`s better to shut your mouth and be thought a fool, than to open it and remove all doubt. If you want to see deception and hear what fals prophets have to say, all you have to do is look on youtube. It`s infested with them. I was just on "Gloryboundkev`s" channel page, he claims he has visions given to him by God. So Yes, your deceptions are closer than you think. Forget Medjugorje, just look around you.

  • so when the apparition states that all religions are accepted and equal in heaven, does this not cause a contradiction to what the church states? does this not completly destroy the need for the catholic church? is this not heretical? decide for yourself. tell me to shut my mouth and all you will get is a flood. you want to debate. then lets debate

  • The Apparition did not state that all religions or equal.The apparition to jakov stated that not all Religions or equal.However all men or equal before God.Yes she states you don't have to be catholic to be saved,however for Catholics much has been given so much will be asked

  • that right there is a contradiction. the church has always professed, that in order to be saved one must first hold the catholic faith. this is infallible teaching. god does not contradict himself, the only anger i have is for those who tempt or missrepresent the true words or intentions of god.

  • .[33] But the divine design of salvation embraces all men, and those who without fault on their part do not know the Gospel of Christ and His Church, but seek God sincerely, and under the influence of grace endeavor to do His will as recognized through the promptings of their conscience, they, in a number known only to God, can obtain salvation.[34] New advent

  • true, this is what we call invincible ignorance. i have no disagreement with this doctrine. but what you fail to understand is that invinicble ignorance, especially in todays world, is a mirical in of itself. also, you cannot say that a person who has been told about christ, told his gospel and knows about his true church can be invincibly ignorant. they have been shown the truth, and have denied it. why do you think the missionaries worked so hard?

  • this is what is exactly wrong with vatican 2 theology. they twist divine scripture and doctrine, into heresy. they have led you to believe that everyone goes to heaven, regardless of who or what they are. that goes against the entire christian foundation. how many non-believers actually follow gods rules? almost none, seeing as they are only a few of his believers that do. only through the catholic church, can one find salvation, because only the church has the truth

  • in some recent personal comments sent to me, you have stated that you are a catholic and yet, believe that all people go to heaven, regardless of their faith. you also stated that i contradicted myself when i said that the message at medjurje destroyed the need for the catholic faith. you said this becuase if all religions are equal in heaven, THEN THE CATHOLIC CHURCH IS JUST AS GOOD AS THE REST OF THEM.

    lets see what our church fathers INFALLIBLY taught on this issue.

    continued...

  • CONTINUED.....

    POPE EUGENE IV, COUNCIL OF FLORENCE, CANTATE DOMINO, 1441, EX CATHEDRA: THE HOLY ROMAN CHURCH FIRMLY BELIEVES, PROFESSES AND PREACHES THAT ALL WHO ARE OUTSIDE THE CATHOLIC CHURCH, NOT ONLY PAGANS BUT ALSO JEWS OR HERETICS AND SCHISMATICS, CANNOT SHARE IN ETERNAL LIFE AND WILL GO INTO THE EVERLASTING FIRE WHICH WAS PREPARED FOR THE DEVIL AND HIS ANGELS, UNLESS THEY ARE JOINED TO THE CHURCH BEFORE THE END OF THEIR LIVES.

    Wow, seems like our infallible church is pretty clear

  • you see, god created the catholic church. his only church. he gave authority to peter, to maintain it and to bind people to it. if it did not matter what faith you belong to, then why would christ create the church? infact..why would he have even came, if it did not matter? you see, you think this a very nice message of unity but by simply believing in it, you have destroyed your faith in christ as the only saviour, and the need for the catholic church.

  • Has i have proven you misquote and distort the facts.Your full of anger and hate i'll pray for you

  • you have proven nothing. lets examine some qoutes from the supposed virgin mary:

    " The madonna said that all religions are seperated on earth, but the people of all religions are accepted by her son."

    "Is the blessed mother calling all people to be catholic? No, the blessed mother says that all religions are dear to her and her son."

    " One cannot truly believe, be a true christian, if he does not respect all other religions as well."

    need i say more.

  • All are called to Catholicism; it is the one true Church, begun by Christ himself. End of story.

  • all you have proven, is that you refuse to accept catholic teaching. pray for yourself, and for all of the poor souls decieved by the vatican 2 anti-church. let me ask you...we do you try so hard to defend something that your leadership itself refuses to defend? what are you defending? when you profess the faith, for what reason are doing it, if your own church teaches that religion no longer matters. that all men are saved and all religions are a road to heaven?

  • You need prayer,your twisted and full of Anger and hate.I'll pray for you like it or not

  • @pbaylis1 Well, I don't see if you realise that you are actually judging iotaunam1 as well... You're a bit too contradictory in your posts. And the patch up excuse of the Virgin Mary on the verge of droping the Child Jesus... that was hilarious actually. Like that happens often to any mother... so yes, it would make sense that it would happen to the Virgin Mary... I'm a Catholic, as cathequist actually, and I trully don't believe in these "apparitions".

  • I've myself experienced that God excist: cause at age of 16 I was really deppressed that summer probably was the summer of 2003 and I prayed to God that he would take me out of this depression and he came to me. I fealt a warm feeling and a happy feeling in my stomeck + I actually fealt a wormth like the sun shining on my skin indoors at evening (in a corner where no sun can shine in) and then it spread all over my body. And it has continued this last 6 years. God is real and he cares!

  • Ah, isn't it just convenient that word "Christ" is written in english rather than croatian language???

  • Perhaps it was in an english country and he wanted to be understood.. Stuff like that happens (But hte christ clouds could be photoshoping..) I heard about a woman up in north of sweden though she saw letters of fire in the sky; it was a passage from the bible. That she shoulds stop toiling (stressing out) and be at peace in Gods grace and his arms was the message don't remember witch passage though..

  • Anyone interested in purchasing property in Medugorje can contact me by messaging me on my youtube account. My family is orignally from Medugorje and were born and rasied in the village prior to and after the visions. If you are interested in purchasing land in Medugorje please contact me here on youtube for further information.

  • These are neat pictures. Thank you for posting.

  • I don't think that Jesus would manifest himself writing in the sky 'Jesus Christ'... or in the clouds see 'him' crucify.. good fantasy activity.. but...

    I totally believe in God and Jesus.. but not Human's manipulations... that's another thing... sometimes men have too much immaginary activity...

  • 40,000 plus messages and apparitions here, in comparision to Our Lady at real apparition sites only coming with serious messages to the world of the dangers of losing your souls for ETERNITY. But here she 'rains peace' on every religion and even talks of football matches? Google what happened at VaticanII and how the 6 protestants wrote the new mass and the cover up with the real Lucia who died in 1949. Time of apostacy-In the new church there is no danger of Hell and purgatory WRONG! Wake UP!

  • Good Catholics should not believe that Our Lady would appear with messages every day. There is so much proof of lies including audio interveiw evidence.' In the end even the elect will be deceived.' Lucias 'real' third secret (in Apocylpse' was to warn us of the apostacy in the Church which occured at VaticanII when the new mass (partially written by 6 protestants)was introduced changing the Catholic words of the consecration of the Host and almost everything else.Find a Latin Mass.End Times.

  • christ is definitely not manifested in the clouds and this whole video is retarted and anyone who enjoys it is a brainwashed troll.

  • wow this is wonderful soooooo wounderful. and i love medjugorje. i am going to go there again this summer. i can't wait!!!!!! it will be my 2 time going.

  • did u see anything the first time u went?

  • Gospa is the Blessed Virgin Mary, mother of Christ.

  • Gracias por las imagenes. Thank U for the images...

  • who's gospa

  • two words

    PHOTO. SHOP.

  • ܘܫܠܡܗ ܕܐܠܗܐ ܗܘ ܕܪܒ ܡܢ ܟܠ ܡܕܥ ܢܢܛܪ ܠܒܘܬܟܘܢ ܘܡܕܥܝܟܘܢ ܒܝܫܘܥ ܡܫܝܚܐ ܀

    και η ειρηνη του θεου η υπερεχουσα παντα νουν φρουρησει τας καρδιας υμων και τα νοηματα υμων εν χριστω ιησου

    Et pax Dei, quæ exuperat omnem sensum, custodiat corda vestra, et intelligentias vestras in Christo Jesu.

  • Beautiful. Thanks for putting this together.

  • the bit where Jesus is written in english is the same when the apostales where in upper room and everyone was baptised in the power of the spirit and everyone spoke in tongues, but each knew what the other was saying, as they where talking. then this could be the same as when the name of jesus was in cloud, the people in medjugorje would have been able to see it in there own language .i am not saying this is what happened, but it could. if the lord wills it so.

  • fallroadirishman,at Pentecost, the Holy Spirit descended on Mary, apostles and followers. Some spoke in tongues, some spoke in various foreign languages, because those that spoke in foreign languages went outside to talk to many foreign Jews from various countries that gathered outside. In St. Paul's Epistle, he states,"what good is it to speak in tongues if no one can interpret what is said". I had the urge to speak in tongues with others, I wouldn't, I like to know what I say. Gods omnipotent.

  • jesus on the cross called thomas to him and said behold your mother,mother behold your son. in revealations our lady is given the roll to crush satan with her heal, if Jesus to whom is god allows his mother to come unto this earth why is it hard for you to understand this. if you truly belive in god then you should belive he has the power to do his will on anything that needs to be done .