Added: 2 years ago
From: 86illyria
Views: 17,039
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (208)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • otra de mis canciones favoritas y la destrozò, que horror no me gusta como la canta, pero que le vamos hacer ahora ella tiene que interpretar las canciones hermosas que cantataba TARJA, y no tiene ni la fuerza ni la prescencia escenica, ahora hay que chutarnos las canciones con ella

  • anette fuking awsome!!!!!!!just can't avoid to love her...

  • ЧЁ ЗА ВОПЛИ?????????????

  • People are stupid and quite frankly should stop these arguments about who is better... U r going nowhere so shut up grow up and just listen to it or not...stop the fuckin immature comments

  • sorry people i have nothing against this person, shes beauty but, tarja turunen was a much better singer, and Nightwish only reached success because of tarja turunen and her voice and way of singing, but, im not even a "Fan" like people say, i just like some musics, i like the "Amaranth" music with this singer, but, tarja was better overall.. maybe they could do a team and this one could sing some songs, but the classics are better with tarja

  • Q PANTALON MÁS FEO!!

  • anette looks like an elf from LOTR

  • @davidmonroy86

    .. and unfortunatly sings like an orc from LOTR

  • @maxadrienne2 You have a B!G FUCKING PREOBLEM ! you are not a REAL nightwish fan! fuck youreself! Tarja is GONE ! Peopole should Respect Anette! she sings like an angel!<3

  • @EvendoBloom

    OMFG WTF RLY?!!1! :) What is a "real fan" anyway?

    If it means being deaf, cretin or say that Anette's karaoke voice is anywhere near tarja's - I don't even want to.

  • @maxadrienne2 OMFG WTF YES RLY! a real fan ACCEPT! new band members and not hate anette because Tarja haft to leave the band! Anette haters GO TO HELL! :) Anette is more powerfull Than Tarja.. :) and it was Toumas choice! and DPP & Imaginarium was a big success !

  • @EvendoBloom

    You really are deranged... you did not even understand I was mocking you.

  • @davidmonroy86 she is an wonderfull Elf!<3

  • Horrible voice as always. Out of tune as always.

    Even if by some Godly miracle Anette would be able to at least sing this song correctly, who cares. I can name at least 3 cover bands able to sing this song perfectly (van Canto comes to mind atm).

    Tarja's VOICE made this song and made old Nightwish legendary. Not her style.

  • I really didn't think she'd be able to sing this song, but this is not bad at all!

    Granted, it's different from the original, but she can do it pretty well.

    You go, Anette! :D

  • Thanks for the upload, such great sound! Anette is such a badass. Love it!

  • ONE FUCKING WORD: AMAZING. ;) she DOES NOT HAVE TO PROVE A SHIT THING. She proved herself by recording TWO AMAZING NIGHTWISH ALBUMS. ;) she rocks, and she will.

  • YEAH!.. Anette finally proved .. pulled off..

    People, need another pair of ears? (I'll toss also a brain as bonus)

    Whole song is in another key to not strain her, and she still misses half the notes.

    --

    And you think the difference between Anette and Tarja lies in style?

    Definitely when God created music was not thinking about you guys :)

  • Finally! I can hear her beautiful voice in action♥

  • Her head voice is GORGEOUS!~She should be trained classically.

  • Quando eu achei que não ia piorar ela vem cantar a música que eu mais gosto e ainda desafina!!!

    Nãooooo To chorando!

  • NO LE DA LA VOZ PARA CANTAR ESTA CANCION TIENE QUE SABER SUS LIMITES

  • no tiene buen audio el video, pero pro fin suena decenta esta man, cuantas puteadas tuvo que aguantar para que le salga bien la cantada, jajajaja pobrecita ella no tiene la culpa, ella hace lo mejor que puede...

  • she finally convinced me of her vocal quality

  • OK, I guess she 'pulled it off' on the technicals at least, and that was more than i was expecting, but her performance lacked the amount of soul that such a great 'metaphysical love song' calls for. For me, Tarja's version is still much better and this "watch?v=0VF0BlXP-0Y" is the definitive version for me.

  • Comment removed

  • is she singing out of tune or its just me? oO the refrain especially... nah still not good Anette

  • @erisblabla about out of tune-have you ever hear tarja's live performances?in this song tarja is always out of tune,much more than anette ever was.i like both old and new nw btw ;-)

  • @junpei19870

    Are you deaf maybe?

    Post me a link where Tarja sings out of tune.

    Properly, like "the note should be X and at mm:ss she sings Y".

    Fucking cretin.

  • @junpei19870

    You just helped in looking again a fool - again.

    Most of us are having that DVD since day one and not even Tarja haters dare say she missed one note. I have footage from tens of performances of the Once tour and also attended 2 of them live and she was flawless.

    Why a I even replying. Really.

  • @rsimion3 you are a very funny for a tarjaholic.

  • @junpei19870

    Thanks you too have humour, only that it's involuntary.

  • @rsimion3 oh you are such a silly silly person!hugs <3

  • givem back Tarja

  • @TheSkellaish  i agree with you :)

  • @TheBlacksilk if you love anette, hang in there good and bad reviews, BEAR IT!!

  • TheBlacksilk if you love anette, hang in there good and bad reviews, BEAR IT!!

  • For these songs not to have been written for Anette's voice, she does a damn good job of singing them. I'm happy that I can still get lost in the Music of Nightwish, regardless of if Anette or Tarja is singing. Incredible band. ♥

  • I meant she's trying to sing more acute ... at this song she doesn't sing with her natural voice, the usual ...anyway I just think that is trying to imitate Tarja'S voice ... I did not say she sang wrong ... but I hate that they want to do like old songs we love with tarja's voice, sing who sings the song, will never be the same.....I love nightwish anyway!!...but is not the same.......

  • @vickyvickyvi She just uses her head voice - it's cool, becouse she wouldn't sang this song well with the chest voice. It's not the matter of imitating Tarja, but of improving skills. It's not natural way of singing for her, but it's really good she started to use it, becouse it's easier to sing high notes with it. Ofc, the chest voice is ok, but not for every song. If the singer sings the same way all the time, it's simply boring.

    It's not the same? Definitely. But it's still good.

  • Considero q para ser uno de los temas mas complicados de Nightwish, es la mejor interpretación que le he escuchado a annette, pero obviamente lo mejor de la vida siempre sera la voz de Tarja Turunen.

  • Anette ogólnie się bardzo rozwinęła wokalnie :)

  • annete would never sing Ghost Love Score better than tarja!!! come on!!!!!!!, here in this song she's trying to imitate the tarja's voice, but does do very well, she tunes!!!!!... but if tuomas likes it, me too :(

  • @vickyvickyvi i don't think she's singing it better than Tarja but that doesn't change the fact that she sounds awesome, also i'm pretty sure she's not trying to imitate Tarja but whatever...

  • @vickyvickyvi Fuck it! She sings it amaizingly! Period! Stop comparing her to Tarja- they are two different women, two different voices. Why does nobody compare Simone Simons from Epica to Amanda Sommerville the first singer from Epica? It's the same fucking situation. Get over people!

  • i tak pieknie, to jedna z moich ulubionych piosenek

  • to jedna z moich ulubionych piosenek, ale ta piosenke Anette spascila. Jest lepsza nic Tarja - ale ta piosenka jej nie wyszla

  • @Moondance6 Eee tam, nie zgadzam się, na odwrót właśnie - Tarja jest lepsza, ale Anetka ślicznie tę piosenkę zaśpiewała.

    I like THIS Anette ;). But her disco-pants are awful!

  • The sound is soooo good ! It's a pity this is not the full song :'''(

  • this Annete like me so much! XD

  • I kinda miss her blond hair :(

    It matched her voice and style of singing!

  • ARGGG MEDIO DESENTONADA, PERO SUS FANS NO LO NOTAN XP

  • OFG SHE IS SO GOOD I LOVE HER ANETTE YOU ROCK 

  • It's so off pitch... :(

  • Isso só me faz sentir uma coisa, vergonha alheia...ela é muuuuuuuuito ruim, péssima na verdade.

  • Tarja vs Annette ( This is so stupid ) , Annette have a great voice, and Tarja too. This happend in anothers bands like Angra , Helloween, with this fucking comparation , Andre Mattos vs Edu Falaschi , Michael Kiske vs Andi Deris . The people don t see that the soul of the band is the isntruments , the melodic sound , the passion for music , the lyrics , Tuemas is a Great Poet , Rafael Bittencourt is a great in Lyrics and Melodic sound , in Helloween have the power , this comparation is stupid .

  • W-O-W *.*

  • Anette ist eine erbärmliche Sängerin! Tarja ist GOTT!!!!!

  • shes very angelic.

  • this is hurting my ears....... tarja was pure magic

  • Wow... Acutally I am a Nightwish fan (no matter who the singer is, I love them both for what they are). So there's no hate, it's just a fact : even if Anette is great most of the time, here it's just terrible, she is so out of tone in the high parts. I am disapointed as I especially loved her version of Wishmaster in Lyon (well, maybe not the lots of tremolos she does in all songs, too much for me...), I expected more for this song I really love... Well this is just not a song for her voice.

  • @AutopsieDunReve well i can agree that this wasn't that good... but u should check out her version from Hartwall, it's really awesome imo. don't judge her just yet :)

  • I like nightwish with Taria and with Anette cuz this band aren't one person.

    NIGHTWISH it also Tuomas,Emppu, Jukka and Marco.

    If you have problems with Tarja or Anette, you aren't real fans of this awesome band.

    (sry for my english)

  • Horrible with Anette!!!

  • was that 2010 or 2009?

  • @Yammina2 you have serious problems :/ 

  • you people must be deaf! this is the worst thing ever happened! this is not about tarja/annete fans conflict... this is just a fact! please pleaseeee don't play this song again live! ever!

  • Wow, this is one of the old songs she sings better!

  • wow this is amazing O.o I never thought Anette would be able to pull it off! But God she's even more amazing then I though >.<

    5 stars Anette!

  • @NemoNameless0

    Are you serious?? O.O

    She's out of key almost all the time...

  • @DeyaLatvia the old songs weren't meant for her voice so its understandible besides if you'v listened to the new album yet she has improved alot. At least she's trying no one is perfect not even Tarja :3

  • @NemoNameless0 she can take classical singing lessons actually :) I mean anyone who trains can sing like Tarja. I know because I know many girls that are studying classical singing. The voice is just an instrument like any other.

  • @DeyaLatvia

    Anyone who trains can sing using classical technique.

    Sing like Tarja.. maybe somebody once every thousand years. Or more.

  • @Evnightlerd

    No, I was talking about your BORING CUNT OF A MOTHER.

    Statements like yours don't worth an argumentative reply.

    Like it? If so, continue in the same tone, let's see how nice we are getting along.

  • @Evnightlerd

    Since when technique can be more or less "boring"?

    What has range to do with it?

    Compared with "Oceanborn-Tarja", at this moment her live singing range extended to almost 4 octaves.

    There is no much sense in what you are saying...

  • @Sun2strider

    Each day and year people of all ages are training canto. Some train "popular" style like Anette, others "classical" style like Tarja.

    However, almost none of them ever get to see a stage or become mediocre singers.

    Aside from that Tarja also did 2 world known conservatories - in which people like Anette cannot even be admitted for study.

    .

    The first test of admission is a perfect ear. It's obvious from her live performances that Anette is seriously lacking musical ear

  • @Sun2strider

    But that's just about formal training. The differences between the two lies much deeper.

    Your statement was malitious and a bit stupid per se, because it's like saying:

    "I go train some football and I will be LIKE Ronaldinho".

    Will you?

    Literally millions of people are training football since childhood.

    Are they LIKE Messi, or Maradona?

    .

    Probably they are, just like Anette will be LIKE Tarja :)

    So spare us, it's getting absurd.

  • @bogdy555ful got to be kidding me, why do people think she has a unique voice? jackie evancho had a better voice than tarja when she was 11 damn years old people. bitchs need to stop bitchin about tarja.

  • @metalkingdom100

    .. or maybe you are just aphonic and have nothing to do in a discussion about music?

    That child's voice is generic classical btw, each town has operas and music schools filled by such singers.

    I bet you can't differentiate Tarja from some opera diva, or a classical singer from another.

    They all sound the same to you..

  • dejen de comparar tarja y anette son buenas ambas si no tuomas jamas las hubiese elegido.... con que mi tuomas sea feliz yo lo soy con nightwish... ademas una cancion no es solo VOZ es MUSICA, LETRA, SIGNIFICADO, SENTIMIENTO E INSPIRACION.....

  • this is the only tarja-generation song i've not seen annette butcher. she has a great voice, but she should still stick with the songs that tuomas wrote for her. not the ones made for tarja.

  • AMAAAAZIINGGGG!!!! WE LOVE YOU ANETTE =) YOU'RE SINGING WONDERFUL :DDDD!!

  • if you dont like this go wacth tarja singing this song. let anette be!

  • Yeah...there are a good amount of hating Anette comments on here. I thought it had died down...but I guess not. Anti-Anette people need to understand one thing: TARJA AND ANETTE ARE TWO COMPLETELY DIFFERENT SINGERS.

  • Not even close

    They need to lose this bimbo

    I can't even discribe how bad she is compared to Tar

  • agreed. Annette FTW.

  • Strange.... not as desastorous as it could be...

  • I was so afraid to hear this version - but no more. :)

  • O B S C E N E. BLAAAAAA!

  • Hate it!

  • omg....

    2:40 It's as if she's singing a love Ballad to me, She's amazing!

  • This is why videos like this are needed... To prove that Anette actually CAN sing and hit the notes Tarja did...

  • esta chika devio recibir clases intensivas de canto antes de atreverse a pisar un esenario ... muy mal...

  • wow anette

  • The depth and power is not there , she is still a bimbo pop singer Not even close

    What a joke

    Brilliant music but stupid business sense getting rid of Tar

  • Pop singers can't do what Annette is doing...

    So, if you don't know what you're talking about, shut up...

  • i...can't...believe..this...is­..Annette...WTF WHERE WAS THIS VOICE BEFORE

  • It's always been there... She just hasn't trained it like she did during their break before....

  • finally, she managed to sing tarjas songs as beautiful as tarja did.

    wonderful!

  • now she sings... why didn't she sing like that always!! btw.. pants... hahahaha XD

  • Absolutely wonderful...what a pity you don't have the full song...

  • she is beautiful, as the song and her voice.

  • j'adore!!!!

  • de pana creo q nunca escucho a nightwish classico es decir con tarjaaaaaaaaaaa.

  • fantastic...

  • Ficou linda essa música na voz dela =)

  • e isso ai viva anette.

  • é isso aí

    Agora é ela que tá na parada e tem que arrebentar!

  • vc ja viu Anette Olzon e The Rasmus na musica October & April esta muito linda canta muito vlw.

  • she has a beautiful voice =)

  • Stop camparing them. Go ahead Anette!!

  • @katinkorn Go Hannah Montana!

  • Wow great fan recording! xD

  • Hate to contradict you all and whatnot, but actually Ghost Love Score with Anette is AMAZING. She sings it so so well, even - dare I say it - better than Tarja did perhaps.

    Anette = win <3

  • agree \m/

  • @Sheliski

    There's no way she can sing it better than Tarja. She can't sing the high parts. It's just obvious. She doesn't hit the tones and she makes too much effort. Yes, she IS a good singer, but not for songs like this.

  • @Sheliski aver ever compare to see CROSS is a thousand times better than this and ruin the songs you sang it to my voice anette missing sink is not something that she does not have and never will have

  • @Sheliski Better than a few of her other songs maybe, but absolutely NOT better than Tarja.

  • @Sheliski lol u r a retard ...how can a non-soprano singer to sing a very high pitched song?? u r a moron!

  • @DrNabser Using head voice, like Anette here ;). She isn't perfect yet, but she's on the good way.

  • OMG!!!!! NO THIS CAN'T BE TRUE! this is a shame! stop singing this song!

  • there are various soprans; lyric,drama... and tarja is classical singer and anette has rocky voice and its obvious tarja seems to have higher voice. maybe they have same vocal pitch but tarja knows how to use it to sound even higher.

  • her hair didn't burn :)) :D:D IT IS SHADOW...

  • This version sounds really great. At Tarja's live performance, her vibration was ruining the song. But this is really great. Anette and Tarja are different. Face it. Tarja can't be better than anette cuz they are different.

    Also everyone must stop thinking of album version while listening this video. Listen as you are listening a new song...

  • actually, you can't listen to is as a new song...and tarja IS wayyyyyyy much better than this burned-hair freak. CAUSE SHE'S A SOPRANO!!!!!!

  • Anette is a soprano too :) She said it officially. Anette has the SAME education with tarja. So anette knows music.

  • anette is a soprano? i guess this is the joke of the week???

  • (From her official blog) she said that:

    " I really dont know my range anymore since its been so long since we checked it. But I am a soprano and if I would use the classical singing more I would be lyrical I think. I have a very wide range and can use both very low notes and high notes. In my belting I can come very high up and in the head voice I am working on it to get higher."

  • anette timbre is from a -light soprano- soprano ligera

  • @DaRkSymphoniCa yes... I have always found that voice type so boring... and not just in anette, but in general...

    that is the reason why I get bored by within temptation so easily...

    the singers voice is beautiful, but if i'm not in the mood, i get tired of it...

    the same happens with anette :S

  • Soprano is a Type of Voice.Not a Genre of music-Education ^-^

  • ohh yessss IT SHOWS when both singgg Both SOPRANOSSSS okkkkkk!!!

  • they have different styles so you can't compare.

  • cando deixará a xente de comparalas?? annette é a nova vocalista de nightwish e temos que deixar de lamentar que tarja xa non está!!

    ademáis, annette demostra nesta canción que pode ser unha vocalista moi boa!

  • a Anette é guerreira.

  • Nice job Anette :)

  • anette is perfect, and nightwish is better without tarja, in my opinion.

  • NEVER!

  • I love Anette!

    I prefer her than Tarja <3

  • O Nightwish não precisa da Tarja.

    A Tarja é quem precisa do Nightwish.

    É claro que existem milhares de candidatas melhores que a Anette (até), mas se o Tuomas a escolheu é porque ela merece o posto de vocalista do Nightwish.

    Pronto. Falei!

  • É isso ai falou certo. Nightwish forever!!!!!!!!!!

  • i'm so tired of hearing people making comparisons between anette and tarya...!!! stop it!!! their are both good singers with their own style and voice...IF TUOMAS DECIDED THAT TARYA WASN'T GOOD FOR NIGHTWISH ANYMORE, you have to accept it! are you all teachers to say that anette isn't good? Tuomas is a real expert in music, and he chose anette! stop criticising and ENJOY THE EXTRAORDINARY, RARE BEAUTY OF NIGHTWISH MUSIC! with or without tarya...Nightwish, i love you, keep on rockin...<3

  • I love her....She sings like an angel :)

  • she sings like a gayfish yes

  • you can't prove that buddy :)

  • agree!

  • jealousy

  • Stasse almeno dritta con la schiena ahahahaha!!! Comunque non si può sentire...con quel falsetto del cavolo!!! Orribile...Ghost Love Score non va assolutamente bene per la sua voce...Non me la deve rovinà per favore...

    Tarja 4ever *_*

  • che por que cambiaron la vocalista, y la pusieron al chanchito porki, canta mejor la anterior

  • Con este comentario se nota que no tenés nada que hacer y que además ni conocés a Nightwish.

    Pendejo!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Creo que si habia mejores Candidatas para Nighwish. y no creo que Thomas este muy contento con esto, pero actuo con mucho resentimiento, y mira que lo admiro, y si de verdad son fans de Nighwish desde sus inicios entonces por que hablan mal de Tarja.

    Tarja Canta las canciones que el publico quiere oir. Quien sera los resentidos?? :P

  • y ya por ultimo si le gusta tarja adelante deleitense con ella pero no venga a dejar toda su porqueria que traen en la cabeza solo porque lesm puede que nightwish sigue adelante mejor que nunca y tarja tristemente sigue haciendo covers de nightwish si a eso se le puede llamar cover

  • Estoy de acuerdo contio como profesional cuando un cantante deside ser solista debe comenzar de cero para poder conquistar y amar un publico, pero tarja (a quien admirABA )desidio imponer la antiguas canciones de NW en su repertorio, es obvio que esas canciones ya NO transmite ese poder y magia, aunque sea en la voz de Tarja, ella devio cantarla en 2 años por lo menos, y darle otro ESTILO eso iama COVER, NO TRATAR DE IMITAR A NW, an eskuxado KinsLayer, ahora no tiene esa magia,

  • concuerdo con nic19913 yo digo que anette esta muy bien en nightwish,ella ya probo que se merece estar en nightwish y que puede con las canciones de TUOMAS y hasta las de marco y emppu como romanticide y the siren, sinceramente tarja nesesita a nightwish porque de solista apesta junto con sus musicos pero bueno no se puede forzar a los wannabe fans de tarja a que les guste nightwish porque asi o mas cerrados los mendigos tarjistas

  • mira antes de criticar tienes que saber muy bien de los Temas, no tienes que humillar a Tarja simplemente por cantar como quiere y lo que quiere, Annette es muy buena, y el entrenamiento que ha hecho recientemente de verdad que creo que puede superar incluso a la antigua cantante, pero definitivamente NW perdió la magia lo especial y lo único que tenía ahora son Buenos. Tarja por el contrario en mi opinión el estilo que tomó por ejemplo OASIS, AND our great divide es mucho mejor

  • Nice voice... Anettes Era!!!