She is a boss performer. I have seen her live. There is no way she is lip syncing especially when she does an improvised or rearranged version. all who dis her need a reality check. She has an amazing range, and is one of the most technically advanced singer. TALENT
Lol, t now she thinks she's a trumpet! She killed "Dangerously in Love" live!!!! The best snippet in this video! If you decide to do this again with recent songs, you MUST contrast 1+1 and use the dressing room version of her live! But I loved this video! Thanks~
Beyonce is a true artist!!! how many singers out there can sing better than their studio songs?... only Beyonce does! thats y everyone loves her performances live better! thumbs up!
@adn187 her live isnt play back and how i no is cos i went to 5 of her shows and u could tell if she was singing ! just cos shes the only singer now days who sounds good live dont mean she used play back or lip sing
I think that you should make one of these comparing her studio recording to the 'I Am World Tour' DVD. The vocals on that DVD are out of this world!!!!!!!!!!!!
She can do that because as a child her father had her and the other girls of Destinys Child running and singing at the same time. She learned how to move and control her vocals at a very young age.
wow she is really good! she is stronger in love n her voice is deeper. she is really good better in live. but i perfer any she is good at everything she does
I've seen her live and she's even more amazing!! Her concerts are insane!! I'm definitely going again if she goes on tour again. I never used to care for her song "Hello" until I saw her perform it live and I loved it live. Anyone who thinks she's lip syncing is misinformed and has never seen her live! Beyonce proved long ago she doesn't lip sync!
Beyonce, as well as 99% of artists today, uses a backing track when performing live!! Some parts of their perfomances are covered by the track while the mass majority of is sung live....AND THIS ONLY PERTAINS TO ARTISTS THAT DO SING LIVE.....unlike Britney Spears whom rarely does it!!
OH MY GOD! I love Beyoncé live... She always brings it... There's no holding back and who said she was lip-synching that's all her... She went from an around the way girl in Destiny's Child to going solo and yes she has come a long way...
@justinbeiberluv14 SHE LIP SING ALOT LOL. BUT SHE REALLY HAS A NICE VOICE. SHE REDO HER SONGS IN THE STUIDO AND SHE SAYS THINGS LIKE (CALI HOWS EVERYONE DOING TONIGHT) ALL OF THAT WAS PRE RECORDED.. SHES GOOD BUT MY EYES AND EARS ARE BETTER. AND IM A HUGE FAN OF HERS. LOL U CANT HOLD PERFECT NOTES LIKE SHE DOES AND CRAWL ON THE FLOOR AND DANCEIN WHILE NOT MISSING A BEAT.
@blackindians2 LOL YOU'RE KIDDING RIGHT??? IF and ONLY IF you're ears were even half as good as you speak of, you would hear that while she's dancing and acting a beautiful fool on the stage that her notes ARE NOT perfect HOWEVER when Beyonce (as well as Pink) performs she sings with so much power that losing her breath to the point that she can't hold a note in a decent manner isn't very likely. This my friend creates the illusion she is lip-SYNCing!! See Pink VMA 09 and Beyonce Grammy 10!!
Thank you so much for this video!! I will admit that I used to be a Beyonce' hater but I have changed after seeing this video. I have forgotten what roads she had to take to get to where she is today...and some of the singers they compare her to will never, ever be able to equal a single percentage of this superstar!! I say loud and proud that she is the bomb singer and she only gets better with time.
the only thing that i hate about her live performances... is that afterwards you go back to listening to the studio recording and it just aint the same. Live versions which are better than studio: ring the alarm, green light, deja vu (@i am.. yours? *dies*), speechless, freekum dress (gritty rock version, THE SHIZZ), scared of lonely... ME, MYSELF & I is legendary nowadays...i could go on, but you get the point hehe
I looove all versions, she sounds amazing both recorded and live, but I think I prefer the live performances because that way you get to see her energy and warmth, and you gotta love her for that. Bee is just the best, she's adorable and lovable and I would kill for her voice (AND her body!)
some reasons could be reverb. reverb brings out dimensions in the voice and can make any vocal sound much better and mysterious. in a large arena, the sound surrounds you. additionally, you are watching her perform it. if they are truly talented, they will usually sound better live. just a thought. :)
i read only the first 3 lines of what you wrote and I answer WHAT THE HELL ARE YOU SAYING?! anyone can do that?!?!!? so come here and do it I really want to hear you. Her live voice is also better than the studio one!!! compare listen live (this one in the vid) to listen studio: in the first one she hits some notes that are also higher than the recorded version!! If you don't agree you may have some hearing problems!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I am a fan of Beyonce's, but i really dont think her live voice is as good as her studio voice... Wen she is singing live she slows down the song to hit her high notes and anyone can do that... I love her performances, but i firmly believe she records a seperate version of her songs for her concerts... She dances too much and too fast to have the kind of control she does... Im a singer and i know that it is impossible to dance around for two hours and then sing ave maria.
I love her live!!! I can't believe people hate on her! She's an amazing talent, and still people hate... I don't get it. i guess it comes with the territory. STING 'EM BEY!
your voice is always going to be a different tone than when you are in the studio. Even rappers, Kayne, Jay-Z and Nicki Minaj are a few...but Beyonce would come this far if she was not a talented singer...
SHE IS AMAZING!!! she is so good in both ways. when she sings live it's like your listening to the song on the CD, but better hahaha and you have all these people you don't know screaming hehe
it's true...I have alot of live versions on my ipod, and I think they're much better. I love seeing her perform..her actions, facial expression, movement and ofcourse her grunts!
The great thing about it is that I can do both: I have all her albums on my iPod. But I have a program that can convert any video into mp3 audi, and I can listen to her live voice on my ipod. Plus, I bought "The Beyonce Experience Live Audio", and it gives me chills.
i've been to beyonce concert(i am tour) where she sings live! and i'm not only saying this because i'm a stan of hers but the girl still murders thoes vocals live as well, i def prefer her live!!
beyonce is one of the best artists of all time..her studio work is amazing and her live performances are stunning and they always exceed the studio work..just saw her live and she blew me away
u know watever people saying about beyonce is their own opinion and even I m also doing so... i dont think beyonce lipsing but it seem she did lipsinging in video phone(im.. tour) and speachless(in beyonce experience).... other than that I am 1000% sure she sing live.. no matter wat it sound.. cos lip singing is very easy to catch.. just a closeup video of lips and song ... and there U go... anyway I love U beee... U r my hero
I've seen B perform live many times and she definitely doesn't lipsing b/c they way she sings her songs differ @ every performance. As busy as she is, how caqn she find the time to record every song different? The only song she lipsung live I saw was Get Me Bodied for the Beyonce Experience. Each one sounded the same. I sing myself and I know the difference of a true performance and a recording.
Beyonce does not lipsync.. thats like saying Christina Aguilera lipsyncs.. They arent Britney, they actually have beautiful voices and sang there asses off.. I have seen Beyonce live before and seeing her again this week and there is no lipsyncing at all in her concerts... the bitch is just fierce live!
I am a huge fan of Bee, but ur definitely in denial. No artist on this planet can say they've never lipsync EVER. Especially on tour, they cant go months on out singin every song full out. Bey is amazing but shez no robot.
uh da only prtz dat beyonce lipsingz iz da choruz az evry artist cuz beyonce need ta save ha voice 4 da choruz.....but b4 lipsingin dey juz uzed baq up 4 da choruz
i am a beyonce fan and she sure as hell doesnt lip sync, if she lip syncs, then so does christina agulera. that proves she doesnt and she i off da chains live and recorded but much better live.
she is just amazing, in my opinion better than any other singer around now. she is so innovative and her songs are all meaningful! her voice is just....wow. i went to see her last week and i am like DEFINITELY one of her biggest fans and i couldn't believe it was her. but then she started singing and i was like yuppp that's bey! she is just........ WOW. i love her man :)
@No1BeyonceKnowlesFan I am Beyonce biggest fan but some of her more dance performances she does she has to lip sync!!! And its ok cause she can do that and she doesn't do it all the time!!!
live you have more liberty to let loose and just get sick wit it. recording has to be plausible for record sales and for music videos....what she does live would be WAY too much for a recording, less radio play because it's too aggressive. that's why she puts it all in a live performance.
live performances are more stressful...have more to prove and a bigger adrenaline rush.
either way she does the damn thing. i love it. i love live performances in general. real talent shows ;)
Things I know about you 1. Your reading my comment 2. Now your saying/thinking thats a stupid fact. 4. You didnt notice that i skipped 3. 5. Your checking it now. 6. Your smiling. 7. Your still reading my comment. 8. You know all you have read is true. 10. You didnt notice that i skipped 9. 11. Your checking it now. 12. You didnt notice there are only 10 facts Copy and paste to 3 videos tomorrow will be your best day ever
Beyoncés voice is made for live singin' but her studio voice is amazing... shes amazing no matter what...
but her singin' live is a dream because it's there her voice comes in power and vocals are getting used way better were in studio they cut some of here power off...
I love her single's on the cd's but when I hear her live performance sometimes I want to cry. I Would love to see her perform live. That's my biggest wish
Bee is sooo not a studiosinger. On tracks she sounds hot and live she sounds magnificent....She my gurl I LUV her....I have neva caught her on singin a false note. She a true performer :D
The reason why artists sound differently in the studio then live is because all albums are edited and re-mastered by sterling sound...I do not care who it is...The recorded version is always done to produce the best sound (in terms of marketing to a mass audience)...The sound generated is something that will be played repeatedly (radio and other media outlets) but when singers sing live they have a chance to always make the performance better...Beyonce is a beast live (not many others are!)
i am a big beyonce fan..but if i had to guess i'd say they do it because it makes her live performances a great experience..you want your live performance to be waaaay better than the cd not the other way around...don't u hate it when u go to a show and the artist sounds horrible?..she does the opposite because she wants you to be impressed when you come to concerts
Why do they mess with her voice on recordings -- obviously she's a real vocalist who doesn't need any vocal tampering. I have noticed briefly before how it sounds slightly more 'nasally' recorded than when she sings live. Still, they both sound great -- least she sounds 'somewhat' the same whether live or recorded. It's hilarious when singers can't sing their own songs live!!!! (Thus, makes it seem anybody can be a singer)
but live, she always gives extra!!! like some new runs or sometihng, or a beat change. as u saw with the first example RTA. she never sings it the same, coz lol that would be boring wouldnt it?
she is so ILL..I LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOVEEE the crazy in love, me myself and I, and the naughty girl trumphet part is fucking crazzzyy..this bitch is saw raw live..HATERS keep hating..she'll be sure to shut ya shit down immediately :-)
BTW, WHERE WAS THAT PERFORMANCE THE LIVE FIRST ONE. Because I saw her in the same kind of scene singing Ring the Alarm [now] and Irreplaceable. Where can I find it, where is it, and what is it called?
Her album is droppin in NOVEMBER; will you support it? Lots of people these days just download, that's not being a TRUE fan. I am getting it! Queen Beyonce.
Beyoncé is one of the most amazing artists on Earth. Specially because she's one of the few singers that sound better live than in studio. When she's live, she puts emotion into the song. It completely changes the song !
beyonce can sing on cd. but she was trained to sing live and that's exactly what she's does. cd's dont do this girl any justice. her live performaces are what i want on cd. cause this girl is a legend.
Beyonce is one of THEE most talented people out there. She is great on CD and live. She can even do those ridiculous dance moves and still sound great at her performances. She is amazing and will be remembered forever. She is the BEST. I love her live becuase it is just so much more real and raw!!!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I always knew she sounded different lived. I thought i was imagine stuff. Her voice is higher in the studio. Perfect example, she cant sing Listen like she recorded in the studio. She takes it down and growls arent as hard. Its too much vocally to repeat it.
She has sang it in the studio key a few times(The performance with Jennifer Hudson for example). Her voice is darker and thicker live, true. In the studio, there is different feel and you get to do takes and re-takes whereas, live it is more raw. And at the least, she once sang Listen better than the Studio(Oprah).
Beyonce's voice is better live!!!!!!!!!
SuperPinkgirl5 2 months ago
She is a boss performer. I have seen her live. There is no way she is lip syncing especially when she does an improvised or rearranged version. all who dis her need a reality check. She has an amazing range, and is one of the most technically advanced singer. TALENT
Jakebeyourself 3 months ago
Her voice is so much richer live than on her old records. On 4 and a bit on Sasha Fierce she sounds great on record too though.
Kaiuchka 3 months ago 2
thats why we love beyonce because shes the only artist you can name that sings and performs better live
mrneverbackupordown 5 months ago 2
Lol, t now she thinks she's a trumpet! She killed "Dangerously in Love" live!!!! The best snippet in this video! If you decide to do this again with recent songs, you MUST contrast 1+1 and use the dressing room version of her live! But I loved this video! Thanks~
ANiare37 6 months ago
Beyonce is a true artist!!! how many singers out there can sing better than their studio songs?... only Beyonce does! thats y everyone loves her performances live better! thumbs up!
tiklovesaom 6 months ago 4
she is better live, and even more better now
Tyisme100 6 months ago 4
Where was the first ring the alarm perfromance? I really wanna hear the whole thing
VenessaVB 8 months ago
@VenessaVB watch?v=B1L_lf4YqUE
Only the beginning is nice though..
Kaiuchka 3 months ago
shes that good live, people think its playback LMAO... Beyonce is a legend! :P
DeanoMcken 10 months ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
IT'S JUST PLAYBACK, NO LIVE
adn187 11 months ago
@adn187 her live isnt play back and how i no is cos i went to 5 of her shows and u could tell if she was singing ! just cos shes the only singer now days who sounds good live dont mean she used play back or lip sing
aranamin 9 months ago
I think that you should make one of these comparing her studio recording to the 'I Am World Tour' DVD. The vocals on that DVD are out of this world!!!!!!!!!!!!
Jayy630 1 year ago
i love her when she sings live, her voice be on point,and her band be on point.
Tiaraizme19 1 year ago
Beyonce is a hundred times better live!!!!
bustit088 1 year ago 21
i like her recordings for what they are and i live her live performances for what they are.
ex. i like naughty girl recorded better, because like all the harmonies and stuff were perfected,
but i like me myself and i live better, because you can feel the emotion.
but the rest of her stuff is mostly better live, especially Flaws and All, i never liked it but then i heard her sing it live and i fell in love!
xWithEyesLikeSunsets 1 year ago 3
Totally Agree..i love her live :]
lmgc2090 1 year ago
live
brebre10291996 1 year ago
She can do that because as a child her father had her and the other girls of Destinys Child running and singing at the same time. She learned how to move and control her vocals at a very young age.
ninetiesbaby10 1 year ago 3
@ninetiesbaby10 i agree , i know she said that her father had them running in high heels, i agree i think only a couple people can do that .
Tiaraizme19 1 year ago
I LOVE her Live performances... she has more liberty to show off GREATTTTT Vocal!
nonisimo 1 year ago 2
she is so much better live singin for dangerously in love n her song listen at the end was amazing performance!
tiklovesaom 1 year ago
wow she is really good! she is stronger in love n her voice is deeper. she is really good better in live. but i perfer any she is good at everything she does
tiklovesaom 1 year ago
Her song are made to be performed.
She's the best performer of our generation. Hands down.
scottiecore09 1 year ago 6
beyonce kills anything you put her way i love u b
eyecandy149 1 year ago
i would rather take a chance to see a diva singing in front of me , and when i got home , i would really have a lot of her recordings on my iPod :P
christian24661 1 year ago
I've seen her live and she's even more amazing!! Her concerts are insane!! I'm definitely going again if she goes on tour again. I never used to care for her song "Hello" until I saw her perform it live and I loved it live. Anyone who thinks she's lip syncing is misinformed and has never seen her live! Beyonce proved long ago she doesn't lip sync!
melanialasagna 1 year ago
Sorry, but this is such bad quality. Unless it`s just my shit.
But i fucken love Beyonce, i wouldn`t understand how & why someone would hate on her. She`s the closest thing to perfect.
bbygiirl15 1 year ago
Beyonce, as well as 99% of artists today, uses a backing track when performing live!! Some parts of their perfomances are covered by the track while the mass majority of is sung live....AND THIS ONLY PERTAINS TO ARTISTS THAT DO SING LIVE.....unlike Britney Spears whom rarely does it!!
koreyt2007 1 year ago
she's borned to sing decidedly
Djoulsification 1 year ago
think flaws and all was better recorded than live. but the rest, well nearly everything is amazing live!!!
Trammelbach 1 year ago
OH MY GOD! I love Beyoncé live... She always brings it... There's no holding back and who said she was lip-synching that's all her... She went from an around the way girl in Destiny's Child to going solo and yes she has come a long way...
xxxMrBligexxx 1 year ago
(8:14) until the end... goosebumps!
OpticalIllusion1992 1 year ago
sshe doesnt lip sing i luv her shes my idol!
justinbeiberluv14 1 year ago
@justinbeiberluv14 SHE LIP SING ALOT LOL. BUT SHE REALLY HAS A NICE VOICE. SHE REDO HER SONGS IN THE STUIDO AND SHE SAYS THINGS LIKE (CALI HOWS EVERYONE DOING TONIGHT) ALL OF THAT WAS PRE RECORDED.. SHES GOOD BUT MY EYES AND EARS ARE BETTER. AND IM A HUGE FAN OF HERS. LOL U CANT HOLD PERFECT NOTES LIKE SHE DOES AND CRAWL ON THE FLOOR AND DANCEIN WHILE NOT MISSING A BEAT.
blackindians2 1 year ago
@blackindians2 LOL YOU'RE KIDDING RIGHT??? IF and ONLY IF you're ears were even half as good as you speak of, you would hear that while she's dancing and acting a beautiful fool on the stage that her notes ARE NOT perfect HOWEVER when Beyonce (as well as Pink) performs she sings with so much power that losing her breath to the point that she can't hold a note in a decent manner isn't very likely. This my friend creates the illusion she is lip-SYNCing!! See Pink VMA 09 and Beyonce Grammy 10!!
koreyt2007 1 year ago
Live, her vice is god den then in the recordings.
dianabv1220 1 year ago
Thank you so much for this video!! I will admit that I used to be a Beyonce' hater but I have changed after seeing this video. I have forgotten what roads she had to take to get to where she is today...and some of the singers they compare her to will never, ever be able to equal a single percentage of this superstar!! I say loud and proud that she is the bomb singer and she only gets better with time.
nickey33 1 year ago
THE BEST EIGHT MINUTES OF MY LIFE!!!! TEAR!!!
demond1889 1 year ago
beyonce is awesome
Adaukwu 1 year ago
idk about yall but i prefer her live lol
greenflagz93 1 year ago
the only thing that i hate about her live performances... is that afterwards you go back to listening to the studio recording and it just aint the same. Live versions which are better than studio: ring the alarm, green light, deja vu (@i am.. yours? *dies*), speechless, freekum dress (gritty rock version, THE SHIZZ), scared of lonely... ME, MYSELF & I is legendary nowadays...i could go on, but you get the point hehe
Crazeemofo9481 1 year ago
All of Beyonce's performance 9/10 times are better then the actual recorded song
757music 1 year ago
Best singer of all time!
peter21d 1 year ago
wow she truly is a legend. Love her forever :)
GarretFARRYA 1 year ago
awesome video!!!!!!
dogz0898 1 year ago
I looove all versions, she sounds amazing both recorded and live, but I think I prefer the live performances because that way you get to see her energy and warmth, and you gotta love her for that. Bee is just the best, she's adorable and lovable and I would kill for her voice (AND her body!)
Mimosee 1 year ago 5
LIVE.
MelBear8 1 year ago 2
I prefer her singing live !! (L) she is just soo lovely
tagna006 1 year ago 5
In my opinion one of the best voices ever heard in music history! Versatile and amazing both live and recorded!Love "Queen BEE"!!! :))
Inkthroat 1 year ago 4
some reasons could be reverb. reverb brings out dimensions in the voice and can make any vocal sound much better and mysterious. in a large arena, the sound surrounds you. additionally, you are watching her perform it. if they are truly talented, they will usually sound better live. just a thought. :)
charlenelouissa 1 year ago
almost forgot, she gets more practice with each and every show and rehearsal. she records those songs at much earlier times usually.
charlenelouissa 1 year ago
She sings beautifully live and in the studio but live so much better.!
Any body to say she cant sing live
must me a deff broke bitch and hasnt seen her live.
If you actully go and see her live your opinion will be changed she is amazing! :)
malydia09 2 years ago 7
i read only the first 3 lines of what you wrote and I answer WHAT THE HELL ARE YOU SAYING?! anyone can do that?!?!!? so come here and do it I really want to hear you. Her live voice is also better than the studio one!!! compare listen live (this one in the vid) to listen studio: in the first one she hits some notes that are also higher than the recorded version!! If you don't agree you may have some hearing problems!
dandapalleggiatrice 2 years ago 4
I damn agree!!
Biggyy007 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I am a fan of Beyonce's, but i really dont think her live voice is as good as her studio voice... Wen she is singing live she slows down the song to hit her high notes and anyone can do that... I love her performances, but i firmly believe she records a seperate version of her songs for her concerts... She dances too much and too fast to have the kind of control she does... Im a singer and i know that it is impossible to dance around for two hours and then sing ave maria.
bova200587 2 years ago
I love her live!!! I can't believe people hate on her! She's an amazing talent, and still people hate... I don't get it. i guess it comes with the territory. STING 'EM BEY!
bmwboi88 2 years ago 3
TRUE ROYALTY...QUEEN B!
MyLeo911 2 years ago 5
i like both, I like studio for her dance music and live for her ballads :)
MJay0018 2 years ago 3
I looooooooooooove her live performances better.
mikaelia0724 2 years ago 49
@mikaelia0724 same here
i love the way she makes them so different and she really plays with her vocals
OpticalIllusion1992 1 year ago
don't hate on her .. every 1 sound different when in studio and live .. shout up pple
sexybabe99100 2 years ago
Beyonce always gives me goosebumps...
-iLy- Beyonce!
Beautifillthanever 2 years ago
your voice is always going to be a different tone than when you are in the studio. Even rappers, Kayne, Jay-Z and Nicki Minaj are a few...but Beyonce would come this far if she was not a talented singer...
justustarique 2 years ago 5
I seen Bey perform live...n New Jersey...N she did an EXCELLENT job...Ppl r always gonna hate on her...Becuz she is the SHIT !!!
jaylanie22 2 years ago 6
Live is perfect
99644732 2 years ago 3
Great Video I agree with you 100% Bee I am...Your Fan
Giuse94LoveBee 2 years ago 4
5:22 .. Get it Bey!!!!
dymondusic 2 years ago
lmao bee is the sugar honey && the ice tea lol... i love her lyfe
sh3sway2c0ccy 2 years ago
Bey is simply #1
funboy42 2 years ago 4
I think she puposely holds back in the studio so she can outshine it on stage.
rtsproductionmanager 2 years ago
Why the heck would she do that?
RelicHunter321 2 years ago
Lol idk, but its like.. she is so much better live. i was just trying to give it reason.
rtsproductionmanager 2 years ago 2
she is amazing.i love beyonce so much
mazda1979 2 years ago
beyonce is a lot better live, I've seen her in madrid and she was amazing!!!!!!!!!!!!!
biansaa 2 years ago 2
...Oops my comment didnt make sence about the scales youtube wouldnt let me write it the way i was trying to explain it"
But what I ment was only this scale Middle C to DEFGC.
FuckingCunt 1:46
vangk0 2 years ago
ThisFagit cant sing a Mozart Magic fluite peice"
All thisShit is cheap raw power music"
....Here all
This is her limits
ABCDEFGABCDEFGABCDEFGABCDEFG ! ! Middle C here to Their
This Bitch cant even do a 3 Octives" .....Only 1 or 2"
FuckThisFagit Opera does up to 4 or 5.
1:46 Bitch
vangk0 2 years ago
pls don't comment beyonce's video ,you are 2 jelaous and stupid ,thank you.
amneris4ever 2 years ago
....? Yeah" your right"
Because she gets to die earlier than I will"
She's so lucky....thatFucking prick"
vangk0 2 years ago
wtf..ur sick o.O
amneris4ever 2 years ago
A true HATER!!
vyshonmusic 2 years ago
she the bomb!!!
kylebenny 2 years ago 2
What other artist can sound as good (or even better) live than in the studio?
Only Queen Bee.
danggerousinc 2 years ago 3
She's so much better live.... reli good vid as usual...
remmy2727 2 years ago 2
SHE IS AMAZING!!! she is so good in both ways. when she sings live it's like your listening to the song on the CD, but better hahaha and you have all these people you don't know screaming hehe
RikiShaeTae 2 years ago 3
it's true...I have alot of live versions on my ipod, and I think they're much better. I love seeing her perform..her actions, facial expression, movement and ofcourse her grunts!
PrincessAfrica3 2 years ago 2
The great thing about it is that I can do both: I have all her albums on my iPod. But I have a program that can convert any video into mp3 audi, and I can listen to her live voice on my ipod. Plus, I bought "The Beyonce Experience Live Audio", and it gives me chills.
RelicHunter321 2 years ago
L.I.V.E so much better
QueenHadise 2 years ago
Live is soo much better
imsofucingtired 2 years ago
i've been to beyonce concert(i am tour) where she sings live! and i'm not only saying this because i'm a stan of hers but the girl still murders thoes vocals live as well, i def prefer her live!!
bee1fan 2 years ago 3
she perform live real well and some artist cant do.... the girl is bad in a good way .....i love her voice
Elquanette 2 years ago 2
beyonce is one of the best artists of all time..her studio work is amazing and her live performances are stunning and they always exceed the studio work..just saw her live and she blew me away
UntrainedSizzle 2 years ago
even if it's diff.. her voice is still stunning.
dereonna 2 years ago
u know watever people saying about beyonce is their own opinion and even I m also doing so... i dont think beyonce lipsing but it seem she did lipsinging in video phone(im.. tour) and speachless(in beyonce experience).... other than that I am 1000% sure she sing live.. no matter wat it sound.. cos lip singing is very easy to catch.. just a closeup video of lips and song ... and there U go... anyway I love U beee... U r my hero
ITANAGAR12345 2 years ago
Everyone knows Beyonce doesn't sing during video Phone, reason why she puts her mic down. Video Phone was just a performance.
MUNCHOSGIRL 2 years ago
I've seen B perform live many times and she definitely doesn't lipsing b/c they way she sings her songs differ @ every performance. As busy as she is, how caqn she find the time to record every song different? The only song she lipsung live I saw was Get Me Bodied for the Beyonce Experience. Each one sounded the same. I sing myself and I know the difference of a true performance and a recording.
rettie19 2 years ago 4
i completly agree with dancekingshon66
:D:D
B is just amazing but no robot
and shes AMAZINGGG at singing LIVE!
she aint no britney guys!
I LUVVV HERR!
duffy8194 2 years ago
Beyonce does not lipsync.. thats like saying Christina Aguilera lipsyncs.. They arent Britney, they actually have beautiful voices and sang there asses off.. I have seen Beyonce live before and seeing her again this week and there is no lipsyncing at all in her concerts... the bitch is just fierce live!
babyboi222 2 years ago 5
i like her betta live cuz 2 me she betta vocally live
DatNuFreshman 2 years ago
i am a very good singer and i sing all day evry day and nothing happens 2 my voice not even if im sick so haters need 2 fall back
cman3446 2 years ago
freakum dress!!!!! pure hotness....love her live
Arnez2222 2 years ago
love B live!!
naebre83 2 years ago
I am a huge fan of Bee, but ur definitely in denial. No artist on this planet can say they've never lipsync EVER. Especially on tour, they cant go months on out singin every song full out. Bey is amazing but shez no robot.
dancekingshon66 2 years ago 2
uh da only prtz dat beyonce lipsingz iz da choruz az evry artist cuz beyonce need ta save ha voice 4 da choruz.....but b4 lipsingin dey juz uzed baq up 4 da choruz
beyocne duz not lip sing
BEYONCEvolve 2 years ago 2
i am a beyonce fan and she sure as hell doesnt lip sync, if she lip syncs, then so does christina agulera. that proves she doesnt and she i off da chains live and recorded but much better live.
WORK IT BEYONCE,
DO YOUR THANG!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1
llangel012 2 years ago
this girl can do both oh so well!!!!!!!!!!
Beyoncefan1000 2 years ago 2
beyonce would never lip sync
people who say that ARE in denial, you're right.
she is just amazing, in my opinion better than any other singer around now. she is so innovative and her songs are all meaningful! her voice is just....wow. i went to see her last week and i am like DEFINITELY one of her biggest fans and i couldn't believe it was her. but then she started singing and i was like yuppp that's bey! she is just........ WOW. i love her man :)
No1BeyonceKnowlesFan 2 years ago 42
I am soo damn agreed!
I thought exactly the same when i saw her!
I cant even describe it.. just .. WOW!
Biggyy007 2 years ago 2
@No1BeyonceKnowlesFan I am Beyonce biggest fan but some of her more dance performances she does she has to lip sync!!! And its ok cause she can do that and she doesn't do it all the time!!!
voguefemme05 1 year ago
Rule: no one maintain the same quality of voice while dancing but B is an XCEPTION
crakecruz 2 years ago 4
Definately LIVE!!! NO question!!!
beyoncefan2706 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
POR FAVOR NO LEAN ESTO (me obligaron)
el 13 de octubre de 1991
un nino llamado nick se tiro de un puente devido a problemas familiares
si ya leiste esto deves copiar y pegar
en otros 5 videos mas o si no
nick vendra por toda tu familia
haslo o moriran porfavor hasme caso
yo lo lei y lo hise & si es verdad..la familia de un amigo murio hace una semana
por favor es to es estupido ya lo hice
pinankis87 2 years ago
live you have more liberty to let loose and just get sick wit it. recording has to be plausible for record sales and for music videos....what she does live would be WAY too much for a recording, less radio play because it's too aggressive. that's why she puts it all in a live performance.
live performances are more stressful...have more to prove and a bigger adrenaline rush.
either way she does the damn thing. i love it. i love live performances in general. real talent shows ;)
borntalented 2 years ago
i prefer her live, she is so good live
taiwogirl2007 2 years ago
POR FAVOR NO LEAN ESTO (me obligaron)
el 13 de octubre de 1991
un nino llamado nick se tiro de un puente devido a problemas familiares
si ya leiste esto deves copiar y pegar
en otros 5 videos mas o si no
nick vendra por toda tu familia
haslo o moriran porfavor hasme caso
yo lo lei y lo hise & si es verdad..la familia de un amigo murio hace una semana
por favor es to es estupido ya lo hice
pinankis87 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
marivelez81 2 years ago
i love be toooooooooo:D
BranislavDream 2 years ago
I love B =D
MiZzLondaSwaggaDyme 2 years ago
she is better live in my opinion
misterroyaltee 2 years ago
I love her songs more live than on the radio !
I saw her yesterday live in Antwerp ( Belgium )
She was AMAZING
asscuntruless 2 years ago
Beyoncés voice is made for live singin' but her studio voice is amazing... shes amazing no matter what...
but her singin' live is a dream because it's there her voice comes in power and vocals are getting used way better were in studio they cut some of here power off...
beyonce0knowles 2 years ago
i like her better live.....and her energy is AWESOME!
chrysEb10 2 years ago 5
live all the way.... she gets down... thats my gurl
92Shay 2 years ago
I love her single's on the cd's but when I hear her live performance sometimes I want to cry. I Would love to see her perform live. That's my biggest wish
DerrilP 2 years ago 2
Bee is sooo not a studiosinger. On tracks she sounds hot and live she sounds magnificent....She my gurl I LUV her....I have neva caught her on singin a false note. She a true performer :D
Cherr0390 2 years ago 6
LIVE!!!!!! she a beast regardless lol
gosh0793 2 years ago 3
LIVE!
Biggyy007 2 years ago 2
She is amazing both ways, but live she takes my breath away...one of my biggest wishes is to c her live :)
Ariel68peanut 2 years ago 5
I went to the Destiny's Child show.
I can't wait for her to announce all her US dates for I Am... Tour so I can get my tickets for NC and see her solo!
aaliyonce 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
watch?v=CkMCVgCsxjo :-)
Hindsight2o2o 2 years ago
watch?v=d1pttfbQ6UM
if u make anotha, the end is great!
deja4993 2 years ago
The reason why artists sound differently in the studio then live is because all albums are edited and re-mastered by sterling sound...I do not care who it is...The recorded version is always done to produce the best sound (in terms of marketing to a mass audience)...The sound generated is something that will be played repeatedly (radio and other media outlets) but when singers sing live they have a chance to always make the performance better...Beyonce is a beast live (not many others are!)
bbeyonce07 2 years ago 4
I LOVE HER! She is the best hands down! Im her biggest fan and cant wait to see her AGAIN in concert!
BrandNu2010 2 years ago 2
i am a big beyonce fan..but if i had to guess i'd say they do it because it makes her live performances a great experience..you want your live performance to be waaaay better than the cd not the other way around...don't u hate it when u go to a show and the artist sounds horrible?..she does the opposite because she wants you to be impressed when you come to concerts
hobschante 2 years ago 3
i know what you mean...her voice sounds higher pitched in her records...she sounds much better live though
mfoxx007 2 years ago
I love her.
i love when she sings crazy in love live<3
tralynTM 2 years ago
she's amazing live :X
dulceyponcho43v3r 3 years ago 2
Why do they mess with her voice on recordings -- obviously she's a real vocalist who doesn't need any vocal tampering. I have noticed briefly before how it sounds slightly more 'nasally' recorded than when she sings live. Still, they both sound great -- least she sounds 'somewhat' the same whether live or recorded. It's hilarious when singers can't sing their own songs live!!!! (Thus, makes it seem anybody can be a singer)
Salarufinn 3 years ago
She sounds great on CD, but she sounds amazing live on stage!
stefandc3 3 years ago 2
beyonce is definitely NOT a studio singer..she's good in the studio but she's a beast live in concert!!!
sheydances 3 years ago 7
Beyonce can stil lsung so ohh well..
And duh the recording are different becuz the area shes in..
And shes not always moving in the studio.
Duh der
chickengoodt 3 years ago
lmao this vid was uploaded on my birthday haha!
Jamez9481 3 years ago
Lol yeah the studio is good!
but live, she always gives extra!!! like some new runs or sometihng, or a beat change. as u saw with the first example RTA. she never sings it the same, coz lol that would be boring wouldnt it?
but yeha, i think the aggresiveness is the sasha!
but i love her growls!
Jamez9481 3 years ago
BEYONCE IS SOO PERFECT I LUV HERRR
leyonceeee 3 years ago 2
I don't see the big deal, she's an awesome performer, she can sing. Stop hatin
poistu 3 years ago 3
she is so ILL..I LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOVEEE the crazy in love, me myself and I, and the naughty girl trumphet part is fucking crazzzyy..this bitch is saw raw live..HATERS keep hating..she'll be sure to shut ya shit down immediately :-)
Pharrellsnumber1 3 years ago 5
AND YOUR HATiiNG !
beyoncefeene 3 years ago
i love her either way!!! but her live performances are great!!
miiszquelsz 3 years ago
This girl is a beast for real. She always sound better live to me. She kill every live performance that she does.
mrlws18 3 years ago 2
ooooo yeah! go Bee!!!
iconecon 3 years ago
zip them lips hater!! you're obviously the dumb and foolish one in this spot.Come back when you can form a smart coherent opinion
unbreakablekat 3 years ago 2
shes amazing in the studio but i think shes even better live....
shes the best :)
xjennix11 3 years ago 3
Love the cd version but love her live better. I saw her in concert in Texas and it was wonderful!
SeptVirgo1 3 years ago
you know you are a perfect singer when you sing better live than your studio she excellent
DOMINIW5 3 years ago 3
1:38 - 1:57 JUST WOW HOW DOES SHE DO IT!! THATS WHAT I CALL A GREAT LIVE SINGER!!! <3 Beyonce <3
kanye2004 3 years ago 3
I love the fact that her voice is so STRONG
Listen to 2:51
CONCii3T3D 3 years ago 4
BTW, WHERE WAS THAT PERFORMANCE THE LIVE FIRST ONE. Because I saw her in the same kind of scene singing Ring the Alarm [now] and Irreplaceable. Where can I find it, where is it, and what is it called?
Thanks.
ibeatyoazz 3 years ago
Her album is droppin in NOVEMBER; will you support it? Lots of people these days just download, that's not being a TRUE fan. I am getting it! Queen Beyonce.
ibeatyoazz 3 years ago 2
Beyoncé is one of the most amazing artists on Earth. Specially because she's one of the few singers that sound better live than in studio. When she's live, she puts emotion into the song. It completely changes the song !
kkkvicente69 3 years ago 3
Live!
theweymouthfam 3 years ago 3
is the video from that live performance of ring the alarm in youtube?
Robertoide92 3 years ago 2
I love her Live!
waydoryu12 3 years ago 3
LIVE wins hands down. I dont know what it is, but her studio recordings sounds like she holds back just a tad bit.
skye009 3 years ago 6
Amazing....She is a true legend
jdevonte 3 years ago 11
I beg to differ myself
Antanese10 3 years ago
she soun betta live
naebre83 3 years ago 2
beyonce can sing on cd. but she was trained to sing live and that's exactly what she's does. cd's dont do this girl any justice. her live performaces are what i want on cd. cause this girl is a legend.
maurisheldon 3 years ago 8
the best!!1
NegreaIoana 3 years ago
Live!
ramarskils 3 years ago
Beyonce is one of THEE most talented people out there. She is great on CD and live. She can even do those ridiculous dance moves and still sound great at her performances. She is amazing and will be remembered forever. She is the BEST. I love her live becuase it is just so much more real and raw!!!
romanswimmer7 3 years ago 4
3:44 lol thats kool
icecream1013 3 years ago
it's a fact that all the legends sound better live
milliondollarbaby93 3 years ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I always knew she sounded different lived. I thought i was imagine stuff. Her voice is higher in the studio. Perfect example, she cant sing Listen like she recorded in the studio. She takes it down and growls arent as hard. Its too much vocally to repeat it.
MusicaJamiel 3 years ago
She has sang it in the studio key a few times(The performance with Jennifer Hudson for example). Her voice is darker and thicker live, true. In the studio, there is different feel and you get to do takes and re-takes whereas, live it is more raw. And at the least, she once sang Listen better than the Studio(Oprah).
FemaleVocalLover1975 3 years ago 2
she sing great and live and recording
seanapeezy 3 years ago