Josiah is a talented kid, but not up to par with many of the contestants that did make it into the top 24. And it's obvious that had be made it, he would ended up surpassing a lot of them thanks to sympathy votes and how "lovable" he is. So I was very relieved he didn't make it.
@psyche0626 pretty good point you have actually. However, I agree with you that he isn't up to par with that specific niche of singing...the rest of them are certainly not up to par with the specific style he belonged in...that's songwriter/musician/singer. He's doing good now I hear.
Kyle Ensley or Josiah should've gotten that last spot. It's about who can go far and who's entertaining, and no offense to Colton, but he was just a filler spot, they knew that he wouldn't get past the first couple shows.
Josiah Leming did not make it because he is arrogant & he does not know how to play the game. AI made it known that they are looking at the personality of the contestant and that they don't take arrogant people. Josiah should stop crying to get what he wants. He should just be nice and work hard with the band & the music coach that are given to him.
Josiah is the most sincere crier in the history of MAerican IDol.. I feel so sorry for him.. but just like it was stated earlier it is a singing competition and Josiah had a little to work on.
I can see it from him that he is over-confident. He should come back next year and if his family with him would be a very positive sign get through top 12. Undeniably he has a big potential.
I feel sorry for the kid but at the end of the day it is a singing competition and he is not a strong vocalist. That's not to say he isn't a talented, expressive and original artist - there is potential here. He cracked under pressure and that's because his personal circumstances seem awful ie, living in his car, and being on his own at such a young age. It would be nice if as a result of this programme someone gives him a hand to get his life in a better place, so he could develop his talent.
i dont think he's overconfident, i just think he is optimistic about something life changing. maybe he wants more out of life than just going to skool everyday doing the same ol thing...
I don't believe that he had alot of potential and I wouldn't be surprised if he came back next year and at least made it to the top 12. And as far as him crying alot because he has gone through several things in his life, didn't you watch his audition it it told about is life. As far I as I am concerned he can sing way better than some of the top 24 example Amanda Overmyer, now that is someone I thought should have left along time ago
This has been flagged as spam show
its justin bieber
SlayerGod999 8 months ago
Please give me the video link for David Archuleta part ,,,help me please,thanks
l34runita 1 year ago
LMAO.
josiah with that hat, he looks like a fucking pokemon.
take that shit off.
Atrophyyy 2 years ago
2:16 that girl has ugly ass hair!
xxTw1L1ghtl0v3rxx 2 years ago
josiah's last performance was an epic failure on his part. are people REALLY that surprised/crushed they didn't let him in?
thedustoflife 2 years ago 13
im sorry... but i hate josiah..
Museleaders 3 years ago
as do i
longlists 3 years ago
simon didnt want david hernandez 2 go cuz he used 2 b a stripper
nfduan1961 3 years ago
No I think that everyone only found out about David Hernandez being a stripper DURING the actual competition- after he was accepted.
wishingstarroxy 3 years ago
Was Archie in part two? I haven't seen part 5 yet so forgive me if I am about to answer my own question..lol.
nascarkraz 3 years ago
shut up yu dumb ass hes the coolest guy out there
liavmostwanted 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
ok josiah is a stupid fuck...
rshorty91 3 years ago
Haha Josiah is a loser I hate him he sucks.
Delphinuim 3 years ago
@Delphinuim why do you hate josiah? he's a good lad, good singer, good song writer.
IrishNickO 1 year ago
It feels so wrong to have the cameras always in their faces, just so we can watch them cry.
Mercilesstantalus 3 years ago
don't worry...Josiah's with Warner Bros. now
RoadKill700 3 years ago 3
josiah kinda lost it towards the end........:(
daughtryhardcore 3 years ago
yup
BlakeLewis108 3 years ago
kyle should've made it and not robbie. IMO. and kady.......should've at least be given exposure in hollywood week.
twentin08 3 years ago
no offence guys. but josiah needs to grow some balls. he cries every episode if u havent noticed.
its not THAT EMOTIONAL that he has to cry about it.
i know everyone loves him
i like him to
but wat a bitch
xXxSCOPExXx 3 years ago
sexist????
daughtryhardcore 3 years ago
lol thats not sexist
rynapostol09 3 years ago
dude...he ran from home to fufill his dream...he sleeps in is car...that's really tough:(
taba1992 3 years ago 3
Josiah is a talented kid, but not up to par with many of the contestants that did make it into the top 24. And it's obvious that had be made it, he would ended up surpassing a lot of them thanks to sympathy votes and how "lovable" he is. So I was very relieved he didn't make it.
psyche0626 3 years ago 5
@psyche0626 pretty good point you have actually. However, I agree with you that he isn't up to par with that specific niche of singing...the rest of them are certainly not up to par with the specific style he belonged in...that's songwriter/musician/singer. He's doing good now I hear.
IrishNickO 1 year ago
have u noticed everyone who made it always covers their mouth of surprise!
rynapostol09 3 years ago
I think Josiah would have had an unfair advantage over the other contestants.
He was shown so much during Hollywood week he was more well known than the others.
I think they made the right choice in not letting him in.
But Kyle Ensley should've made it.
blakelewislover11 3 years ago
i think Kyle and Josiah will join again for the next seasOns i hope they will in the final 24
jonathan0080 3 years ago
i like both of them...i wish he didnt kicked off the band...he would have made it.
JoeyandIra 3 years ago
They're Stupid For Letting Josiah Go.
Branch368 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i agree asia'h shouldve stayed but it should've been carly who didnt made it..damn, sge didint even deserve the top 50
cigi099xx 3 years ago
I wish Asia'h was still in the competition. Damn you, Kristy Lee Cook
onenonlyprincess2 3 years ago 4
Totally agree. The top 12 was almost perfect until they let Kristy in over Asia'h. I couldn't wait for Kristy to get voted off after that.
psyche0626 3 years ago 5
yeah and now i hear kristy has signed record deal with a country label. how did she get a record deal before michael, carly, syesha jason and brooke.
ashley11201985 3 years ago 3
Maybe because she has the best chance of being successful as a solo artist, besides perhaps Brooke and Jason?
tiarnantman 3 years ago
Kyle Ensley or Josiah should've gotten that last spot. It's about who can go far and who's entertaining, and no offense to Colton, but he was just a filler spot, they knew that he wouldn't get past the first couple shows.
sdws17 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
DON'T READ THIS I'M SOOOO SORRY EVERY1!!! If you do not copy and paste this onto 10 videos your mom will die in 4 hours
azninja59x 4 years ago
Psh, Josiah was a lil emo cry baby. I'm glad they canned him. The one who shouldve gotten through was Kyle ensley.
defpunch06 4 years ago 4
yea i think so too
smiley0808 4 years ago
LoL...I don't think a lot of people liked that little crying Emo!!!lol
spacecas 3 years ago
he was too corny to watch
savingvideos 4 years ago
why they gotta torture these people??!!! just send them a letter or something with yes or or no it or an email...ahhahahah...
sweetlevmeem 4 years ago
Personally...I don't like Josiah....
lollergurl 4 years ago
Josiah needs to be more mature & he can try again. AI can't deal with immature contestants right now. They want no more controversy.
PinkFrostyDonut 4 years ago
Josiah Leming did not make it because he is arrogant & he does not know how to play the game. AI made it known that they are looking at the personality of the contestant and that they don't take arrogant people. Josiah should stop crying to get what he wants. He should just be nice and work hard with the band & the music coach that are given to him.
randomgen1161a 4 years ago
poor Josiah... i hope we can see him on tv!
RodenTheBest 4 years ago 3
Josiah should have gotten through
clyons1977 4 years ago 4
wow did they need to show that so long? i hate seeing people cry -_-
qwertishly 4 years ago
i think they should've put him through..hes a hardworking kid..
omar0612 4 years ago
Josiah is the most sincere crier in the history of MAerican IDol.. I feel so sorry for him.. but just like it was stated earlier it is a singing competition and Josiah had a little to work on.
thickpoloatl 4 years ago 3
I can see it from him that he is over-confident. He should come back next year and if his family with him would be a very positive sign get through top 12. Undeniably he has a big potential.
lisngag 4 years ago
i really feel bad 4 josiah, he's not the best but he's definately good, and he really worked hard.
KaRaTeFreaK94 4 years ago 2
I feel sorry for the kid but at the end of the day it is a singing competition and he is not a strong vocalist. That's not to say he isn't a talented, expressive and original artist - there is potential here. He cracked under pressure and that's because his personal circumstances seem awful ie, living in his car, and being on his own at such a young age. It would be nice if as a result of this programme someone gives him a hand to get his life in a better place, so he could develop his talent.
jrwsisterhood 4 years ago 2
I truely think it was because he ditched the band. It's a big NO in a show biz...He needs to learn how to play with a team.
gersing 4 years ago
yeah, its probably a lot harder to get your pitch right without the band guiding you.
oh well, maybe he'll come back next year?
IntelligenceQuota 4 years ago
i hope so. He had a very unique sound. loved it
TurboRSX333 4 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
He needs to grow up and go back to school.
Honestly, he really isn't that good.
And he's WAY to over-confident.
I wouldn't have let him through anyways.
America would just keep him in out of pity.
He cannot sing.
Abreil2772 4 years ago
i dont think he's overconfident, i just think he is optimistic about something life changing. maybe he wants more out of life than just going to skool everyday doing the same ol thing...
lyricsgirl1234 4 years ago
I know right
sweetescape93 4 years ago
uhh yeah he can, otherwise he wouldn't even have gotten through that very first audition
lyricsgirl1234 4 years ago
Ok. Yeah he CAN sing.
But compared to everyone else,
He has/had no chance.
Abreil2772 4 years ago
I don't believe that he had alot of potential and I wouldn't be surprised if he came back next year and at least made it to the top 12. And as far as him crying alot because he has gone through several things in his life, didn't you watch his audition it it told about is life. As far I as I am concerned he can sing way better than some of the top 24 example Amanda Overmyer, now that is someone I thought should have left along time ago
sweetescape93 4 years ago
yeah...Amanda should have left....
lollergurl 4 years ago
ooohh, that was heartbreaking, poor josiah. and there was nobody with him. hope he tries again next season. they may give him another chance.
mpadrelanan 4 years ago 3
oh poor josiah. this was too hard for him. and he's such a nice kid.
zeryic 4 years ago 3
i can't find part 2...
cupolove1 4 years ago
i think they should've put him through..hes a hardworking kid..
omar0612 4 years ago 7