Rick's and Richard's upper register voices had certain similarities early-on with The Band, but less so as Richard's voice coarsened over the years. This song is an example of that similarity, and this one happens to feature Richard on lead vocals. Rick would have sung it well.
Wikipedia states that Manuel sang this as well. Also, to the person to thought that Manuel's voice was deeper; it did get deeper as his alcoholism progressed and he was all fucked up on coke and heroin and the like.
Listen to 2:37. Thats defenitely Manuel. No doubt. Danko didn't sing high notes like that. Danko's phrasing was way different. This Manuel all week and twice on sunday.
with no doubt what so ever this is rick singing, there is no two ways abut it dont be an idiot and claim other wise ok?why do people claim to know things that they do not. if you know the band than you know who is singing
@johnnythunder6565 actually this song was written and sung by Richard Manuel. How did you put it..."if you know The Band you know who is singing"....enough said.
C'mon! This is definitely Richard Manuel singing! It's clear in his falsetto and Rick has a raspier voice. I have a demo version of this where it is just him on vocals and piano. It's gotta be him!
Rick's and Richard's upper register voices had certain similarities early-on with The Band, but less so as Richard's voice coarsened over the years. This song is an example of that similarity, and this one happens to feature Richard on lead vocals. Rick would have sung it well.
Stephanjnj 2 months ago
Wikipedia states that Manuel sang this as well. Also, to the person to thought that Manuel's voice was deeper; it did get deeper as his alcoholism progressed and he was all fucked up on coke and heroin and the like.
aguineapig 5 months ago
Listen to 2:37. Thats defenitely Manuel. No doubt. Danko didn't sing high notes like that. Danko's phrasing was way different. This Manuel all week and twice on sunday.
aguineapig 5 months ago 2
@aguineapig -absolutely.....
Markgr122 3 months ago
Love this version!
JLevy423 6 months ago
I prefer the Basement Tapes version, this is too fast & the circus organ sounds silly
jbolio888 6 months ago
This is Richard Manuel I bet my balls!!
fastrelief 7 months ago
with no doubt what so ever this is rick singing, there is no two ways abut it dont be an idiot and claim other wise ok?why do people claim to know things that they do not. if you know the band than you know who is singing
johnnythunder6565 9 months ago
@johnnythunder6565 this must be pretty embarrassing for you then buddy. you're an idiot
tdawg1294 1 month ago
@johnnythunder6565 actually this song was written and sung by Richard Manuel. How did you put it..."if you know The Band you know who is singing"....enough said.
iangcunningham 1 month ago
with no doubt what so ever this is rick singing, there is no two ways abut it dont be an idiot and claim other wise ok?
johnnythunder6565 9 months ago
with no doubt what so ever this is rick singing, there is no two ways abut it dont be an idiot and claim otherwishe ok?
johnnythunder6565 9 months ago
This is Rick Danko singing!
stevelandy 9 months ago
C'mon! This is definitely Richard Manuel singing! It's clear in his falsetto and Rick has a raspier voice. I have a demo version of this where it is just him on vocals and piano. It's gotta be him!
sagarryankyle 11 months ago 2
This is inferior to the Basement Tapes version...
Didgeridoozie 1 year ago 6
PERFECT!
Marcellinha1202 1 year ago
Thats richard singin100%
hwy49 1 year ago
I thought Richard Manuel had a deeper voice. Heard him sing at The Last Waltz "Shape I'm In"
luisexuperion 1 year ago
I think it's pretty obvious that it's Richard Manuel singing.
needianame 1 year ago
its richard singing c'mon now
jtweedy38 1 year ago
danko is singing
quadstack 1 year ago
Is Richard Manuel singing? Or Danko?
cantarooots 1 year ago
@cantarooots
this is Richard Manuel....all the way....vocals and piano
212cowhand 1 year ago
@212cowhand \thank you sire
cantarooots 1 year ago
i remember this from the basement tapes....
TEMPmichaelhansen 1 year ago 2
Thanks for posting!
titostacos 2 years ago