Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (424)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I can never bear with johns death...when I saw him open the gate I was like "hehehe...I will use my dead eye and Evans repeater to kill all these guys..."(evens repeater 22 bullets) and when there was about 5 guys left I was like "JOHN-NOOOO-FFFFFFUUUUUUUUUUUU­UU"...when John died I felt like I lost my dad or my closest friend...

  • after john's death, i felt like i lost a brother.

  • Such a sad but great song

  • Incredible song. Check out their newest album, American Sunshine, out now on iTunes!

  • R.I.P John Marston Outlaws to the End

  • R.I.P John Marston, your wife and Uncle too, Jack grow some real facial hair soon, and burn in hell Edgar Ross.

  • YAY I'm in the top comments! Thanks everybody xD Still love this song <33

  • @snowdrop857 me2 but i hate it that john dies btw how the fuck can it happen that john died in red dead redemption but is alive in red dead redemption undead nightmare?

  • @grazyed1 Undead Nightmare takes place before John dies so like right after he returns to his family

  • @grazyed1 Okay. Undead nightmare= When John gets his family back, they change the story to have zombies instead. It's not canon.

  • R.I.P John

  • R.I.P. Marston.

  • my eyes are turning red

  • WHY AM I CRYING

  • And manly tears were shed when Marston died.

    R.I.P Marston ♥

  • Comment removed

  • R.I.P john marston

  • this game is so amazing!!!!! the final scene....epic!!!!

    he's not a hero but a fucking tough guy :D

    the song is great!!!!

  • "I aint goin' nowhere old man..."

  • if you guys liked this song, then you should check out their song "the break up song" on their new album American Sunshine. totally sounds like this, sooo good!

  • Remember my family...

  • Gave me goosebumps

  • The Manly Guys Doing Manly Things guest episode with thise song... <3

  • @latex89 Are u kidin me? Its alot better

  • i prefer Red Dead Redemption than GTA becuase Red Dead Redemption had emotion and finece with a real character and amazingz gameplay!

  • @JohnMarshton777 You must have played GTA with your eyes closed then. I think that RDR tops them all when it comes to emotions but GTA4 for instance had a lot of them and the characters were well made and very mature compared to previous GTA-parts.

  • seeing the lyrics makes me understand it more

  • this is a sad song and makes me think on my dead granpa

  • @wintherkill I know that feeling, Kinda same here man :(

  • great video,man

    great vid

    :)

  • @latex89 what about l.a noire?

  • @mrluvs2spooge1 That had a really sad ending :( not as sad as this though.

  • Ill never forgive rockstar for not making it for pc

  • @latex89 i agree, if i had a choice to play either GTA or RDR the later wins every time. Definitely in my top 5 games of all time hands down.

  • @latex89 Thats why the game won game of the year

  • If you pay attention to the lyrics you will notice that the lyrics are destinated to Jack Marston the reason to fight that they spoke of it's his father's (SPOILER!!!) death.

  • @latex89 yer grand theft auto has no story

  • !! WARNING MASSIVE SPOILERS IN COMMENTS - NOT JUST RELATING TO RED DEAD REDEMPTION - IF YOUR A FAN OF OTHER ROCKSTAR TITLES AND ARE CURRENTLY PLAYING THROUGH ANY OF THOSE GAMES DO NOT READ ON !!

  • R.I.P John Marston D; .... R.I.P Sam Odessa D; happy now Rockstar ?! Stop killing the good Characters!!!

  • @MrClintEastwood90 I remember Sam Odessa, poor guy, couldn't found his California.

  • @mrdeath799 your so right man

  • Rockstar really needs to stop with these endings. They make the best games but give them bad endings.Seriously, Its Kate or Roman in GTA IV, cole dying in LA Noire, John Marston in RDR. Not to say the endings make the game horrible, but still.

  • @mrdeath799

    Rockstar didnt make LA Noire u ass

  • @DukeNukem2006 Ya i know they took the credit but didn't fully make the game, if you want to troll on someone's comment who is trying to prove a point, then you need to go back to the mental needs class where you came from.

  • @DukeNukem2006 Yes they did dipshit.

  • @SodaToTheMax9

    No they didnt

  • @DukeNukem2006 LOOK IT UP! When u play the game it has the rockstar emblem.

  • @SodaToTheMax9 & @DukeNukem2006 Both of you shut the hell up. Duke is right actually. Team Bondi made it, but Rockstar produced it. The argument is now over. Now can everyone drop it????

  • Thumbs up if you didn't need the lyrics??

  • @snowdrop857 lol i don't need it

  • @grazyed1 Haha :')!

  • @snowdrop857

    Bonjour, je suis français, et pour soutenir ce que tu dis, je n'ai pas besoin des paroles pour comprendre! Toutes les paroles sont dans " l'âme " de cette musique ;)!

    Hello, I am French, and to support what you say, I do not need lyrics to understand! All the lyrics are in the "soul" of this music;)!

  • @lamasticotXLeretour T'es francais aussi? Je suis pas francais, mais je le parle. C'est bon de connaitre des personnes parlant francais. Ca m'aide de parler francais!

  • would everyone please stop lookin farther into this than its meant to be taken. It's about a guy fightin for his family and then the guys he was doing it for turned on him. thats it. theres no hidden meaning to this game, its just an awesome game, best story in a video game, and best game ive ever had the pleasure of playing. dont ruin for eveyone by tryin to say it relates to other crap cause it doesnt.

  • @Skateboardman10 The hidden meaning (if it´s even hidden at all) would be how to redeem yourself for the sake of your loved ones for the "bad" things you have done.

    BTW: It´s actually quite fun to "read into it" sometimes. Especially in a Rockstar game where many stories are told with a small sample of irony:). You know; like the lawmen in RDR seem more like criminals than those everybody claims to be the outlaws.

  • John Marston R.I.P. D:

  • One hand: didn't expect the ending. Sat in awe for about ten minutes after.

    Other hand: Evans Repeater + Dead Eye = John would've lived. CONTINUITY.

    I just want John back. :(

  • soo... you guys think he went to hell?

  • @TheDezembro Dont know. Maybe so maybe not we wont know for sure lol

  • @TheDezembro

    if theres a god, he wouldn't have sent him to hell after all.

    He regretted what he did and paid twice for it. Being forced to kill your old friends, to leave all you have, your family, your farm....

    He wasn't a killer in the bad way, he was just fighting for the ones he loved.

    And thats what's christianity's all about imo.

  • Okay, this is a settler to everybody fighting about wheter this game is based on a true story or not: It's not. It was a written story. The story is realistic and beautiful, and I can understand that some might want to believe this was true, but it's not. It was written by Dan Houser and two others.

  • What if we're all just data stored on God's hard drive... What if every video game we ever made has a dimension for itself...

  • @yorick1997 Yeah, metaphysics!:D

  • Okay okay people shut the hell up with the fighting. Fighting on the internet makes you a retard. It's what Mother told me and also who cares if John is real or not. This GAME isn't a real story. It's just a game.

  • @Fireclaw812 what do you mean 'its not a real story'?

  • @zonanboy Well, some of it relates to the war and that, but apparently games that you play aren't real stories. And besides. Say, the game Silent Hill relates to a place, but nothing bad happens there in that place. Like, well . . . That place has a forever burning underground. And so does the game Silent Hill. But those monsters aren't real. You don't see a person on a bridge and crash randomly. And you don't get trapped in a "fog" and "other" world. And besides, the towns in Red Dead aren't

  • @Fireclaw812 real. (Derp.)

  • Comment removed

  • @Fireclaw812 screw you just play the game yourself i didnt think it was bad ending to where i would cry but the sad music on here makes me atleast feel sad that the best guy died but atleast just say that the main guy should not have died

  • @bigD3019 I have . . . I myself have cried the first time second time I didn't.

  • @Fireclaw812 well i know its not a real game but im glad that you have feelings about it too and my xbox just broke a day ago and im having a funny video for its death im recording today it should be up by tonight so please subcribe ive also have a idea if john lived going to post it on sunday or try to atleast so please watch and thumbs up so people might watch my idea of john lived video and people might think hes alive

  • @amrahc3232 ur annoying u fucking troll

  • I'll listen to this song after shooting a bullet in my president's head ^^

  • that one picture, the one where hes pointing the sawnoff at the "camera". i fucking hate it, it looks nothing like john at all, (is it just because he has no hat?)

  • Hey how about jack.He is part of the marson family

  • @johnakadopey

    i think the song is about jack

  • I think MOH was a good game, but this, this make me cry, the history, the final song, the protagonist... Rockstar, this is your best game. Awesome.

  • Just got something in my eye... damn it man, don't cry.... don't cry....

  • @TheZiplock60 theres nothing wrong with manly tears.

  • this song is about betrayal and revenge. just like the game.

  • @latex89 gta iv is just boring after you beat it

  • This song, and Far Away, describe the entire game.

  • This game is so sad.... i loved so much John Marston, a great game character (like Big Boss of MGS)...

  • The instrumental of this shouldve played during the last cutscene before he dies slowly getting louder as it progresses

  • @lordxheroth

    thats what happens in the special edition i think

  • i want this song at my funeral

  • i know at the end when he does the showdown the woosh of the dead eye went off and i just literally screamed at the top of my lungs...FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFUUUUUUU­UUUUUUUUUUUCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC­CCCCCCCKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK YYYYYYYYYYYYYYOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­OOOOUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU­UUUUUU!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!

  • ya i know me two

  • this made me cry man even though john marston was a fuking game character :(

  • This game was so fucking good that im starting all over again...just to experience this amazing story all over again....fuck man. Just an outstanding game.

  • R.I.P. John Marston...we will never forget what you fought for and how much you fought...you will always be remembered as the man who took down a million to see you family...and for that i praise you... Rest In Peace John

  • For 4 people luck don't save them tonight.

    Muhaha

  • This song is genius. Fuck, I feel tears coming

  • If only we knew if they would come out with a red dead 3...That would be the greatest thing to ever happen. R.I.P. John Marston.

  • @Reddeadplayer26

    A very large percentage of gamers are waiting for RDR's sequel. I don't see how they can not pursue it.

  • @rookieninetynine Well if they make a sequel, it will probably not be RDR 2. It will probably another "Read dead _____" thing.

  • @dylrules1123

    it was based off red dead revolver so i would assume so

  • this is gay

  • @therocker30001 your gay

  • @therocker30001 Motherfucker

  • john marston was a true husband n father

  • R.I.P. John Marston 1873-1911

  • Damn this song is great... and the game is one of the best I've ever played.

  • Damn this song is great.... and the game is one of the best I've ever played.

  • Edgar Ross gave me a reason to fight :-@

  • Oh damn... John, I miss u ! ... 

  • beautifull song, I cry when I listen it

  • I shudder when I hear this song

  • Outstanding song and upload!

  • thumbs up if you were singing the rylics ;Р

  • best game ever made....100000x better than any cod game or anythign out there....please rockstar bring back another sequal.

  • When i hear this song i remember John Marston and what he do

    it was the best game i've ever played

    Red Dead Redemption forever

  • finishing this game was one of the hardest things I had to do because I already knew what was comming for John a did not want that moment to come and playing with jack didn't help at all since all John ever wanted was to jack not follow the same path he did and on the moment his bullets rip through Ross I knew all that John fought for, died for, was in vain for Jack was from that moment on an outlaw like his father before him.

  • @malkav616 i agree but he got his reavage is father was shot in cold blood i would have done the same thing jack did

  • how many seconds did you guys last before they gun you down when john dies? I lasted like 3

  • ;'-) T-T so awesome, RIP John Marston and live long Jack....

  • ;'-) T_T so awesome RIP Jonh Marston and live long Jack....

  • RIP John. I seriously felt like I knew you after playing this game!!! Hearing this song almost brings me to tears!! Best game I ever played!

  • I know what happenes at the end, but I yet to complete the game. I just can't stand killing John Marston :/

  • ROCKSTAR, MAKE FUNERALS !

  • @amrahc3232 BUT HE IS TRULY A TRAGIC, FALLEN HERO

    DON'T YOU UNDERSTAND THE PAIN HIS FAMILY WENT THROUGH

  • lol jon matson got pwned at the end.

  • @mag741 Them's fighting words.

  • Comment removed

  • I was so freakin pissed!! i was so near the end of this game and then my disc got scratched and would work!!! ughhh i was so pissed!

  • @jstone114 thats what you get for having an xbox

  • @s1r0tt This is a video about jhon marston NOT YOUR FUCKING XBOX PS3 BIAS SO LEAVE NOW

  • @Overnightfuture I dont remember talking to you fag and the only reason his disc is scratched is because his xbox scratched the shit out of it believe me my xbox did the same shit so I sold that piece of shit before it go the RROD

  • @s1r0tt dude your assumeing that he has an xbox

  • @Overnightfuture no ps3s dont scratch their dics xboxs do and RDR aint on the wii

  • @s1r0tt it scratches when you move your xbox around with the cd in it. i had the sims 3 i had no other game get scratches until i moved the xbox around while it was on. ps3 and 360 are both the same except 360 has the RRoD. "which i heard they fixed". ps3 also has failure to. just not as bad as xbox.

  • @jstone114 shouldnt of moved your xbox around with the cd in it.....

  • @colonelfrost8 yah ive learned my lesson

  • R.I.P John Marston..... Robber Thief Killer Revoulutionist

    Soldier Bounty hunter Legend All these Traits Make A War Hero An Old West War Hero

  • rip john marston be in our hearts forever

  • At first I felt angry because I had actually felt like I lost a friend, but then I realized that Rockstar's ending is the right one. It gives the player a sense of reality.

    "Things don't always go as planned" - John Marston

  • John Marston was certainly one hell of a guy. I've got a feeling Jake would have made his old man proud.

  • @DarkReaper1994 his sons name is Jack

  • Every time i hear this song, all the hairs on my arm stand on end. John Marston, you touched me through the most enjoyable medium. 

  • I tried to sexy cry at the end of this game. It didn't work and I was bawling in a few minutes.

  • I finished the Game 3 days ago, but still I can´t believe John is dead! But at least I saw the greatest final and credits in a Game ever! Song and Lyrics fit perfectly!

    Thanks "Rock Star" for that awsome game.

    R.I.P. John Marston

  • WHO DISLIKES THIS VIDEO!!!!

  • @Madkat124 the blackwater government

  • @Madkat124

    Trolls. that's who.

  • i actually want to cry

  • Insert comment about people who disliked this video here.

  • @pinkorpurple432

    DONT YOU FUCKING DARE TRY AND BE EVEN SLIGHTLY HUMOROUS ABOUT THIS, THIS IS THE FUCKING BEST SONG IN ALL THE WORLD AND JOHN MARSTON IS THE BEST PROTAGONIST IN FUCKING GAMING HISTORY

    SHOE SOME GODDAM RESPECT

  • @FalloutB3 Chill man, I love John Marston too. I'm just saying.

  • @FalloutB3

    good on you

  • @FalloutB3 how do I shoe respect?

  • @FalloutB3 john is good but solid snake is beast to, not to mention the xenogears protaganist play xenogears and the metal gear solid series if you dont shed man tears i dont know what will move you

  • @FalloutB3 YOU THE MAAAAN!!!!

  • wow my hat goes off for this songs.

  • I cried at the end of the game :( atleast jack avenged his fathers death!

  • i know .......... R.I.P John Marston :'(

  • @jaakeey MANLY MET DONT CRY! ;(

  • @bloofy thepunchlineismachismo(Dot)com­/archives/495

  • I sing this song in my head everyday... all the time. And never get tired of it.. :)

  • Don't fucking cry.

  • rip john marston 1874-1911

  • @razzereful 1873 - 1911

  • RIP John Marston 4 ever in our hearts

  • @finaledgeonly and our consoles

  • @finaledgeonly ok it was a good game but you have to know john marston where just pixels... he doesn't exist

  • @gunslinger118 He is as real in your heart as he could be in real life. so shut the fuck up.

  • @mrdeath799 He is as real... WTF follow some therapy or someting dude

  • 2 people have no sense in music.....God when i watched this with the ending in where u know who dies made me wanna cry so bad....like a pussy