I never actually completey blame Peyton - because Brooke did alot of bad things in season four yes. But don't for one second try and justify anything that Peyton had done by saying Brooke should have known in the first season. she ASKED Peyton and her 'honest' bestfriend said NO. Brooke did nothing wrong. When Peyton admitted Lucas, it was the way she said she wouldn't do anything about it that got me, cause she already had; bleeding or not. and OBV you would freak out like B did, given history.
I don't understand why so many people defend Brooke but blame Peyton. Truth be told, Peyton was absolutely wrong to kiss Lucas. There's no denying that. But Brooke is no angel. She knew how Peyton felt about Lucas (or she should have known, since she was her best friend, if she had actually been paying attention to someone other than herself she would know), and she still dated him. She put a guy before her friendship, also. And she was jealous of Peyton's deeper connection with Lucas.
@JackLivesTogether Well Brooke was in love with Lucas too. You can't forget that she wrote many letters to him over the summer that she never gave to him. If anything, this is mostly Lucas' fault as he tore them apart.
@1SvetlanaOffcial Peyton always liked him; she was just scared; Brooke was just to oblivious to see that. You can tell how Peyton feels and Brooke sub consciously ignores it. In season 1 when Peyton finally opens up about it being weird for her Brooke thinks she's talking about being the third wheel. Peyton liked Lucas BEFORE Brooke did or before Brooke let her feelings known. She even set both Nathan and Peyton up in the first season to make sure Peyton didn't go after Lucas.
I don't hate brooke but with the whole competition over Lucas Peyton should win. And brooke was wrong to say those things about her mother. I love this video!! Thanks for putting it up!!!
and peyton had EVERY intention of stealing him - She said to brooke when she was "honest" Im not gonna do anything about it - yet she had already kissed him. duh, and then throughout the first 6-7 episodes of season four peytons getting herself in the middle and questioning lucas' love for brooke. DON'T FORGET; Brooke gave Lucas up for peyton. so yeah, brookes the better half.
@BLAlwayss I know this is over a year ago< but I still want to comment. There is a simple fact: you can NOT steal a person. It's not like Peyton hogtied Lucas and forced herself on him. And with the whole kiss thing, Peyton thought she was dying. Anf you must have missed the moments in season 4 where Peyton was trying to get Lucas and Brooke back together, after he told her that it was Brooke that he wanted. Brooke never gave Lucas up for Peyton. If you look back in OTH history...
@BLAlwayss ...Brooke has put all of her boyfriends in front of Peyton, who was supposed to be her best friend. First, there was Lucas, who lets not forget she KNEW that Peyton had feelings for (she even commented on it a few times throughout s1), but decided to try to get him instead and tried to get her best friend back together with her (Peyton) jerk of an ex-boyfriend. Then there was Felix. When Peyton was going through all that drama with Jake and the coccaine situation, Brooke was
@BLAlwayss off benefiting with Felix. And come s3, she's all about Lucas again. And when Peyton realized that she still had feelings for Lucas, she told Brooke on the spot and didn't want to hide anything from her. Brooke was the one who started lashing out and making fun of Peyton's moms deaths, which is a huge no no. And I understand that Brooke was upset. But a ten year friendship one boy comes in between and your best defense is throw a parent in the face. That is WRONG. Whether or...
hmmmm. I hate how peyton gets made out to be innocent. to be honest, peyton and nathans relationship was a sham - she didn't love him. brooke was in love with lucas both times peyton did stuff. PLUS, she wasn't "honest" with brooke, because she had already kissed lucas on the school schooting, that is way brooke cut her out of her life.
she makes fun of her mom's death because in one episode when haley was having pregnant problems and they were all in the car brooke says "well anything peyton loves dies, see dead motheres one and two."
@g1m2z3 She once said "Hi I'm peyton and everyone I love dies, mom 1 and mom 2" or something. And she also said "your I love yous send people to their grave."
this is how i knew that there friendship was gonna make it. Everyone knows that girls who hate one another never get physical they just bitch about each other behind their backs. Haha u know its love when you can go in with the nails, pulling hair!!!! hahaha :)
Ok I like peyton but I love brooke. There is just something about her strength(maybe not in this video) and talent. I mean peytons cool but she stole brookes boyfriend.Twice.
God the acting in OTH. Story lines might not always be the best but oh my god these people can act. Seriously, I am starting to believe that Tree Hill is real and that this actually happens. even if they`re not, they are really truly real to me.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
this scene was trying to make people feel bad for peyton. i did not. peyton did brooke so much worse than brooke did to her. pucas sucks so bad and they were very self absorbed at least Naley were still concern for others as was brucas.
i can understand why both of them are mad : One steals her best friends boyfriend , and the other makes fun of her best friends dead mother . i LOVE breyton :) wonderful acting , and it makes you feel like you dont know whose side to be on . just like real friendship drama !
ok yeah brooke and peyton both have good points but honestly which one is worse , messing around with someone elses boyfriend or making fun of your best friends dead mother ?
and peyton had no intention the second time when she told brooke that she still had feelings for lucas on trying to steal him , she was just trying to be honest .
They were making fun of each other earlier in this season, where Peyton mocked Brooke, saying she stole Peyton's artwork for her clothing line. Brooke responded by mocking Peyton, saying that anyone who loved Peyton ended up dead, then referring to her dead moms.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
hahahahaha and you're obviously stupid for not understanding that I did understand but was just teasing you, hahahahah "get out more" seriously wtf do you know about me or my life?! i bet i have more friend than you have or ever will have for that mather.. you're really getting on my nerves, I mean how STUPID can you get?
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
hahahaha seriously do you really think i would read all? haha i don't give a fuck about you or your opinion got it? :S:S fuck off and stop being so annyoing gosh! Wtf is wrong with you? trying to explain to me how i should be or not be.. seriously if someone needs to get a life it's YOU and stop analyze me, it's kind of creepy..
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Anywaay i may sound like am 10 years old but i i'm not the one who says "asshole" and "stupid bitch".. Seriously just drop the whole I'm-so-mature thing cause it doesn't work on me
@emd1021 Okayy, Brooke did something far, far worse than Peyton ever did......she made fun of her mother's death and Brooke knew how much that affected Peyton but she did it anyway.......how could you make fun of your bestfriend's mother's death???? Especially since Brooke was there when she died??
she did while she thought she was dying! sure its not okay but you would have done that too admit it! but cutting her out for that is just really harsh of brooke PLUS brooke didnt know about the kiss when she told peyton that their friendship is over.
she did go after him ONCE. the other time she was the most loyal friend anyone could ever be. she didnt go after him until they were completely done. and she kept her promise. brooke just cut her out of her life. and there was really no reasonable explanation.
very "loyal", she kissed him again....seriously no friend should do that, and in my opinion it was alright that she cut her out, but anyway i think peyton and lucas are good togehter now, even though i love brucas, but it was just not meant to be, i guess...
im pretty sure if you were dying and you were sitting there with someone youloved you would kiss them too. peyton and brooke both made big mistakes but this "entire fight" was definitely not all peytons fault
i dont like peyton either but the common denominator is lucas he chose peyton he had a choice and he chose peyton if i was broke idk if i could get over that yes i wish they were together but broke cant make him love her ive been in that position and its horrible not being picked
i hated that brooke said "you win" to peyton. lucas is not a prize. he's a human being with feelings and its not peyton's fault he's always been more in love with her than he ever was with brooke or lindsey.
OK so did anyone notice that it looked like brooke wasnt wearing shoes in this whole scene. I was bored watchin it one day and i rewinding it a feww times and couldnt figure it out??? lol
brooke is such a bitch sometimes. you never joke about death mothers, that is sooo mean! and what about the secret code : never date your best friends ex?? i know i never could.
brooke is cool but everyone knows that it's all leyton.the minute leyton stopped in s1 brooke had to take lucas away and then when they went behind her back she's all MY ex boyfriend.
and if it's brooke vs. peyton peyton can sooo take her.
yeah, i remember that. When they were drving to or from a cheer comp. and rach sugested role playing. I laughed when Haley imatated rach haha it was funny. I just thought maybe she said more becuase it said punch lineS.
they were in the car on the way to a basketball game and they were playing roles and peyton said something mean while imitating brooks so brooke said "oh ya did i mention that if u kno me u'll die soon, see mothers 1 and 2" and then peyton and her started hitting each other..it was intense..
omg my favorite peyton scene ever!!! like everytime she talks i cry lol she gives amazing speeches and in this scene i am tottaly on team peyton b/c that was mean of brooke to say that about her dead mom
Brooke est assez cruelle sur ce coup... ces deux la ne devraient pas se battre, c'est triste. Elles sont comme des soeurs. Lucas est venu tout foutre en l'air malgre lui.
I never actually completey blame Peyton - because Brooke did alot of bad things in season four yes. But don't for one second try and justify anything that Peyton had done by saying Brooke should have known in the first season. she ASKED Peyton and her 'honest' bestfriend said NO. Brooke did nothing wrong. When Peyton admitted Lucas, it was the way she said she wouldn't do anything about it that got me, cause she already had; bleeding or not. and OBV you would freak out like B did, given history.
BLAlwayss 2 months ago
haha brooke is such a baby here love peyton :) dont get me wrong i like brooke but i am all team leyton
ilovetrueblood007 2 months ago
I don't understand why so many people defend Brooke but blame Peyton. Truth be told, Peyton was absolutely wrong to kiss Lucas. There's no denying that. But Brooke is no angel. She knew how Peyton felt about Lucas (or she should have known, since she was her best friend, if she had actually been paying attention to someone other than herself she would know), and she still dated him. She put a guy before her friendship, also. And she was jealous of Peyton's deeper connection with Lucas.
AuroraClaire94 2 months ago 2
This makes me so sad to realize OTH will be ending soon :( It's literally been my life!
SweetDezire25 3 months ago 3
what's creepy is that Psycho Derek is watching all of this
tregorn 5 months ago
@BLAlwayss I agree with everything you said! I
seventeenboi 6 months ago
@JackLivesTogether Well Brooke was in love with Lucas too. You can't forget that she wrote many letters to him over the summer that she never gave to him. If anything, this is mostly Lucas' fault as he tore them apart.
seventeenboi 6 months ago
fucking gayyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy
hotboxfoxtrot 7 months ago
I wouldve bulldozed that bitch with my COCK, making fun of someones death is unforgivable
ItsMeAgainXD 9 months ago
i miss peyton from one tree hill heaps!
doona36 10 months ago
Anyone else picture them in g strings
altNaleyForever 11 months ago
peyton can win, cuz brookes got julian! mohhahahahaha
SannahCandyy 1 year ago
@1SvetlanaOffcial Peyton always liked him; she was just scared; Brooke was just to oblivious to see that. You can tell how Peyton feels and Brooke sub consciously ignores it. In season 1 when Peyton finally opens up about it being weird for her Brooke thinks she's talking about being the third wheel. Peyton liked Lucas BEFORE Brooke did or before Brooke let her feelings known. She even set both Nathan and Peyton up in the first season to make sure Peyton didn't go after Lucas.
JackLivesTogether 1 year ago
gahah, I love the sound Brooke makes when Peyton lifts her up **,
emilielis 1 year ago
It´s funny that Brooke is the one with the big mouth but when it comes to fighting she wouldn´t win against Peyton!
Elefanti 1 year ago 2
@Elefanti Well, it looks as though Brooke was kind of holding back in this fight because she is Peyton's friend and she did not want to hurt her.
JAY4LIFE01 1 year ago
@Elefanti That's because Brooke didn't want to actually fight her. She was obviously holding back.
RockedHisBones 1 year ago
I don't hate brooke but with the whole competition over Lucas Peyton should win. And brooke was wrong to say those things about her mother. I love this video!! Thanks for putting it up!!!
leytonlova3 1 year ago
PEYTON, WINNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN
rawrclaire 1 year ago
and peyton had EVERY intention of stealing him - She said to brooke when she was "honest" Im not gonna do anything about it - yet she had already kissed him. duh, and then throughout the first 6-7 episodes of season four peytons getting herself in the middle and questioning lucas' love for brooke. DON'T FORGET; Brooke gave Lucas up for peyton. so yeah, brookes the better half.
BLAlwayss 1 year ago 5
@BLAlwayss I know this is over a year ago< but I still want to comment. There is a simple fact: you can NOT steal a person. It's not like Peyton hogtied Lucas and forced herself on him. And with the whole kiss thing, Peyton thought she was dying. Anf you must have missed the moments in season 4 where Peyton was trying to get Lucas and Brooke back together, after he told her that it was Brooke that he wanted. Brooke never gave Lucas up for Peyton. If you look back in OTH history...
melopez06 4 months ago 2
@melopez06 I completely agree. :D
Bratzgirl100 2 months ago
@BLAlwayss ...Brooke has put all of her boyfriends in front of Peyton, who was supposed to be her best friend. First, there was Lucas, who lets not forget she KNEW that Peyton had feelings for (she even commented on it a few times throughout s1), but decided to try to get him instead and tried to get her best friend back together with her (Peyton) jerk of an ex-boyfriend. Then there was Felix. When Peyton was going through all that drama with Jake and the coccaine situation, Brooke was
melopez06 4 months ago
@BLAlwayss off benefiting with Felix. And come s3, she's all about Lucas again. And when Peyton realized that she still had feelings for Lucas, she told Brooke on the spot and didn't want to hide anything from her. Brooke was the one who started lashing out and making fun of Peyton's moms deaths, which is a huge no no. And I understand that Brooke was upset. But a ten year friendship one boy comes in between and your best defense is throw a parent in the face. That is WRONG. Whether or...
melopez06 4 months ago
@BLAlwayss not Peyton is to blame for the BL breakup.
melopez06 4 months ago
hmmmm. I hate how peyton gets made out to be innocent. to be honest, peyton and nathans relationship was a sham - she didn't love him. brooke was in love with lucas both times peyton did stuff. PLUS, she wasn't "honest" with brooke, because she had already kissed lucas on the school schooting, that is way brooke cut her out of her life.
BLAlwayss 1 year ago 4
"&iNeeded MYy Best Friend More Than Ever, & You Cut Me Out Because iWas Honest With You!! & You Were Never Ever Honest With Me!" You Thats So Sad!!/:
anditsallyduh 1 year ago
"I needed my best friend, but you cut me out because I was honest with you!!!" Thats So Sad!!/:
anditsallyduh 1 year ago
THEY R WHACK
ishmael098 1 year ago
This scene always makes me cry
married2KiDcuDi 1 year ago 3
Peyton is so ME,ME,ME...noone else in the world has problems except her...she's just annoying!
MISCKAB 1 year ago
BROOKE IS BITCH FOR WHAT SHE DID TO PEYTON
koki19bieber 1 year ago
I hate brook so much in this season
milunia7 1 year ago 4
Brooke is hilarous and soo pretty. TEAM BROOKE! (even though she did something bad)
kellytaylorjenegarth 1 year ago 2
she makes fun of her mom's death because in one episode when haley was having pregnant problems and they were all in the car brooke says "well anything peyton loves dies, see dead motheres one and two."
DinoSoc9109 1 year ago
I don´t get it..how did brooke make fun of peytons mother?? can someone plse tell me
g1m2z3 1 year ago
@g1m2z3 She once said "Hi I'm peyton and everyone I love dies, mom 1 and mom 2" or something. And she also said "your I love yous send people to their grave."
NICKISMYHOMEBOY 1 year ago
@g1m2z3 she said "if you love me you're probably gonna die soon,see mothers one and two" whilst talking about Peyton
Missyme2704 1 year ago 2
I don´t get it..how did brooke make fun of peytons mother?? can someone plse tell me
g1m2z3 1 year ago
this is how i knew that there friendship was gonna make it. Everyone knows that girls who hate one another never get physical they just bitch about each other behind their backs. Haha u know its love when you can go in with the nails, pulling hair!!!! hahaha :)
rachelnjake4ever 1 year ago
Ok I like peyton but I love brooke. There is just something about her strength(maybe not in this video) and talent. I mean peytons cool but she stole brookes boyfriend.Twice.
ashley82101 1 year ago
BROOKE
:D
hsmfreak345 2 years ago
God the acting in OTH. Story lines might not always be the best but oh my god these people can act. Seriously, I am starting to believe that Tree Hill is real and that this actually happens. even if they`re not, they are really truly real to me.
14komma2 2 years ago 21
Love this scene...i agree the acting is amazing...makes me cry everytime I watch it !!!
sylborg20 2 years ago 6
I start crying every single time.... I really don't like Brooke in this whole storyline!!!
sunny034 2 years ago 6
i agree......even if a best friend has hurt you, you should never make fun about sombody else death....i like this scene to....oen of the best in OTH
vdnkvndsk00 2 years ago 46
I love it "So who's the whore now?!" and I also love the part @ 0:35 LMFAO! :)
summer1girl2 2 years ago 2
This scene is incredible! The acting is just amazing!
dominate621 2 years ago 10
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this scene was trying to make people feel bad for peyton. i did not. peyton did brooke so much worse than brooke did to her. pucas sucks so bad and they were very self absorbed at least Naley were still concern for others as was brucas.
fight4acause 2 years ago
i can understand why both of them are mad : One steals her best friends boyfriend , and the other makes fun of her best friends dead mother . i LOVE breyton :) wonderful acting , and it makes you feel like you dont know whose side to be on . just like real friendship drama !
shoutyerdreams 2 years ago 10
since peyton is my fav character i side with her in this arguement as peyton was always honest about her feelings for lucas but brooke weren't
sinerita 2 years ago 5
ok yeah brooke and peyton both have good points but honestly which one is worse , messing around with someone elses boyfriend or making fun of your best friends dead mother ?
and peyton had no intention the second time when she told brooke that she still had feelings for lucas on trying to steal him , she was just trying to be honest .
but very good acting on both parts !
: ]
youhadmeathello22 2 years ago 8
i totally agree with you!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! :-)
09stathis 2 years ago
what episode ?!
FatimaPersson 2 years ago
season 4 episode 16 "Prom Night at Hater High"
09stathis 2 years ago
TEAM BREYTON
i hate these scenes (but i also love them, amazing acting)
i hate how they only make you feel sorry for peyton, i mean she really did hurt brooke..and theyre only emphasizing peyton's pain here.
but anyways, great scene, great acting, great best friends :)
xoxoanonymouslove 2 years ago 5
PEYTOOOOON :D
kiwimeekai96 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
it would be good if they jus started makin out
jaYcAp06 2 years ago
Brooke is my fave in this fight! I've always thought that Peyton was weird :P
PeaceGirl21263 2 years ago 2
Peyton could so totally kick Brooke's skanky ass!!!!
Cabenson4eva 2 years ago
yeah Peyton kicked Brooke's ass in that fight
AshleyCA89 2 years ago 5
peyton definitely wins this argument here. hands down.
JackSparrowsGirl08 2 years ago
I'm not team anyone. I love them both. ;o They both have a point.
akiamemegami 2 years ago 8
what a great scene...... i feel sad everytime i watch it.........
09stathis 2 years ago 6
Aw... Brooke was a bitch.
But she's still kickass. & so is Peyton.
x3losahhface 2 years ago
boo hoo peyton cry me a sad song
nicklebaby 2 years ago
What song is playing in the back round? The piano.
paartymonstar 2 years ago
everyones team payton
im team booke.
youareinsanee 2 years ago 2
Peyton rocks!
WhySoSeerious 2 years ago 3
this is a kickass video
PaRtYeLliE1318 2 years ago 4
me too
Meme0shane 2 years ago
Team Peyton all the way!
Rockerchick86 2 years ago
What is the song ? Plz ...
MellexOh 2 years ago
Spinebusterrr
bayernfan1986 2 years ago
LOL.
Robinmeland 2 years ago
"Seriously, you're egging my house!"
xXxBlossumxXx 2 years ago 8
what did brooke thinks about this ?
what peyton tells her ?
sry bad english.. x)
dEStROiEdMYhEARt 2 years ago
can someone tell me what joke is peyton talking about?
what did brooke say?
plz answer my question!
zazitah33 2 years ago
They were making fun of each other earlier in this season, where Peyton mocked Brooke, saying she stole Peyton's artwork for her clothing line. Brooke responded by mocking Peyton, saying that anyone who loved Peyton ended up dead, then referring to her dead moms.
teknicolorsushi 2 years ago
i like Peyton more 'cause i relate to her more.
songbird525 2 years ago
Well i like Brooke more cause she brings me strenght and courage :)
OJOJJOJJJ 2 years ago 5
Comment removed
songbird525 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
haha peyton sucks..........
OJOJJOJJJ 2 years ago
Comment removed
songbird525 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
if u don't care what i think why do you reply to me? haha, you're pathetic! if i didn't have a life how can i live or even write to you now? retard
OJOJJOJJJ 2 years ago
Comment removed
songbird525 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
hahahahaha and you're obviously stupid for not understanding that I did understand but was just teasing you, hahahahah "get out more" seriously wtf do you know about me or my life?! i bet i have more friend than you have or ever will have for that mather.. you're really getting on my nerves, I mean how STUPID can you get?
OJOJJOJJJ 2 years ago
Comment removed
songbird525 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
hahahaha seriously do you really think i would read all? haha i don't give a fuck about you or your opinion got it? :S:S fuck off and stop being so annyoing gosh! Wtf is wrong with you? trying to explain to me how i should be or not be.. seriously if someone needs to get a life it's YOU and stop analyze me, it's kind of creepy..
OJOJJOJJJ 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
and please don't respond, you're so annyoing!
OJOJJOJJJ 2 years ago
Comment removed
songbird525 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Anywaay i may sound like am 10 years old but i i'm not the one who says "asshole" and "stupid bitch".. Seriously just drop the whole I'm-so-mature thing cause it doesn't work on me
OJOJJOJJJ 2 years ago
I like Peyton more than Brooke, because Brooke lies to her all the time and she is angry about lucas and Peyton but they are together so sweet !
this scene reminds me about my "Best Friend" she is like brooke !
dEStROiEdMYhEARt 2 years ago
this scene always makes me wanna cry :( i love their friendship
MaryboBary3 2 years ago 7
i hate peyton, i love brooke (:
gooooo teamm brookeeeeeeeeee !
16ManlyGaga 2 years ago 7
it's not just one person's fault - they both did something wrong.
emd1021 2 years ago 47
@emd1021 Okayy, Brooke did something far, far worse than Peyton ever did......she made fun of her mother's death and Brooke knew how much that affected Peyton but she did it anyway.......how could you make fun of your bestfriend's mother's death???? Especially since Brooke was there when she died??
jbiebfev 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
peyton is so sexy in this scene.
statsbiblotek 3 years ago
she did while she thought she was dying! sure its not okay but you would have done that too admit it! but cutting her out for that is just really harsh of brooke PLUS brooke didnt know about the kiss when she told peyton that their friendship is over.
ilovesoccer08 3 years ago
hilarie rocks in this scene than she usually does. and im glad that for once she tells brooke what a bad friend she has been.
ilovesoccer08 3 years ago 2
why was brooke a bad friend? peyton and nathan were broken up, and peyton went after lucas TWICE while they were still together!!!
miss000sophie 3 years ago 4
she did go after him ONCE. the other time she was the most loyal friend anyone could ever be. she didnt go after him until they were completely done. and she kept her promise. brooke just cut her out of her life. and there was really no reasonable explanation.
ilovesoccer08 3 years ago 5
very "loyal", she kissed him again....seriously no friend should do that, and in my opinion it was alright that she cut her out, but anyway i think peyton and lucas are good togehter now, even though i love brucas, but it was just not meant to be, i guess...
miss000sophie 3 years ago 3
im pretty sure if you were dying and you were sitting there with someone youloved you would kiss them too. peyton and brooke both made big mistakes but this "entire fight" was definitely not all peytons fault
xosportsloverxo1 2 years ago 7
totally agree...
brooke has been nothing but a good friend to peyton.
peyton is the TOTAL Bitch
jcurielk 3 years ago
i love peyton way better than brooke!
MidnightMakeupX 3 years ago
god me too!
ilovesoccer08 3 years ago
they were both rite to fight brooke slept with nathan and never told peyton but peyton never slept with lucas when brooke and him were dating
xbox550x 3 years ago 2
i dont like peyton either but the common denominator is lucas he chose peyton he had a choice and he chose peyton if i was broke idk if i could get over that yes i wish they were together but broke cant make him love her ive been in that position and its horrible not being picked
tvshowsfreak 3 years ago
i hated that brooke said "you win" to peyton. lucas is not a prize. he's a human being with feelings and its not peyton's fault he's always been more in love with her than he ever was with brooke or lindsey.
ThumbMommy 3 years ago
hahahah team brooke
peyton is such a desperate bitch
babyshorty33 3 years ago
Comment removed
songbird525 2 years ago
I would never forgive my best friend if she went behind my back TWICE with my boyfriend and than lied about it :)
OJOJJOJJJ 2 years ago
maybe so, but that doesn't give her a right to make fun of her mother.
songbird525 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
No but at least Brooke felt bad about it, Peyton never did :)
OJOJJOJJJ 2 years ago
yah she did, but who cares.
it's just a show, no need to start anything :8-)
songbird525 2 years ago
that was a good thing that peyton did i would not let somone egg my house and let it slide by the way she did a grest tackle.
ButtCrackSally 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
If i was brooke,I would've killed peyton!!!
I don't hate her now ,but everytime i watch this scene I'm like what a horrible person could do something like that to her best friend??
but brooke forgave her.I love her.
Elil0 3 years ago
it doesn't matter, i love both, they're bffs now so yay!
Jamale1891 3 years ago 4
Go Brooke! ♥
Peyton is a bitch.
hilary1duff2 3 years ago
I love both Peyton and Brooke.
Lucas is a tool. They should find better guys XD
luketaco2323 3 years ago 2
well they are really great actors in this scene
curly940 3 years ago 7
I like Brooke the most. It was stupid of Brooke to make fun of her mom but Peyton has been a very bad friend to Brooke.
Cec25cec 3 years ago
TEAM PEYTON ALL THE WAY!
onetreehillkxy 3 years ago 18
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i hate peyton.
but this moment is so sad.
MoniyahIsabel 3 years ago
OK so did anyone notice that it looked like brooke wasnt wearing shoes in this whole scene. I was bored watchin it one day and i rewinding it a feww times and couldnt figure it out??? lol
crazyone72289 3 years ago 2
Hahaha you're right! Eighter she's wearing socks or maybe some shoes with no heals or anything.. lol
7thsept 3 years ago
Haha, but I think she's wearing flip-flops:P
xXxDisenchantedxXx 3 years ago
first i saw her being barefoot, but then she has socks:P
bugwoman23 3 years ago
it's possible to give me this video ?
chouchou4902 3 years ago
i dont understand, which joke did brooke make?
LovexKimx 3 years ago
she said "hey im peyton, if u love me ur probably gonna die soon, see mothers 1 && 2"
xoxoqossipqirl 3 years ago 2
i love brooke but making fun of peytons mom is wrong
RAWRchristinaRAWR 3 years ago 2
i love that 'so whos the WHORE now!'
RAWRchristinaRAWR 3 years ago
i l,like brooke
shannonwim 3 years ago
brooke is such a bitch sometimes. you never joke about death mothers, that is sooo mean! and what about the secret code : never date your best friends ex?? i know i never could.
sry for my bad english
Dozabz 3 years ago
i think she was talking about both mom...cause in 4.09 brooke says, "be careful if you love peyton...you will be dead...see mothers #1 and 2"
something like that
XOXOMollyBurnettXOXO 3 years ago
Where done? mmmm didn't peyton use that line in season one, when dumping Nathan?
dark1salix 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
what happened to brooke's hand? she has a bandage...I hope sophia didn't try something like cutting her veins...
lauras23 3 years ago
if chad and sophia were still married i bet lucas and brooke would have been what peyton are now... leyton is the most annoying couple on the show.
abbyh21 3 years ago 10
AGREED!
brucas was way better
kaytiepie 3 years ago 4
But Leyton never happened in season one well at least not before Brucas did...
They were leading up to it every episode then it was nothing...
Brooke did give Peyton that weekend to claim Lucas 'member lol
But to be fair Lucas wasn't really Peyton's when Brooke & Lucas started dating
laughingatursadness 3 years ago
haha this is the funniest oth scene eva
ur eggin my house
tekinthepiss 3 years ago 2
tutroilsonanything she is a girl and i almost cried
demilavato2255 3 years ago
brooke is cool but everyone knows that it's all leyton.the minute leyton stopped in s1 brooke had to take lucas away and then when they went behind her back she's all MY ex boyfriend.
and if it's brooke vs. peyton peyton can sooo take her.
OLGA9BX15 3 years ago
this scene is so funny i love itttt!
kmariebaby 3 years ago 5
yeah, i remember that. When they were drving to or from a cheer comp. and rach sugested role playing. I laughed when Haley imatated rach haha it was funny. I just thought maybe she said more becuase it said punch lineS.
MonicaMarie170 3 years ago 2
It's was the game where Haley tells Nathan that their having a boy.. Then she gets run over by Dante in the end..
h06anbjo 3 years ago
wait, what did brooke say about pay's mom ?
MonicaMarie170 3 years ago
they were in the car on the way to a basketball game and they were playing roles and peyton said something mean while imitating brooks so brooke said "oh ya did i mention that if u kno me u'll die soon, see mothers 1 and 2" and then peyton and her started hitting each other..it was intense..
alli452 3 years ago
That scene was intense.. and hot.. i was like WHOAAAH! when brooke said the stuff about peytons mum.. Gaah i LOVE this scene too!
sesame121 3 years ago 2
LoL same! i hat when they fight but when they do they have such clever comebacks that u just have to laugh at lol
alli452 3 years ago 2
Brooke fights like a girl.
TutorialsOnAnything 3 years ago 3
SERIOUSLY YOU ARE EGGING MY HOUSE?
haha :D
NaysillaScott 3 years ago
they're not socks. They're light shoes, I have a pair like that.
demo18 3 years ago
I'm glad Peyton stood up for herself unlike the other one where brooke slapped her
bananasplit613 3 years ago 3
Lmao. Yeaaa i noticed (=
These two always fight. man every1 fights in One Tree Hill!
Absol. Amazing show !!
StaceAndLynn14 3 years ago
lol I lovee this!
p.s., why is Brooke just wearing socks? lol did anyone else notice that?
SVgrl 3 years ago
she lost her shoes during the fight.
gossipgirl513 3 years ago
peyton could so take brooke haha
kawabungachick 3 years ago 2
this is funny with the eggs
Xxmilkshake202xX 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
If you look closely u could see that nobody won they didn't even hit eachother they just rolled around roughly for affect for TV
Puregrl05 3 years ago
She didn't even wait a day after they broke up to sleep with him that not right
Nyfiness 3 years ago
It wasn't even an hour...
h06anbjo 3 years ago
i love season 4
and this is so sad
peyton wins i think ..
MizAckles 3 years ago
omg my favorite peyton scene ever!!! like everytime she talks i cry lol she gives amazing speeches and in this scene i am tottaly on team peyton b/c that was mean of brooke to say that about her dead mom
loveweezy 3 years ago
Brooke est assez cruelle sur ce coup... ces deux la ne devraient pas se battre, c'est triste. Elles sont comme des soeurs. Lucas est venu tout foutre en l'air malgre lui.
sawyerdavis 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
peyton is a two faced slutty little bih in my opinion.
spongeboblover2007 3 years ago
no brooke is
soccerloverkiran 3 years ago
no way!
brooke didn't do anything wrong.
they were broken up and peyton and nathan didn't even love eachother!!!
BROOKE AND LUCAS WERE IN LOVE AND PEYTON JUST HAD TO RUIN IT!!!
I don't hate peyton but she can be a bitch sometimes.
sockdetector 3 years ago 4