Added: 2 years ago
From: FiDiTanzer528
Views: 5,586
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (19)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Wonderful poem, wonderful lied. And Fischer Dieskau is perhaps one of the more refined singers of all times.

  • thank you :--)

  • Such romantic imagery! "wie ähnlich bist du..." such a gorgeous painting!!! The tree root out of the ground and everything! What painting is that? This presentation is so romantic... thank you!

  • @mannerpanner

    Hi and thanks for the comments. The painting you refer to is "Man and Woman Contemplating the Moon" by Caspar David Friedrich.

  • Such romantic imagery! "wie ähnlich bist du..." such a gorgeous painting!!! The tree root out of the ground and everything! What painting is that? This presentation is so romantic... thank you! 

  • The late-night seems to amplify that feeling of isolation which plagues the romantic heart; the longing heart.

  • Wolf truly captures this mood perfectly. The dead of night. The hole in your heart, burning through into your soul. The most lonely moment of all.

  • Once again, many thanks to you! You have prepared such a wonderful presentation of the song that I am certain, even Wolf himself would be pleased. Thank you so much. Greatly appreciated!

  • I do truly believe Wolf himself would love this video as you said. Have you seen Wolf's Im Fruehling by this same YT member? Very good presentations.

  • @mannerpanner Oh yes! I have seen it and it's also great! I am a big fan of Karen's work here in YT.

  • Fischer-Dieskau certainly exploits the dramatic possibilities to the full. Holzmair, in a 1988 recording marking the poet's 200th, has a lighter and more flowing style that is effective in a different way. His CD, which includes settings by Schumann, Nietzsche, Rimsky-Korsakov (in French) and Nathan (the original), can be found in the Bayer Musik Web site (it was re-issued a few years ago), though downloads don't seem to be available.

  • Comment removed

  • Stunning!

  • Thanks, dear friend. How nice to hear from you. :)

  • Ohh Karen, as always the pictures you have selected definately complimented with the mood of the music & the poem! Well done on the video & I enjoyed it very much! Thanks:)

  • Thanks so much, Amy! I'm devoting the month of March to Wolf. So much to explore.

  • Thank you, Karen! I agree with Anne Ozorio. But Fischer-Dieskau [and you] can make me appreciate anything. Thank you again for your artistry - it is deeply satisfying and enriching! -b xx

  • Thanks, B. Like I told you, it takes time and a bit of effort to get into Wolf. He's just not as accessible as Schubert, but well worth the time I'd say. I only hope that my efforts can ease the way a bit toward that understanding. :)

  • very nice Karen... the artwork so complimentary with poem and song! :)

  • Thanks, m'dear. I'm having quite a time exploring Wolf''s songs this month.

  • Thank you again! Before I have heard only the lied by Mendelssohn on this text (and there was used an other translation).

    The last line here is something special!

  • The Mendelssohn, yes. There are also settings by Schumann and Carl Loewe, also to different translations. I think the Wolf version is superior. That might be an interesting project sometime, doing settings of the same poem by different composers.

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more